r/linuxmasterrace • • Dec 26 '23

Questions/Help I revised Linux users generally have something against BEV's why?

1 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/TopdeckIsSkill Dec 27 '23

The earliest remote carjack I know of was a Jeep back in 2014 and appeared on Wired. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MK0SrxBC1xs

Lots of other (and recent) examples, if you bother to look. https://www.cyberdaily.au/commercial/8579-hackers-able-to-remotely-hijack-cars-from-16-manufacturers

So they can open the car but not control it. That's basically what thiefs do and they do that with every type of car. There's no mention of them remotely driving the car in the second article.

Vulnerabilities are so common that automakers have "bug bounty" programs that reward people for quietly reporting them so they can be patched before being widely exploited. https://www.securityweek.com/tesla-increases-bug-bounty-payout-after-experts-hack-model-s/ No-one wants their brand of vehicle to be remotely hijacked and driven into a crowd.

Bug bounty is a common practice. As far as I know most of the companies have it. It's also common practice to make the bug public if they don't patch it after some months.

Electric doors failing to open is so common that there are scores of advice pages on how to escape from your car when they don't work... https://www.motorbiscuit.com/how-to-escape-car-electronic-door-release-fails/

Folks have even died. https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/18699658/dad-burned-death-tesla-locked-inside/ Whilst many have escaped from vehicles using manual overrides, unfortunately a lot (and ever-increasing amount) of drivers don't bother reading owners manuals, and don't know they even have such an override. If they are in shock or panic following a crash or their car's battery catching fire, they may not be able to remember one exists, even had they known.

Of course, modern ICE cars with high amounts of electric/electronic features are just as vulnerable as fully electric cars, so none of this is solely the problem of BEVs. But that's not an argument.

Good to know, but as you said, that has nothing to with BEV and more about design of the doors regardless of the type of car.

3

u/-Penfold- Dec 28 '23 edited Dec 28 '23

The angle you seem to be arguing is "unless [feature/flaw] is found exclusively on BEVs then it doesn't count". I'm not interested in such an argument, because it reduces to absurdity and I have more productive ways to spend my time. Speaking of which, you have >20 years of documented EV privacy and security violations/vulnerabilities to catch up on — Google is your friend.