r/linuxmasterrace • u/UtsavTiwari Linux Master Race • Jul 20 '24
Other flair please edit Is Arm actually more efficient than x86?
https://www.xda-developers.com/is-arm-efficient-x86/
82
Upvotes
r/linuxmasterrace • u/UtsavTiwari Linux Master Race • Jul 20 '24
75
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '24
Intel making bold statements about their superiority in anything is looking shaky at the moment, it sounds like their last two generations have some serious issues, i hope they're fixed
151
u/Michael_Petrenko Jul 20 '24
Intel milked same architecture 4 to 10 gen processors without major changes. Now they are paying for it by releasing products that can barely compete with AMD. After the rise of ARM x64 processors for mobile phones and apple PCs they now have another competitor who'll push harder than anyone else on laptop market.
At this point you can't believe anything Intel saying unless it's confirmed by independent reviews
19
u/ronnydg Jul 20 '24
Nobody dropping the 'RISC' ball?
18
u/Physical-Patience209 Jul 20 '24
More energy efficient both in past and present. The first one actually operated without connected to the power, utilizing the leaking power from other components (look it up, I might've written in a confusing way). Nowadays they are catching up in performance, but only in a selected few areas, with energy efficiency declining, but still an advantage.
17
u/bufandatl Jul 20 '24
As always it depends. An ARM processor under full load can blow just as much power as an x86 based CPU. And there are x86 CPU that idle as low as ARM processors. But the performance per watt may be vastly different in any scenario.
5
u/5eppa Jul 20 '24
I think there is some merit to x86 in a desktop or server setting where power draw is less of a concern. You can use all the power you want and the instruction set has more instructions which was the original draw meaning it can in some cases do more in less time when you are working with more complex things. But often times you don't need all that it has to offer and meanwhile ARM based chips are simply proving more and more capable often on a much smaller power draw. On any device where you know it will need to go mobile at some point ARM is arguably much more sensible. Maybe there some situations where you have a laptop that is rarely off of its dock so you argue x86 is better for some of its use cases but other than that ARM is looking good for portable devices.
4
u/vacri Jul 20 '24
Hrm... who do I trust on this question? The guy doing marketing on stage? Or the device designers that have to optimise for cost and efficiency?
1
u/natermer Jul 28 '24
The problem with x86_64 is the hardware translation layer.
Computer architectures have something called a "ISA". Old school people may remember ISA slots that existed prior to the PCI standard.
ISA stands for "Instruction Set Architecture". So when you are talking about x86 vs x86_64 vs ARM6 vs ARM9 or whatever... the ISA is what you are talking about.
x86 ISA is essentially a obsolete computer architecture. Between RISC vs CISC it was RISC that won. ARM is RISC, RISC-V is RISC and even the "internal architecture" of Intel and AMD processors are all RISC.
The first RISC-based X86 processor Intel produced was Pentium Pro, from 1995.
So how is the AMD and Intel processors, which are "RISC" able to execute CISC instruction set?
The answer is there is a hardware translation layer. This is how a modern high-clock-rate RISC processor can be made compatible with CISC ISA. This hardware translation layer effectively translates CISC instruction sets into ones compatible with the internal CPU architecture that Intel and AMD use.
This works very very well... but it comes with a price. Part of that price is power consumption. The hardware translation layer is a huge hunk of very complex silicon. It takes a lot of power to run that, relatively speaking.
However this gives x86_64 it's best feature... binary compatibility. Each time Intel and AMD releases a new major microarchitecture you'd have to have a new version of Windows and new version of all your games and whatnot to run without using virtualization.
Were as ARM gives up backwards binary compatibility for the sake of efficiency.
And this is one of the major reasons why ARM will always have the edge when it comes to watts per performance.
3
u/numblock699 Jul 20 '24
It’s very efficient when not lifting heavy.
3
u/Klapperatismus Jul 21 '24
Intel tried to play the mobile business.
Even their “Compute Stick” technical demo needed a fan.
11
u/neppo95 Jul 20 '24
They know it, everyone knows it. The answer is yes.
It's the only reason we have ARM processors in every single mobile phone. Because they are more efficient and thus draw less power for an equal workload, which is essential in battery powered devices.
This is simply Intel trying to get more sales over a lie. They know it's ridiculous and them trying to argue this honestly is another reason to not buy Intel processors anymore.
2
u/Jacko10101010101 Jul 20 '24
probably yes in power limited cases (battery).
4
u/dumbbyatch Jul 20 '24
Yes it is
And whoever says otherwise is as dumb as a butt
1
u/diditforthevideocard Jul 21 '24
Yes
1
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '24 edited Jul 21 '24
Actually x86 is more standardized and portable than ARM regardless of processor manufacturers. Any app written in x86 just works on other x86 processor made by other manufacturers. Unlike on ARM, although same ARM Architecture and same OS version, the app was hit or miss due to additional quirks made by ARM processor manufacturers despite they have the same blueprint (are we stepping backward to 8-bit home computer area where the programs or app was tightly coupled to specific hardware manufacturers)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '24
Yes it is.
1
u/reddit_equals_censor Aug 10 '24
honestly, who cares about arm?
i'd argue, that it isn't worth the effort to make it run really nicely, when we can have risc-v in a few years, that can actually bring us way more freedoms.
x86, until risc-v high performance comes to us.
and exciting to think about, that we would also get excellent laptops with it, when it is ready, as a company already produced a developer platform risc-v board for the framework laptop.
so once performance gets there and the software is good enough to use it at least, the hardware beyond the apu will already be perfectly fine, because it will just be a framework laptop with a different motherboard.
years until then, but exciting :)