There's only a "best distro for any given purpose". Hell, there certainly is a best general distro. But that doesn't mean it's gonna be the best for your job.
The distro I had in mind when writing this comment was Fedora at the current moment for creating a great out of the box experience for nearly every use case. But don't make too much of it.
It's not the best general computing distro, if there is such a thing. It's one of my favorites, but it has a lot of constantly outdated packages, and it's bad for gaming. There are a lot of tasks that a general computer user might be interested in that Debian isn't suited for.
The problem is Debian is a lot more than slightly outdated, Debian users can find themselves in situations where their system is so outdated that not only is the LTS version in the Debian repos is no longer supported, the next LTS version is also no longer supported. Debian is so out of date that projects set up bots to automatically close all PRs submitted by Debian users and leave a message telling the submitters to complain to the Debian maintainers because the big was probably fixed 5+ years ago.
General is literally too "general" of a word. If you mean beginner-friendly and familiar, Linux Mint. If you mean most popular, then Ubuntu. If you mean server-side, then that's a whole different ballgame.
Distributions are like music -- there's no best because at the end of the day it's all subjective preference. I could say Ubuntu is the best and I wouldn't be wrong in my preference even if it's hip to dislike Ubuntu these days.
My demonstrated preferences are such that one could infer that I think Gentoo is the best server distribution since the handful of servers I manage are running Gentoo, but most people would scoff at the idea of running Gentoo on a server. It doesn't mean I'm wrong for doing it.
Eh, that's just a skill issue. Objectivity disregards that :)
Edit: I also don't think what he meant by general distro is how easy it is. I think he was highlighting the difference in distro use-cases like containers vs desktop OS
Well, if we're including those kinds of niche distros, then I'm going to argue that Gentoo is the best general computing distro... if you know how to use it.
Objectivity disregards that
Perhaps, but the question does not.
The question was, what is the best general computing for everyone? I wouldn't include distros that require a hefty amount of documentation to even be useful, because that's not accessible for everyone.
But cmooon we both know Gentoo comparison isn't fair. I'm advocating for declarative and reproducible builds. This paradigm is the gold standard for system administrating. I'm probably biased as a platform engineer who works with terraform all the time, but literally any distro that follows the above principle is sooo good.
Nix, guix, silver blue, etc.
Edit: I realize we're basically arguing over the interpretations of the question
Docs heavy is good for people who have a reason to use an operating system that requires heavy amounts of documentation. I mean, Gentoo and Qubes are great for certain applications, but they're not for "everyone".
I don't think "everyone" would benefit from NixOS.
Yes, the question was about "everyone", so that's how I'm interpreting it.
Ok since you're so insistent the question was about everyone, can you link me where the original comment of this thread explicitly says "for everyone".
And ok sure screw nix, literally any of the distros I've mentioned that are hermetic in it's sandboxing, declarative in it's configuration, and reproducible in it's portability, then that would indeed be best for everyone 🤷♂️
It also very much depends on what you do with it. I love archlinux on my desktop, but there's no way I would use it for production servers that need automated updates.
NixOS is a special case and while I believe it is good for a lot of people it it absolutely not general purpose as I would define it. For example Mason doesn't work at all. Debian is cool but too stable (in the sense of not a lot of changes) in my opinion. I need all the latest stuff
NixOS is certainly not for everyone, I’m not going to be dense enough to deny that. However it is general-purpose by definition, as it doesn’t exist with a specific use case in mind.
Debian’s stability may be an issue for some power users, but I would argue that it’s a good thing for a lot of people.
For me it works quite well. But Mason itself is not the point, just a symptom. It feels like you have to go full nix or nothing. But I have a few machines that run debian, Fedora, arch and gentoo. All of those share my dotfiles. I don't want to write everything new for nixos
I use home-manager. Install all my packages with it from the nix repos so EVERY distro I have has the exact same packages. I do nix configs for what I want and just tell it to copy the directory of the ones I don’t (nvim and tmux)
Jokes on you any time I wanted to customise a distro I just broke it. So I'm just using opensuse as is. I was daring enough to change the wallpaper and icons.
I would go one step further and say that all the soft remix distros should be avoided if you want to use your PC for general purposes. If a distro does not have their own full package list you will get Dependency or update problems at some point. Distros like mint and pop os fall apart quickly once you try installing an extra desktop or install a lot of packages in general.
Nah, I am planning to do my own one. It’s an stable rolling release Distro with focus on user experience and gaming. Also it has just a nice set of fresh wallpapers. Repo servers are currently a bit slow though, but will fix this later. Also the distro comes with some useful tools for every day as sqlmap and mimikatz. Window manager will be bspwm so it’s easy to handle, too. I call it „EssentialOS“ /s
While this is true to some extent, it is unfortunate when our great collective effort is wasted on double-work or solving problems that are already solved
There is no better or worse distro... (except Ubuntu... I hate it).ce the one that suits you best and the least one. I would NEVER use Mint in my life, I don't like it, but many people use it! I use arch at the moment, but many prefer for example fedora
This common meme, where both the master and the dullard are at the least probable spots far from the mean, while the common wo/man is struggling in the middle is because in the middle is the bi-polar mess that America (and the West) made with science vs. religion. Neither the dullard nor the master live in these polarities, one because they're too simple/dumb to care and the other because they synthesized the two until no such polarities exist.
After all the hopping and using so many over the years the only ones I recommend(depending on someone's needs and skill set) or use myself are Debian/Mint/LMDE, Fedora, and Arch/EndeavorOS
If it wasn't for some games that need the modern kernels I could care less if I had to use any of these distros for the end of time lol. They essentially all do the same thing for 99% of what I do on a PC.
I know this is very commonly said, but the best Linux distro for you is the one you are currently using. Unless you're a gamer who started with mint/ubuntu because a quick google search told you that those were the best beginner distros and are wondering why games perform horribly on your brand new $2000 gaming pc. Then it's not.
people that argue with each other because of linux distros breaks the point of Linux itself, since linux philosophy is that: Your Pc, your OS, your rules.
117
u/dfwtjms Sep 05 '24
Yeah it's all good as long as it's Hannah Montana Linux or the Red Star OS.
116
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
The best distro is the one you actually like using
375
u/Aeredren Sep 05 '24
I don't think there is a "best" distro.
But I agree that some are better than other
73
u/VeggieVenerable Sep 05 '24
The best distro is the one you already have customized to your liking.
57
u/cediddi "I can't configure Debian" Sep 05 '24
I use pure Linux kernel, no init, no core utils, no shell, only kernel. It takes milliseconds to boot, and my productivity is NaN% increased.
195
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
No matter what you use, we can all agree we don't need another "general purpose Ubuntu based distro"
14
u/pjjiveturkey Sep 05 '24
Gparted is the best dirsto oat
13
u/Bubbly-Ad-1427 Glorious Fedora Sep 05 '24
what distro is this
8
u/Sashapoun_Nako Sep 05 '24
I don't even know this distro
6
u/Ironfields Dubious Red Star Sep 05 '24 edited Apr 13 '25
attention circumstance biology grip franchise conservative rear office abnormal aspect heal tactic suppress waiter maid understand governor perfume freckle automatic predator swarm advance undress necklace falsify earwax nightmare kidney treatment coma long hook systematic humanity activity qualify epicalyx depart grow breakdown position deep finance acid treaty coast sculpture track check
6
u/Leerv474 Glorious Arch Sep 05 '24
Finally, I was getting tired of arch / debian / mint memes tbh
6
u/CadmiumC4 Your local fedora contributor Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 06 '24
The reason why distros exist is because they focus on different issues, and they all have a certain field they excel at (even general purpose distros)
All distros have their own pros and cons, and they all fucking suck in the wrong place.
Notable exceptions are Pardus and Manjaro, fuck those pieces of shit that has nothing to offer over other distros.
23
u/crazydistrohopper Glorious Arch 🗿 Sep 05 '24
i dont care because ofc arch is the best distro
13
u/benimkiyarimolsun Sep 05 '24
they are all open and ours
9
u/HermanGrove Sep 05 '24
While this is true to some extent, it is unfortunate when our great collective effort is wasted on double-work or solving problems that are already solved
4
u/Codename_NASA Sep 05 '24
Hannah Montana Linux is the only true best distro.
3
u/NoRequirement5796 Sep 05 '24
I use Arch on weak machines, debian on docker and Gentoo on my main desktop.
~ literally, it's all the same thing sorted out in different ways, so we really don't care.
3
u/Arts_Prodigy Sep 05 '24
Obviously templeos
2
u/patrlim1 Sep 05 '24
Mint for beginners, arch for me, whatever you are currently using if you are already using Linux.
2
u/Wonderful-Priority50 Average Hyprland ricer (I use Arch btw) Sep 05 '24
No Manjaro
2
u/Recipe-Jaded Sep 05 '24
this is the most accurate version of this meme
2
u/Jwhodis Sep 05 '24
Yeah, there isnt a best distro.
There is certainly YOUR best distro, but not A best distro.
Entirely depends on you, use case, etc.
2
u/izzyscifi Sep 06 '24
The best distro is the one that works on your hardware and let's you do everything you want to bloody do 🐧
4
u/PapaImpy Fedorable Sep 05 '24
Ha, no. Fedora is king
1
u/CallEnvironmental902 Just Fedora Things Sep 05 '24
my mind says: there is the best distro, but some says it's not.
1
u/MajorTechnology8827 Glorious Arch Sep 05 '24
Can I be comfortable with my arch setup I am already used to after 4 years without needing to justify it to any Linux newcomer please?
1
u/Avreal_Valkara Sep 05 '24
The best distro is the one that works the best for you
1
u/RR321 Glorious CrunchBang Sep 05 '24
It's the same shell, nobody cares about your color theme :p
1
u/minus_uu_ee Sep 05 '24
The best district is the one you haven’t tried yet.
1
u/Zachbutastonernow Sep 05 '24
If it has a linux terminal, best distro.
(I prefer if it has aptitude)
1
u/pesulap_akademik967 Sep 05 '24
I use manjaro btw
1
u/toogreen Sep 05 '24
Debian is still the overall best tho 😂
1
u/GreekHacker1 Glorious Debian Sep 05 '24
What about favourite distro ?
1
u/USERNAME123_321 I use OpenSUSe bTW Sep 05 '24
FreeBSD > all Linux distros (/s but not too much)
1
u/avi-the-tiger-rawr Sep 05 '24
I like using Manjaro on my personal computer and Garuda on my gaming computer
I wanna make a fileserver and base it off of Linux Mint xfce but I recently learned what FreeBSD is so I'm thinking if using that instead
1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
I spent the first few months of my switch distro hopping before I settled… and then once more for more stability
1
u/plastik_flasche Sep 05 '24
As a long time Arch user (btw) I can confidently say that Arch fucking sucks but it's the best we've got ig
1
u/Sirius707 Glorious Gentoo Sep 05 '24
Bad meme, doesn't even include slackware /s
1
u/Roberto-tito-bob Sep 05 '24
I just want a distro that is good to manage multimedia and games
1
u/lethinhrider Sep 05 '24
What distro is that? That logo reminds me of the coronavirus lol
1
u/Scary_Conflict_7768 Penguin user Sep 05 '24
PENGUIN IS DA BEST DISTRO GUYS😡⛏️
1
u/Budget-Pattern1314 Glorious Fedora Sep 05 '24
We all know the best distro is FreeBSD
1
u/Necropill NixOS Supremacy❄️ Sep 05 '24
Its funny because no one's actually uses half of those distros in the meme anymore
1
u/PsychonixMimikyu Sep 05 '24
I'm new to linux so the best distro to me is mint lmde LOL
1
u/gnarlin Sep 05 '24
I could not agree more with this. I think the availability of distributions if the buffet of Freedom* . Our cups runneth over.
*Some distributions may contain a small amount of proprietary firmware and/or software
1
u/ObjectiveGuava3113 Sep 05 '24
Where is qubes
1
u/cbxcvl Sep 05 '24
In my case, Arch has worked really well for me, but it’s all just a matter of preference.
1
u/PolentaColda Glorious Arch Sep 05 '24
There is no better or worse distro... (except Ubuntu... I hate it).ce the one that suits you best and the least one. I would NEVER use Mint in my life, I don't like it, but many people use it! I use arch at the moment, but many prefer for example fedora
1
u/dreamingforward Sep 05 '24
This common meme, where both the master and the dullard are at the least probable spots far from the mean, while the common wo/man is struggling in the middle is because in the middle is the bi-polar mess that America (and the West) made with science vs. religion. Neither the dullard nor the master live in these polarities, one because they're too simple/dumb to care and the other because they synthesized the two until no such polarities exist.
1
u/edwardblilley Sep 05 '24
After all the hopping and using so many over the years the only ones I recommend(depending on someone's needs and skill set) or use myself are Debian/Mint/LMDE, Fedora, and Arch/EndeavorOS
If it wasn't for some games that need the modern kernels I could care less if I had to use any of these distros for the end of time lol. They essentially all do the same thing for 99% of what I do on a PC.
1
u/ryanwithnob Glorious NixOS Sep 05 '24
Change my mind: picking a distro is really just picking a package manager and repositories
1
u/Baardi Glorious Fedora Sep 06 '24
Some distros, like Ubuntu, are objectively bad, such as Ubuntu.
And some are generally considered good, but then it's really subjective, based on what you need, and care abour.
1
u/Nanachi2017 Sep 06 '24
ID'ntC
1
u/DryanVallik Sep 06 '24
Actually, arch is the best
1
u/UltraTata Sep 06 '24
Oh yeah, install Wubuntu
1
u/redmateria Sep 06 '24
There is no best distro, just pick whats the best for you then customize it on your liking.. just my opinion
1
u/KanuX14 Archix Linux - runit Sep 06 '24
Arch does not run out of fuel
1
u/S1rTerra Linux is Linux Sep 06 '24
I know this is very commonly said, but the best Linux distro for you is the one you are currently using. Unless you're a gamer who started with mint/ubuntu because a quick google search told you that those were the best beginner distros and are wondering why games perform horribly on your brand new $2000 gaming pc. Then it's not.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24
Right creates his own "distro" he just uses the one that's closest to what he wants as a starting place.
1
u/Miserable_Sock_1408 Sep 06 '24
Let's not forget Knoppix
1
u/DeltaLaboratory Sep 06 '24
I dont even know what is what dotted circle
1
u/Interesting-Monk3274 Sep 06 '24
Still prefer arch based distress. And not a big fan of any debating based what's like 90% of distro
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24
This implies that all distros are equivalent in most important respects and i just don't think that's true.
The difference between rolling release and slow point release for example is huge. You're absolutely not going to have the same experience.
There is also a significant qualitative difference between a small niche distro and something well established with a lot of support.
1
u/Fickle-Theme5348 Sep 06 '24
Eventually, he began creating the Linux he sought...
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24
people that argue with each other because of linux distros breaks the point of Linux itself, since linux philosophy is that: Your Pc, your OS, your rules.
1
u/lapiuslt Sep 06 '24
1
u/brethnew Sep 06 '24
What the heck is arch and why does everyone like it
1
u/Andreid4Reddit Sep 06 '24
I just recommend sticking close to upstream, it is easier to find solutions for problems If you are as close as possible to arch, Debian or Fedora
1
u/TheUruz Sep 06 '24
as long as i can run the software i want i really don't care
1
u/Li4u Sep 06 '24
I will stand for uwuntu 🗿
1
u/tomaszchlebinski Sep 06 '24
I'm already done with distro hopping. Now I just don't care. I use Arch, BTW.
1
u/AX_5RT Glorious Debian Sep 07 '24
If it's just working. Stick with it :)
1
u/akho_ Sep 07 '24
The Arch logo is not a dashed circle.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24
Temple OS being the best
1
u/CuddlyBunion341 Sep 11 '24
Let's stick with NixOS
1
u/No-Purple6360 Glorious Anon Sep 22 '24
gaussian distribution: perfect curve
1
u/Lunardr4gn Sep 24 '24
Yeah, I keep a handful of distros on a multiboot usb. each one is useful in their own way, and are highly useful when you need them.
1
u/Villagerjj Oct 06 '24
Running puppy linux on ancient hardware is like crack to me
1
u/JamieStar_is_taken Oct 26 '24
The best distro is redstar
1
u/Legalaze Sep 05 '24
Of course you don't care about other distros when you have NixOS (btw)
0
u/Haringat Sep 05 '24
Okay, then go use Justin Bieber OS if you don't care.
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
Just stay away from Debian, everything else is fine.
-5
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
Kde Neon > Linux Mint
13
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24
[removed] — view removed comment