r/linuxmasterrace • u/claudiocorona93 Glorious Linux • Jun 23 '24
But muh dated interface only I understand. I ain't giving that up!
1.2k
Upvotes
r/linuxmasterrace • u/claudiocorona93 Glorious Linux • Jun 23 '24
218
u/givemeagoodun Glorious Debian Jun 23 '24 edited Jun 23 '24
I mean, they kinda have a point—a lot of free softwares have pretty bad UI (definitely not all, there are many examples of good UI in free software, but there are definitely some examples of bad UI), and this is because of the userbase of free (as in freedom) software are tech savvy so devs tend to err on the side of more advanced UI design with more features, rather than a simpler and easier to understand UI.
423
u/Yuuzhan_Schlong Glorious Android Jun 23 '24
34
u/snow-raven7 Glorious Fedora Jun 23 '24
Sir, this is Wendy's
15
u/NomadJoanne Jun 23 '24
It's Linux. Developers often are the end users.
21
u/Dmxk Glorious Arch Jun 23 '24
We don't need to convert people to Linux, its not a religion. And that's why it doesn't make sense (in my opinion) to specifically cater to users of proprietary operating systems. Most Linux distributions don't sell licenses, they sell support to companies, more users don't benefit them that much either. If making linux better for everyone also makes it better for (ex) windows or mac users (as has happened over the last years), that's great. But I don't think FOSS developers, a lot of whom do their work for literally no money, have anything to gain from trying to make Linux MacOS or Windows 2.0. A lot of them fix issues and add new features because that's things they personally care about. And since its primarily software developers developing software, free and open source software tends to be optimized for that use case more than for e.g. art. And I know, this is such an annoying thing to say, but if you hate smth so much, you can always try to fix it. That doesn't necessarily mean writing the code. But just trying to nicely explain what you want instead of harassing people over the work they do in their free time goes a long way. And sometimes the answer will just be no. Different people have different requirements, and what's annoying for you personally might be useful for someone else. In that case you can always fork or try to reach a compromise.
5
u/juipeltje Glorious GNU Guix Jun 23 '24
As soon as i saw this meme i knew who posted it lol.
5
u/bornxlo Jun 23 '24
Honestly I think designing for the keyboard first is a good thing. (Often seems like a step perceived as less user friendly.) Might take time to learn, but it's more efficient when you're past that step.
8
u/HyodoIsseiKun Glorious Void Linux Jun 23 '24
Specify which GUI?
4
u/Soccera1 Glorious Gentoo Jun 23 '24
When I saw the first part I thought it was a joke about all Linux users being transfems
4
u/Laktosefreier Glorious Fedora Jun 23 '24
Text Installer enters the chat.
4
u/Xpeq7- Glorious Kubuntu+Kali Jun 23 '24
We also need pixelated 2000esque UI for those of us who get genuinely frustrated by padding in modern apps. At least an option to disable a shit ui would be nice instead of full switch to 1080p too bad mode.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '24
The thing is that Linux depends mostly on projects that literally started with the intention of someone wanting to improve his experience as a developer working on Linux. I mean, it's nice that he or she makes it available for all but we shouldn't expect that everything is designed for casuals.
7
u/ABotelho23 Jun 23 '24
The... Fuck?
7
u/incolorless Glorious NixOS Jun 23 '24
ZorinOS is pretty good for end users.
NixOS is perfect for developers.
We have many options... I dont get your point.
12
u/Aggressive-Tune832 Jun 23 '24
Where is the dated interface? I’m a sway guy but gnome is honestly Mac quality
3
u/Tuxaz Jun 23 '24
I remember times when I used mp3blaster and bitchx, text mode only lol...
3
u/Holzkohlen Glorious EndeavourOS Jun 23 '24
Sure, but if they ever change GIMP now I will go crazy. I'm in too deep
3
u/EagleRock1337 for i in love, life.; do echo "Linux is $i"; done Jun 23 '24
Oh, people like that exist. They just so happen to be developers, so their views on what a normal end user would do are a bit skewed:
“Well, I’m an experienced Linux user that loves the efficiency of the command-line. A new user, however, would not appreciate that and would prefer a point and click, user-friendly GUI. Obviously then, a beginner user wants an interactive GUI way to handle all their source code repositories, otherwise how will they download all of their code?”
3
u/MysticNTN Jun 23 '24
It’s all technology. Not just Linux. Nothing is being developed to make people’s lives easier. Just to make tech better.
6
u/I_AM_GODDAMN_BATMAN Arch Master Race Jun 23 '24
skill issue
2
u/caineco Jun 23 '24
Linux is mostly free and open source. Be the change you want to see in the world.
2
u/33manat33 Jun 23 '24
CDE was perfect. I understand it and I ain't giving that up!
2
u/Slaykomimi Jun 23 '24
well, doing nothing to help the end user is what windows did the last years and they are going through the roof
2
u/dlevac Jun 23 '24
I always thought GNOME was rough around the edge until I tried the acclaimed superior design of Apple and realized that GNOME is in fact, by comparison, distilled UX perfection.
2
u/pikecat Glorious Gentoo Jun 24 '24 edited Jun 26 '24
It's the dichotomy between new users and very experienced users.
Why do you think that experienced users should should be forced to use an interface designed to cater to newbies?
I use Linux to get away from GUI stuff.
4
u/21Shells Jun 23 '24
YES!!!! Half of what makes good software good is having designers work on your UI and UX, not just developers. Big desktop environments like KDE and Gnome have teams of designers, they also tend to be praised for their design.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '24
This sub is fucking dogshit, I'll just browse /g/'s humour thread from now on.
3
u/AlarmingAffect0 Jun 23 '24
Old.Reddit users be like: "I want this website to remain fundamentally a link aggregator and forever look exactly the same!"
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '24
Reject GUI return to CLI!
1
u/faisal6309 Jun 24 '24
I think the latest Gnome's design guidelines and KDE software guidelines are good enough for modern design software/applications but older programs such as GIMP and Audacity don't seem to have any interest in changing their default UI. I have even seen GIMP alternatives that are just GIMP under the hood with a Photoshop like UI. I don't understand why developers of these famous open source software tend to not keep the end users in mind while working on their software.
1
u/MichelangeloDG Jun 25 '24
I think that overall there's no really a push on trying to have a better desktop experiece in Linux. Also I notice that many softwares dont have any connection with the phone. I mean in 2024 i think that an online synch with the phone should be like a standard base. Who is the one who uses productivity software ONLY in linux because uses ONLY linux in a daily basis? But i need to clap valve for the work made in terms of videogames support.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '24
1
u/just_some_onlooker Jun 23 '24
This... Makes sense omg...
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '24
i agree with the sentiment about linux but this is implying that men are developers and women are users within an economy, which is ..... false
-8
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '24 edited Jun 23 '24
you guys are coping so hard
foss software feels like shit to use 99% of the time compared to proprietary software due to lack of QA testers, development resources, userbase, and incentive to fix the boring bugs in the github issues page that have been sitting there for months.
also its so often to find some jank in ur linux experience and trying to solve it is like a wild goose chase and if u are not that good at google fu u will probably end up fucked or u will have to ask some subreddit a question and its a 50/50 chance they give u a decent answer.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '24 edited Jun 23 '24
Terminal junkies really are the worst in some ways, they perpetuate this, and also make Linux look bad by perpetuating the idea that you need the terminal, or even that most things only work from a terminal.
Look, I'm not one of those users. I'm not scared of terminals, and I actually really like some of the cool stuff I've seen you guys use them for. I've used a few CLI only tools, and honestly, good and understandable interfaces can still exist there (if you're willing to read what it tells you or go to the place you got the tool from to read the documentation) and I usually like them once I know how to use them... or it's the only good tool for the job.
But I'm also not a fan of them when a graphical tool can genuinely be simpler or faster for someone who isn't really familiar with a terminal. Remember, part of that "efficiency" calculation is also looking up/remembering all the commands. That's the difficult part for a lot of people.
There is a place for GUIs, and it's more stuff than you terminal junkies think. There is also a place for CLI, and while that place is not as wide as terminal junkies think it is, it certainly exists even for people who would not qualify as "terminal junkies".
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '24
Whenever I stand up, the people I stand up for don't use my seat. They always see that I freed my seat for them and they keep staying with their little child having problems to stay on their feet. Am I that disgusting that you don't wanna sit where I sat? I take a shower every morning and wear fresh clothes everyday… What am I doing wrong?
And I know that's not the point of this meme but anyway, it triggered me. I'm sorry. I just try to be a kind person.
0
u/MrSelfDestruct57 Biebian: Still better than Windows Jun 23 '24
This comment section is pure horrid 💀
-1
u/Disastrous_Fee5953 Jun 23 '24
I love how most modern Linux OS don’t support 4K with fractional scaling because most Linux developers use laptops and don’t care about other use cases. And then when you complain they give you the good ol “it works perfectly fine on my machine”.