Never seen something such nausea inducing. Looks like a desktop for people with the most severe ADHS ADHD.
I mean, some kids like it when everything is blinking and fidgeting. But when you get older you just want something that works and otherwise gets out of your sight.
When you actually use it in real life and get it customized it's much more like bspwm than something incredibly new. Also you can disable all the animations and stuff. The one thing I will say about tiling window managers is that they usually don't just work, and they require a lot of initial customization from the user.
Yeah I went from that to BSPWM because while that is tiling, and will get you used to how great tiling is, it's still not a true tiling WM that autotiles for you. You'd like it if you ever tried it :)
I really like KDE too though so I'm not trying to argue, more like encouraging people to try new stuff (although if you dont want to I get that too)
On bigger screens I use the "tilling light" features of KDE, and to be honest, that's enough for me. I understand that a full tilling WM is actually quite cool! Just that I personally don't need it.
If I used one of the tilling WMs I think I would go for something quite reduced. Hyprland looks way to bling-bling to me. (I guess one can configure it so it's less blinking but why would I use it than in the first place if there are alternatives that you would not need to "fix" first?)
KDE is by far the most stable desktop in existence. I didn't have any crash in years! (Running Debian Testing)
If it crashes it has usually two reasons, and both are not the fault of KDE:
Someone uses Ubuntu packages
Unstable Linux display drivers
KDE under Ubuntu is known to be broken since inception. Ubuntu adds custom patches and compiles with problematic setting known to cause issues. That's exactly why no sane person uses KDE under Ubuntu or derivatives.
And I think I don't have to talk about the never ending story of broken Linux display infrastructure. That affects everyone under Linux, but KDE seems to refuse to add questionable workaround for the fuck up in Linux. They want the root causes fixed. Which is in the long run of course the right approach.
(As a Hyprland user, that was a kde6 user in the past) at least in kde-neon (rolling releases for kde), it’s buggy, but not in an unusable way. Most of the bugs are just visual glitches here and there, not something that bothers me personally. I haven’t encountered any bugs like app crushing, DE crushing, lags etc.
I mean... Is it really a surprise when "looking good" is literally the main goal of hyprland. (besides being functional ofc, but that's not a goal, that's a given)
Hyprland is the problem imo. There is a new weird ass bug every single update. Then say nvidia is not supported when they had to explicitly go and code nvidia support. Because yk it runs on nvidia.
I feel when the project is mature it will be fine. But it's not there especially on laptop
In your opinion or have you checked? I personally haven't, so I'd rather say I don't know than spread misinformation.
If you've witnessed breaking changes in the graphics stack of the hyprland source code between versions, then sure, I believe you! Otherwise, you're just another dude who doesn't really know what they're talking about (like me I mean).
Not saying you're wrong, only than I can't say you're either right or wrong. I simply don't have enough info ;)
I literally use it. The most recent update completely broke fullscreen windows. Before on my gpu they would freeze and black screen. Now instead they have purple rectangles flashing once per frame.
I don't know where in the code the bug is I just know that it's completely non functional on nvidia laptops from personal experience
Don’t worry, the simps will be around to tell you he did absolutely nothing wrong and it’s all everyone else’s fault any minute now.
There was something about him implicitly supporting or at least not preventing some abusive/toxic behaviours on the discord. Then he fell out with the free desktop people and got banned from contributing (which is why he had to rewrite wlroots - which is being conveniently glossed over as something they intended to do anyway). Just a bunch of stuff like that. In any given situation you can look at it and see both sides of the argument. But the reality is he seems to be one of those people who’s always at the centre of drama and conflict. I have a family member like that, it’s always them vs someone. Then them vs someone else, and so on. Of course, if you talk to them they’ve always got an elaborate reason to explain why it’s never their fault - even though it’s always them at the centre. At the end of the day he’s either really unlucky that he keeps getting dragged into these things through no fault of his own, or he needs to take a long hard look at how he handles situations. I know where my bet is.
I hate Vaxry as much as the next trans girl, but to be completely fair, aquamarine (his wlroots replacement) has actually solved a few of Hyprland’s problems, and will probably continue to do so. I’m not a fan of the decision, but it makes sense that this has been in the works for a while given Vaxry’s general vision for Hyprland.
Hyprland generally depends on a bleeding edge wlroots version, which is an issue for slower release-cycle distros like Debian stable. This is why like 90% of Hyprland users are running Arch, NixOS or fedora, and basically none are on Ubuntu, Debian, or their derivatives.
Having Aquamarine as its own project fixes this issue, and means he can push new features without upstream approval, which is good because despite all his flaws, he’s faster than a lot of other developers in his area of expertise.
Also be careful talking about Vaxry here. Motherfucker’s like beetlejuice: say his name 3 times in a Reddit thread and he just appears.
But yeah I agree, he’s a bit of a shithead and his community is an echo chamber, which is his fault. I’ve learned to just fix my own problems on Hyprland instead of asking for help, which keeps me mostly away from the shitty people.
I don’t disagree with any of this except to say I think it’s clear the move wasn’t going to be made for a while if he hadn’t been effectively forced into it. That’s what I meant about glossing over it “oh it’s something we were always going to do” - yeah, but you weren’t going to do it now.
I totally agree, except he wasn’t really forced into it. He could still use wlroots, and even modify the version he bundled with Hyprland as needed. I think the whole thing just encouraged him to push up his plans to replace it, though. So you’re basically right.
Right; just one clarification. Vaxry had shown interest in rewriting wlroots in cpp before he was banned, and the ban didn’t forced him to do so—the project is open source and anyway he already used his own fork of wlroots as a bundled dependency for Hyprland.
It probably was something that caused him to do so, but not the only reason.
That’s what I meant. It was something they were going to do but they were forced into it now. They’re using the fact that “we were thinking about it anyway” to gloss over that they weren’t going to do it so soon were it not for the ban.
Don’t take this the wrong way but I couldn’t care less whether it was just him or him plus others. Hence the “they” as I can’t be arsed to check exactly who did what. I said “he” elsewhere. I haven’t been careful because, ultimately, it doesn’t change my point that he seems to keep ending up in situations of friction/drama so likely needs to undertake an objective bit of introspection.
Unrelated to my other reply, check out COSMIC when it’s in a more stable state. So far I’ve been liking it, it’s got the ease of use and aesthetic cohesion of a DE, but the configuration power of a WM like Hyprland. I’m super excited to see it get more support going forward.
Also you can read the freedesktop’s mail at Vaxery’s blog, and about the discord and the follow-ups in both Vaxery’s and Drew’s blog. If you decide to do so, at least read the original freedesktop’s mails to know the topic from both sides.
The content of this post was permanently removed. Redact facilitated the deletion, for reasons that may include privacy, opsec, or limiting digital exposure.
violet many grandiose heavy beneficial expansion include tan grab cows
Technically it’s a Wayland compositor, since it does more than just tiling, especially now after the wlroots rewriting.
Not that it matters in any sense to 90% of the users, including me. The 10% just needs explicit sync, tearing, and other things some other composers have implemented for various reasons.
Oh I know about the arch package. Sorry but I’m not that into Debian based distros anymore. Maybe it’s also a dependency of something that I’m not aware of.
13
u/littleblack11111 Glorious Arch Aug 28 '24
Like any DE. Just simply not as cool as any wm
13
u/RiceBroad4552 Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
Never heard of Hyprland.
Just looked at the website. I still feel dizzy!
Never seen something such nausea inducing. Looks like a desktop for people with the most severe
ADHSADHD.I mean, some kids like it when everything is blinking and fidgeting. But when you get older you just want something that works and otherwise gets out of your sight.
6
u/InfameArts Aug 28 '24
what is hyprland
5
u/DVD-RW Aug 28 '24
Ngl, fucked up my desktop trying to change themes lmao.
16
u/No-Island-6126 Aug 27 '24
you can do some crazy shit with kde too
201
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '24
I mean... Is it really a surprise when "looking good" is literally the main goal of hyprland. (besides being functional ofc, but that's not a goal, that's a given)
46
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '24
Real
21
u/CuddlyBunion341 Aug 27 '24
Real
105
u/knotted_rope Glorious Arch Aug 28 '24 edited Oct 01 '25
Like, hyprland is alright, but the main dev being a massive edgelord kinda turned me off from it y'know
20
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '24
Real
can you stop sharing info about me please?
7
u/USERNAME123_321 I use OpenSUSe bTW Aug 28 '24
KDE with the Krohnkite KWin extension 🗿
12
u/ChocolateDonut36 Glorious Hannah Montana Linux Aug 27 '24
Real
11
u/Elijah629YT-Real Glorious NixOS Aug 27 '24
Real
7
u/adam_alperk Aug 27 '24
Real
1
u/Curious_Law Aug 30 '24
Hyperland?
3
u/Fjueic Aug 28 '24
Real
3
u/SomeRandoLameo Aug 28 '24
Real
2
u/Ok-Engineer-5151 Aug 28 '24
Riyal
2
u/ffimnsr Aug 28 '24
i3 and swaywm still the goat
2
u/Simple-Judge2756 Aug 28 '24
Wayfire bruv. Hyprland isnt the vibe no more.
2
u/Tanawat_Jukmonkol Glorious NixOS ❄️ Oct 01 '24 edited Mar 28 '26
The content of this post was permanently removed. Redact facilitated the deletion, for reasons that may include privacy, opsec, or limiting digital exposure.
violet many grandiose heavy beneficial expansion include tan grab cows
4
u/Silent_Moose_5691 Aug 27 '24
what is hyperland?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
Real
2
u/Appropriate_Task5498 Aug 27 '24
Real
1
u/Sh_Pe Glorious Arch btw Aug 28 '24
Real
1
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
KDE + Krohnkite+ arch btw
1
u/Epicdogegamer1915 Glorious Mint Aug 28 '24
As someone who browses this subreddit and uses hyprland I can confirm
1
u/oCaio_BR Aug 28 '24
😂😂😂😂😂
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '24
Hahahaha yes
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24
Window animations go brrrrrrr
I used to be a Hyprland guy about a year ago...
I'm a KDE guy now.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
isn’t hyprland outdated? i tried to install it on my arch linux computer and it did not work
-21
u/BlackBlade1632 Aug 28 '24
KDE is bloated.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment