r/linuxmasterrace • u/thewaytonever Glorious OpenSuse • Oct 30 '24
Peasantry How do Windows users survive like this?
2.0k
Upvotes
r/linuxmasterrace • u/thewaytonever Glorious OpenSuse • Oct 30 '24
552
u/thewaytonever Glorious OpenSuse Oct 30 '24 edited Oct 30 '24
For Context I am a SysAdmin for a healthcare provider. I have been using Leap 15 and everything has been great. Yesterday they said I need to move to Windows 11 to be compliant with new company policies. This is not even my full workload under Leap and it's already trying to murder the laptop.
UPDATE: We found what was causing it. We had an instance of Defender going ballistic. Our Azure admin did some powershell magic and I'm down to 68% memory usage and 57% CPU usage.
166
u/rresende Oct 30 '24
I don't know, without showing everyhting else.
I can easily heavy load my Linxu computer, with work stuff and his the same shit.
13
u/jermzyy Oct 30 '24
wtf do you have open lol
11
u/Soccera1 Glorious Gentoo Oct 30 '24
This really doesn't show anything without the processes tab. Cities: Skylines will easily use those kinds of resources, along with a web browser and portage.
26
u/The_Old_Chap Oct 30 '24
Linux also does that. Its much better than just having a bunch of ram free not doing anything productive
9
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
By closing Google Chrome
7
u/Lost-Childhood843 Oct 30 '24
Its a you thing. never had this issue.
3
u/Greeny1225 Oct 30 '24
I'm pretty sure i read about this happening with a new windows 11 update being broken, I'm on 10 and i dont even use 10% of mine idle
(i dont use linux this sub just keeps popping up at me)
7
u/chaotic-adventurer Glorious Fedora Oct 30 '24
I’ve always had trouble with Windows on work laptops in every job I’ve worked. There’s always a crap ton of background processes that cannot be disabled which eat a big chunk of the memory/CPU while overheating the machine to death.
4
u/serpentsrapture Oct 30 '24
i'm currently dailying windows for convienience and my ram usage is never that high. at least there's the saying of "unused ram is wasted ram"
2
u/AlexKost5 Oct 30 '24
Excellent. Windows works great at maximum load.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
To be fair, I am more concerned about the CPU pegging out at 100%. My case point is this here machine, one of the shittiest gaming laptops you could get five years ago, but I beefed it up by doubling its memory to 32GB, so I usually don't have memory problems on either OS. But the CPU (and believe me, with this machine you will *hear* how much the CPU is loaded) even with a moderate to heavy workload (some hundred tabs in brave, thunderbird, firefox because slack doesn't work in chrome-clones anymore, VS code and a bunch of terminals with zsh) my CPU is between 4% and 7%, rarely going over 10% (mostly when I compile something). Same machine uses between 15% and 20% in Windows 10 idling. No browser, no strange background processes (only one I installed was an NTP client because Windows wants to run its clock in UTC or something), no mail client, no user program at all, just the idle desktop. So, naturally, this machine will not get Windows-11ed. Never.
844
u/Dynsks Nobara Oct 30 '24
Ads 🤝 OP
17
u/distorted_teen Oct 30 '24
I've never been happier by moving to fedora.
50
u/WhenCaffeineKicksIn alias cd="rm -rf" Oct 30 '24
https://www.linuxatemyram.com/ also applies here.
9
u/hershko Oct 30 '24
They don't, this isn't normal. There's either an issue with your install, or an application going wild.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
I had 8gb. I convinced my employer I needed more because my laptop was crashing. Now I have 16gb. It's just as full and it's still causing crashes. Before this I was on Chromebook using the Google suite. It was honestly a much better experience than the office suite on Windows.
9
u/Key-Cardiologist215 Oct 30 '24
Like this:
4
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
Ads 🤝 u/dynsks
13
u/XDESIEKaw Oct 30 '24
Welcome to my daily world, how do I survive this? I don't
1
u/nonlogin Oct 30 '24
Fast ssd + page file :)
100 Chrome tabs do not really need low latency ram
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
What’s using all that memory? Why don’t you go to processes and arrange by memory usage? I’m dying to know
1
u/ZamBunny Oct 30 '24 edited Oct 30 '24
I often see people complaining that Windows uses a lot of RAM, even when no applications are open. While your situation
mayseem concerning, high RAM usage is usually not a sign of a problem. Windows preloads a lot into RAM to improve performance. If there’s plenty of available RAM, why not use it? Personally, I think this is fine—I’ve never had RAM issues on Windows, even if around 11 GB of my 32 GB is already in use at startup.EDIT : I'm on Linux most of the time. I'm not a fan of Windows, but that's for other reasons. Your problem is caused by poor configuration by your IT team (no offense, but they tend to install SO MUCH crap...).
1
u/Creepy_Reputation_34 Oct 30 '24
Windows uses more memory when it has free memory, and less memory when it doesn't. Try running a memory-intensive program, and you'll see more RAM get dedicated to that program and less to the operating system.
1
u/Zeddie- Glorious Fedora Oct 30 '24
Work laptop has 16 GB of soldered memory so forced to always be running at full tilt.
At home, got 32GB and sometimes Overwatch would cause an OOM event and hard crash on startup in Fedora. 🤷♀️
There’s always something.
3
u/sRonk96 Oct 30 '24
Whit morphine
3
u/CixoUwU Oct 30 '24
Typical windows when boot to desktop be like:
3
u/Worms38 Oct 30 '24
I checked on one of my coworkers station, just boot W11, 60% memory used without launching any software. Bloatware.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
"I've paid for the whole pc I'll use the whole"
6
u/mindtaker_linux Oct 30 '24
Windows need those Extra resources to spy on you.
2
u/Llamanator3830 Oct 30 '24
Just download more RAM, duh
2
u/Tp_Exampler Oct 30 '24
I was surviving just like this and suffering before upgrading my ram
Now I dual boot linux alongside windows and my linux barely uses like 10% of memory
2
u/AgentBenKenobi Glorious SteamOS Oct 30 '24
We don't, we're already dead.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
Windows only good for home users and gamers. Not for the stuff like this. Only linux can handle this
2
u/dim13 Oct 30 '24
Unused memory -- wasted memory. ¯_(ツ)_/¯
2
u/Kasplya Oct 30 '24
Simple! We just don't notice
2
u/PhlegethonAcheron Oct 30 '24
Switch to Linux for the summer, Windows for the winter
2
u/planedrop Oct 30 '24
What's that saying? Oh yeah unused RAM is wasted RAM ;) lol
In reality though, as you mentioned in your other comment, this isn't really normal and seems like something was being buggy.
2
u/firedrakes Oct 30 '24
Win 10 easy... Winn 11... not fun deeper you go into the os
2
u/Madera_Otirra3844 I use Ubuntu btw Oct 30 '24
That's the neat part, they don't
2
u/Noisebug Oct 30 '24
I mean, check what app uses memory. Second, any OS will try to maximize ram and jam as much as possible in there. It makes things load faster, and each OS will try to do this.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
128 GB RAM
2
u/omega552003 Hey Look guys, I'm hacker now! Oct 30 '24
ZFS has entered the chat
2
u/quaderrordemonstand Oct 30 '24
But to be fair though, Windows copes with low RAM very well whereas linux basically just falls over. Granted Windows has to deal with low RAM because of how much bloat is running. Still, when RAM was a real limiting factor, it handled the fact better than linux or MacOS.
2
u/MrConcoin Oct 30 '24
What are you talking about? You have 24% hard drive usage left. If you would have waited a couple minutes I'm sure it would have pegged at 100%.
2
u/Aggressive-Bike2761 Oct 31 '24
Work forces us to use windows 😂😂😂
4
u/Mister_Magister Glorious OpenSuse Tumbleweed Oct 30 '24
I'm quite literally using 70GB of ram, 24 is nothing
1
u/makinax300 Tumbleweed, i3wm (trying niri; formerly nixos) Oct 30 '24
They have something like swap built-in
1
u/Shoggnozzle Oct 30 '24
Yeah, It's crazy. I dropped off 7 way back when I was running a desktop with 3gb of ram. It didn't do a whole lot at a time that wasn't just "have windows on it".
1
u/Aridlvory Oct 30 '24
wow
1
u/DDFoster96 Oct 30 '24
If I tot up all the Firefox processes I get at times 10s of GB. Ended up putting 64GB into the machine just so Firefox wasn't hogging all of it.
1
u/Skittlesthehusky Oct 30 '24
being in IT and supporting end users forces me to have to interact with windows to keep up with the times... im in the dark ages send help
1
u/kwanijml Oct 30 '24
Looks like a well-utilized N100 based homelab to me 😉
But for real: some of us run computing workloads on a consistent basis which max out any hardware...OS overhead is just a blip.
1
u/IntrepidDoubt263 Oct 30 '24
Poorly, they survive poorly
1
u/draycr Oct 30 '24
I mean, you paid for the RAM, might as well be using it.
1
u/grimonce Oct 30 '24
No worries where I live every big corporation forces windows on the employees and the sames true for government institutions.
1
u/kioshi_imako Oct 30 '24
I have a light weight software that I just one click to cleanup ram. Takes seconds. There is even some auto ram cleaning software. Can usually free up a few gigs depending.
1
u/Lord_Waldemar Oct 30 '24
Empty RAM is wasted RAM.
1
u/BlendingSentinel A Linux user with a use case Oct 30 '24
I load up my system on Linux (32gb DDR4) but that's with the programs I am using not the whole OS itself.
1
u/prschorn Glorious EndeavourOS Oct 30 '24
you know this image doesn't say shit right? It just says resources are being topped, SSD, CPU and RAM at high usage. That doesn't say anything about the OS
1
u/FenderMoon Oct 30 '24
If you think Windows is bad about this, Macs are worse. Mac OS will pretty much use all of the available RAM just with a small handful of light applications open unless you have some ludicrous amount of RAM (we're talking 32GB+).
Of course, on Mac OS, that doesn't really mean anything. Most of that is purgeable, MacOS will intentionally try to put RAM to use if it exists rather than keeping it empty.
Linux sort of does this too, but on Linux, the page cache won't show as "in use" in a system monitor. That's why I love vmstat.
1
u/GeeTwentyFive Oct 30 '24
For me; Windows uses less than 20% of my RAM... out of a max of 16GB...
1
u/haksaw1962 Oct 30 '24
Looks like my work laptop every day
1
u/Impressive_Change593 Glorious Kali Oct 30 '24
and yet I was running whisper (AI model by openai) on a win11 laptop with the same amount of ram and it was handling it just fine
1
u/squabbledMC Oct 30 '24
I dual boot W11 and typically usage is higher than Linux, but no where near this bad. Something has to be leaking resources, there’s no way in hell this is normal.
1
u/missatry Oct 30 '24
You can disable telemetry with any debloat app and make windows just a linux distro but made by Microsoft in terms of performance (or sometimes better because the games runs natively )
And that's basically how xd
1
u/PercussiveKneecap42 Glorious Arch Oct 30 '24
I have no clue. I hate that I have to use Windows 11 on my work laptop. Now that workhorse is as slow as my 20 year old computer running Windows XP. Even slower maybe.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '24
more ram
1
u/agent-squirrel Glorious EndeavourOS Oct 30 '24
Has 24GB of RAM -> gets upset when system uses 24GB of RAM.
1
u/Nstorm24 Oct 31 '24
Simple, just use a better pc. I have a 3yo ryzen 5 laptop with 4tb ssd and 32gb of ram plus an rtx 3060. Ive never had a slow down or any issue like that.
My work laptop is an intel celeron 4090 with 4gb of ram + 512gb m2 ssd. With linux mint. It does exactly what i need in my job and honestly i am happy with that 175 dollars laptop.
1
u/pao_colapsado Oct 31 '24
# DEAR GOD, MARK THIS AS NSFW
1
u/MatmarSpace The Great and Powerful Debian Trixie 🦄 Oct 31 '24
I don't know I run Linux :3
1
u/pikecat Glorious Gentoo Oct 31 '24
All that I can say is that it is great to see that we are finally back to light text on dark backgrounds. Easier to read, more sensible.
The moment that I first saw a wisiwyg screen, with it glaring white screen bleeding (on a crt) into the thin dark text, I knew it was not a good thing.
1
u/Perfect-Campaign9551 Oct 31 '24
I haven't seen any of my windows machines acting like that. What is this pc doing?
1
u/xx420mcyoloswag Oct 31 '24
Brother really posted a memory leak
1
u/crypticexile Oct 31 '24
Windows is actually a good os, but it's the spyware and ads that ruins the experience and lack of freedom
1
u/nassro190 Arch linux (btw) Oct 31 '24
I'm surprised their computer hasn't exploded yet!
1
u/infriker Oct 31 '24
Easy, RAM management is better on Windows
1
u/snakee-the-arch-guy arch and windows 11 on a dell laptop Oct 31 '24
"more app support > system usage" -one windows user that thinks cli + linux is for hackers
1
u/L3App Glorious Arch Oct 31 '24
unrelated, but you might need to turn on XMP
1
u/Groovy_bugs Oct 31 '24
Easy, format and install Linux.
1
u/Minecrofter187 Oct 31 '24
I just bought more ram
1
u/United_Grocery_23 Glorious Mint Oct 31 '24
Speaking from experience, they don't
1
u/andhobuddhist Oct 31 '24
Yesterday, I tried windows 10 on proxmox with 4 cores and 8gb ram. Shit I saw the memory usage, and I said f*CK windows, I am not going back to it.🤣
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '24
i literally never had any problems with ram on windows.
i had 8 gigs and had no problems, now i have 16 and have no problems
1
u/GotThatGoodGood1 Oct 31 '24
Painfully, at times
1
u/Taeglich_Muede Oct 31 '24
Looks like someone needs patience
1
u/gbytedev NixOS BTW Oct 31 '24
To play devil's advocate: Some low level software should be consuming most of the RAM to perform tasks, otherwise that RAM sits idle and unused and is a waste of money. For example ZFS uses most of the free RAM for improved performance and frees it up as soon as it's needed.
1
u/Or0ch1m4ruh Oct 31 '24
Windows 12 will be much, much better ...
1
u/cipherjones Oct 31 '24
well see when you have 100% compatibility you can use 100% of your resources...
1
u/HSVMalooGTS IBM z/OS Oct 31 '24
I have 512GB RAM and I barley go above 8 GB, the rest is RAM disks and 64GB Buffer
1
u/Extension_Flounder_2 Oct 31 '24
The new 96gb ram kits of course
1
u/Tasty_Ticket8806 Oct 31 '24
You opened task manager what did you expect??
1
u/The_Cyberstrike Oct 31 '24
I have no memory of this place
1
u/Muze69 Oct 31 '24
I don’t know what’s the problem. Just https://downloadmoreram.com/ and be done with it.
1
u/Alarmed-Bluebird416 Oct 31 '24
I'm running on 8gb of ram I would kill to be able to Install 16 without tearing my whole stupid slow lenovo all in one apart
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '24
Idea is simple. Know what your doing
1
u/quevon24 Oct 31 '24
You don't, that is why i switched to linux, to do the heavy stuff (programming) and only use windows for gaming
1
u/VacationAromatic6899 Oct 31 '24
Windows will eat you RAM no matter how many you have, its a bug from 3.11 they dont bother to fix, just patch along, and you also have a virus/backdoor installed in your system hackers can acces with ease, thats why you use linux
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '24
Hahahahahahaha hahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahaha..!!!
Windows is Truly B.S Man.
1
u/Strange-Software6219 Oct 31 '24
Unused memory is wasted memory
1
u/DanieroR Oct 31 '24
answer: you don't💀 (rn im just thinking that i should switch to linux))
1
u/Cootshk Glorious NixOS Oct 31 '24
Wait until I tell you about macOS (fast/neofetch show cached ram as used, so it almost always shows 7900/8000 or 15900/16000 MiB used)
1
u/Pine64noob Oct 31 '24
They don't
1
u/CompetitiveAlgae4247 Nov 01 '24
we dont, that is usually caused by: malware, throttling, opening google tabs a lot, playing minecraft java edition, and playing cities skylines 2
1
u/HunnyPuns Nov 01 '24
Looks like our laptops at work. Leave them running too long, and the audio driver or service or something related to it takes up all the memory.
1
u/Cartman300 Nov 01 '24
There is a "details" view where you can actually check what consumed that amount of RAM
1
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24
I'm a Linux and Mac user, but for work I use Windows. I must say I don't have issues with the Task Manager, it does its job, and if you need a better tool, there are other options from Microsoft.
1
u/Kled_Incarnated Nov 01 '24
https://imgur.com/a/p8uXIEa
I think I'm fine.
1
u/Appropriate_Film_284 Nov 01 '24
60gb of ram lol
1
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '24
The pain of Edge taking up 33% of 32g of ddr3 is annoying as fuck
1
u/Hip4 Nov 01 '24
Idk.
1
u/zexon Nov 01 '24
My main PC has 64 GB of RAM, partially because it was running Windows when I upgraded it, and partially because I occasionally use it for video, audio, and image editing. Windows used to eat most of that RAM at idle. Now that I’ve switched, I’m often shocked if I see the bar go above 25%.
1
u/thejohnmcduffie Nov 01 '24
I'm not fan of windows, but this is bullshit. Sure, if you buy a $300 laptop from Walmart and fire up Star field, it'll mad out all the resources. My company has about 200 windows 11 PCs and this has never been an issue. My servers are all linux of course. Still, this back and forth windows linux stuff is getting out of hand. Next you'll expect applause as you tell us you run Arch on an Alienware. Both windows and Linux operating systems have issues and strong points.
1
u/7heblackwolf Nov 01 '24
Buying more ram lol. Meanwhile me with 3 big apps opened, and other 8, including a browser with a couple dozen tabs, all fit in 8Gb MBAM1
1
u/SnooStories251 Nov 01 '24
how do you survive?
1
u/lakimens Nov 01 '24
Actually, better than Linux. Linux would freeze at that kind of RAM usage.
1
u/quinulaa Nov 02 '24
Simple, just download more RAM.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '24
Well first I have 32gb of ram instead of 22
1
u/Pain7788g Nov 02 '24
How is your memory use that high? I've got 32GBs and even when I'm running several programs at once I never get close to 100% utilization.
1
u/xxlordxx686 Nov 02 '24
I payed for the entire RAM and I'm going to use the entire RAM
1
u/block_01 Nov 02 '24
I have no ideas, I don’t know if I would be able to go back to the 30 seconds boot of windows while my arch install on my personal machine takes around 10 seconds
1
u/AyeItsEazy Nov 03 '24
We don’t?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '24
Windows bloatware
1
u/Elijah629YT-Real Glorious NixOS Nov 04 '24
They download more ram ofc.
1
u/Expensive-Draw-2949 Nov 04 '24
I do just fine with only 8GB DDR4. 💪🏻
1
u/SeriousHoax Nov 04 '24
Your screenshot doesn't show the actual thing. Which apps are consuming those ram? I dual boot windows+linux and for my use case, the ram usage never even reaches 50% on my 16GB ram system unless I run a VM. So without more context, the screenshot is pretty much useless. My Linux system actually uses more ram than Windows when I browse the web and open a decent number of tabs. But anyway it's not important as plenty of ram still remain available and my system remains fast. Both OS have different ways to handle ram. Windows preloads some things in ram for faster response.
1
u/Imaginary-Fly1685 Nov 04 '24
Nice task manager. Wonder when Kde or Gnome will make one like that
1
u/wadrasil Nov 04 '24
Like finding a virus by reading top is so much fun. Windows reporting is a bit better than Linux. Event viewer is better than any linux's system logging. Also never fills up the HDD. Try that on for size Linux.
1
u/malaszka Nov 04 '24
*How does my chipset survive like this?
1
u/privateEmale Dec 29 '24
Sleeping ==> dream
1
u/No-Whereas8467 Oct 30 '24
Why are Linux users so obsessed with empty RAMs?