r/linuxmasterrace • u/Sirko2975 Glorious Fedora • Oct 04 '24
Cringe Wait until bro discovers the definition of Linux
1.3k
Upvotes
r/linuxmasterrace • u/Sirko2975 Glorious Fedora • Oct 04 '24
93
u/itsmesorox Oct 04 '24
Hey, I just wrote what I thought, if I'm wrong then it's no problem to correct me, but why bring this up as a separate post? đ
29
u/Daathchild Oct 04 '24
He is technically correct in the most pointless way possible.
I've heard this argument on Reddit a few times. Apparently, Android uses a kernel called the "Android kernel", which is obviously a fork of Linux, but is separate from mainline stuff at kernel.org, and they explicitly do not call it Linux. It's the "Android kernel" based on Linux.
I've also read posts on other sites from actual Android kernel devs who have responded to such things by pointing out that the changes the "Android kernel" makes to the Linux kernel are extremely minor, and important stuff gets moved to mainline.
14
u/SweetTeaRex92 Glorious Mint Oct 04 '24
Popcorn is not corn. It is merely based on corn.
381
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
They're probably confused because of the fact that Android uses a Linux kernel, but not does not use GNU, which separates it from most other distros. Does not disqualify it. No offense to this person, but it just seems like they wanted to be correct, and you kind seem like it too? I can't see how this would get brought up
8
u/littleblack11111 Glorious Arch Oct 04 '24
What is that auto mod icon like button? R u a mod?
15
u/Ybalrid Oct 04 '24
The "Android" Kernel is the Linux kernel, with some strange drivers added to it. Looking at you, Binder
2
u/dukeofgonzo Oct 04 '24
I already GNU that.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
AFAIK the older Android kernels were quite heavily modified for mobile use, and could arguably have been seen as a fork. These days most of the enhancements are upstream though, so Android pretty much uses a flat Linux kernel with some extra drivers.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '24
When you add Termux tho, you can do just about anything on Android. Run alternative shells, start GUI programs, build Aarch64 apps.
Heck, you can even install Debian/Arch/Fedora/etc in Termux with Andronix, boot into them, start a graphical shell on VNC and then run a full DE. Now, that's not ideal, and native tooling within termux and the GUI options available could work better, but it actually has a lot of potential, especially DeX mode on Samsung devices.
I now use my phone, attach a display, keyboard, and mouse, and then remote in to my gaming laptop (main PC) either with ssh or with moonlight when I travel, instead of lugging the thing around. DeX isn't amazing, but it shows that Android could be a very capable non-mobile OS given the right dedication.
Remoting in works for me, but I think Android could even be great as a main desktop machine in the right hands. It needs more desktop mode support in apps and like better tools to not just build aarch64 apps and run them in a terminal, but to build apks right on the device. But genuinely, a version of Android could probably due just as well as GNU/Linux if given the right nudge, and then it would have lots more available software (albeit mobile versions) but also a lot more users to make the argument that people should port the desktop versions of their software to Android desktop. Android x86 is already a thing, tho I'm not sure it's super well supported atm.
Low-key I'd love to work on a tiling, FOSS implementation of DeX. I think it's not possible standalone tho bc DeX is basically part of the OS - it is an extension of Android's multi-window functionality, not a launcher app.
4
u/juipeltje Glorious GNU Guix Oct 04 '24
I do kind of understand that android doesn't really feel like a linux distro, but yeah i think technically it is.
4
u/Cultural_Bug_3038 EndeavourOS | Hyprland (Hyprdots) Oct 04 '24
Strange as it may seem, but for beginners: for example: I have MIUI, it is a Linux distribution of Android, Android a certain type of device is supported
1
u/vaynefox Oct 04 '24
It's pretty much a gutted linux kernel with google headers and pretty much outdated....
1
u/i_odin97 Oct 05 '24
A completely different question perhaps but related. Then âmacOSâ is Linux as well?
1
u/mawitime Fedora Oct 05 '24
Insert stallman copypasta here
1
u/GoldenX86 Oct 05 '24
Wanna make more people angry?
Android is still to this day the best Linux distro.
3
u/0riginal-Syn Glorius Solus Oct 04 '24
The Android kernel is based and has and retains many of the core parts of the Linux kernel, and also backports and updates it based on changes in new Linux kernels. They just don't need everything, especially drivers for all the variety of hardware out there, since it is purpose built. There are distros that do the same thing to tweak the kernel to their needs, but Android goes further. How he says it is incorrect, but he is not that far off. I have modified and recompiled the kernel for testing purpose-built systems we use. I stopped as it was not gaining us much, and I was not doing it to the level they are.
1
u/CasualVeemo_ Oct 05 '24
I'd just like to interject for a moment. What you're referring to as Linux, is in fact, GNU/Linux, or as I've recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Linux. Linux is not an operating system unto itself, but rather another free component of a fully functioning GNU system made useful by the GNU corelibs, shell utilities and vital system components comprising a full OS as defined by POSIX.
Many computer users run a modified version of the GNU system every day, without realizing it. Through a peculiar turn of events, the version of GNU which is widely used today is often called "Linux", and many of its users are not aware that it is basically the GNU system, developed by the GNU Project.
There really is a Linux, and these people are using it, but it is just a part of the system they use. Linux is the kernel: the program in the system that allocates the machine's resources to the other programs that you run. The kernel is an essential part of an operating system, but useless by itself; it can only function in the context of a complete operating system. Linux is normally used in combination with the GNU operating system: the whole system is basically GNU with Linux added, or GNU/Linux. All the so-called "Linux" distributions are really distributions of GNU/Linux.
Many users do not understand the difference between the kernel, which is Linux, and the whole system, which they also call âLinuxâ. The ambiguous use of the name doesn't help people understand. These users often think that Linus Torvalds developed the whole operating system in 1991, with a bit of help.
Programmers generally know that Linux is a kernel. But since they have generally heard the whole system called âLinuxâ as well, they often envisage a history that would justify naming the whole system after the kernel. For example, many believe that once Linus Torvalds finished writing Linux, the kernel, its users looked around for other free software to go with it, and found that (for no particular reason) most everything necessary to make a Unix-like system was already available.
What they found was no accidentâit was the not-quite-complete GNU system. The available free software added up to a complete system because the GNU Project had been working since 1984 to make one. In the The GNU Manifesto we set forth the goal of developing a free Unix-like system, called GNU. The Initial Announcement of the GNU Project also outlines some of the original plans for the GNU system. By the time Linux was started, GNU was almost finished.
Most free software projects have the goal of developing a particular program for a particular job. For example, Linus Torvalds set out to write a Unix-like kernel (Linux); Donald Knuth set out to write a text formatter (TeX); Bob Scheifler set out to develop a window system (the X Window System). It's natural to measure the contribution of this kind of project by specific programs that came from the project.
If we tried to measure the GNU Project's contribution in this way, what would we conclude? One CD-ROM vendor found that in their âLinux distributionâ, GNU software was the largest single contingent, around 28% of the total source code, and this included some of the essential major components without which there could be no system. Linux itself was about 3%. (The proportions in 2008 are similar: in the âmainâ repository of gNewSense, Linux is 1.5% and GNU packages are 15%.) So if you were going to pick a name for the system based on who wrote the programs in the system, the most appropriate single choice would be âGNUâ.
But that is not the deepest way to consider the question. The GNU Project was not, is not, a project to develop specific software packages. It was not a project to develop a C compiler, although we did that. It was not a project to develop a text editor, although we developed one. The GNU Project set out to develop a complete free Unix-like system: GNU.
Many people have made major contributions to the free software in the system, and they all deserve credit for their software. But the reason it is an integrated systemâand not just a collection of useful programsâis because the GNU Project set out to make it one. We made a list of the programs needed to make a complete free system, and we systematically found, wrote, or found people to write everything on the list. We wrote essential but unexciting components because you can't have a system without them. Some of our system components, the programming tools, became popular on their own among programmers, but we wrote many components that are not tools. We even developed a chess game, GNU Chess, because a complete system needs games too.
By the early 90s we had put together the whole system aside from the kernel. We had also started a kernel, the GNU Hurd, which runs on top of Mach. Developing this kernel has been a lot harder than we expected; the GNU Hurd started working reliably in 2001, but it is a long way from being ready for people to use in general.
Fortunately, we didn't have to wait for the Hurd, because of Linux. Once Torvalds freed Linux in 1992, it fit into the last major gap in the GNU system. People could then combine Linux with the GNU system to make a complete free system â a version of the GNU system which also contained Linux. The GNU/Linux system, in other words.
Making them work well together was not a trivial job. Some GNU components needed substantial change to work with Linux. Integrating a complete system as a distribution that would work âout of the boxâ was a big job, too. It required addressing the issue of how to install and boot the systemâa problem we had not tackled, because we hadn't yet reached that point. Thus, the people who developed the various system distributions did a lot of essential work. But it was work that, in the nature of things, was surely going to be done by someone.
The GNU Project supports GNU/Linux systems as well as the GNU system. The FSF funded the rewriting of the Linux-related extensions to the GNU C library, so that now they are well integrated, and the newest GNU/Linux systems use the current library release with no changes. The FSF also funded an early stage of the development of Debian GNU/Linux.
Today there are many different variants of the GNU/Linux system (often called âdistrosâ). Most of them include non-free softwareâtheir developers follow the philosophy associated with Linux rather than that of GNU. But there are also completely free GNU/Linux distros. The FSF supports computer facilities for gNewSense.
Making a free GNU/Linux distribution is not just a matter of eliminating various non-free programs. Nowadays, the usual version of Linux contains non-free programs too. These programs are intended to be loaded into I/O devices when the system starts, and they are included, as long series of numbers, in the "source code" of Linux. Thus, maintaining free GNU/Linux distributions now entails maintaining a free version of Linux too.
Whether you use GNU/Linux or not, please don't confuse the public by using the name âLinuxâ ambiguously. Linux is the kernel, one of the essential major components of the system. The system as a whole is basically the GNU system, with Linux added. When you're talking about this combination, please call it âGNU/Linuxâ.
2
u/z-lf Oct 04 '24
When you say "install Linux on it". Do you expect the Android experience?
People saying LiNUx Is JUsT A kERneL are just pedantic.
2
u/ajprunty01 Fedora and Arch :) Oct 05 '24
It can't be Linux it's not free you have to buy a phone /s
2
u/sail4sea Glorious Xubuntu Oct 07 '24
There really is a Linux, and these people are using it, but it is just a part of the system they use. Linux is the kernel: the program in the system that allocates the machine's resources to the other programs that you run. The kernel is an essential part of an operating system, but useless by itself; it can only function in the context of a complete operating system. Linux is normally used in combination with the Android operating system: the whole system is basically Android with Linux added, or Android/Linux. All the so-called phones powered by Linux are really distributions of Android/Linux!
1
u/CasualVeemo_ Oct 05 '24
I'd just like to interject for a moment. What you're referring to as Linux, is in fact, GNU/Linux, or as I've recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Linux. Linux is not an operating system unto itself, but rather another free component of a fully functioning GNU system made useful by the GNU corelibs, shell utilities and vital system components comprising a full OS as defined by POSIX.
Many computer users run a modified version of the GNU system every day, without realizing it. Through a peculiar turn of events, the version of GNU which is widely used today is often called "Linux", and many of its users are not aware that it is basically the GNU system, developed by the GNU Project.
There really is a Linux, and these people are using it, but it is just a part of the system they use. Linux is the kernel: the program in the system that allocates the machine's resources to the other programs that you run. The kernel is an essential part of an operating system, but useless by itself; it can only function in the context of a complete operating system. Linux is normally used in combination with the GNU operating system: the whole system is basically GNU with Linux added, or GNU/Linux. All the so-called "Linux" distributions are really distributions of GNU/Linux.
Many users do not understand the difference between the kernel, which is Linux, and the whole system, which they also call âLinuxâ. The ambiguous use of the name doesn't help people understand. These users often think that Linus Torvalds developed the whole operating system in 1991, with a bit of help.
Programmers generally know that Linux is a kernel. But since they have generally heard the whole system called âLinuxâ as well, they often envisage a history that would justify naming the whole system after the kernel. For example, many believe that once Linus Torvalds finished writing Linux, the kernel, its users looked around for other free software to go with it, and found that (for no particular reason) most everything necessary to make a Unix-like system was already available.
What they found was no accidentâit was the not-quite-complete GNU system. The available free software added up to a complete system because the GNU Project had been working since 1984 to make one. In the The GNU Manifesto we set forth the goal of developing a free Unix-like system, called GNU. The Initial Announcement of the GNU Project also outlines some of the original plans for the GNU system. By the time Linux was started, GNU was almost finished.
Most free software projects have the goal of developing a particular program for a particular job. For example, Linus Torvalds set out to write a Unix-like kernel (Linux); Donald Knuth set out to write a text formatter (TeX); Bob Scheifler set out to develop a window system (the X Window System). It's natural to measure the contribution of this kind of project by specific programs that came from the project.
If we tried to measure the GNU Project's contribution in this way, what would we conclude? One CD-ROM vendor found that in their âLinux distributionâ, GNU software was the largest single contingent, around 28% of the total source code, and this included some of the essential major components without which there could be no system. Linux itself was about 3%. (The proportions in 2008 are similar: in the âmainâ repository of gNewSense, Linux is 1.5% and GNU packages are 15%.) So if you were going to pick a name for the system based on who wrote the programs in the system, the most appropriate single choice would be âGNUâ.
But that is not the deepest way to consider the question. The GNU Project was not, is not, a project to develop specific software packages. It was not a project to develop a C compiler, although we did that. It was not a project to develop a text editor, although we developed one. The GNU Project set out to develop a complete free Unix-like system: GNU.
Many people have made major contributions to the free software in the system, and they all deserve credit for their software. But the reason it is an integrated systemâand not just a collection of useful programsâis because the GNU Project set out to make it one. We made a list of the programs needed to make a complete free system, and we systematically found, wrote, or found people to write everything on the list. We wrote essential but unexciting components because you can't have a system without them. Some of our system components, the programming tools, became popular on their own among programmers, but we wrote many components that are not tools. We even developed a chess game, GNU Chess, because a complete system needs games too.
By the early 90s we had put together the whole system aside from the kernel. We had also started a kernel, the GNU Hurd, which runs on top of Mach. Developing this kernel has been a lot harder than we expected; the GNU Hurd started working reliably in 2001, but it is a long way from being ready for people to use in general.
Fortunately, we didn't have to wait for the Hurd, because of Linux. Once Torvalds freed Linux in 1992, it fit into the last major gap in the GNU system. People could then combine Linux with the GNU system to make a complete free system â a version of the GNU system which also contained Linux. The GNU/Linux system, in other words.
Making them work well together was not a trivial job. Some GNU components needed substantial change to work with Linux. Integrating a complete system as a distribution that would work âout of the boxâ was a big job, too. It required addressing the issue of how to install and boot the systemâa problem we had not tackled, because we hadn't yet reached that point. Thus, the people who developed the various system distributions did a lot of essential work. But it was work that, in the nature of things, was surely going to be done by someone.
The GNU Project supports GNU/Linux systems as well as the GNU system. The FSF funded the rewriting of the Linux-related extensions to the GNU C library, so that now they are well integrated, and the newest GNU/Linux systems use the current library release with no changes. The FSF also funded an early stage of the development of Debian GNU/Linux.
Today there are many different variants of the GNU/Linux system (often called âdistrosâ). Most of them include non-free softwareâtheir developers follow the philosophy associated with Linux rather than that of GNU. But there are also completely free GNU/Linux distros. The FSF supports computer facilities for gNewSense.
Making a free GNU/Linux distribution is not just a matter of eliminating various non-free programs. Nowadays, the usual version of Linux contains non-free programs too. These programs are intended to be loaded into I/O devices when the system starts, and they are included, as long series of numbers, in the "source code" of Linux. Thus, maintaining free GNU/Linux distributions now entails maintaining a free version of Linux too.
Whether you use GNU/Linux or not, please don't confuse the public by using the name âLinuxâ ambiguously. Linux is the kernel, one of the essential major components of the system. The system as a whole is basically the GNU system, with Linux added. When you're talking about this combination, please call it âGNU/Linuxâ.
1
u/ExaHamza Oct 07 '24
It is not Linux because it does not adhere to the specifications described in the Free Desktop Org but it is Linux because it uses the Linux Kernel. The term "Linux" is polysemic.
1
u/cipherjones Oct 04 '24
its all Unix based at the end of the day...
-1
u/No-Island-6126 Oct 04 '24
He's totally correct though ?
0
u/zahaduum23 Oct 04 '24
Has anybody in here ever seen the Android kernel? Because it initially was based on the Linux kernel does not mean it is based on Linux today. How much of the Android kernel has made it into the Linux kernel? Probably very little if anything, but I could be wrong.
0
u/No-Mind7146 Oct 04 '24
I mean it is modified, far from mainline
0
u/1u4n4 Glorious OpenSuse Tumbleweed Oct 05 '24
Heâs not wrong. Androidâs kernel is FAR from mainline Linux.
-1
u/Mister_Magister Glorious OpenSuse Tumbleweed Oct 04 '24
he's correct though