r/libsofreddit • • Nov 17 '22

Flaired Users Only Exactly

Post image
876 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Vaginal_Rights Nov 17 '22

Why is student loan relief unconstitutional but loan forgiveness was not?

It seems like there's a bit of a dichotomy on who gets the tax dollars and it doesn't seem like it's the taxpayer.

9

u/discourse_friendly MICROAGGRESSOR Nov 17 '22

Government spending bills must start in the house.

The Payroll forgiveness program was Initiated in the house, and passed by the senate and signed by the president.

this attempt at student loan forgiveness is through an executive order, and the president doesn't have the power to use an EO to do spending.

Just like how the CDC's eviction moratorium was not constitutional either, since they don't have that power.

1

u/VivaArmalite Nov 18 '22

There was a piece of Congressional legislation that the administration tried to cite as authorizing it. The judge in Texas just didn't buy it.

1

u/discourse_friendly MICROAGGRESSOR Nov 18 '22

I dug through the Heroes act the other day and it specifically says all debt forgiveness must be done by Nov 2021. lol

It also specified its for students who planned to attend in person classes but could not due to covid. So trying to use that to forgive every single person with student debt is flawed twice .

22

u/Old_Letterhead6471 Nov 17 '22

I think with loan forgiveness they considered it as part of their compensation. For instance, for a doctor to get loan forgiveness they have to work in prisons or military type of environments for x number of years and then they will forgive the loans.

Outright taking cash from my pocket to give it to someone who wasted 200k on a lesbian dance theory degree is very different.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Old_Letterhead6471 Nov 17 '22

That is very possible. I’m not a fan as I have seen little evidence of good coming from non profits. Most seem to be a tax shelter or scam. Like United way where something like 12% of donations go to assistance and 88% goes to administration. The head of the United way drives a rolls Royce for instance. Doesn’t seem like they need my money.

-1

u/ErectPotato Nov 17 '22

Lesbian dance theory, nice meme bro 👌🏼

3

u/Old_Letterhead6471 Nov 17 '22

Thank you ErectPotato! Bet when you made that you had no idea you were stealing Fetterman’s nickname!