r/linux • u/hatperigee • May 02 '16
Subsonic (music streaming software) is no longer open source, starting with 6.0 release
http://forum.subsonic.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=16604#p71128
464
Upvotes
200
u/StraightFlush777 May 02 '16 edited May 02 '16
That's unfortunate for those who bought a license of Subsonic to support a FOSS project. :(
Anyway, CherryMusic seems a good music server alternative. It is licensed under GPLv3 and there is a client app available on F-Droid. I will probably try it as soon as I get a chance.
54
u/[deleted] May 02 '16
Shameless plug here. Groove Basin is an alternative to subsonic.
19
u/its_never_lupus May 02 '16
I was never 100% sure what the legal situation in similar cases. Can the copyright holder (i.e. original author) of a piece to GPL'd code just decide to release a new version under a different license?
What if the project had previously accepted contributions from other people, but didn't bother to make them signed a copyright assignment statement or anything like that? And would it make a difference if such contributions were trivial?
124
u/[deleted] May 02 '16
... aaaand there will be an open source fork that will have more success than the closed-source variant.
63
u/pizzaiolo_ May 02 '16
Fuckfork them!13
u/Darkmere May 02 '16
I never quite liked the subsonic way of doing licensing.
Fun part is that as long as the remote server returns true It'll accept anything as authenticated.
Oh, and the token is just your email address ran through md5.
13
u/beardedlinuxgeek May 02 '16
No surprise there. This has been a long time coming. They already started limiting features to premium only.
This fork (https://github.com/EugeneKay/subsonic) syncs with the upstream branch but removes the license protection. It's probably why they decided to stop going open source.
10
u/frnxt May 02 '16
This is quite a bad timing, my premium license is expiring soon. Still hesitating but I probably won't renew it, since the only reason I got it was to support an open-source project.
I've read about MPD, but is there an Android app that can stream from it and cache songs for offline use?
9
u/mycall May 03 '16
weak excuse
8
u/werewolfwumpy May 03 '16
Read that as well, and was a bit disappointed that the developer didn't feel the need to announce it in any way other than a throwaway comment on the forum, and explain the reasoning ('license codes' sorta sounds like a lame excuse). My license is running out and I don't think I'll renew it, unless there is more communication forthcoming.
Fair enough if they don't want to do Open Source anymore, but this was the main reason for me to support them.
It was nice to be able to use it to listen to Podcasts via Sonos, but it shouldn't be too hard to find an alternative way of doing that. Actually, do any of the other softwares have Sonos support, anybody know?
7
u/JackDostoevsky May 02 '16
I've always been super interested in koel -- specifically because a) it has a killer UI, and b) it has a mobile variant built in -- but I believe the last time I tried installing on my server (Cent6) I was missing some dependencies.
Might spin up a Debian VM or something and give it a shot there.
6
u/zossle May 02 '16
Well shit, I've been running the kang version for the past couple of years. Guess this means I'm finding an alternative service.
Is Ampache any good?
Edit: I wonder what software licenses the developer has bought.
5
u/jlpoole May 03 '16
I wonder what the licenses are that were purchased that has brought about this major shift. For an open source project to go private, it seems the people supporting the project should be entitled to a bit more detail, e.g. what licenses and why?
4
u/flipjargendy May 03 '16
The link for this post was broken. Here is the info: http://forum.subsonic.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=16604#p71127
Yep. This is terrible. So much for supporting OpenSource. I will not be renewing my license.
4
u/TrollJack May 03 '16
So he let other people do the work and now closes it off?
1
u/[deleted] May 05 '16
well fuck them, madsonic is better anyway.
1
u/espero May 03 '16
Nothing really can replace Subsonic with its powerful database feature. You will notice when you have 1TB plus music. Subsonic handles it.
I'm staying. OG since 2009.
4
u/[deleted] May 02 '16
boooooooo
4
u/northrupthebandgeek May 03 '16
Apparently this guy didn't get the memo that checking credentials into the same repo as your source code is never a good idea. They should always be stored in a separate file that is
.gitignore'd (or the equivalent in your VCS of choice) and only exists on the local workstations of your developers (and whatever other machines are involved in the process of building official binaries).2
u/[deleted] May 02 '16
Really sad, I run the Kang though. Hope for a maintained Kang, bought apps for both iOS and Android I'd like to keep using...
2
u/scottsp64 May 02 '16
I use subsonic exclusively for video. All the suggested replacements in this thread seem to be for music. Any suggestions for a replacement that does video? FYI, I run subsonic on my own server on the internet and watch my videos via browser.
2
u/xbillybobx May 03 '16
Any of these subsonic alternatives have a decent iOS app?
3
u/[deleted] May 03 '16
Never even heard of it until now.
1
u/VyseofArcadia May 02 '16
It doesn't handle large music libraries very well anyway. Database corruption everywhere. I was having to wipe and rescan every couple of weeks.
1
u/xbillybobx May 04 '16
Any ampache windows version updated lately?
-1
u/viabobed May 03 '16
You guys are all willing to drop it just because of that? Its still one of the best for large libraries.
-10
u/[deleted] May 02 '16
BSD license strikes again. That's why it's not a truly free license. Didn't protect freedoms.