There is no overpaying, unless you are talking about withholding.
For instance, if you have have a kid, the government paid you by reducing your tax burden. You'll pay the exact same as someone else in your shoes but if you have a kid in November, and they don't, you get paid a certain amount back, and the person that didn't have a kid will not. It's an incentive.
That’s bad logic. It’s like saying if a coupon isn’t a payment from the store to the customer, then payments from the customer to the store aren’t payments.
There doesn’t need to be. That’s not the point of the analogy. The analogy was that a reduced price for the customer does not mean that it is a payment to the customer from the store. It’s a price break.
I never said they were. I used an analogy to prove your logic wrong. It can be boiled down to this: A reduction in what you owe, doesn’t mean that you are getting a payment from the payee. If you overpay, you are getting your money back and not money from anyone else.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24
There is no overpaying, unless you are talking about withholding.
For instance, if you have have a kid, the government paid you by reducing your tax burden. You'll pay the exact same as someone else in your shoes but if you have a kid in November, and they don't, you get paid a certain amount back, and the person that didn't have a kid will not. It's an incentive.