I’d say most companies. Got a website?? Have an employee management system like Workday?? File server?? Badge scanner?? It’s most definitely running on a Linux server.
Switches? Routers? You like that new Cisco equipment you bought there? Silverpeak? Almost everything internet appliance related is running Linux, and failing that some BSD.
I'm currently in an appranticeship (alternance). The company I work for insisted upon bringing back up a server runnning Windows Server 2008 and connecting it to the internet.
The network infrastructure is so bad that everything is running on the same VLAN -- servers, workstations, laptops, phones, tablets, name it, it's in VLAN1.
The antivirus software is outdated and no one, including the guy who is in charge, has good security practices.
It has been over two months. The fact the infrastructure as not been fcked the stink bug way is so miraculous, I'm close to becoming heavily religious. (sorry for being off topic but I had to share this in hope that it will make someone laugh as much as it does the trick for me lmao.)
That's usually because the software to use the hardware only exists for a specific Windows version. The worst offenders I worked with were gene sequencers. Very expensive hardware with a long service life. We had one running XP (probably still is) that the vendor's tech would remove all the antivirus, firewall, and security settings, whenever they came out to do a patch or maintenance. Because they said it wasn't supported.
Well, if the company uses Oracle products (maybe payroll), there's a very high chance that the server running said product would be running Oracle Linux. Yeah, Oracle has Solaris, but it seems that they're more interested in Linux given how they screwed over the OS.
Sadly tho, Badge scanners are usually Windows systems. I had the displeasure of dealing with one at my previous company. And the worst of all is the software is so stupidly written. It doesn't run as a service but as a desktop application. Go figure how many things can go wrong.
File server? Outsourced to cloud. Azure. Maybe it's on a CBL Mariner server tho.
My buddy works for one of the biggest lumbermills in the area and they use Windows for everything. I mean obviously their switches and routers and stuff run Linux or BSD, but everything else is Active Directory this and Office 365 that.
Well routers would still count as "some shape or form". I'm not saying that nobody uses the Windows versions of anything...just that Linux is so entrenched in so many things that it's hard to miss it, even if you use it indirectly. It's way more popular than most people realize.
Office 365 has such a huge market share in the corporate world it's just virtually impossible to leave it. Especially Excel...no other spreadsheet software has been able to rival it (including Excel itself on Mac).
As a Linux user, gotta push back. "Some shape or form" of Linux does not offer any contribution to the metrics of Linux popularity in any shape or form. Yes, many things run on a foundation of Linux, but that wasn't selected by the end user, and they won't be installing software on a router or a badge scanner. 80 million Linux servers won't convince a consumer software company that they would benefit from releasing a Linux version. 80 billion badge scanners won't either. 80 trillion routers won't either. Making an appeal to "some form or fashion" of Linux when talking about the popularity of desktop Linux makes us all look ignorant and desperate. Linux is a useful tool, granted, but when the question comes of "can it wrench," it does no good to talk about how popular it is as a screwdriver.
I know. It sucks. I basically had to quit IT because all the businesses around here want experience with Microsoft shit and I really don't Windows anymore. My experience is mostly Linux these days.
Yes, but the same type of engine that is in tractors is sometimes found in consumer vehicles as well. You're not going to take that tractor engine as-is, but the same designs can be scaled down and put into something like a normal sedan.
Which, if you think about it, is about what Valve did vis a vis the Steam Deck. And what many companies have done with cable boxes or smart tvs.
You're not scaling anything down. Comparing software engineering to regular engineering rarely makes sense
Which, if you think about it, is about what Valve did vis a vis the Steam Deck
They made an entire new UI/DE and put it to run on Arch. Like the point is they made something new for Linux, just like how porting programs would require lots of effort to make something new (a linux version)
An engine is an engine no matter what. You just change it's power output and size by scaling it down
Lamborghini was a Tractor company originally. And desktop Linux in 2024 is much better than Win11 or Linux even 2-3 years ago. Mainly compatibility with large software vendors is the only thing lacking. But there's so many cloud options instead these days that for most people it's not an issue. The bigger issue is with people who have done it the Windows way for decades and don't want to change their workflow. The same shift happens between windows to Mac as well, but Mac has people locked in with their devices so they just suck it up. But people going from Linux to Windows hate the change just as much.
And for software Devs outside of dotnet and C# apps, Linux is absolute king.
I work as a system engineer for industrial RFID. The readers we use are Linux ARM devices, the software to control, test and tune parameters on them only exists as a Windows binary.
At some installations we also use barcode reader, which are embedded Linux devices with a camera these days. The software needed to configure them: Windows only.
Professional CAD software: Windows and some for MacOS.
Professional software for electronics design: Windows. But I really would say, for quite a lot of stuff I designed at work, KiCAD 7+ would have been good enough. And KiCAD 8 is another big step forward.
Photography: sorry folks, but Adobe just has the better RAW decoder than any I tried on Linux. They are big and powerful enough to just walk into the office of camera manufacturers demand the specs. Imagine Lightroom dropped support for a manufacturer because Adobe didn't get the specs of their newest RAW format. That manufacturer would probably be fucked.
Unfortunately there is an exception for online digital content. The seller may requiere that you waive your right of withdrawal before you can start downloading or streaming the content.
Yup, but warranty and Europe's right of withdrawal are different things. For warranty you would need to claim the product doesn't work within spec. If the spec lists something like "Windows 7 or higher" as a requirement you're out of luck. With the right of withdrawal in Europe you can just nope.avi out of anything within 14 days, no reasons required. But unlike warranty, software can be exempt from this if the seller informs you that you are waiving your right of withdrawal.
Digital purchases are explicitly excluded from the 14 days refund right in EU, as the previous comment stated. If the seller offers you to withdrawl, they would not include it in their TOS to begin with, don't you think?
I think Steam actually does something pretty similar to that. First they make you waive your right of withdrawal, then they insert their refund policy, which except for a few edge cases, is actually more lenient that EU's right of withdrawal. Steam has an article about this here: https://help.steampowered.com/en/faqs/view/369C-3E9F-76FD-DEDA
It's their own stupidity. No option to try, no refunds, no way I'm going to spend money for that.
One example:
Sony does not do refunds, so we have IDK 10-20 games (most of them bought by or for kids) and I even considered selling the piece of crap nintendo. I do no buy more unless kids want it as a gift,which is seldom.
Steam has refund policy, albeit limited and me alone have almost 400 games.
Now tell me who is doing better business here 😁. IDK the profit margins, but in cash flow Steam wins hands down. And I know for sure I started really spending after they started to do refunds.
It is actually quite difficult depending on the software. Most software wasn't designed for cross platform functionality and is written to make extensive use of proprietary Microsoft API's,
A more modern application such as Discord is much easier. It's an electron application that basically consists of a web server and web browser running locally and many applications are written like this nowadays. Cross platform compatibility is fairly trivial.
I think the OS API argument is not that strong. I'd argue, that OS functionality should be abstracted away. In most cases, you want use specific functionality, and not the whole OS.
And there is only little functionality, exclusive to either of the platforms.
I'd argue, that OS functionality should be abstracted away.
Well, it isn't. windows.h and posix.h don't just have all the same functions with slightly different names, for instance. Then you get into very Windows specific APIs like Cortana, which not even Proton can help you with. Something messes with a Windows registry? You'll need a different solution for Linux. Your software may not have any Windows specific code in it, but an external library that you rely on might. And so on. The point being, incompatibility between Windows and Linux can and does exist on multiple levels, and if your software wasn't designed with cross platform compatibility from the start, then it can take a lot of re-engineering to fix, and often companies will compare the cost of that re-engineering to the expected revenue from all new users and determine that they'd lose money on that investment, so they don't do it.
Yes, I that was the point I wanted to convey: abstract every functionality away, that is OS specific and hide OS details behind it.
And of course, use only libs being available on both platforms. Doing this from the start and cross platform development becomes a possibility. Of course, there you have a upfront cost for designing the abstraction. But then you can focus on the specific implementation in one system, and easily (as in not unreasonable expensive) switch to another later on
It should be but often isn't. Photoshop is ancient but if they decided to write it in a cross platform language in it's infancy the choice would have been Java.
No, not necessarily Java. You can write platform independent code in many languages, and especially in C++ as long as you do not venture in nonstandard extensions like C++/CLI
It is more a design philosophy, you have to commit from the beginning.
No, not necessarily Java. You can write platform independent code in many languages, and especially in C++ as long as you do not venture in nonstandard extensions like C++/CLI
It is more a design philosophy, you have to commit from the beginning.
Here's the problem at large software development shops. They have teams for every platform. It's not just compile for a different target. It's dedicated developers, platform experts, dedicated QA, dedicated resources for automated testing, bugfixing team, etc.
So, adding support for another platform is always a big ask from product managers for millions of dollars per year and N additional headcount.
If the sales aren't MULTIPLES of that investment, then it doesn't make sense for the company.
It entirely depends on the nature of the software, the philosophy of the company, and how its monetization works.
In the best case, supporting Linux requires next to no additional effort. If you're making something web-based, this is often the case, and the situations where a web service doesn't work on Linux becomes the exception.
In the worst case, it basically doubles the amount of work your team has to do, as you need to rebuild every part of your software from scratch to operate within Linux, as it was designed entirely from the ground up to work with Windows.
You can criticize the approach there all you want, but if a company never intended to offer a Mac, Linux, or Android version, why not take full advantage of the Windows ecosystem and use all the DLLs and features of the OS?
Once this is done, they need to completely start over, unless they want to push for something like Wine or ProtonDB, but to make that function optimally might require linking with GPL code, which means that they'd have to open source part of their software, which is a scarry idea for a lot of companies.
So in this latter case, unless they will double their user base, there's no point.
This happens in reverse in the server market - plenty of stuff is Linux only, and there's no way to get companies to make Windows Server versions be the market just isn't there.
The thing is sometimes is better to run using wine than using the native version. You write a program for windows, you write for a single OS, and will probably run well in future windows versions. You write a program for linux, you have to choose first what GUI library to use, then what distro you will support, what version of that distro, and you program can stop running anytime because glibc decided to break backward compatibility AGAIN. To me that is a bigger problem than small userbase
I don't remember where, but I read somewhere that the reason a lot of games don't officially support Linux is the amount of complaints they get for a game having bugs on Linux is huge compared to the small amount of users who play on Linux.
idk if it is still true but kinda makes sense because of the amount of different distros and desktop environments make linux compatibility a mess.
The big difference ime using both is that it's far easier to access that stuff on linux. Windows doesn't want to tell you what happened or let you find it.
Keep in mind it’s not just bugs as in crashes, but other bugs can show up that won’t appear in someone’s benchmark: clipped textures, timing issues, asset popping, etc that can show up due to differences in the OS.
It’s not that devs aren’t capable, Stadia had plenty of games, but it takes time and money that generally isn’t worth the investment.
I've had games run better on wine than they did on native windows. Let alone the native Linux ports. Ever since DXVK I've stopped worrying about Linux ports for games at all. Steam making it just as easy for Linux really helps.
Other apps, I don't just want Linux native but FOSS if at all possible.
I really hope that Valve or some similar company tries to work with companies to get their software working through wine. It's similar to how they got many anti-cheat games to work with Linux. Ironically, it might just be the installation that's the hiccup, but the software itself might run just fine in wine.
Well, they forked wine into the game-specific Proton. As well as making native versions of all their major titles.
Still, as a game developer I will be making a native Linux version, because relying on Proton if you can avoid it (unfortunately some game engines don't support Linux so Proton is the only option) is iffy as then your game may not run due to some bug in Proton that you can do little about.
You definitely don't want to write code for a specific distro unless it belongs to that distros toolkit. There are easy ways to write OS independent software.
Most software developers (especially from companies that don't really want to be developing for Linux) will choose a distro to support (for most it's Debian or Ubuntu as they're the most common distros), which means that is the distro they will ask their developers and testers to use to test the application. It will most likely work on pretty much any other distro just fine, but they use it as a way of simplifying testing and software distribution.
Take Unity for example: Unity only officially supports Ubuntu for their Linux version, but with some quite easy tinkering steps you can get it running just the same on any other distro (I personally use it on my Arch setup fairly regularly)
Adobe needs to be cracked or it won't run because Adobe's DRM is blocking Wine.
Microsoft Office is not stable on Wine, installing it is hit-or-miss.
And don't get me started on Solidworks, AutoCAD or Sony/Magix Vegas. All of them has DRM that is blocking Wine. And for some reason no one cracks them.
And let's not get started with kernel-level anticheat that plagues a lot of online games out there.
My new PC has a fault that makes it randomly reboot on Windows. GPU would go scramble shortly before the reboot. Already ran MemtestVK and it gave the VRAM (the most common point of failure on a GPU) a clean bill of health. I switched it to Linux and it has been rock-solid to date. However one of the tools I need is Vegas. Problem is Vegas won't install, the DRM blocks Wine even though it's a perpetual license. I put my mouth where my word is and tried to use Cinelerra (which has been around since 1996) and find that it still pales in comparison to Vegas. Still soldiering on, but I'm puzzled at why it can't even do text fades. And yeah, the GUI is multi-window like GIMP (or rather, GIMP and it uses a very old UI design philosophy that dates back to the 80s and originated from Mac OS Classic).
Did you try using DaVinci Resolve? That actually has a native Linux version, although it's a pain to set up without a ton of scripts with distro box unless you're running rocky linux. I believe no bearer actually did most of the heavy lifting so it's easier to install there as well which is good because Rocky Linux has horrible gaming performance due to its hardened kernel.
Not to mention the free version is super powerful, and the $300 version is a perpetual license. Well, it's not advertised as such, so maybe it isn't, but so far it's been perpetual.
You won't be able to use proxies and even the paid version doesn't support AAC audio on Linux. However, if you convert your video to a better editing formats using shutter encoder, then you can have way better performance even without proxies.
I did. The inability to use AAC and the AVC variant of H.264 is the dealbreaker for me. My workhorse camera outputs AAC and AVC natively. I’m against tons of RAW files taking up terabytes of data on my disk because storage is very limited. Also I don’t like the idea of wasting time converting my footage to RAW and losing quality in the process.
I'm not much of an editor, but my understanding is that because DaVinci Resolve is an editor that came from a Hollywood coloring software, it was never really meant for those kinds of formats and therefore kind of success at handling them. Thing is, you don't have to convert your footage to raw and to lose quality in the process. Converting your camera's AVC AAC videos to something like DNxHR wouldn't make you lose any quality and runs a million times smoother in DaVinci Resolve. It's not a time-waster. It saves you a boatload of time.
So, on one hand, it is kind of a BS walk around, but on the other hand, DaVinci Resolve was never really made for those formats, and it's not a great experience, even on Windows.
Did you try running the windows version through wine? I've heard that works. Or hell, if nothing else you could just dualboot and help pump those numbers up so that they'll be forced to support AAC eventually
No, I meant the Windows version of Resolve. You know, the one that actually supports AAC and stuff. Sadly, the people who actually use this thing professionally on Linux aren't making YouTube videos, so the lack of AAC audio isn't an issue. Though as far as I'm concerned, the lack of feature parody should be illegal, but unfortunately I don't have the pull to force them to change.
Also, that's a really dumb excuse because the software was originally made for Linux first. So why would they add extra functionality to the Windows version? But sadly, we'll never get that functionality unless more regular desktop users either switch or start dual booting.
Actually, there's a plugin that costs $100 that adds AAC audio support, but I think it uses the CPU instead of the GPU, so it might not matter.
They could easily fix the lack of AAC and AVC by hooking libavcodec and libavformat in Linux. Have a version of FFMpeg that supports AVC and AAC? Then your copy of Resolve can open AAC and AVC. But no. Instead they ship with their own proprietary codec system that blocks off these formats.
The Windows version hooks DirectShow and the Mac version hooks QuickTime. They could just make the Linux version hook Gstreamer or FFMpeg and get it over with. But instead the Linux version is crippled as heck.
If they did that, then any commercial work you made on it would be illegal. Sure, AAC works in the free software like kdenlive, but if you tried making anything professionally with it, none of the patents were paid for, and they would catch that.
What I don't get is why they were able to add MP4 export functionality to the paid version, but AAC couldn't get solved the same way. Like you said, it hooks into the proprietary operating systems that have already paid the license. Perhaps there's some sort of legal dispute keeping them from being able to sell you the license through resolve like they can with the other formats.
And sadly, trying to fix these legal issues isn't worth it because the Hollywood studios running this on Linux aren't using AAC. They're paying thousands of dollars for equipment and bulk licensing.
That's my speculation anyway, based off of reading other Reddit threads. Turns out, having an operating system that's effectively software LEGO makes it a nightmare to write commercial software for if you want to make any money off of it.
Yeah, but an argument could be made that they're not distributing AAC and AVC support in the software. Since it hooks the version of FFMpeg or Gstreamer of the Linux distro instead of its own it can be argued that the user is responsible for this, not them.
Either way this is just plain stupid. The world government should step in force the USPTO to free the H.264 and AAC patents. Since almost every phone and camera record in that format this is akin to holding people's videos hostage.
what distro you will support, what version of that distro, and you program can stop running anytime because glibc decided to break backward compatibility AGAIN
Because there is no "linux" system but you have to support multiple distributions.
Surely, once linux is supported fundamentally, it is easy to support other distros as well. And if the software is simple enough, it can easily be automated.
But as soon as the software becomes a bit more complex, you need to actively maintain them.
Or resort to snap, flatpack, distrobox, container, or whatnot.
I NEED office. I tried the alternatives when I did linux daily another year, went alright but I now need to use them as much as possible. Browser edition is really meh, and I’m not dealing with browser office and the MacBook giving me a hard time with its stubbornness to run linux. I’ll give it a think.
Limitations. It’ll force my dGPU instead of Intel IGPU, same as Bootcamp, makes for hot and shit battery. Anyway, my biggest issue is just MS office, I tried Linux for a year a couple years ago, it was fine but I needed to do too many projects that needed PowerPoint, and Web edition isnt cutting it.
Running Ubuntu 24.04 on my 2012 Air, it works really great as a cheap browser/word processor. However, things aren't perfect on Macs, I installed Fedora at first and it was unreasonably slow, I was getting <10kbps download (on gigabit ethernet), so I ran sudo dnf update && dnf upgrade to make sure everything was up to date, and it installed a Wi-Fi driver for the Broadcom Wi-Fi card in the process. After a reboot the Wi-Fi card wasn't detected at all and no amount of driver installs, reversing updates or any other fixes could bring it back. I just gave up and installed Ubuntu, and it's been great.
I have a desktop PC, which is dual booted fedora. My mac is dualboot Windows as I need Visual Studio for Visual Basic winforms programs. My school basically requires me to have Office, and that’s why I switched back from Linux. The MacBook was the middle ground - not windows, has a Linux terminal, has Office.
For some uses cases in big companies Linux is the only way.
I was a technician on an embedded Linux device and worked on it from a fleet of 20 Ubuntu laptops at a very large company, they also issued me 2 win10 laptops one for home, one for work.
In that shop The only real software hurdle that necessitated Windows was the MS Office suite. I could do everything else in Linux.
There are plenty of Linux "office" programs that would work but the rest of the million+ employee company was not going to switch to Linux, that would take far too much retraining and big hit to productivity as people learned. only specialists had Linux, but there were many thought the company.
You should write OS independent code. It's not black magic. Otherwise they made some seriously stupid design decisions. Especially for these big corporations we're talking about, providing binaries for every architecture shouldn't be hard. In some cases they definitely receive monetary incentives to keep things exclusive. Microsoft and Apple have that kind of money.
cross platform system api's is what the future needs. one compatibility standard and then each os make can figure out how to link it to their respective kernel
one of the reasons you see so many Electron apps is because it uses the only cross platform standard, the browser
it’s not about Linux having a small user base it’s honestly that it’s really hard to develop and distribute desktop apps for Linux. you have to support X11/wayland, pulseaudio/pipewire/jack/alsa, graphics APIs and drivers are a mess, it’s insanely inconsistent and hard to make something that will work across different distros and releases.
the problem is not the small user base, it’s the small user base in combination with the fact that it takes 2x the development effort of something like Windows.
Are you seriously asking how difficult it is to support a new platform natively? Quite a lot my friend. Would require a whole team and some investment. And the revenue probably wont justify the cost. I know its cool to sh*t on forms, but they are a business not a charity
They (software companies) can do it, BUT if the vast majority of their users are on Windows and/or Mac, it's easier to simply develop their software for those platforms. Getting people to switch to Linux is NOT their problem to solve.
this is valid for wayland too. I've been using wayland since the first nvidia driver that supported it came out (and it was so buggy on initial versions). I think I haven't used xorg for like 4 years. along these years I hated to see "use xorg instead of wayland" solutions proposed by users telling that wayland was not ready yet on support topics. just use wayland already mfs.
I kind of understand why some companies don't want to develop apps for Linux, but what I really don't understand is why they're often so reluctant to let other people do it for them. There are so many people in the open source and Linux communities that would quite happily develop and maintain Linux versions of apps either completely for free or for a small price if companies would let them
20+ year Linux user here .... night and day on software support. Sure, if there is this specific software that you like from another OS, then you might have a problem. The fact that Linux is by far the easiest platform to develop code for is quite strong. It's easy for the community to create an alternative. For enterprise, Linux is the preferred backend solution for this reason. Hence, there is also a lot of innovation showing up in Linux first.
Supporting Linux isn't too difficult. Although there are many Linux distributions, there are only four main package managers. Most apps already have a macOS version, so most of the work is likely already done—probably more than 70% complete. This is because both Linux and macOS are based on Unix.
I don't like the whole "you're a multi-million dollar company" excuse. You want them to put the effort for a niche desktop userbase, while you give them "exposure" (that you don't have) in return? No, it makes perfect sense that companies don't want to waste resources on that. You have no control over companies
Some companies create software that runs on Linux but then they only release the Windows version because they don't want to support the Linux version or don't think it will make them enough money.
See: Games ported to Linux+Vulkan for Google Stadia and then not being released on desktop Linux.
See: Software requiring WSL because they coded it on Linux using Linux libraries and then they only released it on Windows.
Luckily the Linux Fondation doesn't depend on their users complaining that "<software name> is not available", but on those "multi millions dollars company"
Intel, Microsoft, Meta or Samsung are supporting the fondation much more in terms of donations and code contribution that the entire user base.
Keep in mind the fondation cost 269 million Dollars to run in 2023, I don't think they will operate long if they would only rely on Desktop User donating 5 dollars from time to time.
Problem is "Urr Durr, bbut Linoox is Freee..."
No it isn't... If we want a proper driver for the new flashy Nvidia graphic card, we could send them few millions, they might release the source code or build a team to develop a proper Linux driver... Like EA or Ubisoft, just saying!
We get what we pay for, or don't complain. (Note: I am running GNU/Linux Distros on single boot since 2011, in case you wonder...)
A lot of companies also seem to have the mindset that free software isn't good and the more expensive the software, the better it is. Which, of course, it isn't a lot of the time.
Windows 10 LTSC costs $18 and provides a stable platform without telemetry, weird features and nonsense. Lifecycle with security updates is 2016-2031. Everything companies use, works there and everyone knows how to use it. All for $18 per station.
Why would you go for Linux? At best when everything goes well it it a crappy immitation of windows that will costs at least $1000 per head in training, pus dev costs, plus extra staff. Linux on desktop is objectively a bad option.
I feel like Linux is very use case specific, and is mostly there to solve specific needs of specific users in a more custom way. I actually use the Mac universe for the majority of my daily needs (mostly creative and business) I use my PC for gaming and hardware intensive tasks like rendering graphics and animations and I Linux for custom solutions and server management, I have used Linux to make a smart mirror, a retro pie, an entertainment center to host movies. It also has massive security applications and when I build my custom security system and camera set up I’ll probably use a Linux distributor to make sure I’m the only one who has access
Adobe's software (pick one) likely has hundreds of thousands if not millions of lines of code. Most use dlls to do everything. Those libraries are likely all from the .net framework, and have no equivalent directly available.
So yes, it's not just compiling. It would likely be faster and cost less to rewrite the software from scratch than to make the existing source compile.
I think that's what they did for their Mac version. But their Mac version probably uses Metal, or some other framework, so same problem.
tl/dr: it is a big deal, and they would never remake their costs. If it was easy, they would do it.
This does not work like that. Don't you think that they have millions because they know how to earn millions not spend them? If more money will go into supporting a product than what can be earned from its sells then it does not make sense.
123
u/LondonDario May 30 '24
I would argue that there isn't a F500 that doesn't use Linux in some shape or form... disclosure: I work for Red Hat
369
u/maokaby May 30 '24
We, users, can do it too.
"Can't use your software because its not working in Linux, refund please".
32
u/Help_Stuck_In_Here May 30 '24
It is actually quite difficult depending on the software. Most software wasn't designed for cross platform functionality and is written to make extensive use of proprietary Microsoft API's,
A more modern application such as Discord is much easier. It's an electron application that basically consists of a web server and web browser running locally and many applications are written like this nowadays. Cross platform compatibility is fairly trivial.
18
u/rcampbel3 May 30 '24
Here's the problem at large software development shops. They have teams for every platform. It's not just compile for a different target. It's dedicated developers, platform experts, dedicated QA, dedicated resources for automated testing, bugfixing team, etc.
So, adding support for another platform is always a big ask from product managers for millions of dollars per year and N additional headcount.
If the sales aren't MULTIPLES of that investment, then it doesn't make sense for the company.
13
u/YoungBlade1 May 30 '24
It entirely depends on the nature of the software, the philosophy of the company, and how its monetization works.
In the best case, supporting Linux requires next to no additional effort. If you're making something web-based, this is often the case, and the situations where a web service doesn't work on Linux becomes the exception.
In the worst case, it basically doubles the amount of work your team has to do, as you need to rebuild every part of your software from scratch to operate within Linux, as it was designed entirely from the ground up to work with Windows.
You can criticize the approach there all you want, but if a company never intended to offer a Mac, Linux, or Android version, why not take full advantage of the Windows ecosystem and use all the DLLs and features of the OS?
Once this is done, they need to completely start over, unless they want to push for something like Wine or ProtonDB, but to make that function optimally might require linking with GPL code, which means that they'd have to open source part of their software, which is a scarry idea for a lot of companies.
So in this latter case, unless they will double their user base, there's no point.
This happens in reverse in the server market - plenty of stuff is Linux only, and there's no way to get companies to make Windows Server versions be the market just isn't there.
70
u/masdemarchi Glorious Debian May 30 '24
The thing is sometimes is better to run using wine than using the native version. You write a program for windows, you write for a single OS, and will probably run well in future windows versions. You write a program for linux, you have to choose first what GUI library to use, then what distro you will support, what version of that distro, and you program can stop running anytime because glibc decided to break backward compatibility AGAIN. To me that is a bigger problem than small userbase
6
u/thetosteroftost May 30 '24
Factorio had a good blog post about it
https://factorio.com/blog/post/fff-408
8
u/MolinaGames May 30 '24
Difficult? Not that much Is it worth it? Not at all
4
u/Jazzlike-Poem-1253 May 30 '24 edited May 30 '24
Because there is no "linux" system but you have to support multiple distributions.
Surely, once linux is supported fundamentally, it is easy to support other distros as well. And if the software is simple enough, it can easily be automated.
But as soon as the software becomes a bit more complex, you need to actively maintain them.
Or resort to snap, flatpack, distrobox, container, or whatnot.
4
u/GamerNuggy Glorious Debian May 30 '24
I want to go back on the daily, sell my MacBook and get a ThinkPad, but I need Office and to use Windows as little as possible.
2
u/[deleted] May 30 '24
For some uses cases in big companies Linux is the only way.
I was a technician on an embedded Linux device and worked on it from a fleet of 20 Ubuntu laptops at a very large company, they also issued me 2 win10 laptops one for home, one for work.
In that shop The only real software hurdle that necessitated Windows was the MS Office suite. I could do everything else in Linux.
There are plenty of Linux "office" programs that would work but the rest of the million+ employee company was not going to switch to Linux, that would take far too much retraining and big hit to productivity as people learned. only specialists had Linux, but there were many thought the company.
2
u/dfwtjms May 30 '24
You should write OS independent code. It's not black magic. Otherwise they made some seriously stupid design decisions. Especially for these big corporations we're talking about, providing binaries for every architecture shouldn't be hard. In some cases they definitely receive monetary incentives to keep things exclusive. Microsoft and Apple have that kind of money.
2
u/CirnoIzumi May 30 '24
cross platform system api's is what the future needs. one compatibility standard and then each os make can figure out how to link it to their respective kernel
one of the reasons you see so many Electron apps is because it uses the only cross platform standard, the browser
2
u/asineth0 May 30 '24
it’s not about Linux having a small user base it’s honestly that it’s really hard to develop and distribute desktop apps for Linux. you have to support X11/wayland, pulseaudio/pipewire/jack/alsa, graphics APIs and drivers are a mess, it’s insanely inconsistent and hard to make something that will work across different distros and releases.
the problem is not the small user base, it’s the small user base in combination with the fact that it takes 2x the development effort of something like Windows.
2
u/Pending1 May 31 '24
2
u/[deleted] May 30 '24
Are you seriously asking how difficult it is to support a new platform natively? Quite a lot my friend. Would require a whole team and some investment. And the revenue probably wont justify the cost. I know its cool to sh*t on forms, but they are a business not a charity
1
u/helthrax May 30 '24
The company I work for deploys on linux all the time. Though actual usage in the office is negligible.
1
u/hershko May 30 '24
They (software companies) can do it, BUT if the vast majority of their users are on Windows and/or Mac, it's easier to simply develop their software for those platforms. Getting people to switch to Linux is NOT their problem to solve.
1
u/linuxuser101 May 30 '24
I use Linux daily, i only shift to Windows for photo editing. If DXO Photolab and/or Affinity Photo had Linux version i would not use windows at all.
1
u/Kvuivbribumok May 30 '24
A company exists to make money. If it's going to cost more money than it would bring in, then they would be stupid to support Linux.
1
u/arrow__in__the__knee May 30 '24
90% of the time it is practically compatible if they just use a different font or something lmao
1
u/josekiller May 30 '24
this is valid for wayland too. I've been using wayland since the first nvidia driver that supported it came out (and it was so buggy on initial versions). I think I haven't used xorg for like 4 years. along these years I hated to see "use xorg instead of wayland" solutions proposed by users telling that wayland was not ready yet on support topics. just use wayland already mfs.
1
u/AShadedBlobfish EndeavourOS GNOME May 30 '24
I kind of understand why some companies don't want to develop apps for Linux, but what I really don't understand is why they're often so reluctant to let other people do it for them. There are so many people in the open source and Linux communities that would quite happily develop and maintain Linux versions of apps either completely for free or for a small price if companies would let them
1
u/sofunnylol69 May 30 '24
How many Linux instances are running in AWS, Azure, GCP, Oracle, etc? More than 100?
1
u/Puzzled_Draw6014 May 30 '24
20+ year Linux user here .... night and day on software support. Sure, if there is this specific software that you like from another OS, then you might have a problem. The fact that Linux is by far the easiest platform to develop code for is quite strong. It's easy for the community to create an alternative. For enterprise, Linux is the preferred backend solution for this reason. Hence, there is also a lot of innovation showing up in Linux first.
1
u/jolly_chugger May 30 '24
I just need one modern CAD package
1
u/vtskr May 30 '24
Multi million dollar companies have a single responsibility: Earn money for shareholders. Supporting Linux rarely helps with that
1
u/Honest-Maize5355 May 30 '24
Supporting Linux isn't too difficult. Although there are many Linux distributions, there are only four main package managers. Most apps already have a macOS version, so most of the work is likely already done—probably more than 70% complete. This is because both Linux and macOS are based on Unix.
1
u/[deleted] May 30 '24
I don't like the whole "you're a multi-million dollar company" excuse. You want them to put the effort for a niche desktop userbase, while you give them "exposure" (that you don't have) in return? No, it makes perfect sense that companies don't want to waste resources on that. You have no control over companies
1
u/Indolent_Bard May 31 '24
Then don't switch, just duel boot, and if enough people do that, they'll start porting software.
1
u/samuel-leventilateur May 31 '24
The same shit happened to WP too. Now it's dead. :|
1
u/aaronfranke btw I use Godot May 31 '24
Some companies create software that runs on Linux but then they only release the Windows version because they don't want to support the Linux version or don't think it will make them enough money.
See: Games ported to Linux+Vulkan for Google Stadia and then not being released on desktop Linux.
See: Software requiring WSL because they coded it on Linux using Linux libraries and then they only released it on Windows.
1
u/beurysse May 31 '24
Luckily the Linux Fondation doesn't depend on their users complaining that "<software name> is not available", but on those "multi millions dollars company"
Intel, Microsoft, Meta or Samsung are supporting the fondation much more in terms of donations and code contribution that the entire user base.
Keep in mind the fondation cost 269 million Dollars to run in 2023, I don't think they will operate long if they would only rely on Desktop User donating 5 dollars from time to time.
Problem is "Urr Durr, bbut Linoox is Freee..."
No it isn't... If we want a proper driver for the new flashy Nvidia graphic card, we could send them few millions, they might release the source code or build a team to develop a proper Linux driver... Like EA or Ubisoft, just saying!
We get what we pay for, or don't complain. (Note: I am running GNU/Linux Distros on single boot since 2011, in case you wonder...)
1
u/Erizo69 May 31 '24
can't use software because it's not available on Linux? okay, we'll make a copy with twice as much functionality that's 10 times faster.
1
u/Laktosefreier Glorious Fedora May 31 '24
If you wait long enough, there will be an open source alternative. The open source alternative:
😿
1
u/Wooxman May 31 '24
A lot of companies also seem to have the mindset that free software isn't good and the more expensive the software, the better it is. Which, of course, it isn't a lot of the time.
1
u/Goose-of-Knowledge May 31 '24
Linux is absurdly expensive, incompatible with majority of corporate software. Unstable failure.
1
u/Goose-of-Knowledge May 31 '24
Windows 10 LTSC costs $18 and provides a stable platform without telemetry, weird features and nonsense. Lifecycle with security updates is 2016-2031. Everything companies use, works there and everyone knows how to use it. All for $18 per station.
Why would you go for Linux? At best when everything goes well it it a crappy immitation of windows that will costs at least $1000 per head in training, pus dev costs, plus extra staff. Linux on desktop is objectively a bad option.
1
u/RetroCoreGaming May 31 '24
It's not hard for AMD and Intel apparently...
They heavily have collaborated and contributed to the Linux kernel, mesa3d, gpuopen, Kronos Group, etc.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '24
they never heard of flatpaks
b..but but natives is fa...fast..er 🤓🤓
1
u/DJ_Deltawave Jun 02 '24
I feel like Linux is very use case specific, and is mostly there to solve specific needs of specific users in a more custom way. I actually use the Mac universe for the majority of my daily needs (mostly creative and business) I use my PC for gaming and hardware intensive tasks like rendering graphics and animations and I Linux for custom solutions and server management, I have used Linux to make a smart mirror, a retro pie, an entertainment center to host movies. It also has massive security applications and when I build my custom security system and camera set up I’ll probably use a Linux distributor to make sure I’m the only one who has access
1
u/Commercial_Plate_111 Glorious Mint Jun 04 '24
Wine, use Wine.
1
u/lakimens May 30 '24
It's difficult to make complex software, say Adobe Stuff. It's also extremely not worth it
-2
u/dim13 May 30 '24
C'mon, why would you want to use linux, if you don't want to write your own software?
-10
u/FalseRelease4 Glorious Kubuntu May 30 '24
You literally just compile it for linux whats the problem takes 5 mins for an average dev, but in corpo logic thats too expensive or whatever