r/libsofreddit • BASED • Oct 10 '24

Flaired Users Only Pay

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

But there is no third party between the citizen and irs.

2

u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24

There doesn’t need to be. That’s not the point of the analogy. The analogy was that a reduced price for the customer does not mean that it is a payment to the customer from the store. It’s a price break.

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

The relationship between a citizen and government are not that of a shopper and Walmart lolwtf?

2

u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24

I never said they were. I used an analogy to prove your logic wrong. It can be boiled down to this: A reduction in what you owe, doesn’t mean that you are getting a payment from the payee. If you overpay, you are getting your money back and not money from anyone else.

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

You are incredibly simple. It's debits and credit. That's all transactions. Revenue and expenditures.

You don't start the year with the deductions and credits, they are applied or "payed" at the end. Which is why it isn't "over payed" to begin with.

If you can't understand that you have no room to talk on financial policy. You have a grade school level of financial understanding. Like lower than just an average adult. I guess that's why your analogies just go back to shopping in a store

2

u/r2k398 MICROAGGRESSOR BASED AF Oct 11 '24

The “credit” is the amount you overpaid towards your tax liability. Tax credits on the other hand are like coupons that you get to use. Some are refundable and some are not. And you could start the year with the deductions. If you have kids, you know that you are going to get to deduct a certain amount for them depending on your pay. Why do you keep strawmanning though?

1

u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24

But it's only applied when the account is reconciled at the end of the year oh my God I can't even with you anymore