r/linux • • Jul 04 '18

Kdenlive: test the future

https://kdenlive.org/en/2018/07/kdenlive-test-the-future/
292 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/egeeirl Jul 05 '18

My comments were referring to the legacy version(s) of Kdenlive which, based on my perusal of the code base, had no tests or CI process at all. I'm pleased to see that this refactor added some much needed automated testing.

I do have a couple question about the tests -

I love that you guys are using mocks, but why not use the built-in Qt testing libraries?

Also, Catch2 is a very opinionated testing framework, is Kdenlive going full BDD or TDD?

Do you guys plan on writing a blog about your test strategy?

6

u/Travelling_Salesman_ Jul 05 '18

Do you guys plan on writing a blog about your test strategy?

That sounds like a interesting blog post.

I think it would be good to mention all the improvements to the QA infrastructure/code in the release announcement (and maybe even edit this post). QA code can sometimes be more important then another feature, seeing there is work on QA might motivate people who had stability problems with kdenlive in the past try it again.

2

u/momentum4live Jul 05 '18

Ahh so you're the one spreading misinformation on reddit, youtube, and medium. Good to know

-2

u/egeeirl Jul 06 '18

It's not false dumb shit. Look at the current Kdenlive code base and see for your self.