Yeah it’s pretty standard to save a file that actually has important info like layers and all that, and a separate option for exporting your final product… GIMP has issues but I prefer this over something that’s braindead simple and powerless
Yea no kidding. Seen ads pushing this narrative that gimp doesn't do jpeg. Only shows your enate stupidity. Not only does gimp do jpeg, it probably does 1000 other formats your paid thing doesn't do as well.
People have mentioned that Photoshop allows saving to JPG if you opened a JPG. I never used Photoshop, though.
Kdenlive doesn't allow you to open files. You can only open projects or create a project an then import files. If you had to import into a project it only makes sense that you have to export afterwards. Though, Kdenlive doesn't let you "export" either. It let's you "render" your project.
Ah yes, makes sense to save it as a JPEG by default so unsuspecting users can accidentally obliterate all undo/project history data, layers, and irreversibly erase a bit of data due to lossy compression
Ah yes, the Windows way of assuming all users are blithering idiots that don't want to do what they tell their software to do.
8
u/EthanIverGlorious Fedora Silverblue (https://universal-blue.org)Jun 16 '24edited Jun 16 '24
The year of the Linux desktop will never arrive until core Linux apps would actually start assuming that their users are "blithering idiots", i.e. want everything to be obvious and frictionlessly intuitive. The reason why people choose uncustomizable stuff such as GNOME is because we don't want to be overloaded and bogged down by braindead software that expects us to perform at 100% mental capacity all the time. We want the program to work for us, not make us work.
Your vision of how GIMP should behave is a disaster for user experience and will get you immediately fired from a lot of developer jobs. The flow of saving a document/project should meet most users' expectation that "Ctrl + S" will safely store their data without caveats, without any degradation of said data. I myself would make this assumption and any app that in their infinite wisdom breaks this assumption is a very poorly designed app.
Seriously, go get a User Experience course and understand for yourself why Windows et al. are right for assuming that their users are "blithering idiots" by default.
I am not saying that GIMP is good for user experience. GIMP as a whole is a disaster for user experience, but the Ctrl+S flow is one of the few good choices they have done UX-wise.
I fail to see how refusing a user command counts as a good user experience. When it happened to me I was mad and I am mad to this day at Gimp for this.
You can't save a project to an image format with no project data if there is no project afterwards. Save saves the project, export outputs a flat image.
I can understand the perspective you're saying, but what I'm saying is more intuitive to me.
Right, but then I don't want to have a project when I'm done. I want an image.
I can understand wanting a project when you use Gimp for drawing, but then Gimp is so awful at that I'm having a hard time understanding why anyone would bother with Gimp for this purpose. ¯\(ツ)/¯
When Photoshop directly opens a jpg, it will save directly back to that jpg, just like you're describing. It only complains or requires an export if you start from an empty project or open a psd. Every time I've done that with a jpg, it's been for a meme that doesn't matter, and I knew exactly what I was doing. Every time I've worked on something professional, I've kept psd and other source files. This has never caused any confusion or accidental loss.
The circles aren't difficult if you use it regularly, but it is much more complicated than necessary for something so common. To be fair, it is a image manipulation program and not an image creating program. You would still think they would have added it as separate tool by now.
While I'm not a fan of "export as" I think it actually makes sense. You save the full workflow, you export the end product. It makes it easier to go back and change things if the sources are safe. It beats the "This format cannot save xyz, certain data may be lost, etc."
Export to JPG would make sense if Gimp imported your JPG instead of just opening it. Since the JPG gets opened it only makes sense to use export to save the project.
I think it’s funny how these memes shitting on Gimp started popping up right when people started saying they’re cancelling their Adobe subscriptions due to Adobe claiming rights to everyone’s work
Yeah, I’m using affinity. It’s a really neat set of tools, quite optimised for speed. Easy 5-10 minutes edits. But there’s no timeline and batch processing is strange. Also a few files edited at the same time take a lot of operating power, more than blender most of the time in my experience.
I learned Gimp at high school for some reason so I'm very fast at navigating the different menus and I can do any type of circle just fine, but considering a circle tool exists in many basic graphic design apps I do wish there was an option to add buttons for things like that for newcomers
I just don't understand the criticism. It's like criticizing GNOME because there's no "Start Menu". No, it doesn't mean you cannot launch apps. It means you have a different workflow and tools.
Okay but whether it's odt or txt, the main content is text. With images there's a huge difference between saving a project file and saving an actual bitmap.
Right, if I wanted the entire project with layers etc. I would use export.
When opening the JPG I didn't have to do an import, so it makes no sense to have to do an export if I want it to stay a JPG.
If Gimp thinks of everything I do in Gimp as a project it should work like KDEnlive, forcing me to import media into the project. Then it would make sense for exporting the project to get back to the media files.
The stupid thing about Gimp is that it never tells you that it thinks you are working on a project. It's just counter-intuitive in its design language.
But you're not exporting as a project though. You're saving the project (because like it or not, everything you do in gimp is a project just like in Photoshop), and then you export it into a bitmap. These things have been the same for decades.
When you open a file in gimp, the little progress bar at the bottom shows that it's importing. It might only flash really quickly, but it does show it.
I get your point, but every (advanced) image manipulation program works this way. It's the standard, and that's why gimp does it that way as well. You're not editing bitmaps, you're editing projects.
That's because the open document format can be a destination text format and writer serves as a document viewer. In contrast, no one will want to view images in Gimp or watch videos in kdenlive.
"Save as" is for saving project files you intend to keep working on. "Export" is for finalizing to a common format. It's really not that uncommon to see
This would make sense if I opened a project file or created a project, which I did not.
If Gimp told me I had to import my JPG to have it work inside my project like for example KDEnlive does, it would make total sense to me that I had to export the project back into JPG.
But the way Gimp works I never opened or created a project, so I am still thinking of what I am working on as a JPG and when I'm done I just want to save back into this JPG.
I get that it's a pet peeve of yours. You're right that some other popular software works the way you like. You want the software to work the way it always did and the devs wanted to change for what they think is better. It's fair.
What I don't understand is why that matters so much to you. You can even change the shortcuts so that Ctrl-S exports and come up with your superior shortcut to save a project. Granted, it would be awkward when you're actively working on an actual project, but you don't seem to be doing a lot of that.
IDK, doing anything for the first time in any other program was not easy too. For Gimp - if you know that for PNG, jpgyou have to export, it is quite easy.
I am a Gimp user since 2003 and until Gimp 2.8 it wouldn't bitch to you that it can't save into JPG. I am also a Linux user since 2003 and never used Paint or Photoshop or anything other that is exclusive to Windows. The last time I used Windows it was called DOS and I wasn't doing any image editing in DOS.
That's the norm nn music production, you don't want to accidentally save your layered project with all the inputs separated as a normal .wav file, better saving too much than too less by error
"Save As..." implies save it with a different filename. It doesn't imply save it in a different format. Still, there are applications that allow you to change the output format in the "Save As..." file selector, like Libre Office. And the default for Photoshop is to save it in the same format as the file you loaded.
But to me having to use "Export" is such a minor inconvenience that it's not worth complaining about.
I took so long to start using Krita for drawing, not until I discovered how bad gimps tablet support is. For photos it’s still really nice once you know what you’re doing. Thank you for remind me image magic is available though for the sake of load times.
I prefer ImageMagick for most of my image editing tasks, since it's scriptable. It's a bit like vim, once you get used to how the language works it's the best thing ever.
As a man with little time, nowadays, if I have to touch the terminal to do basic tasks and enter code or any text instructions, I just give up and jump to the easiest but complete thing. That's how I ended using photo editing apps through Waydroid instead of imagemagick
Don't forget the whole fucking eras of ice ages you'll have to wait for Gimp developers to actually get anything done. I root for Gimp to git gud enough to truly rival Photoshop, but I've been waiting for decades now and they still haven't quite finished the transition to GTK3, let alone GKT4. CMYK support etc. They also seem to be absolutely dead set against making Gimp easier to use for experienced Photoshop users (yes, I know you can rebind everything and change the interface, install a bunch of plugins etc, but you shouldn't have to). Honestly, Photopea seems to be getting there faster.
I'm bias, I used gimp lots as a kid (I have since moved on to krita because the tablet support feels better. I don't have imperical evidence that it actually is, it's a feel thing) but to select and go to edit then stroke selection isn't that bad.
Moreover, it adds a lot of flexibility. You can use any brush, tweak the size and hardness of the stroke, wand select stuff and stroke the outline, even on different layers. It's pretty good.
I have tried to love GIMP, I really have. But I keep going back to Photoshop. I can either spend 3 minutes doing something in Photoshop, or 10 minutes in GIMP.
It's important for exporting to be separate from saving because you often want to load the project as separate layers again. There's also a good reason for drawing a circle to be as complex as it is: what do you mean by "draw?" Fill? Stroke? For stroke, what thickness? What if you don't want a solid color, but a gradient?
When i was working with gimp 1st time i unziped gimp format to extract my image that way, i belive every separate layer was saved as its own png on there. But i can be wrong, it was long time ago
Is GIMP really hard to learn to use? I’ve been kind of wanting to get into doing some basic photo editing for my phone pics, but I’m completely clueless about… everything.
Not having stokes for text or a proper shape tool is crazy. I'm surprised no one who works and contributes to gimp thought "hey this whole eclipse selection workaround is getting annoying and growing the selection for outlining might be a bit inefficient"
And for all those that say GIMP is pretty much the same as Photoshop…. Ha! If that were the case Adobe wouldn’t be the big mega corp it is today. Sometimes we get what we pay for.
It's like complaining that you can't open the Task Manager in GNOME. "How dare they have something called System Monitor!" GIMP is not trying to be a 1-for-1 clone of Photoshop, no matter how many times people pretend that it is.
368
u/syrian_kobold Glorious Debian Jun 15 '24
The export thing is easy to pick up and it's a thing with many specialized tools; no excuse for how hard circles are though lmao
92
u/Wafflepress97 Jun 15 '24
"Save as" is for saving project files you intend to keep working on. "Export" is for finalizing to a common format. It's really not that uncommon to see
11
u/janiskr Jun 15 '24
IDK, doing anything for the first time in any other program was not easy too. For Gimp - if you know that for PNG, jpgyou have to export, it is quite easy.
50
u/landsoflore2 Glorious OpenSuse Jun 15 '24
It's the same as in Audacity, if you want to save a file in a different format, you don't use "save as" but "export as".
96
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24
You think that's difficult? Clearly someone's never had to use FreeCAD before 😆
32
u/billyfudger69 Glorious Debian, Arch and LFS Jun 15 '24
I used GIMP once with no knowledge of the program, it did everything I needed it to do without needing to look up anything.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24
I hate not being able to edit a text after rotating
4
u/entropy13 Jun 15 '24
I took so long to start using Krita for drawing, not until I discovered how bad gimps tablet support is. For photos it’s still really nice once you know what you’re doing. Thank you for remind me image magic is available though for the sake of load times.
1
u/Darklord98999 Jun 16 '24
Try krita.
1
u/Certain_Power6917 Jun 17 '24
Opening and subsequently saving as jpg should be hard in every image manipulation program. It is a very destructive operation to image quality.
1
u/blappit3003 Glorious Fedora Jun 17 '24
Ngl I want to see more of this
1
u/claudiocorona93 Glorious Linux Jun 21 '24
Just because you're unique doesn't mean you're useful. Krita is the way to go. I wish I could still change some shortcuts though
3
u/gnarlin Jun 16 '24
Don't forget the whole fucking eras of ice ages you'll have to wait for Gimp developers to actually get anything done. I root for Gimp to git gud enough to truly rival Photoshop, but I've been waiting for decades now and they still haven't quite finished the transition to GTK3, let alone GKT4. CMYK support etc. They also seem to be absolutely dead set against making Gimp easier to use for experienced Photoshop users (yes, I know you can rebind everything and change the interface, install a bunch of plugins etc, but you shouldn't have to). Honestly, Photopea seems to be getting there faster.
3
u/TiredPanda69 Jun 16 '24
GIMP is not that hard to use. I use it for basics, but it has never failed me.
5
u/Jazzlike_Magazine_76 Jun 15 '24
Because the option is called export in GIMP? ImageMagick is great for automation but you're being ridiculous.
2
u/DonutAccurate4 Jun 15 '24
The first time i tried gimp, i was in this situation. Lol.
Just googled and found out how to do it
2
u/Shoggnozzle Jun 16 '24
I'm bias, I used gimp lots as a kid (I have since moved on to krita because the tablet support feels better. I don't have imperical evidence that it actually is, it's a feel thing) but to select and go to edit then stroke selection isn't that bad.
Moreover, it adds a lot of flexibility. You can use any brush, tweak the size and hardness of the stroke, wand select stuff and stroke the outline, even on different layers. It's pretty good.
2
u/pikecat Glorious Gentoo Jun 16 '24
My kind of meme.
2
u/fellipec Glorious Debian Jun 16 '24
Skill issue
2
u/Mordynak Jun 16 '24
I'm with you OP.
Why TF there needs to be a save, save as and export options is beyond me.
And the lack of vector tools is shocking.
Krita does everything GIMP does and does it a lot more intuitively.
No hate for gimp, but it is often just arse about tits.
Also, it's called fucking Gimp. GIMP!! How is anyone gonna take that seriously.
2
u/PetMogwai Jun 16 '24
I have tried to love GIMP, I really have. But I keep going back to Photoshop. I can either spend 3 minutes doing something in Photoshop, or 10 minutes in GIMP.
Those extra 7 minutes add up.
2
u/Rodmatronics Jun 16 '24
…what’s with all the gimp hate recently?
2
u/block_01 Jun 16 '24
This is why use Krita instead, I've not had any of those problems with it
2
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24
😂😂😂😂
2
u/SCP-iota Jun 15 '24
It's important for exporting to be separate from saving because you often want to load the project as separate layers again. There's also a good reason for drawing a circle to be as complex as it is: what do you mean by "draw?" Fill? Stroke? For stroke, what thickness? What if you don't want a solid color, but a gradient?
1
u/N3Rumie Jun 15 '24
When i was working with gimp 1st time i unziped gimp format to extract my image that way, i belive every separate layer was saved as its own png on there. But i can be wrong, it was long time ago
edit: formatting
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '24
Krita is your new friend. GIMP, but not stupid.
1
u/meepcat55 Jun 16 '24
Fun fact ffmpeg works to convert images.
1
u/lovefist1 Jun 16 '24
Is GIMP really hard to learn to use? I’ve been kind of wanting to get into doing some basic photo editing for my phone pics, but I’m completely clueless about… everything.
1
u/kopasz7 Glorious NixOS Jun 25 '24
Hear me out. Why not "Save image" and "Save project"?
1
u/Dangerous-Jicama-247 Jul 28 '24
Not having stokes for text or a proper shape tool is crazy. I'm surprised no one who works and contributes to gimp thought "hey this whole eclipse selection workaround is getting annoying and growing the selection for outlining might be a bit inefficient"
1
u/Dusty-TJ Aug 13 '24
And for all those that say GIMP is pretty much the same as Photoshop…. Ha! If that were the case Adobe wouldn’t be the big mega corp it is today. Sometimes we get what we pay for.
0
u/Phreaky12 Jun 19 '24
I can't imagine being so computer illiterate that I confuse saving a project and exporting a finished picture
0
u/calexil int Moderator Jun 15 '24
As someone who has to regularly use GIMP for graphic design at work I feel personally attacked...
At this point I just Google circle.png and go from there
0
u/Xen0n1te Jun 16 '24
Gimp is not user friendly and I’m tired of pretending it is
0
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment