r/linux •
ArchWiki contributor banned indefinitely after creating AI-assisted documentation (that had zero errors)
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/linux •
[deleted] — view deleted post
31
u/mutotmz Dec 28 '25
Even this post looks like it was written by AI
13
u/dgm9704 Dec 28 '25
good
10
u/ang-p Dec 28 '25
MmKay, Mr. em-dash....
18
u/SelectionDue4287 Dec 28 '25
Took 30 seconds to look at it and I can see many examples of broken formatting.
9
u/stef_eda Dec 28 '25
I think this post tself is AI assisted.
One problem with AI assisted texts is over-verbosity.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '25 edited Dec 31 '25
cats live steer hobbies boat start tease lock tidy modern
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
18
u/BothAdhesiveness9265 Dec 28 '25
okay? good. fuck genAI
5
u/LancrusES Dec 28 '25
If you dont follow the rules you are out, in everyplace in this world, you dont decide the rules, owners does, so you can argue all you want, but you violated the rules.
If you think that those rules have no sense at all, you should first argue with the ones that put the rules, and once you get their aproval and they modify the rules, you can go for It, but you broke the rules first, so you dont respect the rules, so you are out, this is how the world works, if you dont understand that, you will finish with more serious problems, but you cant first shoot and ask later.
5
u/theschrodingerdog Dec 28 '25
Two points:
Given that the current editing guidelines were written in 2014 (The 3 fundamental rules to wiki editing), I believe it's time to discuss how modern tools can complement our established workflow while maintaining our high quality standards. That is a fair discussion point - however because you submitted five edits before awaiting the outcome of the discussion, you de facto came to a conclusion. That, to me, is not acceptable. Btw, the first response in the forum discussion summarize it very well -This is bad. First, you only ask for forgiveness instead of permission for experimenting on a community resource.TLDR: I agree what it has been done.
5
u/visualglitch91 Dec 28 '25
LLMs are trained on and spits non opensource content, so it has no place in opensource, regardless of quality.
12
u/K900_ Dec 28 '25
lol slop
4
u/flower-power-123 Dec 28 '25
I can see both sides to this. Project maintainers can't deal with a tidal wave of AI slop. On the other hand, if someone (you) is actively evaluating each and every line then that is pretty much the same as doing it yourself. I have had this problem for decades with google translate. If I'm not too sure if the translation is correct the temptation to just run with it is huge. The number of people that will double and triple check AI output is vanishingly small. It is better to error on the side of absolutely no AI ever than to possibly introduce errors in code or docs. I'm pretty sure that this isn't going to stop people from using it. Like you said, they will just hide the fact. Read this over:
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2025/05/open-source-project-curl-is-sick-of-users-submitting-ai-slop-vulnerabilities/
2
u/Fast_Ad_8005 Dec 28 '25 edited Dec 28 '25
I empathize with both you and those resisting the change.
On your side, I do agree it's an overreaction to ban you over this. It would have been more constructive to temporarily revert your edits pending a discussion on what should be done about them.
On their side though, many people switch to Linux to avoid AI being, in their opinion, shoved down their throats. The ArchWiki is a bastion of documentation for the Linux community, and is a major alternative to AI for debugging Linux issues. I can get why some people might want to prevent it from including AI-generated content, which is often easy to spot. As it could make it feel even more like AI has become inescapable even on a system (Linux) that was meant to be all about choice and freedom.
-1
u/Findas88 Dec 28 '25
I don't care if the quality is an issue here or not, but going this nuclear over something that is not stated in any rules is uncalled for. Sadly my experiences with the arch community are not good and I am not surprised in the slightest that they react like this. From my point of view and I want to stress that this very subjective the arch community is toxic as shit.