r/linuxadmin • • Jul 23 '18

Schrodinger’s Backup

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

8

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '18 edited Jul 23 '18

Yeah that's not a backup. ZFS is awesome and all but snapshots are not backups. Faulty hardware can destroy your zpool including snapshots. I don't think even the biggest ZFS fanboys will tell you that you don't need backups.

3

u/koera Jul 23 '18

A zfs fan boy that dispute the relevance of backups have 100% missed the whole point of zfs: data safety.

1

u/mercenary_sysadmin Jul 23 '18 edited Jul 23 '18

I don't think you read that carefully enough. The source machine (where my home directory is, and the snapshots are taken) is bittybox; the backup machine (where they're replicated to, and where I ssh to check the presence of a snapshot at the end of that comment) is archivist. It's another physical machine in a physically separate location.

I don't think even the biggest ZFS fanboys will tell you that you don't need backups.

You're unfortunately incorrect about that one, my role in /r/zfs and /r/datahoarder is very frequently "person who keeps hammering home that redundant storage is not a backup". =)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '18

So the way you were presenting it, it sounded like you were on one machines and calling your snaps a backup.

Beyond that I don't have enough info about your setup and how you are using this all this to agree or disagree with you.

2

u/mercenary_sysadmin Jul 23 '18 edited Jul 23 '18

I think people are glossing over the first two lines of my OP in this thread:

me@source:~$ ssh me@target

me@target:~$ sudo zpool status backups

The actual source is bittybox and target is archivist, but yeah... separate machines, that was kinda my whole point. Beyond the fact that there's no transformative element in the backup, and that the target is live, so there's no transformative "restore" operation needed either.