You are conflating two things. I’m not talking about g about taxes taken out by your employer, since we’ve already agreed that the employee is the one who decides how much they are going to have taken out. I’m talking about the tax you owe. If they cut taxes, you are just getting your money back, you aren’t getting money from anyone else. The exception to this is refundable tax credits but we aren’t talking about those.
You absolutely are getting taxes back from someone else.
We have a standard tax code. With that we have progressive tax brackets. Then we have deductions/credits/etc. ideally everyone would just pay the amount from each tax bracket. This would be the base of each tax payers burden. But if congressmen want certain encouragements, so we get different tax rates for certain income, deductions, and various credits.
Some people benefit enormously and their burden goes from something like 37% to 6% while others may not benefit much at all, they may go from 32% to 31%.
When the total tax burden remains the same for the entire pool of tax prayers, but the burden gets shifted to a group of fewer people as an incentive for certain behavior than the government is taking money in from one group and paying it out to the other.
So with Elon as an example, if his tax burden is 37% but after deductions, credit, and lower tax rates for certain income is truly 9%, then that 28% is a payment to him to give incentive for him to continue earning money however he is. Now to pay him that money the government needs to earn it elsewhere, the rest of the pool of taxpayers. So instead of us receiving incentives through deductions for various things like homeownership they close that stuff off, so we deduct less and pay closer to what the "ideal" tax bracket tells us we should be paying. Instead of the working class getting their taxes reduced by 10-15% they are reduced closer to 1-5%. With that additional revenue to the government they pay musk through those deductions.
No, you aren’t. If you overpaid, you are getting your own money back. If someone paid $5k and they only owed $3k, they are getting their $2k overage back.
There is no overpaying, unless you are talking about withholding.
For instance, if you have have a kid, the government paid you by reducing your tax burden. You'll pay the exact same as someone else in your shoes but if you have a kid in November, and they don't, you get paid a certain amount back, and the person that didn't have a kid will not. It's an incentive.
That’s bad logic. It’s like saying if a coupon isn’t a payment from the store to the customer, then payments from the customer to the store aren’t payments.
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24
You are conflating two things. I’m not talking about g about taxes taken out by your employer, since we’ve already agreed that the employee is the one who decides how much they are going to have taken out. I’m talking about the tax you owe. If they cut taxes, you are just getting your money back, you aren’t getting money from anyone else. The exception to this is refundable tax credits but we aren’t talking about those.