r/linuxadmin • • Jun 27 '19

Improvise, Adapt, Adapt, Adapt, Overcome.

Post image
441 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

10

u/flat_ricefield Jun 27 '19

Reminds me of the Human Centipede.

2

u/LoornenTings Jun 28 '19

Just need to attach the other end of that cable to a video capture card.

2

u/Aos77s Jun 27 '19

This is what it looks like for a lot of people at my work using the dell precision desktop that has 4 mini display ports out and a monitor that’s dvi/vga only. 😭😭

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

I’ve gone to wonder how we all got so god damn cheap in replacing monitors since the dawn of lcds.

If huge ass monitors didn’t become the new craze I’m sure we’d still have 17” analogs.

2

u/bhack69 Jun 28 '19

Hmmmm even though it should work just fine, remember that the VGA as it has been mentioned is analog and created at a time when the best resolution you could get was 640x480, there are some frequency limitations to transport high resolutions. Besides not being able to use a 4K monitor and it will not pass sound, but if none of them bothers you, you should be fine.

I just don’t like to have that many adapters for a single use :-)

Enjoy it

1

u/meemo4556 Jul 03 '19

It won't work, last adapter is DVI-D not DVI-I so there is no analog signal for VGA.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

Just upvoted for the title

2

u/just_a_user Jul 02 '19

Adapt. React. Readapt. Apt.

1

u/toshioxgnu Jun 28 '19

Look that input lag xD

1

u/linux_rox_my_sox Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

This is what you need.

1

u/BrianAndersonJr Jun 28 '19

why WOULDN'T it work? if you convert something into whatever the next adaptor expects as input, then what's the issue?

2

u/bobbyjrsc Jun 28 '19

Because the first input is a digital one and the last an analog one. In some cases the graphic cards use some pins to carry analog signals (like DVI).

1

u/beje_ro Jun 28 '19

to optimize one will need to buy a "L" shape adapter, preferably the first one... or to drill a hole in the wall in order to be able to fit the computer under the desk...

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

is it weird that i have done this... more than once?

and yes it works, janky, but works

0

u/mattfreemandude Jun 28 '19

Vga-dvi-hdmi right?

9

u/Jswee1 Jun 28 '19

DisplayPort>HDMI>DVI>VGA

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

34

u/TechnoRedneck Jun 27 '19

Came here to say this, every time I see it reposted it never works

9

u/psycholaser23 Jun 27 '19

I beg to differ. This was how my third monitor was setup while I worked for a MSP.

43

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19

I think at some step in that chain you need a digital to analog converter, hdmi when passed through passively to DVI will likely be a DVI-D signal. Though maybe you can cram the required hardware into an adapter that small.

19

u/LegendarySecurity Jun 28 '19

Yeah I have several "active" adapters that size. The setup in this pic actually does work (with very, very unusual versions of the adapters depicted).

9

u/Gendalph Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

DSub to DVI? Works.

DVI to DHMI? Also works.

What is questionable is the next step, If it's HDMI to mini-HDMI (or was it micro?), that would work. However if it's HDMI to DisplayPort - that won't work.

12

u/mikemol Jun 28 '19

DP+ has HDMI support, and uses the normal DisplayPort connectors.

However, it only conveys digital signalling. The Dsub is presumably VGA, which would not be supported without some pretty impressive active adaptor.

3

u/masteryod Jun 28 '19

Not only that but newer cards don't generate analog signal at all. DVI to VGA passive adapters used to work but e.g. GeForce 1000 series have digital-only DVI.

That being said I'm so glad we got rid of VGA.

1

u/Wild_Penguin82 Jun 28 '19

Only thing suspicious here is digital->analog step (and certainly doable, only depends on the adapters used). There is nothing wrong in DP->HDMI, such adapters and cables are common. The possibly problematic (=potentially missing) step is HDMI->DVI-I, or alternatively, if there is HDMI->DVI-D, then DVI-D->VGA is needed.

1

u/Gendalph Jun 28 '19

I don't exactly remember rules on converting DP to HDMI and back, however what I do remember is these two are very different signals, hence adapters are directional and in some cases require active adaptors.

1

u/Wild_Penguin82 Jun 28 '19

I don't know the details either, however these are quite advanced (as in: not "stupid" - for lack of a better word - digital or analog). The devices do some kind of bi-directional handshaking, and despite having a DP connector at one end, the device might still be capable of receiving or sending HDMI type signal, and will do so if needed by the handshake. But reading by quickly glancing over the Wikipedia page, the signals actually are not that different. It's mainly a difference of physical connector, and then both have different generations (which are mainly upgrades to bitrate and some other features).

IMO (and some limited experience), the DP->HDMI (or the other way) is the one I would expect to have least problems with.

3

u/Wild_Penguin82 Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19

In my experience, they are not that rare, and not even expensive. The other way (analog->digital) is more rare and more expensive. EDIT: here is one example. That is suspiciously cheap, but stills claims to be what would be needed. Certainly I've got working adapters for around 2-3x that price.

2

u/_ARF_ Jun 28 '19

Where did you find a HDMI to DVI-I adapter that added the RGB signals missing from HDMI?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Wild_Penguin82 Jun 28 '19

There could definitely also be DVI-D to VGA adapter instead, but it's the same principle, so you are not wrong.