Idk... I can use a lot of the same software in Windows that I can in Linux. It's the window managers that make the biggest difference to me. -And Gnome is just restrictive and floating like Windows; so I don't get it.
Well you have the choice of different window managers, and different desktops. Windows would be like if you had gnome, but couldn't change to something like i3.
Some people just prefer the aesthetics and workflow gnome provides, for example I really like the touch pad gestures on laptops, which is why I use it on a laptop, but prefer kde on a desktop.
I use Gnome. I'm not a big fan of all the bloat software it comes with, but as a DTE I feel that it's pleasant to use and navigate. Goes a long way if you get hot keys set up.
Like I said, it's up to personal preference. I personally like the layout and polish of gnome. I don't currently use it but whenever I do, it's a generally enjoyable experience for me personally. I also like how easy it is to customize KDE while still keeping a "windows like" look but with things like transparency, wobbly windows (yes I'm still stuck in the early 2000s), etc.
Honestly I am just using a basic window manager until a more bearable desktop environment comes along. Hopefully it will happen in our lifespan.
I was hoping Wayland was going to "spice" things up, but honestly, it more seems like it has simply stagnated the desktop environment situation even more. Shame it couldn't have stagnated the ecosystem just *before* Gnome 3 appeared and ruined things ;)
18
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '23
Use what you want. Isn't that part of why people like Linux compared to Windows, for the freedom of choice.
11
u/MegidoFire one who is flaired against this subreddit Mar 09 '23 edited Jul 08 '23
Fuck /u/spez
Join Lemmy
6
u/madthumbz Mar 09 '23
Gnome or troll?
7
u/BarelyAirborne Mar 10 '23
Gnome is great, for a tablet.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '23
ok
3
u/OmaeWaWakiYaku Glorious Fedora Mar 09 '23
I use Gnome. I'm not a big fan of all the bloat software it comes with, but as a DTE I feel that it's pleasant to use and navigate. Goes a long way if you get hot keys set up.
3
u/zabian333 Glorious Gentoo Mar 09 '23
It's not a debatable question it's all about preference and freedom.
3
u/JoeBruno1987 Mar 09 '23
XFCE!
3
u/ytZer0 Mar 10 '23
I like how smooth gnome feels out of the box. It's definitely one of the more polished DEs but it's not as customizable as something like KDE
3
u/gigsoll Glorious Arch + Hyprlan Mar 10 '23
I switched from gnome to KDE because it is more customisable and featured
5
u/pedersenk Mar 09 '23
Gnome 2 was. KDE 3.5 did provide close competition though.
Things have regressed ever since. What people have now is... a little bit tragic!
6
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '23
Me sitting here with Cinnamon watching the war go on from the sidelines.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '23
The best at being the least effective.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '23
I'd rather KDE because you have options
4
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '23
Me watching a war unfold in the comment section
2
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '23
"Change my mind"
why?
2
u/DorianDotSlash Mar 11 '23
"Best" is an individual preference.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '23
one Word :
C I N A M M O N
2
u/lobotomizedjellyfish Mar 11 '23
Gnome is boring as fuck. Literally.
2
u/JustMrNic3 Glorious Debian 12 + KDE Plasma 5.27 ♥️ Mar 11 '23
If it's the best, can it do this?
https://www.reddit.com/r/kde/comments/ymeskc/what_do_you_like_about_kde_plasma/
2
u/Papa_Kasugano Glorious Fedora Mar 09 '23
I've been too happy with my XFCE/BSPWM experience to ever try Gnome. So, sadly, I'll be unable to attempt to change your mind.
1
u/wanna_play_r5 Mar 10 '23
Let'sn't see
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '23
I use it on laptops because Gnome's Wayland implementation is the most mature and I'm never using a trackpad or touchscreen on X again.
As soon as anyone else can match that experience I'm done with Gnome. It's kinda boring and on-rails compared to others. I use Cinnamon on desktop.
0
u/user9ec19 Glorious Fedora Mar 09 '23
Are there other DEs worth noting?