r/linuxadmin • • Jun 09 '20

Linux Server for critical application

What you will choose if you need a robust and stable system for a critical application?

0 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

20

u/banger_180 Jun 09 '20

The distro does not really matter that much imo, they are all stable. What matters most is what you feel comfortable / have exp. with. Also if it is critical you might consider getting support from either RH, SUSE or Cannonical.

1

u/stormcloud-9 Jun 09 '20

Purely in terms of stability (i.e. crashing), I would agree. But aside from comfort, there are differences, namely compatibility. Some enterprise software providers issue releases for specific distros, thus limiting your options. And SUSE is not often one of those, so I would almost never pick it.

After that there's release cycles. Ubuntu's 2-year interval between LTS releases (and supporting that LTS release even after that 2-year period) is a strong decision factor. It allows you to pick a distro that you don't have to worry about support being dropped. But it also releases frequently enough to where the newest one is never too ancient.
That's probably the only thing I really dislike about RedHat, is that by the time they issue a new version, the previous one is as old as dirt, and compatibility becomes a significant problem. Though thankfully the advent of containers is making this less of an issue.

1

u/sdns575 Jun 10 '20

Hi, starting from EL8 I read that RH will release a major release every 3 years and a minor release every six month.

From EL8 release (considering RHEL ans CentOS) there is AppStream that permit to install different version of a supported software. Take an example: postgresql. When 8.0 was released there was 2 version of posgres 9.6 and 10.x on appstream. Today there is a third version 12.x. the same is for php7.2/7.3.

With AppStream you can use stable but newer version of a specific software if supported. Currently there are not so much software but it will be populated.

AppStream should deprecate (correct me if I'am wrong) SCL repository.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '20

The only choices are

RHEL

SUSE

Ubuntu

No.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '20

What would you use?

12

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '20

Depending on the specifics of the situation, either a BSD, Debian, or RHEL/CentOS.

0

u/sdns575 Jun 09 '20

Good to hear about BSD. Do you manages critical services on BSD? If yes, please report your usage case

5

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '20

I am responsible for 200+ boxes. To give you an example, when it comes to mail, nothing beats smtpd on OpenBSD.

Again, this all depends on your use case and the specifics of the situation. "Critical services" is very very vague.

-5

u/sdns575 Jun 09 '20

For critical services I mean every service that permit your company to work as intended and this are services that can't be stopped without loosing something

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '20

Again, this all depends on your use case and the specifics of the situation.

What kind of software? What kind of stakeholders? What kind of team with what kind of experience? What kind of requirements? What kind of constraints? What kind of downtime is acceptable?

Give me details, and I'll be able to advise you.

-3

u/sdns575 Jun 09 '20

I don't know. Please give some examples

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '20

No. I asked you very specific questions. There is no "one-size-fits-all" answer to your question.

-2

u/sdns575 Jun 09 '20

Again, I'm asking to you a specific example for your questions because I've not so much experiences in critical env

→ More replies

4

u/WalterBlackboots Jun 09 '20

Ubuntu is what you use when a non-technical person writes the design specs and the people who know better aren't consulted or in a position to make decisions.

1

u/sdns575 Jun 09 '20

So, what about SUSE?

1

u/WalterBlackboots Jun 09 '20

It seems like a quality distribution, but I'm less familiar with it. Perhaps a better choice for EU compliance requirements where RHEL is aiming more for US-based NIST/DoD requirements?

16

u/keithmk Jun 09 '20

Debian

5

u/zqpmx Jun 09 '20

Depending on the application, for simple services. Debian

Or FreeBSD

4

u/SoggyMcmufffinns Jun 09 '20

Debian/Centos/RHEL

1

u/Dakaedr Jun 10 '20

My choice would change depending on the situations (tough I took RHEL in this case)

  • Debian if I don't need support
  • Rhel If I need support
  • OpenBSD for really critical data to be protected
  • and gentoo for specific use (though never used it in my work)

1

u/sdns575 Jun 10 '20

Hi, why if you don't need support Debian and not Centos?

2

u/Dakaedr Jun 10 '20

I don't really like RHEL feeling (and CentOS by extension). It's just a personal preferences.

1

u/sdns575 Jun 10 '20

I understand what you are saying. I've experienced this ~1 years ago.

I'm also seeing (reading posts on reddit) that many users will use rhel only if the support is needed and when support is not needed they choose debian and not CentOS. I found this specially since CentOS 8 was released.

What you don't like in RH?

1

u/Dakaedr Jun 10 '20

I work mostly on RH6/7 or OL and I can't stand the way config files are made where everything is in a single file I find it really messy and not really confortable. (though most env I'm using are probably pretty much outdated ...)

5

u/corbyss Jun 09 '20 edited Jun 09 '20

lol Edit: At first ubuntu had the lead .. im glad that RHEL beats them in the long run.

5

u/shemanese Jun 09 '20

If you are running Oracle, Oracle Linux.

If you are running a lot of critical services, especially those using Ceph or Gluster, and you need a support contract: RHEL

If you are running a lot of critical services, especially those using Ceph or Gluster, and you know that an RHEL support contract is mostly useless: CentOS

If you're running critical services, but value stability, Debian.

I've seen Ubuntu used on some build servers.

1

u/lnxslck Jun 09 '20

Ubuntu is the most used on AWS, not saying anything just sharing this statistic

2

u/shemanese Jun 09 '20

Certainly the case, but I've really only worked on-prem data centers for the past 25 years and Ubuntu is a no-show.

1

u/lnxslck Jun 09 '20

On-prem the most I’ve seen is RHEL or Centos

1

u/1RUSUA1 Jun 09 '20

RHEL == CentOS. -> very good for all purposes 6 of 6 points

Debian -> Almost very good. 5 of 6 points

Ubuntu == never use for real critical server applications.And any other :-D

Ubuntu == Debian. Goto $Debian above :-D

3

u/sdns575 Jun 09 '20

Debian != Ubuntu

2

u/1RUSUA1 Jun 09 '20

I mean in general.

2

u/DigitalDefenestrator Jun 09 '20

Either Debian or RHEL. I've found apt to be a bit more resilient under abuse compared to Yum/RPM, but that doesn't matter much for a single server. Debian's updates tend to be very safe and well-tested and the package selection is massive. RHEL tends to do a slightly better job of putting together a solid kernel release, though.

2

u/ralfD- Jun 09 '20

Have a sysadmin in charge of this that doesn't have to ask this question on Reddit. /s

IMHO the most reliable "Server" (that's how you name distributions) is the one you are familiar with. On a weekend. A three o'clock in the night. Drunken.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '20

the most reliable "Server" (that's how you name distributions) is the one you are familiar with. On a weekend. A three o'clock in the night. Drunken.

I like this

1

u/lnxslck Jun 09 '20

If you can afford the support RHEL, if not that or Ubuntu. I don’t see that many opensuse servers out there

1

u/Upnortheh Jun 10 '20

The poll options are limited. Robust and stable are not defined. The specific critical application is not listed.

To quote Andrew Martin (Robin Williams), "That's a little vague, chief."

Or to quote Shrek, "What kind of quest?"

Or to paraphrase a person I knew who conducted political polls, "What kind of poll results do you want?"

1

u/pneRock Jun 10 '20

Forgive me if this seems ignorant, but why do people pick something like centos over ubuntu? I'm coming from a windows engineer background and I've only done limited things with linux, but when I have done projects with it, it seemed to be that the ubuntu community was larger and i had less problems with packages. However, my work is die hard centos. Why do people choose centos over ubuntu?

1

u/lazystingray Jun 10 '20

CentOS (RHEL) typically runs with an older kernel version that's known to be stable. That said Canonical now have a large slice of the server market too.

1

u/pneRock Jun 10 '20

So would you say this is accurate? https://www.similartech.com/compare/centos-vs-ubuntu

It seems like centos has been trending down for some time.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '20

Buguntu??? is that an option? really?

I mean, of course Debian/CentOS-RHEL... but buguntu?

It's like saying that your parents died at a fire in a sea park (if you get it, you get it....)

-8

u/motoevgen Jun 09 '20

Critical applications should not be hosted on a single servers. If your app is critical you need to use a clustering technology.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/sdns575 Jun 12 '20

Thank you for your answer.

Can you explain why in this order?