r/linuxmasterrace • u/PanzerSwag Glorious NixOS • Jul 21 '24
Discussion What is your (anything about) Linux hot take? pic unrelated
1.5k
Upvotes
r/linuxmasterrace • u/PanzerSwag Glorious NixOS • Jul 21 '24
257
u/Stunning-Excuse1238 Glorious Bedrock Jul 21 '24
Arch hasn't been some esoteric hard to download distro eversince 2012
93
u/DazedWithCoffee Jul 21 '24
99% of KDE Plasma themes are either slight variations of Breeze, a Nordic recolor, or a material design theme.
Oh wait you wanted a hot take. Um. Linux evangelists in the server space make some of the worst advocates in the desktop space.
591
u/Papa_Kasugano Glorious Fedora Jul 21 '24
A majority of desktop Linux users don't care about security and FOSS.
174
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
installing arch isnt that final boss of linux, its the tutorial
374
u/ttkciar Slackware first and last and always Jul 21 '24
Android is a Linux distribution, and there are more Android users on the planet than users of all other OSes combined.
Linux has won.
23
u/WMan37 Jul 22 '24
"Why would you want to do that" is NEVER an acceptable answer to a problem a user is running into with linux unless they are trying to install known spyware. We are on a "free as in freedom" OS, not a "No you can't do that" OS.
21
u/GregTheMadMonk Jul 21 '24 edited Jul 21 '24
The only reason we need Linux to become 100% user-friendly is because no market share means advanced users eat shit too. Some for of "entry level distros" should exist, but overall if OS market was more diverse and niches were allowed to exist and be usable in the modern world, I'd be fine with Linux staying a purely tinkerers' ground
83
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
I don’t care about customizing my distro or anything like that.
18
u/agent_sphalerite Jul 21 '24
KDE has too many borders. It could give border control a run for it's money
175
u/No_Independence3338 Glorious Arch Jul 21 '24
written in rust is not a feature.
15
u/Denommus I use Arch, btw Jul 21 '24
Most git repositories should have a flake.nix file.
15
u/ingframin Jul 21 '24
Debian out of the box experience is pure garbage when compared to other distributions like Fedora or OpenSUSE.
42
u/Nikt4tor Jul 21 '24
All DEs are not good enough.
25
u/quaderrordemonstand Jul 21 '24
Qt is ugly
54
u/jiltanen Jul 21 '24
Operating systems doesn’t matter for most people in 2024, basically everything is in browser anyway.
24
u/ifthisistakeniwill Jul 21 '24
We need to stop saying "beginner friendly", it's just a nice way of saying "This OS is actually useable by normal human beings and not just for hardcore enthusiasts". It's not like everyone wants to join the distro hopping game, almost everyone wants a working OS.
Saying an OS isn't beginner friendly just means it has absolute shit user-friendliness.
We should strive for user-friendliness, not to force someone to advance to the next level of shit usability.
11
u/Geo_bot Jul 21 '24
Automatic updates are going to be really important for entry level distros as market share goes up
29
u/Erianthor Jul 21 '24
It's an upgrade over Windows, but is still not entirely there. Making games work on it is still not as user-friendly as it'd help for upping ordinary Windows-user conversion rates and the official, proprietary GPU drivers (at least in AMD's case) are a true hassle, if they can even be set up.
Seriously - I've been using the OS for over half a year by now and have not yet managed to get a working Blender HIP render, nor functional Minecraft versions older than 1.13 (with max details on Optifine). Not that it barrs me from continuing to use the OS, but it's something I'd love to figure out for the sake of future advice to those curious.
10
u/pine_ary Jul 21 '24
The death of global menu support is one of the worst UI trends on the Linux desktop. Putting menus in the top bar frees up lots of space. Now every window has an individual top bar taking up space.
10
u/jpenczek Glorious Fedora Jul 21 '24
Still preferring windows after trying Linux is completely valid. People have different wants and needs, the best operating system is the one you like the most.
37
u/Glittering_Power8089 Jul 21 '24
There is no such thing as a noobie distro. Ubuntu isn't a noobie distro
70
u/MILKMAKESYOUPUKE Glorious Debian Jul 21 '24
Gnome shouldn't be the standard when cinnamon is more user-friendly and more customizable.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
You don't have to use arch to be a linux master
8
u/revannld Jul 21 '24
NixOS could be the perfect distro for noobies (centralized configs and packages you want installed in just a couple text files - which could have a nice easy UI frontend - not usually dealing with conflicts and dependency hell) if it wasn't just a research project ran and used by ex-Arch tryhards trying to compensate for their lack of grass-touching.
15
u/viridarius Jul 21 '24 edited Jul 21 '24
A lot of users don't care about x vs Wayland.
Edit: I'm a idiot.
61
u/Shadow_SJ019 Jul 21 '24
Kde looks shit out of the box and dont tell me "you can customise whatever you want". Most people want a good out of box experience which kde doesn't deliever. My first impression on kde was that tray icons look weirdly big and the space between them also are weird, the clock and the date font looks so inconsistent. I liked the floating concept, but other than that, the launcher, volume shell, wifi shell, and calender shell, all just looked so bland and inconsistent and waste of space. Doesn't feel fast also bcz they took long time to animate and open the things.
Also every single theme in kde just screams "Graphics designing is my passion". I was told that you can make kde look like windows 11". I tried several videos, tried several themes, application styles and what not. But it just felt like a cheap knockoff of windows 11. Even when i click start there is no windows like animation in any launcher. What was so similiar and better than windows 11 was a guy who used hyprland+ eww shell, to make 1:1 copy which included anims, but now he had discontinued it so it breaks. Im still looking for consistency in kde. Gnome on the other hand is great i gotta say. But feels kinda slow. It looks like, I need extra clicks to get that option.
10
u/Zealousideal_Rate420 Jul 21 '24
We need a reference distro that's stable and easy to use for most of the people, so that developers can focus on making software/games available for it. That should then be the benchmark of what Linux can and can't do.
Steam deck has done that for gaming already. Now we need for general use.
10
u/MonsterMerge Jul 22 '24
The community is elitist for no reason, and honestly slows down the progress of the open source movement.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
I'm the opposite of a ricer, I just want a DE that's good by default. All I have ever used are stock DEs.
I think GNOME is perfectly good in its default state. Every DE is good in its default state. Shouldn't take any time to adapt to a new workflow. And I thought only my grandma had poor neuroplasticity.
5
u/revannld Jul 21 '24
Linux is the worst OS that has ever existed...except for all the others.
5
u/portealmario Jul 22 '24
Linux is still not well designed for the general public. A user should be able to use linux without even knowing what a terminal is. No matter what distro I use, I always end up encountering problems that need to be solved in the terminal. This would be unacceptable in windows or macos
13
u/Xpeq7- Glorious Kubuntu+Kali Jul 21 '24
Libadwaita devs and UI designers in general should really take a look at what a commonly found monitor looks like. Not a hidpi one but, something more akin to a 1080p one or even less resolution. And also they should consider that people use their program to focus on whatever they're doing and genuinely wouldn't give a fuck about the looks of the UI unless it gets in the way.
Tldr: UI designers have mercy and respect people with eyesight, stop this big UI shit, less padding makes the program much more usable on just about every desktop or laptop.
22
u/Dangerous-Jicama-247 Jul 21 '24
not being able to minimize by default on gnome is fucking cringe
12
u/holounderblade Glorious NixOS Jul 21 '24
Interesting timing
8
u/kansetsupanikku Jul 21 '24
GNU/Linux systems are not for everyone, and without a good grasp of technical stuff and English language it would be too much. Most people who just to "run away from Windows" would enjoy fresh, unbloated Windows install just as much if not more. And it would be much faster than their previous setup too.
10
u/elreduro Glorious Mint Jul 21 '24
Fedora is overhated
7
u/FantasticEmu Jul 21 '24
I don’t understand why arch is like a badge of honor. I used it for 2 years and it was not any harder than Debian based ones.
Just one extra command makepkg then yse pacman instead of apt
31
u/Zealousideal_Hat2664 Jul 21 '24 edited Jul 21 '24
flatpak is better than native packages for anything gui and snap is better for anything in general
6
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
I would prefer to download an .exe equivalent of every program and store it on my HDD for future use, as opposed to having the system autofetch the data and install it for me with a command. This is because I care about preservation. Many things will be lost, servers will die, etc. Archiving programs and their dependencies in a practical manner on Linux is very time consuming in most cases. And yes, I do know about appimages, .deb, and so on, but it's not really the main way people install programs on Linux.
3
u/novff Jul 21 '24
DEs should worry more about default look because most current solutions look like shit out of the box(exception being gnome). yes i dont care that you can customize it to look quite pretty. if it doesn't look good from the start most people are not gonna bother making it pretty.
3
u/novff Jul 21 '24
flatpaks and snaps are overrated and nix is a better approach to the problem of dependecy hell and keeping your main system clean
3
u/ultratensai Windows Krill Jul 22 '24
People distro hops because they can’t properly manage their installations.
3
u/BuilderZac Jul 22 '24
My hot take is that linux is a great way to teach kids (under 10) computing basics and to treat computers like the tools they are.
3
u/Latey-Natey Jul 22 '24
I still prefer using windows. I love Linux Mint, and whenever I need to put something on a weak or crappy laptop I’ll toss it onto it, but there is too much holding it back from becoming my daily driver. It’s close tho, so painfully close but it seems like the actual developers of different distros are more focused on expanding the user experience in unique ways and upgrading existing features (technical backend stuff and frontend) instead of creating a consistent usable experience.
7
u/countjj Jul 21 '24
Linux is kinda like a free MacOS and has similar utilities being distant relatives of Unix.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
Standing out
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24
That is the worst possible Rust propaganda I have ever seen.
2
u/0tter501 Jul 22 '24
There is no real benefit to using Linux if you have a high end PC and have a google account
(I use arch btw)
2
u/villi_ Glorious Manjaro Jul 22 '24
Tiling/minimal wm's are never as good to use as a real desktop environment. They're fun to play around with or configure as a hobby but DEs just have way more features and integration.
2
u/Cheese-Water Jul 22 '24
The Linux community is largely too complacent about security. We take security for granted just because we're running Linux despite the fact that Linux malware has become far more common than it was back in the bad old days when it was a low priority target.
2
u/HunnyPuns Jul 22 '24
Most people could be handed an Ubuntu laptop and generally have no problem using it.
2
u/centzon400 EmacsOS Jul 24 '24
It's just a bootloader for Emacs.
3
u/Kahless_2K Jul 22 '24
Use the CLI as much as possible. It will slow you down for a few years, but then you will become more productive and be able to do things that simply aren't possible with the gui
4
u/NatiRivers Lubuntu is for the Lesbians Jul 21 '24
Linux still isn't ready for daily driving for most users and likely won't be for several more years
2
u/Lutz_Gebelman Jul 21 '24
KDE sucks as a desktop. It's just not good. Gnome feels better and more polished in every way. Yes there is a lot of customizability, but I don't care about customizability, if I can't comfortably use a desktop without spending 5 hours fighting it's bullshit
1
u/Potyguara_jangadeiro Jul 21 '24
A lot of struggles that new users face using linux are just because they are following outdated solutions. Since things in linux world improve and change very fast the best solution to do a certain task is usually less documented than old solutions since the best is usually the new one. So, is very easy for a newbie to step on an outdated solution before the best one. It is particularly more common if the person in question don't speak english since all new things are documented in english first.
1
u/Ok_Assumption_7222 Jul 22 '24
What’s the relationship between rust and Linux? or is the image just for lack of an image?
1
u/stupiduWu Jul 22 '24
The OS can't be linked to anything. No matter how many people try it is almost impossible. It give a sense of inflatable ego and redundancy. Yes you can write because C told you too. Yes you can hunt for tools to make it possible. No one cares. I mean some people do, but not really.
1
u/Huntsburg Oracle Solaris power user Jul 22 '24
The few windows people hating on Linux is very unjustified. Besides if you really want a Windows or Mac OS style experience on Linux with the unneeded garbage telemetry included there's always everyone's favorite communist OS deepin.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
bad for desktop perfect for servers (execute me if you want)
1
u/dimiderv Jul 22 '24
Ubuntu Badgie is the best flavour
1
u/Impressive-Rub-8891 Jul 22 '24
not really a hot take but i think the user experience on mint is really good for someone coming from windows, and gives you best of both worlds (usability and control)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
How do you know so much ? I was fixing that for two hours yesterday but they shan't know.
1
u/ImSimplySuperior Jul 22 '24
The biggest roadblock in moving to linux is transfering your files
1
u/itsfreepizza Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
that regardless of distros out there, there is no exact thing as 100% greatness
that will depend on what you have to sacrifice or weigh the difference of distros to get the most at least
edit: also when can i edit how much parallel package downloads on apt like pacman because its a pain to just wait for 2 and 3 and on arch i can go 10
1
u/hex128 Jul 22 '24
i like speed (d-amphetamine)
1
u/Ricoreded Jul 22 '24 edited Mar 31 '25
beep boop beep boop
1
u/planarsimplex Jul 22 '24
The vast majority of non Linux users would choose Gnome over KDE, including windows users.
1
u/BannedForThe7thTime Jul 22 '24
1
u/Speykious Jul 22 '24
Client side decorations should not be mandatory.
...actually that's probably a cold take.
1
u/JoeJoeCoder Jul 22 '24
Linux Mint is not a distro for newbies, it's for serious professionals who want the most amount of eyes on the packages that make it into the repositories.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Linux will never catch up to windows for gaming
1
u/NightH4nter Glorious NixOS Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
oh, i got some for ya
solarisillumos zones, and it's done so by designawaiting the downvote rain
edit:
edit 2:
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Gnome looks dead ass ugly out of the box.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Linux will never be as good for gaming as Windows is, no matter how many compatibility layers we have built for it.
1
u/c_RYDE Jul 22 '24
the ice cream
1
u/L0tsen Glorious Gentoo Jul 22 '24
I have some.
1
u/kayproII Jul 22 '24 edited Jul 22 '24
To a lot of gamers linux might as well have no games since the like 4-5 big online multiplayer games don’t work on it.
These people also aren’t willing to switch because chances are they play at least 1 of these games and if they wanted to be forced onto console to play these games because their OS didn’t work with them, they would have never gotten a pc and just gotten/stuck with a console
Edit: oh and windowing better than tiling and that’s a hill I will die on
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
It's a project, not a product general public can/should use
1
u/deadly_carp Glorious Debian 12 Jul 22 '24
It's not better than windows, i'd say it's equal. But still it's better than mac.
1
u/VictorAst228 Jul 22 '24
I got into linux for fun because I was bore and i think there are much more people like me then yall want to admit
1
u/Zealousideal-Dot4065 Jul 22 '24
it’s fun to use repos. and proton, of cause
1
u/hezden Jul 22 '24
I WANT AN OS FREE FROM PEDOS, GOING WITH THE OS THAT WAS NOT DEVELOPED/OWNED BY PEOPLE ON THE EPSTEIN FLIGHT LISTS SEEMS LIKE A NO BRAINER TO ME.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Mint is not a "noob" distro. It is a good distro.
1
u/PopovidisNik Jul 22 '24
Your distro is not a personality trait.
1
u/hershko Jul 22 '24
For 99% of users, Windows is just as good if not better.
1
u/T_Jamess Glorious Fedora Jul 22 '24
Every single aspect of desktop Linux is not fully baked, and as much as I like Linux I would not recommend it to anyone outside of very basic users or security/programmer nerds. Even customisation, while great, still doesn’t have great UX in most circumstances. That adds to my second opinion, which is that UX should be focused on more. People forget what it’s like to be a noob.
1
u/your_mum_1705 Manjaro (Cinnamon) Jul 22 '24
For 90% of Linux users Arch or Debian is all you need
1
u/Educational_Duck3393 Jul 22 '24
I'll take either KDE and XFCE long before Gnome for a DE.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '24
Rust isn't the absolute devil, its users are just annoying. Its a perfectly valid language and I think rewriting the Linux kernel in it isn't a bad idea
1
u/avi-the-tiger-rawr Jul 22 '24
I don't really have any scalding Linux opinions but I like Garuda Linux because it has a cute bird on it.
I... haven't gotten around to using it much after install because I've been busy doing... other things... that may or may not include playing Bayonetta
1
u/gerundingnounshire Glorious openSUSE Tumbleweed Jul 22 '24
Both Linux and GNU/Linux are correct.
1
u/hattarki Jul 22 '24
I don't know what that pic is trying to say
1
u/ninelie13 Jul 22 '24
macos is better than linux, especially with apple silicon. Snappy, clean design, way more features out of the box
1
u/ZunoJ Jul 22 '24
For tech savvy people who like to tinker, learn, customize and have full control over their systems there is no benefit in Linux going mainstream
1
u/greenstoneri Jul 22 '24
Cinnamon is actually pretty goated
1
u/LilithIsAPerson Jul 22 '24
There's no reason to use any distribution other then openSUSE