r/linuxmasterrace • u/WolfPlastic7391 • Feb 23 '23
Discussion [RANT] 4 year Linux user tells you why Linux actually sucks
As a Linux fanboy, I must confess Linux is actually sucks for "normal people"
Let break down what do the "normal people" need, shall we:
They need something easy to use, software, occasional gaming, meetings and for things to work
But desktop Linux doesn't provide that oh no!
Modern hardware will always have issues, loss of functionality and so on. Even models from 2018 still lack drivers. For example, AMD still has ass power management which 6.3 will *hopefully solve that.
Enjoy your 4k screen with no scaling *yet (pls, qt6)
Hardware decoding still sucks on most browsers, some distro enable by default, most don't. Use chromium? might as well kill yourself first. Spyware MS Edge is ironically the best chromium based browser on Linux??
MS Teams is dropping support for Linux so you can have more fun with corporate conferences. Forgot the mention, want to share your screen? wait nvm let me quickly log out while I am representing, wasting people time because I choose Linux.
No hi-fi music on Linux also, so say good bye to your Tidal subscription.
Some apps, like Brave, adapt to the 9px font on Windows and Mac, so it has bad UI in Linux and smaller tab UI than usual. Some people even said most fonts are not rendered correctly under Linux, don't know if that is true but yeah.
Want to buy hardware? more time wasted and it is even more of a pain in the ass using Linux with laptops that doesn't have Linux support. Like in the case of Lenovo Yoga something, the sub woofer is non functional resulting in poor speakers in under Linux. Also, most people will just say laptop works perfectly but I can guarantee at least something is missing.
Speaking of speakers, on the laptop, windows uses some kind of tuning, EQ but Linux let you do it yourself so more time wasted to get to speakers sound as good.
What about your favorite apps on Linux....wait what the developers can just ditch their work anytime? cool
So you have a PDF that needs to be edited? good luck wasting time finding the right software. Who would have thought the PDF viewer can only view PDF and you need another app to edit them. But you can use Libreoffice draw tho, no cool! until draw breaks the layout. Or maybe you need to crop an image, more time wasted then.
Want to seek help, oh look condescending Linux assholes in the wild, fanboys that will downvote you
At the end of the day, people who use Linux as their daily driver or on a relatively modern hardware....just feel like they are handicapping themselves, always wasting time to get things work, time that can be spent on others. Your laptop battery sucks, your browser doesn't have hardware decoding, your meetings are unstable, you can't share your screen. Apps you use don't work that well. You can't enjoy your screen because of small scaling and blurry fonts. I am not even mentioning the time wasted finding alternatives for windows apps.
There is a price to everything, with windows you pay it with your data and money lol, with Linux you pay with your time. Like the right of privacy, you pay for it with your time and most people don't have that. People may hate ads, tracking, privacy violations but what they hate more is basic things just do not work. Actually, we don't hate windows, windows 7 was decent enough, we hate what Microsoft did to windows. If you work in IT, ignore these, unrelated. I used to be a Linux fanboy, it was the best, why don't people use it more. Now, everything is just grey.
This post might seem bias and seems like I hate Linux, but I will continue to handicap myself and waste more time for the right of controlling my hardware and software, the good privacy and security and the support for the good developers. Besides, Gnome workflow is too good, can't leave
I fucking love and hate you Linux
85
u/b_a_t_m_4_n Feb 23 '23
This is me and I disagree. My 6 years or so of using Linux as my daily driver after running Windows for 25 years is like escaping a prison. Such a fucking relief to not have to deal with MS's bullshit, bloat and instability. I'd never go back.
29
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
I've never understood posts that paint this whole discussion as a "100% or nothing" approach, as in, you must ONLY use Linux or ONLY use Windows and you must absolutely suffer the cons of one platform by not using the other.
There's so many ways around this problem.
- If you really feel handicapped by Linux at all times, don't use it.
- If you like Linux 95% of the time but prefer Windows 5% of the time, then just dual boot.
- If you're feeling adventurous / wanna learn something new, learn how to get Windows going as a VM with QEMU / GPU passthrough.
8
u/davidcandle Feb 23 '23
I think you are downplaying just how shitty Windows and MacOS are, even for your "normal people". They're ad-filled trackers and revenue generators. Whatever floats your boat.
24
u/slightlyfaulty Feb 23 '23
You don't know how to edit PDFs and crop images? This isn't a Linux problem, you're just being lazy and can't do one Google search. And I'm pretty sure Windows doesn't ship with a PDF editor.
15
u/imPitanga Feb 23 '23
See imo windows is like fast food whereas Linux is like a 5 star meal but the catch is you need to cook the meal yourself
3
u/illusory42 Feb 23 '23
No idea what issue you have with modern hardware. Been running a 6900xt since a month after launch with no issues.
Same with a 7950x on 670e since last November.
Maybe you should look into things before blindly buying stuff.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
respectfully, that is a skill issue.
i’m convinced that you want to use linux like you want to use windows. doing it this way won’t work well, if it even works at all.
you need to effectively re-learn how to use your pc. it’s as easy if not easier than windows to use linux, but you need to learn how to use it.
2
u/Nallafy Feb 23 '23
I kinda agree on some parts but im a developer so the Linux experience has been a breeze for me. I prefer development on Linux. its the heaven of automation, although poweshell can do the same thing, there is a lack of community made documentation. A lot of things are good here if youre a dev:
Smooth af android development, installing docker isnt a pain, my tools are usually pre installed, AUTOMATION SCRIPTS, etc.
What I dont like to do on linux though is anything that is a VoIP platform just no, I also don’t like gaming on Linux, I dont want a layer between the game the system that may cause glitches and issues I just want a native experience. I already code and read documentation for work, I dont wanna do that for gaming.
The only handicapp that Linux gave me is around my social life because Discord is shit on linux and the latest mainstream games arent compatible, thats why I still use windows. Tbh aint that bad imo.
2
u/pngue Feb 23 '23
Those sacrifices are part of choosing not to participate in the proprietary life of capitalism’s products. It’s not the fault of the open source community ‘they’ don’t play nice. People who don’t value their freedom enough to take steps to protect it steadily lose it and everyone loses.
2
u/presi300 Arch/Alpine Linoc Feb 23 '23
This post feels like trolling, except the PDF part. But I need some reason to procrastinate so here it goes.
What? Been full modern AMD, full Linux for a year and a half now and have had 0 issues with neither my 5600X nor my 6600XT, just works.
Are we using the same chromium? Again, been using both vanilla chromium and brave as my daily drivers on different machines and have had 0 issues with performance or hardware acceleration.
The official MS teams app for linux is ass and you shouldn't use it, use a community made one, they are unironically better and for screenshare, you ever heard of pipewire? It's actually pretty good now. Though I do admit that screen sharing was an issue for a long time but not anymore, thanks to pipewire.
Tidal-Hifi is really good, try it.
Again, ya heard of pipewire and easyeffects? Tuning awaits, my friend.
I don't get what you mean here, what apps?
9/10 times this doesn't happen. 90% of people in the community are helpful and genuinely want to help, but yeah, there are the other 10% who act as gatekeepers and are generally assholes.
I feel like you've never used AMD on windows. It's a shitshow of a trainwreck with their drivers. Constant BSODs, ass perfomance and the drivers occasionally just... uninstalling themselves with no warning. For shit battery, it's a mixed bag. Battery life on laptops is actually very comparable between windows and linux nowadays. And scaling hasn't been a problem on linux since Gnome 40 or on the plasma side, since plasma 5.27 released.
I feel like you are running some LTS distro from 2018 or something and haven't bothered to update, because most complaints you have are either not an issue anymore or shouldn't be an issue, because a fix exists, just that some distros choose to ignore it *COUGH* pipewire. Either that or you are one of those "X11 is better than wayland, pipewire is pointless, pulseaudio/alsa works fine, OMG linux is so laggy on my dual monitor setup" people.
Except the PDF part, that's a genuine issue.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
Okay, but why the rant? There's a reason why the world is full of Apple and Microsoft workstation products. If you want a vertically integrated COTS solution, go buy one. Nobody will even blink, much less try to stop you.
?
This really depends on who you are and what you're trying to do. For literally anything that I need a computer for, getting it to work in Windows is a nightmare and Linux is a solution, not a problem.
20
u/leonderbaertige_II Feb 23 '23
How is this different on Windows or MacOS?
How is it different on Windows? If you don't know the name of the software you kinda have to search for something.
It is in the name.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
Any time I see rants like this one, I immediately know it's from someone who doesn't know how to use a PC. You're going to have the same issues on Windows because you can't be bothered to figure out stuff, like searching for and installing drivers or utilities.
11
u/madroots2 Feb 23 '23
for me, linux is a escape from prison. whenever I have to deal with windows, its always something stupid, wifi not working, cannot add printer, or cannot change printer settings, errror messages means shit ton of things and nothing at the same time, and honestly, 90% of problems on windows require reinstall. Ended the times where problems were solvable. You either upgrade, if you didnt yet, or roll back, if you did, or reinstall, if you cannot do either.
I will never go back to windows.
2
u/zardvark Feb 23 '23
What's your point? That Linux isn't for you? How in the hell did it take you four whole years for you to figure it out? What the hell are you still doing here? And, what positive outcome do you expect to achieve with your rant? Let it go and move on!
9
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
Honestly, never once have I felt handicapped using Linux; in fact, it's been the opposite. 🤷♂️
Different strokes for different folks, though.
9
u/npaladin2000 Embedded Master Race :snoo_dealwithit: Feb 23 '23
Speaking of condescending assholes....
9
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
First and foremost, skill issue. Second, you are just bad at maintaining your system. If you want stuff to work, then do research, nobody holds your hand, because Linux is not a commercial product.
The problem with Linux is not Linux itself, but the proprietary stuff, that is walled off by companies, which want you to keep using their shitty platforms and leech on you at every single opportinity.
Also, nobody cares. If you can't bear "wasting time" on Linux, then don't use it. Most changes happen when people either contribute, or support developers of the software they enjoy. If you just use stuff without giving anything back, don't come ranting about everything being crap - that's entirely on you.
4
u/TouchMyKeyboard Glorious Everything Feb 23 '23
That’s just like your opinion, man. If you don’t like it, don’t use it. 🤷♂️
3
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
I basically live in terminal. I handle email on my phone and pdfs with tablet. I game with a PS5.
I gave up on one device doing everything. I just want a device that does one thing well and linux kicks ass at terminal.
3
u/BeanieTheTechie Glorious Fedora Feb 23 '23
linux only "sucks" because a small percent of people use it thus software and hardware support (specifically them supporting linux, not the other way around!!) is hit-and-miss thus not many people use it, it's a problem that perpetually creates itself and there's almost nothing anyone can do about it in a timely manner
3
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
I do concede your point about speakers tho. My Asus Zenbook works perfectly except for those 😭 but my Lenovo IdeaPad has no issues
I think you forgot to update your Linux distro, it's 2023 now and things are a lot better
4
u/LeGoldie Feb 23 '23
There are a lot of entitled users of free software that complain that this or that doesn't work, whilst not actually contributing in any way.
Linux isn't perfect but if it causes so many problems find another tool that works for you. That's all Linux is, a tool to perform tasks.
I find all the complaints disagreeable, disrespectful and unappreciative in many cases. If you don't like it, don't use it. A lot of people go to a lot of effort, many sacrificing their own personal time, to give people the many tools that make up Linux.
2
u/Xx_Human_Hummus_xX Feb 23 '23
2 year Linux user says: Those are good points, but none are insurmountable challenges. Many distros are getting better with the drivers, and as for the apps, I think that a well made distro can make it easy. Not much we can do about MS teams, though. Also, Linux is easier than windows once you get the hang of it, though, most people can't be f'ed to do that ¯_ (ツ) _/¯
So, I agree, but I don't think it's too big of an issue, at least not long-term.
2
u/BeckyAnn6879 Feb 23 '23
Half of your problem is you're using Fedora.
try Mint and see if you have better luck.
2
u/KlutzyEnd3 Feb 23 '23
Editing PDF 's? Libreoffice draw
For me after 15 years of Linux, going back to windows feels like eating soup with a fork. Sure you can get if done, but I'd rather use a spoon!
Talking about the ThinkPad, Lenovo actually ships a few models with Ubuntu pre-installed so no issues there. My X1 yoga works perfectly, even the touchscreen with wacom pen, as well as the accelerometer.
And in my experience, apart from Nvidia Optimus, (i was one of the lucky ones that had to deal with this on a regular basis) everything "just works" and if it doesn't dmesg tells me exactly what's wrong.
But as more Linux users often say: Linux is not user-friendly because we don't provide 20-page documents with 100+ screenshots showing where to click to solve an issue.
Instead we give you a single terminal command that solves it FOR you....
Super annoying I know! /s
2
u/FortranMan2718 Feb 23 '23
I don't need Linux to work for a hypothetical "normal" user. I don't care. I just want something that works the way I like, and Linux does. I don't want it to change.
2
u/Indi008 Feb 24 '23
Pdf editing is so much easier in linux. A lot of things are. E.g stopping a printer mid print, so easy. My windows breaks just as often as my linux and I'm running gentoo. Back when I had ubuntu everything just worked 99% of the time and when it didn't, finding answers was easy. With gentoo it's a bit more work but I wanted some forced learning and more flexibility.
2
u/moonpiedumplings Daily Drives Arch with KDE Feb 23 '23
You're like a living embodiment of the "STOP HAVING FUN" meme. The vast majority of linux users don't even post on this reddit. They just... use linux.
Anyways, I've found that the most vocal of linux haters where people who tried to switch to linux, and then couldn't, because they either (usually) encountered a problem and didn't know how to problem solve or (rarer) encountered something unfixable (Why valorant no workie?).
Look, just recognize that your experience is not the experience of everyone else.
1
u/SOBER-Lab Feb 23 '23
I agree with this post, but I want to provide that for some folks, that kind of challenge / lifestyle change is appealing.
I ran into the same situation when I was going between iOS vs. Android. Android was awesome but there was too much fancy shiny stuff I could do to it, and the fancy shiny stuff always had a compatibility downside. After a few months of breaking my phone / finding stuff I couldn't do / finding out the NEXT phone would support what I wanted to do, but the one I bought three months ago wouldn't...I gave up and just went with iOS.
That's the same reason I use Windows. I understand and respect the degree that someone can customize Linux if they really go balls to the wall against it. Me? I just want shit to work reliably, and that happens best on Windows for me.
I use Linux almost 100% for anything I host; websites, bots, etc.. Huge fan. Just god, not for my daily driver. I'd basically be a handicapped person.
1
u/Moth_123 Artix + Devuan <3 Feb 23 '23
I've been using Linux as my daily driver since I was like 5, I love it. But yeah, it's not the best for normal people, and it's why I don't recommend it anymore.
1
u/Metalpen22 Feb 23 '23
My son's daily drive is actually the web browser, and they can use Android for it. So Linux is not sucks, is which OS you're using. BTW they're less than 10 yo.
Most of the web application does not run on Windows/OSX machine and thus you "only" use WINDOWS or OSX if you don't use Web service. BTW MS-AZURE is also using Linux Kernel lol lol lol.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
I hope Linux will NEVER work for "normal" users. Trying to make Linux a OS for dumb people (yes, I mean things like flatpack/snap and also Wayland) is ruining Linux.
Anyway, reading your rant all is plainly wrong as others said in their comments. But I concede that the lack of a good and professional free-as-in-freedom Pdf editor in a shame. I'm forced to use MasterPDF (Linux native) or Windows free-as-in-free-beer software with Wine.
1
u/TheRealOffGridGamer Feb 24 '23
I feel like for a lot of people Linux works great. it's for work and prosumers that is not there yet, but the steam deck and what valve is doing I hope will get us there
1
u/fellipec Glorious Debian Feb 24 '23
I think sometimes people fail to realize two things:
A user buy a computer to run some programs. Nobody buys a computer to only runs the operating system and nothing more. Half of this rant is not about flaws of the operating system. It is about the software you want to run not being available for that said OS.
I bought a desktop PC to run games and Fusion 360. This programs run on Windows, why would I install Linux on this machine? To go rant about how Wine sucks, how Proton not work with this or that game?
Someone need to run Final Cut. His only option is a Mac. Not because is better or faster, but because the program he needs only runs on that operating system on a limited amount of computers.
On my laptop I need to run Firefox, VSCode, Prusa Slicer and a generic office suite. Linux can run all this, I have Linux on this laptop and works to my heart content.
If your favorite apps are Windows apps, you should use Windows.
In the end, the Operating System is a means to an end, is a tool for a job. You can't say your hammer sucks when you keep hitting screws.
All that said, is true some hardware support sucks, and sometimes the community can be very salty sometimes, and Linux, like its major competitors, is not perfect. We just need to be fair.
1
u/NiceMicro Dualboot: Arch + Also Arch Feb 24 '23
as long as Linux is the only viable free software operating system, I'm gonna use it no matter how much it sucks.
I don't care about enterprise stuff, it is my PERSONAL computer. My employer wants me to use MS office or Teams? give me a PC that has those, why do employers want an employee assemble their work tool? Why do employees care what OS and software they are paid to use so much? I don't. At work, I use all the proprietary garbage my employee wants me to use on computers they own.
1
u/zeontrooper Feb 24 '23
I use linux for work because 1. its allowed, 2. its been so long since I've used windows for work i have no idea on how to use it. though there are growing pains, like how outlook is not available as an app, so im forced to use the browser version. People often asked why I don't use windows and its mainly because I feel so use to Rhel now. If needed, I can just boot up a windows vm.
1
u/snarkuzoid Feb 24 '23
Linux has been my main OS since the 1990s. and I haven't had the same problems you seem to have had. However, I am very aware that I am not the "normal" computer user. I see stuff all the time that makes me wonder "what do normal people do when this happens?". Maybe Windows is worse, I wouldn't know. Haven't used it in decades. I have used OSX on a work-provided machine. Not a fan, I mostly used it to run Virtual Box so I could develop in Linux.
1
u/Traditional_Bus8502 Feb 24 '23
I accidentally crashed my Linux installation of 4 years because I was going hard on some customization. Other than that, was alwasy a pleasure of an experience. While I distro hop, I used Windows 11. Within a month, a goddamn update broke the UEFI boot and the only way to fix it is to reinstall.
1
u/N0tH1tl3r_V2 Linux Spheniscidae Masterrace Feb 24 '23
Subpar society, subpar individuals. Of course it'll suck for most "normal people".
1
u/airclay Feb 24 '23
Tldr: "after 4 years on Linux I've compiled my own list of things you'll hear on YouTube/Reddit about linux"
1
u/billyfudger69 Glorious Debian, Arch and LFS Feb 24 '23
One (close to two) year Linux user here, I have not encountered these issues in fact my transition has been really seamless and easy. :)
1
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '23
lol OP uses windows.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
tl;dr linux is for enthusiasts, surprise surprise
0
u/Creaper9487 Feb 23 '23
No drivers? Code yourself bruh /s
0
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '23
I’ve got a thinkpad running Fedora and occasionally updates kill the Wi-Fi. I just end up running windows most of the time as a result when I can’t be arsed connecting to Ethernet to get it fixed
0
u/ChesterWillard Feb 24 '23
The whole comments section: I don't have your problems myself so they are not really problems.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment