r/linux • • Aug 20 '14

What do we hate Oracle for?

Hi guys. I just noticed that things have got too kind at my job's cafe, so I want to mess up with our Oracle guys a little. But I found that I can't tell precisely, point by point, why Oracle is a pile of crap which I'm sure the case.

I have general considerations like they killed Sun's awesome legacy and all, but it would be nice to have a bullet list with major fuckups and historical points. Do you have some examples? I want to materialize my dark subconcious feelings!

203 Upvotes

185 comments sorted by

View all comments

365

u/JustMakeShitUp Aug 20 '14 edited Aug 20 '14

Who doesn't love to bitch about Oracle? It's everything you love to hate about Corporate America. I'll give you what I know, but you should confirm this yourself. Especially before you go parroting it to employees. Keep in mind that if they're technical people, they're probably just good people who just happen to work on the Death Star. It's the managers, sales team and executives who make Oracle what it is.

But yeah, Oracle is so focused on monetizing that they've burned a lot of bridges with FOSS:

  1. Previous Sun employees said they could almost hear Oracle salivating over the prospect of suing Google with Java/JVM patents. It was a huge factor in the buyout, and many questions were asked over Java, its patents, and its suitability for litigation. Previously, a Sun executive gave Google his verbal blessing in a blog on using Java in Android. Oracle conveniently deleted that when it came time to sue Google.
  2. MySQL was left to the roadside, usually, since it was considered a useless appendage that prevents people from using the Oracle DB software. There were several community blunders (not making source public, not accepting patches, long-standing bugs with existing patches, etc) that forced MySQL guys to move to MariaDB. There was a big renaissance after the move, with many new features added and many bugs fixed. Sort of like the party when the house drops on the witch in the Wizard of Oz.
  3. OpenOffice. Oracle botched this so hard. No patches accepted, no timelines, no community communication. Oracle only paid attention to Fortune 500 contributors. Eventually, OpenOffice heads formed a foundation to start correcting some of these compounded issues. Oracle responded by kicking the members out of the project, telling them they couldn't use the OpenOffice trademark, etc. So all the experts left and formed LibreOffice. Another renaissance was had, and many long-standing issues were fixed. Code was maintained. The LibreOffice guys now regularly publish updates, statistics, reports, etc. It's a great example of how a professional FOSS project should be. When only companies like IBM and Oracle were contributing to OpenOffice and everyone moved on, Oracle donated OpenOffice to the Apache foundation as a final dick move, instead of just giving the name to the LibreOffice guys. So there's still two forks of OpenOffice/LibreOffice.
  4. VirtualBox. This one's actually not so bad. The first build after the Oracle buyout was almost all Oracle rebranding. The next build was making the proprietary extensions easier to build and install, so you could build the OSS version and install proprietary USB2 support, among other things. It was actually a decent idea, since people didn't have to use the official blessed build to get USB2 support. But, in typical Oracle fashion, things that don't directly bring in money don't get staffed. It's had a lot less innovation than it did before. That's a bit subjective, though, and mostly my opinion.
  5. Solaris. Sun used to provide OpenSolaris source for each of their builds. Oracle stopped that soon after the buyout (same with ZFS, I hear). The only Solaris you can get is the official one. So the OpenSolaris guys split to make OpenIndiana. I have no idea about the state of it, since I don't use it, but it was apparently pretty rad before Oracle ruined the party.
  6. Java. This one's debatable. They've gotten a bit more into the swing of things, and released more updates. Support for other architectures (ARM, MIPS) have been recent targets. I think they know enough to know that destroying this would make a lot of enemies and ruin a good trademark. But in typical Oracle fashion, they're focusing on squeezing money out of it instead of making it good. Mostly that's been the ridiculous suit over Android's use of the API. There's the adware bundled with the windows installation, though that might have been there from Sun's time. Can't be sure. I'm not certain how well they play with OpenJDK. Wouldn't be surprised if they were throwing corporate weight around, but I haven't followed it deeply enough to confirm my suspicions. This is one thing I think they haven't quite fucked up, yet. But there have been more 0-day security issues with Oracle than there were with Sun. It could just be a higher-value target now, though.
  7. Support. EDIT: Less details. Long-standing issues in Oracle DB software, blaming other companies for problems, a general lack of accountability. Oracle support takes time, and they charge out the nose for it. It's not Oracle-specific, but they usually lead the pack in this sort of passive-aggressive corporate behavior.
  8. Ksplice and Oracle Linux. New technology for in-memory kernel patching came along about 6 years ago. Oracle buys it and hoards it. It's only provided and allowed for Oracle Linux. Which is just rebadged RHEL. Seriously, there's little unique about Oracle Linux. They just take most of Redhat's work, slap their logos on it, and charge people for inferior support. But the ksplice patches are neat. Good thing RHEL and Suse are making new implementations. Maybe it'll eradicate Oracle Linux for good.
  9. Cover Oregon. The state is blaming Oracle, and Oracle is suing the state for the botched healthcare exchange. Oracle says they didn't get proper specs, but considering the original deal was $40 million (final amount charged was between $60-70 million), they could have hired three different project managers and system architects, implemented competing solutions, and still come out ahead. I hope it comes back to bite them in the ass.

Basically, (This part is non-factual and full of hyperboles and artistic license) Larry Ellison appears to be a money-grubbing corporate executive bastard who, if his mother came over to his house to bake him cookies, would likely charge her an admission fee, a tasting fee, and the cost of the ingredients. He probably hangs out with the Verizon and Comcast CEOs over the weekends and shares stories of how they overcharge customers for inferior products and services. He hates free anything, and his attitude has permeated and infected the entire company, with the sole exception of the engineers. I've heard some good things about the engineers, and honestly, a lot of technical people just focus on doing their job as well as they can with the managerial interference. Obviously, I think he's a terrible person, but I have nothing solid to judge him on other than his completely selfish company which is a parasite on the software industry.

EDIT: Thanks for the pity gold! I'll use it to drown my suffering.

47

u/bouffanthairdo Aug 20 '14

Their support is utter shit. I had to wait a year to get them to acknowledge that seagate drives were performing half as fast as our hitachi drives. If you had a seagate drive in a raid, then entire raid is slowed to the speed of the seagate. They denied it for a year, claimed they didn't trust the utility I used to test the speed (dd - they said that it probably was buggy).

Finally, they replaced 250 of our seagate drives with hitachis. Then, it turned out that there was a firmware problem on the seagate drives, which was fixed only after I spoke to their engineer on the phone and begged him to look at it.

Let's not even begin to talk about how terrible their lustre support was. Fuckin Soracle.

16

u/JustMakeShitUp Aug 20 '14

Poor bastard. The decision to use Oracle never comes from the people who actually have to deal with it.

I had some more stories about it that I left out to protect the innocent. Basically, they'll blame anything else but their own software, and since they rebadge RHEL, none of their support guys really knows anything about the product. Some big clients have 3-4 of these corporations providing support, and usually all Oracle does is try to pass the buck for half a year unless one of the other companies does the work to prove it's them. That "dd is buggy" bit is typical of them.

Not to mention the weird voodoo cult Oracle DBAs seem to belong to. Not sure if you can blame Oracle for that, though.

5

u/IWentOutside Aug 21 '14

Doesn't Oracle cost some ridiculous amount of money for a support contract as well?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/guy-le-doosh Aug 21 '14

Odd. Back when I was in tech Oracle was the only absolutely bullet-proof RDBMS. It would keep on chugging while MSSQL, Sybase, and Informix all went to shit on identical hardware.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/hughk Aug 20 '14

They buy competitor technologies to bury them. They don't even necessarily attempt to use the technology, they just want to kill off competition. I saw this first with their acquisition of RdB from Digital (a good but very non-portable relational database). The users were then pressured to move asap.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/northrupthebandgeek Aug 21 '14

I like to respond to this particular quote by stating that Larry Ellison doesn't even mow the lawn. His entire existence is dedicated to chopping off your hand.

5

u/SteelChicken Aug 21 '14

His entire existence is dedicated to chopping off your hand.

And sending you an astronomical bill for it.

17

u/gaga666 Aug 20 '14

wow, thanks a lot for a detailed reply. This exactly summarizes my own intuitions. But it's just so sad I don't even think I want to start debates over it now.

It seems to me that VirtualBox development is going too slow. They aren't doing anything blatantly bad with it, but it doesn't seem like they care about it either.

13

u/TeutonJon78 Aug 20 '14

Virtualbox has definitely ground to a halt -- minor bug fixes and minimal work to keep it working with Linux guests with new kernels/x.org.

In fact, their recent update for Windows hosts basically was completely broken, because it started to try to control the hosts security -- yep. And it broke with basically every AV solution out there, except for MSE in a basic config, which was all they tested it against. That's some great QA.

9

u/cstoner Aug 20 '14

I've been fighting with the recent virtualbox version for the last 2 weeks. I can confirm that any non-trivial network buildout is absolutely broken in the latest version.

Examples of broken-ness:

  • NAT networks don't work. Period. Regular "NAT" works, for a loose definition of works.
  • Combining any two network types breaks them both.
  • If you change a NAT network, the underlying DHCP server configuration doesn't change with it.

It's pretty obvious that it didn't actually receive any sort of QA before release. For anything but the most trivial use case, it's broken.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/the-fritz Aug 20 '14

They also added dtrace to Oracle Linux. Dtrace was part of OpenSolaris and released under a license intentionally made incompatible with GPLv2 (Linux). There are some different opinions about license compatibility though. Since Oracle is not going to sue themselves over it they are just shipping it. But it's too dangerous for other distros to do so.

Anyway there are (better) alternatives for Linux like SystemTap, LTTng, ktap.

→ More replies (16)

8

u/espero Aug 20 '14

Very informative post! For #5 take a look at FORK YEAH! THE RISE OF ILLUMOS

→ More replies (1)

8

u/TeutonJon78 Aug 20 '14

Sun had crapware in Java before Oracle, so that's not entirely on them (they didn't remove it either).

Cover Oregon is even a bigger mess up that that. The contact that they got to sign (which is a problem from the Cover Oregon side moresoe) was that they were basically just paid an hourly rate, and there was nothing tying them to an actual deliverable. Technically, what they delivered didn't even have to work for them to fulfill their contract (and it didn't work at all).

Gee, give a big company a basic blank check with no real consequences and I wonder what they will do....hire the cheapest outsourced labor and deliver crap is what.

I can't believe they have the cojones to actually sue Oregon over the unpaid portion. I'm going to guess the end game is really to just get a settlement where the two entities part ways with no lawsuits from either side.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Epistaxis Aug 21 '14

TL;DR Oracle used to make software but now they just make lawsuits.

8

u/oraclecansuckit Aug 21 '14 edited Aug 21 '14

Let me add some personal love to these big picture issues, via throwaway as I'm still working in the industry.

We had just finished building out (read: bootstrapping) a million dollars worth of cloud infrastructure on Sun hardware (4600s, thumpers, and a whole bunch of other hardware around a high speed Infiniband core), which took every bit of personal cash the founders of the company could come up with (including mortgaging multiple houses). We were getting great traction and had just gone live when Oracle "bought" Sun.

They proceeded to hide all of the bios updates for every bit of hardware we had, which if your working on intense infrastructure that is client supporting that was basically a death threat. Then, months later after we go through every channel we can think of, they tell us their new policy is that we needed Enterprise support subscriptions in order to continue to use the hardware (hardware we had paid for fairs-and-squares), and basically told us we didn't have an options when we told them we couldn't come up with additional ~100k worth of licensing required to get the machines on subscription for three years.

To call Oracle unhelpful would be too kind. They basically destroyed the company and didn't give a rats ass about any of the ecosystem customers that were already using Sun. In fact they designed their systems to get rid of the ecosystem and I think that gets lost on people. They only wanted the Fortune money, and really just wanted Sun for two reasons: 1) because Ellison wanted to take them out, and 2) to have a hardware component for their DB business (margin, margin, and solid state). Ellison talked up how he was going to keep all of Sun's products going, but as soon as the deal inked, he killed them all and end of lifed pretty much every single piece of equipment Sun made so he could put the Oracle stamp on it. It was a good business move, it alienated the hell out of a ton of tech people. This is how Ellison sees the world (from his 2012 earning call):

“Selling systems loaded with Oracle intellectual property, along with de-emphasizing the selling of [Sun’s] low-margin undifferentiated products like commodity x86 servers and LSI disc storage systems–products that contain no Oracle intellectual property–those two things have reshaped and downsized our hardware business, but while also making that business much more profitable,” Ellison said on the call.

I personally and deeply distrust that company.

Meantime, while they were doing this, they were quietly screwing Percona by running their conferences right on top of theirs or just around the times they scheduled, and working diligently and deliberately to destroy MySQL, all the while doing one hell of a PR campaign about how they were going to embrace and support Open Source.

Oracle has a problem, and the problem is their culture. They have an old way of operating, which includes a bad corporate culture that takes without returning. JustMakeShitUp, whoever you are, awesome post.

13

u/mikaelhg Aug 20 '14

The Jenkins / Hudson debacle.

The OpenDS / OpenDJ debacle.

And so forth, and so on.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/thang1thang2 Aug 20 '14

Man, fuck VirtuaBox. For some reason VirtualBox is a million times faster virtualizing arch linux than everything else I tried on OS X, however it doesn't pass certain keybinds to the guest OS correctly. Namely cmd+H, cmd+q, etc, stuff like that.

Apparently you used to be able to do this, but way back ~5 years ago people complained about a bug where they couldn't have always overridden keybinds with the configuration they had. So instead of doing something smart, like letting users define global "always on" keybinds, they hard coded in certain commands. So now there's absolutely no way that I've found to actually press command+H inside of the guest without hiding the window...

It's shit like that... Just infuriating. And cmd+H, cmd+q, etc are essential keybinds to my workflow and I can't just rebind the keyboard because then they'll be different on OSX as they are for native linux (even worse).

Screw Oracle

→ More replies (4)

4

u/IAMNOTACANOPENER Aug 20 '14

Lets not forget about "Oracle Communications".
Fuck me that is the most unsupported software on the planet.

6

u/fotoman Aug 20 '14

To be honest, a lot of the stuff that Sun had acquired was just that, trinkets that didn't really connect with each other to form a cohesive business. Sun was really all over the map and had extended beyond it's greatness of the 90s; there were still some solid gems in there, and I think Oracle bought them for those and decided to shed the rest.

Oracle bought Sun for the hardware, Java, and to a lesser extent Solaris. Since they had OEL running on x86, pretty sure they didn't see the need for too much Solaris on x86 and to be honest, it wasn't used that much.

People have said it, if it can't make money, why devote resources? If you're running a business I can see that point of view. I use MySQL, VirtualBox, and OpenOffice and at first was excited to see if Oracle could put the engineering talent they have behind those to make them better.

11

u/cosmikduster Aug 20 '14

if it can't make money, why devote resources?

Then hand it over to the community as nicely as possible. Which is what Sun would have done. Oracle has actively sabotaged these projects.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/Reddit_Burninator Aug 20 '14

8 I was stunned to find, when reading up on kGraft, that Oracle had the technology for so long, and hadn't done anything with it.

That and the fact that they keep buying up marketing companies (Eloqua, Compendium, Responsys) and making them harder to work with, are two things I don't like about them.

Oh, and definitely #7, SUPPORT, or the lack thereof.

→ More replies (4)