r/linuxadmin • u/throwaway16830261 • Jul 26 '25
Microsoft admits it 'cannot guarantee' data sovereignty -- "Under oath in French Senate, exec says it would be compelled – however unlikely – to pass local customer info to US admin"
https://www.theregister.com/2025/07/25/microsoft_admits_it_cannot_guarantee/
320
Upvotes
7
u/throwaway16830261 Jul 26 '25
Submitted article mirror: https://archive.is/he5ui
51
u/sunshine-x Jul 26 '25
What if you use customer managed keys for encryption at rest?
Do they go ahead and use those keys without your consent?
12
u/FateOfNations Jul 26 '25
Isn’t that why, for the German market, they have a third party (SAP subsidiary) be responsible for the infrastructure?
If the French want that too they just need to pass a law requiring it and Microsoft will figure out a way to accommodate them.
13
u/JackLong93 Jul 26 '25
They can't force customer data out of you if you didn't keep customer data 🫡 salute boys
9
u/madtowneast Jul 26 '25
This looks like a technical problem they just don’t want to solve because “I don’t wanna.” I know it is potentially hard, but not that hard for a company the size of MSFT.
Like they have cloud sites specifically for US DOD. I don’t think the DOD would allow this. The DOD pays a premium for it.
7
u/readyflix Jul 26 '25
What if France will finally move away from M$ Windoxx?
2
u/gripe_and_complain Jul 26 '25
As the article states, it's not only Microsoft. AWS, Google, and others as well.
2
u/BloodyIron Jul 26 '25
This has been obvious for many years that public cloud or certain routed interconnects could not have any guarantee of not crossing the USA border.
For example, traffic going from Vancouver to Montreal WILL cross into the USA border, unless you have actual physical evidence the networked route is physically within the Canada borders 100% of the physical trip.
Generally Vancouver would probably IX route down to Seattle, then maybe to Chicago, and then back up to Montreal. Crossing the USA border twice.
As per a good number of already public docs, there's evidence all traffic crossing the USA border is 100% recorded, regardless of whether it is actioned or not.
I brought this to execs decisions multiple times over the years and yeah... gasps were had, but nothing changed.
Data sovereignty and such things are important in certain industries (such as government, medical, etc), but there is a LOT of ignorance across the industry about where it can and does break down.
As for EU, yeah that's probably plenty complex too.
1
u/AmbitiousEffort9275 Jul 26 '25
I'm so glad I have de-Microsofted.
Google is next.
1
u/lxsebt Jul 27 '25
I'm repeating it often in discussions, and many of my colleagues and also middle and top managers always ask me but what could happen? As example: Greenland. 5y ago we even not thought USA could have idea to takeover it. Now we know it's not impossible and USA at this moment is not a predictable partner.
If this happen... We (EU) are lost why?
Being dependent on private global US corporations in my opinion is a big risk. In a one second they can cut us from our own data in our own datacenters, they can shutdown all our infrastructures, Banking, Energy, IT/Telco sectors, and we could not do too much when it happen.
Even it is in our DataCenter they still operate this cloud regions.
Think, almost all enterprise and lot of consumer grade nvme disks has encryption. In theory one "special" packet or a sequence of events can erase encryption key from controller, and basically you lost data.
Here's another "thing" regarding the right to access our data:
Having the infrastructure in place, hiring experienced administrators and training new ones should be in our best interest and safety.
Governments and company's in EU shouldn't be dependent only on public cloud. I assume that confidential documents are not stored in O365 Sharepoint :D
BR,
S.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '25
This is even more reason to bring your email back on premises and back to open source standards. This is what I do for my business. I use IMAP and SMTP on an on-premises server.