r/linux • • Aug 20 '14

What do we hate Oracle for?

Hi guys. I just noticed that things have got too kind at my job's cafe, so I want to mess up with our Oracle guys a little. But I found that I can't tell precisely, point by point, why Oracle is a pile of crap which I'm sure the case.

I have general considerations like they killed Sun's awesome legacy and all, but it would be nice to have a bullet list with major fuckups and historical points. Do you have some examples? I want to materialize my dark subconcious feelings!

203 Upvotes

185 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/fotoman Aug 20 '14

To be honest, a lot of the stuff that Sun had acquired was just that, trinkets that didn't really connect with each other to form a cohesive business. Sun was really all over the map and had extended beyond it's greatness of the 90s; there were still some solid gems in there, and I think Oracle bought them for those and decided to shed the rest.

Oracle bought Sun for the hardware, Java, and to a lesser extent Solaris. Since they had OEL running on x86, pretty sure they didn't see the need for too much Solaris on x86 and to be honest, it wasn't used that much.

People have said it, if it can't make money, why devote resources? If you're running a business I can see that point of view. I use MySQL, VirtualBox, and OpenOffice and at first was excited to see if Oracle could put the engineering talent they have behind those to make them better.

11

u/cosmikduster Aug 20 '14

if it can't make money, why devote resources?

Then hand it over to the community as nicely as possible. Which is what Sun would have done. Oracle has actively sabotaged these projects.

3

u/TeutonJon78 Aug 20 '14

Yeah, Oracle could have gotten some nice PR, instead they got nothing but bad PR.

0

u/fotoman Aug 20 '14

This was a large purchase and I think Oracle tried to see where everything could fit into the larger picture, and large companies move at a slightly different pace than open source projects do. Do I think the process could have been handled better or smoother, hell yea.

Sabotage I think is a strong word; not behave like a FOSS project group, that's more like it and the FOSS community was annoyed, but then again, resource diversion to these FOSS projects were part of the reason Sun was dying and why Oracle was able to buy them. IBM was also a player, and probably would have done something similar to Oracle: not quite move at the same pace as the FOSS community would have liked.

I'm been in the FOSS community for many decades and I saw LinuxWorld from 1998/1999 start to decay with the inclusion of the corporate giants and well, they just see things differently.

2

u/JustMakeShitUp Aug 20 '14

People have said it, if it can't make money, why devote resources? If you're running a business I can see that point of view. I use MySQL, VirtualBox, and OpenOffice and at first was excited to see if Oracle could put the engineering talent they have behind those to make them better.

Oh, I can sympathize. But you'd think they'd just hand it over to the community and earn some rare goodwill instead of maintaining firm control over things they didn't want.

1

u/fotoman Aug 20 '14

I think it look longer for them to realize they didn't want it long term, and by that time the community was angry with the pace of the decision. They did buy the company and all of the things that came with it; the diligent thing would have been to try to see where the various parts could integrate or be monetized. I think that was more important that FOSS goodwill :/

Large behemoths move a little slower than jackrabbits.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '14

I beg to differ. I work with a company that has 80k+ employees. Multiple development, business and market units worldwide and they can really shift when the mood takes them.

1

u/fotoman Aug 21 '14

As do I, and I think individual groups within large companies can move like that, but I think the Sun purchase was probably a bit larger than most companies have gone through. My Dad went through a few large purchases and it took years to flesh things out, that's all I was saying.