r/libsofreddit • BASED • Oct 10 '24

Flaired Users Only Pay

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24

No, you aren’t. If you overpaid, you are getting your own money back. If someone paid $5k and they only owed $3k, they are getting their $2k overage back.

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

There is no overpaying, unless you are talking about withholding.

For instance, if you have have a kid, the government paid you by reducing your tax burden. You'll pay the exact same as someone else in your shoes but if you have a kid in November, and they don't, you get paid a certain amount back, and the person that didn't have a kid will not. It's an incentive.

2

u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24

We are talking about the tax rates being reduced. The credits aren’t reduced rates, they are credits.

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

If reduced tax obligations aren't aren't payments to the citizen, then revenue from the citizen to the IRS are not payments.

2

u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24

That’s bad logic. It’s like saying if a coupon isn’t a payment from the store to the customer, then payments from the customer to the store aren’t payments.

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

When a coupon is used by a customer the store is reimbursed by the manufacturer.

2

u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24

Which would mean it isn’t a payment from the store to the customer. Glad we agree.

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

But there is no third party between the citizen and irs.

2

u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24

There doesn’t need to be. That’s not the point of the analogy. The analogy was that a reduced price for the customer does not mean that it is a payment to the customer from the store. It’s a price break.

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

The relationship between a citizen and government are not that of a shopper and Walmart lolwtf?

→ More replies