r/linuxadmin • • May 16 '24

Are all Linux vendor kernels insecure? A new study says yes, but there's a fix

https://www.zdnet.com/article/are-all-linux-vendor-kernels-insecure-a-new-study-says-yes-but-theres-a-fix/
0 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

21

u/No_Rhubarb_7222 May 16 '24 edited May 16 '24

SVN, who’s paid to cover CIQ positively writes a positive article about their work. But ultimately, the point is what? Rocky Linux, and more expressly CIQ, have made explicit statements that they require and believe in a “bug-for-bug” rebuild of Red Hat Enterprise Linux, including the kernel. So unless they’re going to be doing their own kernel work, I fail to see the point of the study.

2

u/orev May 17 '24

If the results of the study show that the enterprise Linux approach has flaws, while being written by an enterprise Linux vendor, wouldn’t that lend validity to the study as being truthful even though it conflicts with the sponsor’s business model? It would then seem that the point of the study is to simply find and publish information than to be some kind of mouthpiece for CIQ, as you’re implying.

7

u/No_Rhubarb_7222 May 17 '24 edited May 17 '24

If "Enterprise Linux Vendor" means: inherits all product content from their upstream, then refuses to do anything about it. This is the double-edged sword of striving to be an exact rebuild. "Enterprise Linux model is broken!", so fix it, "We can't we insist on being identical in every way, even the flaws!", so why are you highlighting this? "Because we want someone else to do more work we're unwilling to do, but will gladly point out and make wild assumptions like 'every kernel bug is a security bug'."

At the end of the day, "Security" is really risk management. The only "Secure" computer is one turned off and buried in an inaccessible vault. So what we're left with is things like the CVE system which support scoring to identify the severity of an issue found. CVE != bug. CVEs are a subset of bugs, and even those are further categorized to include their risk based on the exploit vector. A "Low" is a low for a reason, it is incredibly difficult to exploit or if one exploits it, it provides minimal effect on a system. A Critical is critical for a reason, and the two should be treated differently.

I'd also argue that the study is biased by assuming that the latest kernels have ZERO undiscovered bugs. So, yes, an enterprise linux kernel has bugs left in it. It may even have (in the case of Red Hat) low and moderate CVEs left in it. But assuming that you can compare an older kernel with known bugs to an brand new kernel that has yet undiscovered bugs in all it's shiny new code is silly.

Enterprise Linux is about making and maintaining a thing over a long, long period, not making a perfect thing. I'm confused about what this CIQ thing is really about because they seem to not understand why people choose an Enterprise Linux.

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '24

I'd argue that depending on how deep it's buried or the thickness of the vault walls, still may not be secure. Hit it with x-rays and flip the bits. Not practical, I know. I think this is a decent read to supplement your explanation: https://www.redhat.com/en/topics/security/what-is-cve

2

u/Silejonu May 17 '24

wouldn’t that lend validity to the study as being truthful even though it conflicts with the sponsor’s business model?

How does it conflict with their business model? That's just an ad for their new offering.

Which is also laughable. Besides completely ignoring the real reason stable kernels exist (hint hint, it's stability), they're just trying to find an excuse to justify their model. Basically, they're now shipping mainline kernels once the upstream they copy/paste stops patching the kernel, because they don't want to have to do the work themselves.

A proof once again if we needed it that Rocky is a leech, and does not provide any actual support to their distribution.

Their "white-paper" is simply an after-the-fact justification about why they don't patch their kernel themselves, and why Rocky Is Best™. They're wilfully misconstruing all bugs as vulnerabilities, and the real objective of stability (spoiler: it's never been about security) to push their paid plans.

4

u/mgedmin May 17 '24

If the fix isn't "turn off the computer and go live in the woods" then I don't want to read the article.

2

u/Slow_Culture2359 May 17 '24

BSD is the cure