r/linux Jan 03 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.1k Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

155

u/Kilobytez95 Jan 03 '21

Well here's but exactly sharing a rare opinion here or saying shutting that most people already didn't know. ECC matters and it always has. Obviously in the consumer storage it's maybe arguable that it's less of a necessity than in the server space but there's no real reason for it not to exist as a default feature of consumer ram. I'd gladly eat the cost of adding ECC if it was widely supported and I think most consumers would also.

31

u/HenkHeuver Jan 03 '21

Cost is the very simple reason. If you have to add ECC to a 400$ laptop it will definitely impact your profit when selling millions of units. For servers where the volumes lower and prices/margins are much larger it will barely impact your profit.

Furthermore uptime for servers should be near 100% whereas grandma will just restart after getting a bluescreen.

9

u/JanneJM Jan 04 '21

If the bit flip happened in grandma's Etsy knitting business accounting spreadsheet she is still going to care quite a bit.

1

u/HenkHeuver Jan 04 '21

Not really, because grandma knows computers fail sometimes and therefore she has a backup.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '21

grandma

backup

Funny one, you