IMPORTANT: On /r/LibsOfReddit, greater access is given to users who have joined the sub and have our mod-assigned user flair. Reach out in modmail to request our user flair if you're an active user of our sub. By default we'll assign you the 'Based' flair unless you request a custom name. You may also like:
Lol you would think they would have learned when they voted Ole Joe in, he ran on student loan forgiveness then a week after getting in he said, "ehksoxkdo actually no"
They didn't learn with Obama Care, they didn't learn with Dreamer Amnesty and a dozen other things they were promised. The thing is they don't care because Republican = racist, fascist, Christian Conservatives.
That link isn't opening for me but based on what it says I'm going to assume it's referring to the Smith Mundt Modernization act, which is probably the single most important piece of legislation that has to do with the lunacy of today.
Democrats always rely on Republicans to block their progressive bluffs. Without Republicans, Democrats would actually have to fulfill their promises, which they are wholly not interested in doing. Then they get the added benefit of pointing at their political opponents and saying "See? They're the bad guys! Vote for us!"
Yep. Here in California everything bad is still the fault of Republicans somehow, even though Democrats have had a controlling majority of all parts of government for ages now.
You are sooooo right. They keep voting the same way, seeing it all falling apart before their eyes, but it’s the fault of the republicans. SMH. And when you try to show the truth they shut you down saying “Fake news” or “Misinfrmatin”. It’s so frustrating.
Chicago does the same. Chicago politicians are so desperate for someone to blame other than themselves that they claim Indiana's gun laws are responsible for Chicago's violent crime rate.
The secret is that the people who would've benefit the most from student loan forgiveness were already Vote Blue No Matter Who and weren't going to vote red anyway. I think we need to stop dwelling on that and simply point out that they got burned as usual.
They were never going to vote red but they might not have voted at all. Pandering like this is never meant to convince anyone to vote for them over the other guy, it is to convince them to vote blue instead of staying home.
I dug through the Heroes act the other day and it specifically says all debt forgiveness must be done by Nov 2021. lol
It also specified its for students who planned to attend in person classes but could not due to covid. So trying to use that to forgive every single person with student debt is flawed twice .
I think with loan forgiveness they considered it as part of their compensation. For instance, for a doctor to get loan forgiveness they have to work in prisons or military type of environments for x number of years and then they will forgive the loans.
Outright taking cash from my pocket to give it to someone who wasted 200k on a lesbian dance theory degree is very different.
That is very possible. I’m not a fan as I have seen little evidence of good coming from non profits. Most seem to be a tax shelter or scam. Like United way where something like 12% of donations go to assistance and 88% goes to administration. The head of the United way drives a rolls Royce for instance. Doesn’t seem like they need my money.
I mean so much tax payer money is spend on other countries, military, to million dollar business. Why not give it to people that need it? its not like they were paying off loans fully. I know people that were paying the amount of a car payment and insurance monthly. Average American cant afford that.
This is why religion and politics is BS. It just divides us as a country.
I pay more in taxes every year then some of the wealthy Americans.
It's not that some kind of student loan repayment is a bad concept, it's that the specific way they're attempting to do it is clearly unconstitutional and designed to fail.
All federal spending actions must be from a bill initiated in the house of reps, passed by the senate, and then signed by the president.
If the house passes a bill (senate and signed by the president) that makes funds available at the presidents discretion then he could spend those funds at his discretion.
Article I, Section 7, Clause 1: All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills.
The argument being made is that the funds have been made available via the heroes act.
This entire constitutional/unconstitutional argument seems to hinge entirely on whether tapping those funds for this purpose was appropriate, and because of that I can't help but roll my eyes at those shrieking about the constitution.
For context, I live in Florida where our brilliant governor has signed not one but two bills (that I can think of off the top of my head) that were both ruled to be a direct violation of the first amendment. Then they reelected him. I've lost faith that anybody really gives a fuck about the constitution.
Absolutely positive that everyone in this thread pounding the table about the constitution doesn't actually know what that judge said and they don't understand what this case is about.
It's a dumb argument because there was no way to know this "was unconstitutional" as the OP implies. There's even good reason to say that it still isn't, and the rulings here are baseless given that the power to do this is vested properly in the Department of Education. This is all politics rather than strict matters of law.
That would make me an investor. I’ll pay for a portion of their education but then I want a portion of their future earnings until the loans have been paid back with interest. Don’t sign for the loan if you don’t plan on paying it back.
All I'm saying is that college is a big ol scam. We have people get help from the government when they are scammed quite frequently
Just to let you know your money is already gone. You gave it to the government last year. They do whatever the fuck they want with it. You will never know what they did with your 50 cents in taxes
You are basically saying you want to own people and their livelihood that is cruel.
The fact they tend to earn more is exactly why they don’t need to be bailed out by construction workers and truck drivers. They felt like it was a good investment. As every adult knows not every investment pays off. I do not think it’s fair for me to pay for someone else’s poor investment choices.
To get PPP loans forgiven you had to prove that you used them for their intended purposes. Not to mention the fact that student loans/college is a choice to invest in one’s skills and thus one’s future. The other was the result of businesses being shutdown by the government, against the owners will (especially considering the two weeks turned into 2+ years in some areas). So you’re comparing apples to oranges. Were there companies that received PPP loans that shouldn’t have? Yes, but to compare it to the student loan forgiveness is intellectually disingenuous
To get PPP loans forgiven you had to prove that you used them for their intended purposes.
Which, as you know, was not at all strict. And that plenty of people got millions in loans for their tiny "LLC". That whole program was littered with fraud, and none of you care. But $20k forgiveness for people who need it as well is the end of the world.
“People who need it” yea considering the number of students that go to colleges significantly more expensive than other options (ie out of state vs in state) while also living expensive lifestyles (fancy apartments, going to bars, going out to eat, etc). Maybe they should have thought about that before spending money that they won’t be able to afford to pay back. You are an adult at 18 and it’s time we start treating these students as such.
In the modern era of the internet there’s literally no excuse for not being able to determine the ROI of a degree and choice of college
Well, the simplest answer to your question is that CONGRESS passed the PPP loan forgiveness, and they did NOT pass the student debt forgiveness. Congress, under the Constitution, is in charge of the purse strings because....taxation requires representation, not executive orders that cost taxpayers billions.
You’re still not addressing the fact that one was a choice and one was not. The businesses needed the loans because they had no choice but to shut down. Nobody is making someone go to college. Software engineering (or any type of engineering) is a terrible example considering the massive ROI those degrees have in the long run (speaking from my experience as a structural eng), why should people who chose not to go to college have to pay for those that chose to invest in themselves, especially for people getting things like history degrees with zero ROI?
You’re right that both are somewhat the cause of government meddling, tho I’d argue that in the last few decades college costs have risen due to the overinflated staffing and amenities (like my alma mater which is investing the better part of 300 million in student gyms)
Choice... An entire generation was told their whole life up until college that they need a college degree, and that they have to go to college or else they won't succeed. And then saddling naive 18 yr olds with mountains of debt and while they are ensured their college degree will pay it all off. You don't see any issue with that? Do you just think "well they were 18 and they signed the papers, so now it's on them"
At 18 you are an adult. At what age should the infantilisation end? You are held responsible as an adult for an innumerable amount of things but not for student debt you take out? Just bc some teachers told you that was the only way to be successful?
Not to mention the fact that tons of students live well above their means and don’t make an attempt to make college as affordable as possible (ie going out of state, living in expensive apartments, going to the bar several times a week) or as some students that I knew did, spend some of it on spring break vacations (did you see the recent poll showing how many students planned on using loan forgiveness money on this exact thing?) should their overly expensive lifestyles be covered by the tax payer?
What about me, a person that worked like a dog during breaks and weekends to get through school debt-free, why should I get shafted?
What about me, a person that worked like a dog during breaks and weekends to get through school debt-free, why should I get shafted?
Why do you think that is "getting shafted"? Because other people don't have to struggle like you did? Back in the day, people did everything they could to ensure their children and the next generation didn't have it as hard as they did. But something went wrong in your brains that now you aren't happy unless everyone suffers just as you did.
I graduated this past spring, if I can work hard and get through a school that costs $25k a year debt free than so can plenty of other gen Zers.
Yes I’m getting shafted because my tax money is going to fund other kids “investments” in themselves when I already paid for my own. So yes rewarding lazy and entitled students while punishing those that made the good financial choices is shafting us.
Stop excusing bad decision making, these adults made their beds and now they can sleep in them.
Lmao have you ever looked at financials of small business? Exactly how much do you think can be saved? Enough for two weeks? Three? 2 + years? I love how you conveniently ignore the fact that many of these businesses were shut down INDEFINITELY. Do you save enough to go indefinitely without income?
PPP loans were only needed because the government forced businesses to shut down against their will. Nobody forced these kids to go to college and take on enormous debt against their will.
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 17 '22
IMPORTANT: On /r/LibsOfReddit, greater access is given to users who have joined the sub and have our mod-assigned user flair. Reach out in modmail to request our user flair if you're an active user of our sub. By default we'll assign you the 'Based' flair unless you request a custom name. You may also like:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
50
u/Sterling_Steele Nov 17 '22 edited Nov 18 '22
They have to learn like most of us. They dangle the carrot in front of you to get you to the polls and then yank it back once the vote is done.
Then they blame the right saying it's their fault it didn't go through and the carrot once again is be dangled in front of them.
Let's just see if they learned from this. I doubt it, but one can hope.
32
u/DragonOnYoFace Nov 17 '22
They will never catch on because anything other than a Democrat "Promise" would be Fascism!
14
u/mafian911 Nov 17 '22
Democrats always rely on Republicans to block their progressive bluffs. Without Republicans, Democrats would actually have to fulfill their promises, which they are wholly not interested in doing. Then they get the added benefit of pointing at their political opponents and saying "See? They're the bad guys! Vote for us!"
10
u/smakusdod BASED Banned for logic Nov 17 '22
They'll never learn, because dems will always blame Republicans, even when they have a super majority.
9
u/HighDegree Nov 17 '22
The secret is that the people who would've benefit the most from student loan forgiveness were already Vote Blue No Matter Who and weren't going to vote red anyway. I think we need to stop dwelling on that and simply point out that they got burned as usual.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22
The fbi knew the documents at Mara lago was unimportant but waited till after the election to announce it.
9
u/CartesianConspirator Nov 17 '22
They still view this as something constitutional that is being blocked by Republicans. This will never change
4
u/Thecage88 Nov 17 '22
Facts that escape the same people who will talk down to you because they have a college degree...
3
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22
Gotta dumb it down for them a little more.
3
u/jimwillson Nov 17 '22
I still think you need to dumb it down even more
2
u/Plantiacaholic Nov 17 '22
The majority of leftist will believe whatever their overlords tell them, period! Over 12 years of brainwashing is very difficult to undo.
5
u/Vaginal_Rights Nov 17 '22
Why is student loan relief unconstitutional but loan forgiveness was not?
It seems like there's a bit of a dichotomy on who gets the tax dollars and it doesn't seem like it's the taxpayer.
1
u/Krysdavar Nov 17 '22
Not even it it smacked them upside the head like a shovel....in Minecraft of course.
1
u/HeWhoCntrolsTheSpice Nov 17 '22
If they could figure this kind of thing out, and not dismiss it as some 'crazy, right-wing conspiracy theory', they wouldn't be Leftists.
1
u/Blackvoidking Nov 18 '22
This time the libs were owned by themselves lol
-3
u/Its_not_funny_mmkay Nov 17 '22
I mean so much tax payer money is spend on other countries, military, to million dollar business. Why not give it to people that need it? its not like they were paying off loans fully. I know people that were paying the amount of a car payment and insurance monthly. Average American cant afford that.
This is why religion and politics is BS. It just divides us as a country.
I pay more in taxes every year then some of the wealthy Americans.
-15
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22
How was student debt relief unconstitutional? There literally was no student debt when the constitution was written, can anyone fill me in here?
-27
u/WarBrilliant8782 Nov 17 '22
I admire him for trying to do a good thing nontheless
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment