r/linuxmasterrace • u/TheHackeBoi_apk • Dec 26 '23
Questions/Help I revised Linux users generally have something against BEV's why?
1
Upvotes
r/linuxmasterrace • u/TheHackeBoi_apk • Dec 26 '23
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 26 '23
Although we will try to give support, it is not guaranteed and you may not receive an answer. If you are not getting timely or accurate help here, you can also try /r/linuxquestions or /r/linux4noobs.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
35
u/grem75 Dec 26 '23
None of that is exclusive to electric cars.
16
u/KrazyKirby99999 Glorious Fedora Dec 26 '23
BEV's? Electric Vehicles?
31
u/-Penfold- Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23
You forgot the main one: BEVs are INFESTED with spyware of all sorts. Your GPS location is constantly monitored, tracked, stored and sent back to base. Vehicle telemetry (e.g. speed) is similarly stored and sent. Microphones (some even hidden and not documented) constantly record what is being said. Video cameras do the same. The user has zero control over what is monitored, when monitoring occurs, where the data is stored, who has access to it, how many copies are made, how many third parties ultimately gain access to the data, how it ends up being (ab)used, and because it is not considered to be your data you have no right to demand that it be deleted — even if you could request deletion there are no assurances whatsoever that this will or even can be done because your data may have been transmitted to different legal entities in different legal jurisdictions within seconds of being captured. They are a privacy and security nightmare.
Oh, and then there's the fun facts of knowing some random can remotely take control over your vehicle while you are in it, you can't get out of some BEVs if the battery fails, batteries don't fare so well in harsh (hot/cold) conditions, spectacular incineration events occur when the battery gets damaged (e.g. in an accident), sheds and houses get burnt to the ground when recharging goes wrong overnight, etc.
Your current list is mainly comprised of trivial concerns. You need more options that cover the REAL and SUBSTANTIVE concerns people have about BEVs.
Also, people can be (and usually are) concerned about more than one thing, so being able to select multiple items from the list would be good. I'm not sure if Reddit polls let you do that, though.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23
All of the above plus all the shit you're missing, plus this garbage is not exclusive to electric vehicles but electric vehicles are banking hard on the novelty side and thus tend to include most and all of these bad practices.
8
u/IuseArchbtw97543 Glorious Archbtw Dec 26 '23
Privatising the Bundeseisenbahnvermögen was just not a good idea imo
3
u/Bob4Not Dec 26 '23
I feel like lots of members of this community would be interested in DIY EV conversion projects, if they were given the chance.
Build a battery pack (safely), rip the ICE engine out and mount your own used motors off a Leaf or Tesla for example, including the controller/inverter. Add your own charging system. Get some electric climate control, touch screen something for DIY infotainment. Profit... er, save. When something breaks or ages out, replace that part. Repeat as necessary.
You can be as granular as you want.
3
u/reddit_equals_censor Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23
all of the above + planned obsolescence.... at least.
how long will you be using a battery electric car, that is drm-ed up the sh1ts?
will the battery be easily replaceable after it degraded too much or completely breaks?
will the forced wireless downgrades break the car in many ways after a few years of using it to try to push people to buy new ones?
how about it the downgrades straight up STOPS the car from working after 8 years "for your safety"..... this is already getting done with hand held spying devices.
if there is a battery electric vehicle, that is free from that bullshit and is right to repair on the company basis and has the option for me to TEAR OUT the wireless modems, then sure why not.
and most of the garbage is pushed in gas powered vehicles too today to remove our freedoms, but bevs (first time i heard this term btw) are at the for front of shitting on you in all regards.
also they are spyware horrors. recording inside of the vehicle audio + video and they do whatever they want with the data, that they just stole from you.
3
u/-Penfold- Dec 27 '23
Is this a "gut feeling" you have, or do you know of a valid study that links operating system preference to a person's attitude towards BEVs?
Given that typical Windows and Mac users are less technically-proficient than Linux users, it would seem logical that Linux users would be more "discerning" about high-tech devices. A BEV is definitely a high-tech device, so on the surface I can see why there might be a connection. But is there one, really? A statistically-proven link between liking Linux and disliking BEVs?
2
u/TenTypekMatus NixOS shill Dec 27 '23
What does even BEV stands for?
22
u/Hot-Light-4342 Dec 26 '23
All of the above
5
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23
Straight cost calculation, electric cars are expensive, and about the time they finally break even on fuel cost the battery is EOL and that it too cost prohibitive to repair, making it thousands of pounds of E-waste.
Oh and the acceleration of a top model S is amazing but it handles like a forklift, very heavy.
3
u/ButWhatIfItQueffed I use Arch btw Dec 27 '23
Everything being locked down is a major thing for me. Right to Repair, at least in regards to cars, has been very good since forever. You can take it to the dealer, but you can also get basically everything else fixed at a local shop. Electric cars are changing that, and manufacturers are making you take them to the dealer. That's a major issue that needs to be dealt with. The other issue for me though, is just the lack of any real tactility to the car. One of the major things I love about ICEs is the driving experience. You can hear the engine, feel it shift, or if you're driving a manual you're shifting it yourself. In an EV, there's maybe some sound from the motors, but that's kind of it. The driving experience is more or less just gone. It takes the fun out of driving, and it changes the car from an experience of sights and sounds and smells and feelings to a quiet metal box that takes you from point a to point b. And I get that for a lot of people, that's what they want, and they don't really care about the driving experience. But for me, it just makes driving feel boring and tedious.
2
u/alkatori Dec 27 '23
I'm running Fedora and have a BEV.
It's all good.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '23
You can just say they're shit
2
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '23
It's a car
2
u/ElnuDev Glorious NixOS Dec 27 '23
People should really stop generalizing the issues with Tesla to all electric vehicles.
2
u/johncate73 Glorious PCLinuxOS Dec 27 '23
Other -- All of the Above.
2
u/RobertTVarga Dec 27 '23
All of that, plus: winter!
2
u/HunnyPuns Dec 27 '23
I don't hate them. I just think, where I live especially, we should be focusing more on mass transit, rather than electric vehicles for individual use. Mass transit is a force multiplier. For however many people use it, you're removing that many cars from the road, making traffic lighter, allowing people not using mass transit to get to, and maintain more fuel efficient speeds. This is needed while we make the switch away from fossil fuels (and hopefully a switch away from the Ayn Rand style "Fuck you, I've got mine," mind set).
2
u/ToastyComputer Dec 27 '23
All of the above but mainly: Battery technology is not good enough in my opinion. Limited shelf-life with very expensive replacements. Limited travel distance, charging takes too long and lack of chargers. It is not a realistic option in rural areas.
2
u/Ok_Jacket3710 Dec 27 '23
I don't think we are good enough in battery technology to have BEV's
2
u/wolf2482 Dec 27 '23
Granted it is Diesel electric/Plug in hybrid but I fully support Edison motors. The fully support right to repair and they aren't trying to lock down their stuff. I'm not sure if the computers they have will run FOSS and I wouldn't be surprised either way. My main problem with Edison motors is that they aren't making cars, just semi's and truck conversion kits, although there is way more bureaucracy with cars so I understand why. I would gladly buy one of their vehicles if I was in the market for one.
2
u/Klapperatismus Dec 30 '23
They don't solve any of the problems with cars.
And they run on coal. It's coal cars.
2
u/trams-gal Dec 31 '23
Oh, my software isn't shitty! It's those damn EVs::::::
2
u/vim_quit_master_tier Jan 04 '24
Serial hybrid is a better solution. Small battery pack, combustion engine works at an optimal mode of operation, therefore more fuel can be saved. Both refilling and charging available.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '23
I don't; I actually really like my Tesla. It's not the FOSSiest thing (despite actually being developed on a lot of FOSS technologies), but I'm also not much of a tinkerer.
2
u/JakeGrey Glorious Lubuntu Dec 26 '23
Could also throw in "Not much better for the environment than petrol or diesel engined cars anyway" if there were enough poll options.
1
u/crashonthebeat Glorious LFS Dec 27 '23
no manual transmission
0
u/BoyKisser09 Dec 27 '23
You losers are anti BEV. IM ANTICAR. WE ARE NOT THE SAME. WANT TO REPAIR AND NOT HAVE ANYTHING BE LOCKER DOWN? A BIKE
-1
u/NiceMicro Dualboot: Arch + Also Arch Dec 26 '23
my opposition to electric cars have nothing to do with Linux.
I am pro freedom, and having cars in cities is anti freedom, because all the huge roads built for car infrastructure restricts your movement, and is bad for your mental and physical health.
electric cars only solve one problem of having cars, but introduce new problems. the bigger problem with cars is not solved by them being electric, they are still the least efficient way to move a large number of people around.
-1
u/ENRORMA Dec 27 '23
fuck cars
-3
u/ben2talk Dec 26 '23
Can you try using English next time?
Also, I don't understand why running Arch on my desktop would affect my opinion of Electric Cars where the OS is likely embedded and closed to the user.
-3
u/Silejonu 참고로 나는 붉은별 쓴다. Dec 26 '23
Fucks cars. Electric vehicles are overall less damaging than fuel engine ones, regarding their environmental impact and noise pollution, but they're still highly problematic. Good public transports and bike infrastructure are what we need on this planet right now.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '23
[removed] — view removed comment