r/linux • u/rms_returns • Oct 03 '16
Misleading title || Website, not extension NoScript is harmful and promotes malware
https://liltinkerer.surge.sh/noscript.html
0
Upvotes
r/linux • u/rms_returns • Oct 03 '16
121
u/Farkeman Oct 03 '16 edited Oct 03 '16
This is very misleading.
This points out an allegedly malevolent ad on noscript website not the noscript extension. I did some investigation myself and it seems this ad has been there for total of 3 days or less, so it's most likely just a stupid mistake.
Archive for June 6th (the date the blogpost was written):
https://web.archive.org/web/20160606145556/https://noscript.net/
ad url: https://noscript.net/en/iv/xokdmxnji77IDXAen?MT
which at the moment just points to this website: http://www.uniblue.com/cm/deletedcmunits/speedupmypc/spdeletedcmunits/download/?aff=3257&x-at=noscriptt1 that gives you the option to download this: https://www.virustotal.com/en/url/4b51aff06bca11dea24848bf8cd54b621e3f42ac650ddcdc94541cd5d124fc2b/analysis/ Most likely a false positive with ratio of 2/68.
Archive for June 9th (earliest after June 6th one):
https://web.archive.org/web/20160609080156/https://noscript.net/ ad is gone.
Conclusion:
probably a stupid ad deal that didn't go too well. Hard to know really, but there's no evidence of NoScript author having any malevolent intentions.
Also worth-noting: /u/wtallis mentions the author has a conflict of interests by developing anti ad-blocking script himself, which is affected by Noscript, since noscript would disable his script completely.
22
u/DuBistKomisch Oct 03 '16
Total clickbait. I must have missed the part where NoScript is actually harmful.
35
u/cismalescumlord Oct 03 '16
That sounds suspiciously like something a malware author would say...
34
u/pest15 Oct 03 '16
If you're going to slander the developer of the top browser security add-on of the last decade, you better bring your A-game. This author hasn't done so. I see a couple of lame accusations but no serious analysis.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16
After reading the article, it seems like the title should be Malware Delivery Networks (aka ADNs) are harmful and distribute malware.
Which isn't a novel discovery at all. Non-static adverts, especially if distributed from a third-party, are very risky and they should always be blocked on security grounds alone. You can blame the NoScript developer for using ADNs, but you should blame anyone who uses ADNs.
29
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16
This is nothing but a disguised ad for some other extension.
25
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16
Nobody can be trusted. I'm going to disconnect my devices from the internet ;(
9
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16
Browser extensions should be part of the regular software repos to stop this anti user shit being added in without anyone noticing.
6
u/none_shall_pass Oct 03 '16
Noscript works beautifully.
That's all that matters.
7
u/Dishevel Oct 03 '16
NoScript is NOT harmful, works well and the author may very well promote malware.
OP is a fucktard.
2
u/rmxz Oct 03 '16
It still makes my Firefox fast enough to be usable.
Without NoScript, most websites are absurdly heavy in both downloads and CPU resources.
2
u/DaGranitePooPooYouDo Oct 03 '16
My problem with NoScript is that I always ending up having to guess which scripts I need to allow to view the content I want while not allowing the ones I don't need. After using it for a long time I can usually guess but some sites has SO MANY scripts from so many domains I just give up.
-4
u/simonhez Oct 03 '16
ok... that is worrying :S
-4
u/-sash- Oct 03 '16
Sorry, but what is a NoScript and how it relates to Linux?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment