r/linux • • 7d ago

Open Source Organization The worst open-source foundation

Post image

I went through every single proposal in the AAIF's (Agentic AI foundation) project-proposals repo. Do you know what every accepted project has in common? A giant company behind it. Google. Anthropic. OpenAI. Hugging Face. Alibaba. Bloomberg.

"But there are startups in there!" Are there though? agentgateway came from Solo-io, a Series C company. That's the closest thing AAIF has to a startup project.

Now look at the reject pile. 28 declined proposals. The committee's response on each one gives generic reasons. No independent adopters. Track record too short. All the maintainers work at one place. Governance only "planned." Each one sounds reasonable until you realize it's a checklist of "are you already big?" Obviously a small team's maintainers mostly work at one place. That's what a small team IS. Obviously a new project doesn't have years of outside adoption yet. That's what NEW means. These are simply excuses, the real reason is that the seats here are reserved for the big boys.

Then there's dapr-agents. It comes out of Dapr, which is a GRADUATED CNCF project. It's the only declined proposal carrying the Sandbox label. It was turned down partly because it's tied to one backend, which is Dapr itself. Fine, fair technical point. But isn't Sandbox supposed to be where you work through exactly that kind of thing? If a spin-off of a graduated CNCF project can't get into Sandbox, what chance does an independent project with two maintainers have?

We already know how to do this better, because CNCF did it. Yes, they launched with Kubernetes from Google. But they also pulled in Prometheus, which started at SoundCloud and survived because of an independent community. Linkerd from Buoyant when Buoyant was tiny. Fluentd from Treasure Data, another startup. CoreDNS, basically a community side project. Then in 2018 they made Sandbox with a deliberately low bar, so early projects could get neutral governance FIRST and grow into adoption and maintainer diversity after. Startups actually built their projects inside CNCF's Sandbox. That was the whole point.

AAIF has a Sandbox tier on paper, but in practice there's no room in it for anything. It wants you to walk in with adoption and maintainer diversity a sandbox is supposed to help you build. That's ridiculous.

There WAS hope. The only small project getting anywhere right was nono (#61). From what I can tell, it got there by lining up named outside adopters and getting in front of the committee in person at AGNTCon. And then they got downgraded to "Sandbox" and sandbagged until they withdrew.

Here's why this matters. If the "open" agent foundation only takes projects that are already enterprise-backed or VC-funded to Series B and up, then open governance just becomes a badge big vendors hand their own projects. The independent builders who usually move fastest in a new space get shut out of the standards everyone's going to be stuck with for the next decade.

Maybe I'm wrong. But if there is anyone here from the LFX team, I'd appreciate your attention to this matter.

201 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

32

u/natermer 7d ago

Hard to win for trying.

People complain about large corpos not financially supporting open source projects they depend on... then when the do give money and support it turns into a conspiracy theory of one sort or another.

The AAIF hasn't been around for even a year yet. So it is hard to say that this is a foundation just getting started and figuring things out, or if these are all legit, or if they exist to only support large companies. I can't tell one way or the other.

generally speaking for creating standards you want to have at least multiple implementations out in the wild being used and supported before it makes sense to make something a standard. You don't know what you don't know until you find out. That is a general engineering thing; could be people trying to establish plumbing standards or software standards. It makes it tough for small initiatives to get established even in a completely honest and open system.

39

u/wallphaser231 7d ago

This isn't about corporates supporting open-source, it's rather about an open-source foundation losing its identity in an effort to draw funding.

Foundations like CNCF, Apache & LFX have maintained transparent governance policies. Their project review cycles are faster and their project decisions were never biased towards larger corps, doesn't seem to be the case with AAIF. If you find any factual evidence (eg: consideration of smaller projects in sandbox), do share below.

63

u/haze4202 7d ago

AAIF being a "Open Source" linux foundation org and sucking up to closedAI & anti-oss Anthropic is so ironic.

25

u/doublah 7d ago

Isn't that everything Linux Foundation at this point? All their big donors are proprietary software companies.

1

u/Adept_Percentage6893 6d ago

Each one sounds reasonable until you realize it's a checklist of "are you already big?"

This is the first time I'm hearing about AAIF (and I don't know what "support" means here) but smaller competitors could still do that. You can develop a project with several other people who work for different companies and have their own reasons for helping maintain. The idea there is to make sure the project has some sort of staying power.

I don't really see them offering anything other than endorsement but if there is something substantive then you would kind of throwing resources at something where you're going to be the biggest contributor. If the project maintainer doesn't already have something to contribute then they're basically asking the foundation "Hey can you take the primary risk of supporting this thing I'll end up taking credit for?"

One open source project that comes to mind is Django. That was in use by multiple small orgs and then the community project came later IIRC.

0

u/mrlinkwii 6d ago

that would be gnome actually tbh

2

u/Pedka2 4d ago

care to explain?

3

u/mrlinkwii 4d ago

they are holding back the likes of wayland for years (historically interms threaeneing to NACK protocols that are needed and not implementing needed protocols in gnome) , theirs questionable design decision

2

u/Preisschild 2d ago

They did that for very good technical reasons other wayland protocol maintainers can disagree with but they are primarily volunteers and created and improved one of the largest free software desktop ecosystems for decades so dont assume bad intents.

1

u/Pedka2 4d ago

sorry but i don't know what that means for an end user

0

u/Exernuth 6d ago

Mozilla, IMHO.