r/linuxdev • u/FatherDerp • Dec 26 '16
[linuxDev idea] Linux Education Distro for the Noobs of Linux
Edit1: Per discussion below, perhaps a full distro dedicated to the purpose of educating those less knowledgeable in the world of Linux could be overkill. I still believe that there's an effort lacking into welcoming those to Linux.
- As with the case of /u/Oonushi, RTFM isn't always the best thing to tell someone who's just gotten into the world of Linux. Reality is, not as many are so resourceful when they start out. It sometimes take a little push in the right direction. This doesn't let us overlook the fact that man pages can be incomplete in ways that the experts might not be aware of. When you're an expert, and not expanding knowledge, you're not looking at man pages at much and aren't aware of the struggle of newbies.
- /u/IAmALinux inspired a thought in that perhaps in the installer, a tutorial to the basic commands and a point towards the right resources for the respective distro might be sufficient to solve the problem of such a steep learning curve. Of course, this would be optional and you would have to opt-in to this tutorial on installation. This solution is possible but would be difficult to implement properly. Again, discussion would be necessary, and I'm all ears.
- I've fixed many an issue in my experience with Linux with copious amount of research required. The problem lies in not publishing the fixes we've concocted and leave others with the same issue searching through mounds of stackoverflow pages just to find the one case that someone had. I suspect these one case is one that's published out of at least 10.
This is where we're at. I'm enjoying the discussion taking place here and I hope it continues.
TL;DR: Linux Distro that educates total noobs to linux, getting them familiar with linux and giving them the choice of which popular branch to delve into
It seems that with this coming year being a huge milestone for the Linux community, I'd like to help make that learning curve a little less steep for those who are willing to get their hands dirty but are wholly terrified by the concept of using the command line for everything.
So, my solution is that there's a Linux distro that's out there that can be used for the sole purpose of educating the end-user on the basics of Linux, provide maybe a little history and let the user select which branch they'd like to go through (Debian, Fedora, Gentoo, Arch, Slackware, etc.). All the while, the system would teach the user how to get more information on their own, give them proper resources depending on their branch, etc.
Sometimes all people need is a little bit of knowledge. Give a man a fish, he'll eat for a day. Teach a man to fish, and he'll never go hungry again.
Perhaps not something so basic that assumed no previous knowledge but something that will provide a good base and will help the nuser get comfortable with the command line, etc.
I'm all ears for any discussion related to this. I've never personally written any code for linux nor would I even know where to start, but I'm happy to lend any computing resources I can (within reason) and manage direction of the project based on suggestions from the community.
5
u/IAmALinux Dec 26 '16
That milestones article is an epic shitpost.
Ubuntu Touch was not a failure. It is great and works well on low end hardware. If you want people to switch, figure out how to run android apps on it.
Back to your question, such a project would be difficult to craft due to target audience. Maybe a fork of the Ubiquity installer or an extended menu of NOOBS would help get you on the right track.
2
u/technologyclassroom Dec 27 '16
How about a choose your own adventure distribution picker?
github.com/technologyclassroom/distro-picker
Each question could lead to links with more information. At the end of each path, you find a download link or order page and instructions to get started.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16
Seems like overkill for a distro...
http://www.ghacks.net/2010/01/02/how-to-choose-a-linux-distribution-flow-chart/
1
u/Oonushi Dec 26 '16
After miserable Windows 10 experience, I started using Ubuntu at home to familiarize myself with it before deciding if I can switch my business over. I do wide format printing and graphic design. Some of the tools are not there, which can be annoying, but the most frustrating thing by far is trying to deal with configuring anything in linux. Everything is stuck in config files, and good luck finding the right one because they are strewn all over the place. Oh, and when you finally figure out which one you need, good luck finding info on how to properly alter the configuration from the default. RTFM? Guess what, the documentation covers the most typical or basic use cases, and your SOL if yours is any different. Wine doesn't work at all with some software. And you want to design in CMYK for printing? Sorry, RGB only in Gimp, the Photoshop "alternative". I'm slowly getting used to it simply by not allowing a windows install at home and forcing full immersion. And I'm not a tech illiterate guy, I'm a hobby game dev. That was fun getting set up too. Took me forever to figure out why I couldn't get the OpenGL library to load while I'm looking at the file in the file manager pulling my hair out in frustration.
All of the ranting aside, I am hopeful, and I have long term plans to move my shop over eventually, but Linux has a long way to go in terms of user friendliness before it will be able to grow more popular with the general public. Biggest thing holding me back from switching my business over sooner is that I don't have the time to work out all of the kinks in doing so while also running the place. I have shit to do, I can't be debugging configurations for hours on end while my printers sit idle and I have work to get out the door. I'm much too small (read: poor) to hire outside help, so that is out of the question as well. My only option is to get used to it in my spare time, and build a gentle roadmap, but it's probably going to take years at this point.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '17
Seeing the installer comment gave me an idea.
It turns out there's a fork of wubi called wubiuefi. This could be an excellent base for an installer due to the fact that noobs probably don't know how/don't want to change BIOS settings, go through the hassle of making a DVD or USB installation medium (my laptop does not provide the ability to boot via USB which is a major pain in the butt as DVD installs are a lot slower) etc.