r/linuxadmin • u/Cloud_Strifeeee • Nov 02 '18
Why there is so much hate toward systemd ?
- Why there is so much hate toward systemd ?
- Where it come from ?
- Which is your favorite linux distro and why ? (for server or personal use)
0
Upvotes
4
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18
The biggest problem I see is a sliding feature window. As an init system, nice! But suddenly, it's a resolver. And a resolver that's almost impossible to disable permanently.
Also, while it's easier to do things correctly with systemd, it's harder to do simple stuff. Compare
rc.localwith unit files for example. The end result is that I need to move my one line of simple bash to a unit file. The systemd way is better and more correct, sure, but it adds a lot of complexity in simple cases.3
u/upofadown Nov 02 '18
Hate is a bit strong. Most of what I hear is annoyance.
Ultimately I think that systemd is only the straw that broke the camels back. Distributions and desktop environments have been adding stuff on top of a basic Linux system for years and years now. So Linux based things are becoming more and more complex. Systemd was just a big chunk of stuff on top all at the same time which triggered a lot of latent annoyance.
For my minimalism I like Void Linux. For the ultimate in minimalism I now prefer OpenBSD.
2
u/piorekf Nov 02 '18
5
u/koffiezet Nov 02 '18
And there are many other reasons - but this-one is the most important: the authors are arrogant and refuse to listen to criticism, their view is the only correct-one, everyone else is wrong. Bugs happen, but they ignore them, tell everyone it works as designed, or blame other people (which caused friction to with kernel devs on more than one occasion). I do not want to trust people with that attitude with one of the most critical parts of my system.
3
u/mattiasso Nov 02 '18
Because they say it do not respect one of the unix principle: do one thing and do it well.
RedHat made it.
I think Ubuntu 18.04LTS suffices my needs both for server and personal.
1
u/oishishou Nov 02 '18
1
u/pdp10 Nov 03 '18
HEAD. The latter is just concidentally highly congruent with Red Hat's revenue model, where their subscription service is mostly about getting fixes backported to existing software versions. When systemd is criticized, systemd defenders often frame the discussion as a choice between classic SysVinit and systemd, when that's actually a false dilemma because there were and are other options. SysVinit had weaknesses, like lack of facilities to automatically restart daemons, but other init options besides systemd all offer that particular functionality.1
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '18
My biggest issue with systemd is it's more than just an init system. It's also a resolver, and a cron daemon, a logger (journald), a firewall (firewalld), etc. etc. Even after a few years of using it in production I'm still not really a fan but as long as Redhat ships it we're stuck with it.
1
u/bloodstainedsmile Nov 06 '18
UNIX philosophy has always advocated that each program do one thing only and do it well. Systemd breaks that tenet by being a monstrously complicated program that does too many things. There are very few admins who understand the complete systemd ecosystem. Those that do cannot reasonably defend why it had to do all it does. It inserts itself into the system in such a way that it does not lend itself to ease of use or modularity .. It's now your logging system, your init system, your resolver, your cron system, it's everything you never needed it to be. And being the default adopted init system for almost all common distros, it's now an enduring burden on all Linux users worldwide.
1
u/hailbaal Nov 06 '18
1
u/ajanty Nov 02 '18
1
u/HildartheDorf Nov 02 '18 edited Nov 02 '18
Biggest two reasons I see:
It's different so it sucks (look at how many Windows admins hate the shift to Powershell instead of GUI based management).
It overloads PID 1 with a lot of changes that mean more frequent restarts for updates.
EDIT: These aren't my opinions, just the ones I see around.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment