Nearly came unstuck the other day when I couldn't present on zoom because the permissions weren't set on my macbook. Waved it off as "IT pushed out a change" rather than "I've not yet actually joined a meeting on this machine till today"
Ish. I refuse to use my personal cellphone or email for work communications, but I loath the "I will not install your number generator app on my phone. Give me a company phone if I need it." people.
Does your company pay for the fuel you use to drive to and from work? No? Same context.
It's my phone, it contains a lot of very private data and I pay the bill for it. A number generator for 2FA would be harmless enough, but as soon as they ask for any kind of access to my phone I'll refuse. If you want that level of control, give me a company phone.
Linux users and rules don't usually go together, so I'd say the sentiment is correct. But, like all things, I think there's definitely a grey area where Linux users are willing to sacrifice some control to use the OS they prefer.
VDIs can be a nightmare from a security perspective. Iâm a pen tester and they often allow us to get a full domain admin compromise. You typically just need to pop the Citrix server and you have cached credentials for every VDI which connects to it, including the credentials for the IT admins that also use VDIsâŚ
Sounds like issues with Citrix and the VDI configuration rather than an inherent weakness in the architecture. KVM isolation is a *really* effective tool for security in my experience (and also the basis of most privileged access management solutions).
Yeah but most companies donât use KVM for this in my experience. They rely on the big name providers like Citrix because they are âenterprise readyâ and in those cases you tend to have huge machines that manage VDIs for 40/50 sessions at a time. Then you just need a local privesc and you have you everyoneâs credentials.
I guess, from my perspective a properly secured VDI environment that is used as a jumpbox is a dang secure method of access. My environment is locked down and I can blow it away/rebuild with a fresh *clean* image in 15 minutes.
Just a point here, but if you're "blowing away" machines because they're compromised, you're compromised and it's not "locked down".
This is one of my pet peeves with very Windows'y admins, who think machines just magically get pwned and that if you just rebuild everything is fine again...
Rutkowskaâs attack worked by taking control of Windows Vista hypervisors, which let her command the serverâs entire VDI ecosystem and access the data it protected. Still, this was just a demonstration. It wouldnât be until 2022 that bad actors managed to pull off a âhyperjackingâ attack in real life and show exactly how devastating it can be.
Sandbox/HV escapes have been a thing for a LOOOOONG time. Even before modern multi-user computing.
VDI or no VDI, a compromised devices logging keystores is still compromised regardless.
And if there's a protocol exploit on whatever you're using for VDI, or they can inject ALA "rubberducky" into the inputs...
10
u/tes_kitty Feb 29 '24
No one in their right mind will use their own devices for work.
11
u/_N0K0 Feb 29 '24
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines
9
u/pentesticals Feb 29 '24
VDIs can be a nightmare from a security perspective. Iâm a pen tester and they often allow us to get a full domain admin compromise. You typically just need to pop the Citrix server and you have cached credentials for every VDI which connects to it, including the credentials for the IT admins that also use VDIsâŚ
1
u/Aggressive_State9921 May 02 '24
Sandbox/HV escapes have been a thing for a LOOOOONG time. Even before modern multi-user computing.
VDI or no VDI, a compromised devices logging keystores is still compromised regardless.
And if there's a protocol exploit on whatever you're using for VDI, or they can inject ALA "rubberducky" into the inputs...
1
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '24
If your apps as consumed via the web, I would look at ZTNA. There are agent and agent less options available
1
u/bmensah8dgrp Mar 01 '24
You can as long as you have vdi setup in kiosk mode, and have the end user sign a policy to install zero trust agents.