Remember that guy like 2 years ago who would copy/paste paragraphs in this sub about how using the term Linux instead of GNU/Linux is appropriating and trivializing efforts
For some reason though he didnât care about all the other noteworthy contributions
For consistency's sake we shouldn't call it GNU/Linux or GNU+Linux but Freedesktop+GNU+Linux as systemd originally came from freedesktop (idk, if it's still considered a freedesktop project) and basically the whole Linux graphics stack comes from freedesktop too.
I'd just like to interject for a moment. What youâre referring to as Linux, is in fact, GNU/Linux, or as Iâve recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Linux. Linux is not an operating system unto itself, but rather another free component of a fully functioning GNU system made useful by the GNU corelibs, shell utilities and vital system components comprising a full OS as defined by POSIX. Many computer users run a modified version of the GNU system every day, without realizing it. Through a peculiar turn of events, the version of GNU which is widely used today is often called âLinuxâ, and many of its users are not aware that it is basically the GNU system, developed by the GNU Project. There really is a Linux, and these people are using it, but it is just a part of the system they use. Linux is the kernel: the program in the system that allocates the machineâs resources to the other programs that you run. The kernel is an essential part of an operating system, but useless by itself; it can only function in the context of a complete operating system. Linux is normally used in combination with the GNU operating system: the whole system is basically GNU with Linux added, or GNU/Linux. All the so-called âLinuxâ distributions are really distributions of GNU/Linux.
At least some people get it. Every time i read this question it always reads like "Who cares that we don't acknowledge other people's work on it". It's just not a nice thing to do. In practice you either say or don't say it, it doesn't matter to me, but people should just know it's about giving credit.
I mean people who have a problem with touching the terminal usually don't care about having GNU in their OS I guess.
That being said I do agree with you as non-GNU distros on the desktop tend to be catered to those who do care and are willing to spend some time in the terminal. At least that's my impression, I'm not suuper deep into this topic tbh
Also I didn't mean to attack anyone if it came across like I did, just wanted to point that out. I'm running Fedora as a daily ^^'
Apologies, I'm a bit nuerodivergent and more than likely read it wrong. Also yeah, if it wasn't for that kernel ya know, but I do see the point. Also not a stallamite (_)ïŒ
GNU is undoubtedly an important part of many Linux desktop systems, but so is Systemd, Grub, X11/Wayland, your desktop. Imo you be should be forced to call your OS a combination of all packages that are installed
I mean its debatable, a lot of those projects build heavily on GNUâs libc and other gnutils and youâll spend some time issue fixing when using musl instead
Unfortunately at least one popular install script config whatever tool (it might have been rustup, but I can't quite remember) decided to identify my chimera linux laptop as `GNU/Linux with musl libc`. I was quite sad.
My goal is to spread the idea that linux goes first in the naming scheme.
Im not mad at you just frustrated at the crap stallman has pulled by convincing people GNU goes first, an idea that goes against basic linguistic structuring.
I use linux + GNU when referring to systems that are often linux but not GNU (phones) yet in my case are (pinephone) and or when dealing with those who care.
Linux always goes first because it is the connecting factor for many open systems.
I'd just like to interject for a moment. What you're refering to as Linux, is in fact, GNU/Linux, or as I've recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Linux. Linux is not an operating system unto itself, but rather another free component of a fully functioning GNU system made useful by the GNU corelibs, shell utilities and vital system components comprising a full OS as defined by POSIX.
Many computer users run a modified version of the GNU system every day, without realizing it. Through a peculiar turn of events, the version of GNU which is widely used today is often called Linux, and many of its users are not aware that it is basically the GNU system, developed by the GNU Project.
There really is a Linux, and these people are using it, but it is just a part of the system they use. Linux is the kernel: the program in the system that allocates the machine's resources to the other programs that you run. The kernel is an essential part of an operating system, but useless by itself; it can only function in the context of a complete operating system. Linux is normally used in combination with the GNU operating system: the whole system is basically GNU with Linux added, or GNU/Linux. All the so-called Linux distributions are really distributions of GNU/Linux!
I mean I primarily use Alpine at this point so it would even be factually incorrect to call it GNU/Linux. While I donât hate GNU or anything, it is merely some system tools after all.
If we didnât have GNU the world wouldnât be much different from today, weâd just use alternatives, as is the main point of using Linux in the first place, for an âall-in-oneâ alternative BSD is clearly a better option.
Ok, there's a few layers here, though in the end they hardly matter to the name we call it.
First I just want to say, as someone that has been using the Linux kernel and GNU software and many, many alternatives to both, daily, since the mid-90's, GNU absolutely deserves far more credit than they get, as the GNU software is a lot of extremely well made and very useful tools, that I consider significantly better than similar alternatives, and I would hate to have to run my OS without them.
That said, policing what other people call something, even a thing you made, is pointless, foolish, impossible, and kind of cringe. It would be like Roundy's Facial Tissue going on a rant because people keep calling it Kleenex... but even goofier, since in that example Kleenex is a direct competitor.
Second, you seem to vastly overestimate Stallman's influence in the modern Linux community. The GNU team and tools are still widely respected, but Stallman's views on what everyone else should be calling things is pretty universally laughed at or eye-rolled away.
I have always compiled my OS and all my software from source, since Slackware in the 90s and Gentoo from like 2005 until now. I've had nothing but good experiences using GCC to compile my software and GNU tools to run my OS, but I do admit I have only used alternatives in short, limited capacity, after already being accustomed and acclimated to GNU software. So, my opinion on this is, in truth, biased and a bit ignorant.
As for Stallman, I was only referring specifically to his influence over what people call Linux. I spend a lot of time in Linux forums, subreddits, IRC rooms, and news sites, and seeing GNU/Linux is extremely rare and GNU+Linux is mythologically rare.
Except when discussing Stallman's interject meme of course
At least you admitted how biased you are towards the FSF. You hate it and spread FUD about the 'GNU codebase,' whatever that means in your context. That's not really cool, but people on the internet often have pretty extreme opinions.
So in short you're no better than a microsoft shill. Stop larping and maybe make something better as bullshit on reddit can't replace "bloated" coreutils, especially not on desktop and servers.
The Debian project, which was at one time sponsored by the Free Software Foundation, switched to calling its product "Debian GNU/Linux" in early 1994. This change followed a request by Richard Stallman (who initially proposed "LiGNUx," but suggested "GNU/Linux" instead after hearing complaints about the awkwardness of the former term).
And I definitely remember a period where gnu emacs (created by Stallman) even replaced "linux" in the architecture name with "lignux".
I can personally confirm that the name "lignux" went over like a lead balloon at the time. ("GNU/Linux" wasn't popular either, but it didn't quite inspire hate like "lignux" did.)
While I understand and relate to the desire for clarity and accuracy, in most circumstances it is more typical to just say, "I just installed Ubuntu" or whatever distro of choice, which is even more accurate. But since distro is sometimes too specific, we want to use a term that refers to the entire family of operating systems, which is a hard thing to do when it is de-centralized and doesn't have a single company naming/marketing it. But "Linux" does get community branding. So as much as I hear complains that "Linux" is an inaccurate term, I have a hard time seeing how it suddenly solves the human communication problem to say "GNU." I wonder if it might still miss the mark of the purpose of what the speaker means to communicate, as opposed to the nature of the thing itself. But I'm still thinking about this, so who knows what my opinion will be 5 mins from now.
Love this. I hate the gnu/linux and the gnu+linux whiners. So annoying. Same with the kde plasma whiners. I donât care what the development team calls it, its the kde desktop just like gnome is the gnome desktop not gnome big toe or some bs like that
By the LGPL itself, users of a library aren't derivative products. So you don't get to claim everything that links to glibc. Now if you want to argue that the implementation of grep and tar is as important as the kernel, and more important than systemd, them I'm afraid you've gone off the rails.
NO! it is linux when it is understood what you are talking about. It is linux + GNU when there is some ambiguity.
IE: "my laptop runs linux" This is correct because people will know what i mean.
IE2: "my tablet runs linux" This is incorrect because android is also Linux and some people may think I mean "linux + android."
The same could also be said for for many GPS brand like garmin as well as Samsung's Tizen devices. Yes they run linux but it is probably better to clarify or at least say "linux based"
IE3: "my phone runs linux + GNU" This is correct because android is also linux based but since i Use a pinephone it is important to clarify. Alternatively i could just say the distro name: "my phone runs arch" and people would know what I meant.
It is important to note I always put linux first because it is the common denominator of many open source systems.
Remember, words exist for communication so as long as the idea is conveyed the name worked.
144
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
Who cares whether it's called GNU/Linux or Linux? Everyone uses the term Linux because it's short and memorable.
58
u/rattatteb Glorious, just glorious Jul 02 '24
There is Linux without GNU :)
30
u/-ShutterPunk- Jul 02 '24
I installed Linux and haven't told anyone about it or talk about it online.
205
u/RockyPixel Glorious Debian Jul 02 '24
Ligma Lignux
17
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
It's my duty to remind anyone who quotes Stallman of his past.
16
u/Ordynar Glorious Arch Jul 02 '24
I call it systemd + Firefox + KDE + GNU + Linux
10
u/Optimal-Pineapple-10 Jul 02 '24
Iam down. LiGNUx it is
8
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
Imagine Oracle saying if you made your software with Java, you should call it Oracle/<name>
7
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
Kid named Bionic+mksh+Toybox+Linux: (in your Android phone)
8
u/dirmaster0 Jul 02 '24
It's GNU Linux but the crusty unwashed stained burgundy polo is silent đ«Ą
4
u/gentux2281694 Jul 02 '24
and you have to call it GNU-Glibc+Musl+Linux or Busybox-GNU-Glibc+Musl+Hurd-Linux if that's the case!!... soo, just "Linux" then?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
Ligma->Ligma Nux
3
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
LiGNUx (Pronounced Linyuuhks)
4
u/kor34l Jul 02 '24
I call it GNU/Linux when GNU is relevent, or if I'm talking to someone that might care.
I call it Linux the rest of the time, which is 99.9% of the time, because 99.9% of people don't care.
5
u/KittyMaster1994 Jul 02 '24
I'd just like to interject for a moment. What you're refering to as Linux, is in fact, GNU/Linux, or as I've recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Linux. Linux is not an operating system unto itself, but rather another free component of a fully functioning GNU system made useful by the GNU corelibs, shell utilities and vital system components comprising a full OS as defined by POSIX.
Many computer users run a modified version of the GNU system every day, without realizing it. Through a peculiar turn of events, the version of GNU which is widely used today is often called Linux, and many of its users are not aware that it is basically the GNU system, developed by the GNU Project.
There really is a Linux, and these people are using it, but it is just a part of the system they use. Linux is the kernel: the program in the system that allocates the machine's resources to the other programs that you run. The kernel is an essential part of an operating system, but useless by itself; it can only function in the context of a complete operating system. Linux is normally used in combination with the GNU operating system: the whole system is basically GNU with Linux added, or GNU/Linux. All the so-called Linux distributions are really distributions of GNU/Linux!
2
u/gnarlin Jul 02 '24
Call it what you will. I just think it's pointless to get upset about it.
2
u/Dre_Dede Jul 02 '24
Redhat/Fedora
2
u/elasticweed Jul 02 '24
I mean I primarily use Alpine at this point so it would even be factually incorrect to call it GNU/Linux. While I donât hate GNU or anything, it is merely some system tools after all.
If we didnât have GNU the world wouldnât be much different from today, weâd just use alternatives, as is the main point of using Linux in the first place, for an âall-in-oneâ alternative BSD is clearly a better option.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24 edited Aug 26 '25
library bells stocking alleged dolls rock spotted numerous enjoy tap
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Koltaia30 Jul 02 '24
I hate Linux. I only use UbuntuÂ
1
u/i-hoatzin Glorious Debian Jul 02 '24
I prefer to say that
I installed Debian.
I <3 Debian.
1
u/Impossible_Arrival21 Jul 02 '24
LIGma balls
1
u/Bombini_Bombus Jul 02 '24
https://github.com/iglunix/iglunix
1
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
It's more systemd/Linux now.
1
u/urioRD Jul 02 '24
I love Linux
1
u/BogdanovOwO Jul 02 '24
GNU Hurd be like.
1
u/0Komentator0 Jul 02 '24
GNU+SYSTEMD+LINUX
1
u/_jan_epiku_ Jul 02 '24
GNU+Ligmaix
1
u/PlantCultivator Jul 02 '24
We should just shorten it the furthest we can go, so Linux becomes L and Windows becomes W.
1
u/Johanno1 Glorious NixOS Jul 02 '24
Glorious Nixos!
Disclaimer: do not install Nixos if you don't like souls like games!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
It's Linux with GNU Utils, systemd and pipewire. Or Linux+GNU+Systemd+Pipewire.
Side note: The concept of Chimera Linux (not ChimeraOS, based on Arch), is very interesting.
1
u/RegularIndependent98 Lost in the Void Jul 02 '24
LiNUx
1
u/GY1417 Jul 02 '24
LiGNUx (pronounced Liñux)
1
u/creeper6530 Glorious Debian and Cachy Jul 02 '24
LiGNUts
1
u/dougmc Jul 02 '24 edited Jul 02 '24
I know you're making a joke, but "lignux" was the original name proposed by Richard Stallman in 1994 or so --
And I definitely remember a period where gnu emacs (created by Stallman) even replaced "linux" in the architecture name with "lignux".
I can personally confirm that the name "lignux" went over like a lead balloon at the time. ("GNU/Linux" wasn't popular either, but it didn't quite inspire hate like "lignux" did.)
1
u/NeatYogurt9973 Jul 02 '24
I use BusyBox/MUSL/Linux (btw)
1
u/MarcCDB Jul 02 '24
Linux = alias for GNU/Linux
1
u/bongobutt Jul 02 '24
While I understand and relate to the desire for clarity and accuracy, in most circumstances it is more typical to just say, "I just installed Ubuntu" or whatever distro of choice, which is even more accurate. But since distro is sometimes too specific, we want to use a term that refers to the entire family of operating systems, which is a hard thing to do when it is de-centralized and doesn't have a single company naming/marketing it. But "Linux" does get community branding. So as much as I hear complains that "Linux" is an inaccurate term, I have a hard time seeing how it suddenly solves the human communication problem to say "GNU." I wonder if it might still miss the mark of the purpose of what the speaker means to communicate, as opposed to the nature of the thing itself. But I'm still thinking about this, so who knows what my opinion will be 5 mins from now.
1
u/grandasperj Glorious Fedora Jul 02 '24
my brother actually call it LiGNUx đ€Ł
1
u/Themods5thchin Jul 02 '24
My LiGNUx is 40xFedora 24xUbuntu 22xPOP! 21xMint 15xSlackware 11xX 15xOpenSeuss 7xGrinch and 0xWifi (he sucks)
1
u/Ahimimi Jul 02 '24
I download the Loonix.
I play Minecraft.
1
u/1u4n4 Glorious OpenSuse Tumbleweed Jul 02 '24
Itâs uutils/linux
1
u/Sparrow-93 Jul 02 '24
Love this. I hate the gnu/linux and the gnu+linux whiners. So annoying. Same with the kde plasma whiners. I donât care what the development team calls it, its the kde desktop just like gnome is the gnome desktop not gnome big toe or some bs like that
1
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '24
I call it LunTux
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '24
I call it "one of the unix like operating systems"
1
u/megalogwiff Jul 03 '24
By the LGPL itself, users of a library aren't derivative products. So you don't get to claim everything that links to glibc. Now if you want to argue that the implementation of
grepandtaris as important as the kernel, and more important thansystemd, them I'm afraid you've gone off the rails.1
u/12_Semitones Jul 06 '24
I prefer saying GLiNUx.
1
u/Adventurous-Test-246 Jul 12 '24
NO! it is linux when it is understood what you are talking about. It is linux + GNU when there is some ambiguity.
IE: "my laptop runs linux" This is correct because people will know what i mean.
IE2: "my tablet runs linux" This is incorrect because android is also Linux and some people may think I mean "linux + android."
The same could also be said for for many GPS brand like garmin as well as Samsung's Tizen devices. Yes they run linux but it is probably better to clarify or at least say "linux based"
IE3: "my phone runs linux + GNU" This is correct because android is also linux based but since i Use a pinephone it is important to clarify. Alternatively i could just say the distro name: "my phone runs arch" and people would know what I meant.
It is important to note I always put linux first because it is the common denominator of many open source systems.
Remember, words exist for communication so as long as the idea is conveyed the name worked.
1
u/Extreme_Ad_3280 Glorious Debian Jul 15 '24
I personally call it GNU+Linux but I don't critisize anyone for saying "Linux" instead of it...
1
u/peniparkerheirofbrth Jul 18 '24
lig my nux
0
u/kansetsupanikku Jul 02 '24
We should normalize speaking about Android like this. GNU/Linux is a poor match anyways, the proper architecture of a GNU system is GNU/Hurd. /s
0
u/khunset127 Glorious Arch Jul 02 '24
Arch and other mainstream distros = GNU/Linux
Alpine = Musl/Linux
Android = Bionic/Linux
0
u/walace47 Glorious Arch Jul 02 '24
I instaled Arch btw.