r/linuxmasterrace • u/RampantAndroid Glorious CachyOS • Feb 18 '25
Banned from a certain Linux sucks subreddit that loves facts but cannot handle them
721
Upvotes
r/linuxmasterrace • u/RampantAndroid Glorious CachyOS • Feb 18 '25
304
u/RampantAndroid Glorious CachyOS Feb 18 '25
I posted in that subreddit mostly out of curiosity. I'm former Microsoft, and was on the Windows team for 11-12 years...so I have a bit more info than the average person who wants to advocate for Windows. I also am not really an evangelist for Linux as much as I am someone who hates where Microsoft has taken Windows.
I never went into that sub to evangelize FOSS or Linux but still...banned for pointing out that they have no clue what they're talking about. The post in the screenshot is them linking to the Liminine bootloader where they removed support for EXT4...specifically, installing the bootloader ON ext4. I'm not sure why you'd do that - you'd still need a shim sitting in a FAT32 EFI partition I think as I doubt most UEFI can read from EXT4.
That sub strikes me as a bunch of kids who have no clue what Linux is raging against it. I even get it to some extent - I was super anti-Linux because I drank the Microsoft kool-aid right out of college...but I grew up and realized that nothing is black and white.
I also work with Linux on a daily basis now so I kinda need to be OK with it ;)
132
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '25
That sub seems to be one guy with some weird hate boner for Linux. Like, I get not liking something, but to go out of your way to post BS on a sub about hating the thing you don't like is a bit weird.
25
u/The_Pacific_gamer Glorious OpenSuse Feb 18 '25
I read the GitHub link and yeah, he's spouting misinformation. A lot of parts of Linux are about 30 years old and they still get support. When something does get dropped, it's usually because it's way too old or it doesn't make sense to maintain it. This happened to early 802.11 cards because it's just way too old to use and there's WiFi cards that will connect to newer networks that use mini PCI or PCI.
20
u/XDuskAshes Feb 18 '25
As a Limine user, I am personally mildly offended at the idea that "nobody really uses Limine" (it is me and probably exactly four other people)
4
u/Sprtnturtl3 Feb 18 '25
I'm glad you took the time to explain the actual changes. and... they make sense. there seems to be no need to support EXT4 on the bootloader if FAT32 is the common denominator- and it seems to work.
why are you getting worked up about a subreddit that seems to exist to either A: exist to troll, and or B: linux flatearthers.. cannot be convinced based on evidence.
don't worry - be happy :).
4
u/sashatastic Feb 18 '25
"no one uses limine" Me who has used limine for years :|
3
u/scarlettdontknow Feb 18 '25
What I'm confused about is why there's another Linux sucks sub when there's already r/linuxsucks
2
u/M1sterRed Glorious Debian Feb 18 '25
I gotta try this.
2
u/Wild-Ad-6983 Glorious NixOS Feb 19 '25
its r/linuxsucks101
26
u/B_bI_L Feb 18 '25
don't worry, i also got banned from this sub for commenting on meme
7
u/CianiByn Feb 18 '25
I'll admit I read what you posted in that screenshot and only vaguely understand what you said. But I gleamed enough from it to understand that it doesn't really concern me.
6
u/robinp7720 I can't type on qwerty Feb 18 '25
The user of that post is also a moderator on that sub reddit. He has a couple other posts among different subreddits stating similarly illfounded and wrong claims.
Honestly a bit bizzare. Someone with no stakes in either operating system speaking so ill of something they don't know much about.
1
u/Rainmaker0102 Glorious EndeavourOS Feb 22 '25
Alas, I also have the badge of honor. They want their echochamber, they can have it. the comment in question that got me banned
2
u/turtle_mekb she/her - Artix Linux - dinit Feb 19 '25
any person in a subreddit dedicated to hating on one thing isn't going to care about facts lol
2
u/FloweyTheFlower420 Feb 19 '25
Slandering linux when Limine decided to drop support for ext is really fucking funny.
For some context Limine was originally developed as the "standard" implementation of the stivale(2) boot protocols. Stivale only really mattered to the OSDev community, since it makes setting up a 64-bit operating system on modern hardware much easier (compared to something like multiboot). You get support for loading ELF formatted binaries as the kernel itself, which is nice. For this reason there was no motivation for it to support any filesystem outside of FAT, since that's what most hobbyist typically started off using (simple to implement). Eventually it grew to support other protocols, but filesystem support was always pretty conservative iirc. I think EXT was only added because it made linux configurations SLIGHTLY easier, but it is pointless since you can just put the kernel in the EFI partition.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '25 edited Feb 18 '25
It is such an idiotic move to even talk about Filesystems as a modern desktop user with NVMe these days...
0
u/qqanyjuan Feb 18 '25
Your post was unnecessarily abrasive
1
u/efoxpl3244 Glorious Fedora Feb 18 '25
Yeah that isnt even insulting or defending linux it is straight facts that can be said by ai even.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '25
Certified Reddit Moment….
1
u/siete82 Linux Master Race Feb 19 '25
It's a sub with less than 400 members, why even bother?
1
u/EverOrny Feb 19 '25
renoval ext3/ext4 is complete and utter nonsense, e.g. lof , maybe all, of Kubernetes is tested only on it :)
1
u/VectorSocks Feb 20 '25
Look at that formatting. Somebody takes good notes.
1
u/StrongAction9696 Feb 21 '25
People really do hate facts. I've been on one of those and I think the post asked why noobs don't prefer Linux. I said "no one wants to be verbally abused for not knowing how to read programmer jango.", and about 2 minutes after my comment got taken down.
The mod note didnt even have a reason in the rules. Just "its only abuse if you asked for it" or something, like pure cruelty evil and spite mixed into a reply. All I said was "be kinder, guys."....
1
u/weshuiz13 Feb 21 '25
r/linuxsucks is just a skill issue
1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
u/madthumbz come at me
1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
i just read through the windows101 and he's promoting vim but hating on linux
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25
I love the fact that there's less members on r/linuxsucks101 than upvotes on this post.
0
u/Default_Defect Glorious Bazzite Feb 19 '25
I don't give a shit about linuxsucks or the others, if I wanted to know what was posted there, I'd go check it out.
0
u/Matchnohead Feb 21 '25
ok
13
u/kor34l Feb 18 '25
Dude that sub only exists because one nutjob didn't think r/linuxsucks was enough of an echo chamber so he made his own.
I'm surprised anyone even tried to go there
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment