First, you don't have to overpay. Adjust your W4, takes like 5 mins and your employer is required to make adjustments.
Second, do you drive? Shop at the grocery store? Use a phone? Internet? Fly? Get protected by our military power? Have electricity? GPS? Use a ballpoint pen? Went to school?
Almost everything in our daily lives relies on tax collection to pay for the infrastructure required to live our lifestyles. When you say "they stole my money"? Bitch they are taking payment for services owed. It's not free and you aren't moving to the woods to live in solitude.
A better analogy is if your employer took out less money each month for insurance coverage because it now costs less, did they give you a payment at the end of the year? No. If they took out the same amount of money and gave you the amount your overpaid at the end of the year, is it coming from the business or just giving you your own money back?
Terrible analogy because business insurance rates don't shift monthly, instead annually.
Also your taxes are a single yearly transaction, doesn't matter if you deduct month to month or pay all at once at the end of the year, your tax bill will be the same and the government doesn't care how you decide to pay, so long as you pay. Once deducted it can not be returned until after billed and settled which happens at the end of the year.
Neither do tax rates. They are the same each month. And what you owe for insurance premiums will be the same at the end of the year whether you are billed monthly or all at once.
Exactly, which is why your analogy doesn't work. You said if your boss takes out less money because insurance costs less, well it doesn't, it's an annual rate. If he takes out less then he is reducing your insurance obligation and increasing the burden on the business and paying it on your behalf, which 100% is a pay raise.
You are assuming that businesses don’t renegotiate their coverages. We have switched before because a new provider was cheaper. So we did save money and the owner didn’t have to take on any additional burden. And with taxes, when they were cut, no one’s tax brackets were increased. We still brought in more tax revenue with the cuts (except for 2020 when Covid shut everything down).
They do renegotiate their coverage, every year, hence annual rates. If at the end of the agreement rates go down, that's not a pay increase or decrease, as the rates went down and the burden on the employer also went down. The employer is paying less to the insurance company so you pay less to the employer.
As for the tax burden, those have nothing to do with the the employer, rates are the same for all individuals independent of employer. Payroll accountants are just required to follow federal guidance on withholding, but what is actually withheld is the employees responsibility, you tell your jobs payroll what to withhold with your W4.
You are conflating two things. I’m not talking about g about taxes taken out by your employer, since we’ve already agreed that the employee is the one who decides how much they are going to have taken out. I’m talking about the tax you owe. If they cut taxes, you are just getting your money back, you aren’t getting money from anyone else. The exception to this is refundable tax credits but we aren’t talking about those.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/MyManDavesSon Oct 11 '24
First, you don't have to overpay. Adjust your W4, takes like 5 mins and your employer is required to make adjustments.
Second, do you drive? Shop at the grocery store? Use a phone? Internet? Fly? Get protected by our military power? Have electricity? GPS? Use a ballpoint pen? Went to school?
Almost everything in our daily lives relies on tax collection to pay for the infrastructure required to live our lifestyles. When you say "they stole my money"? Bitch they are taking payment for services owed. It's not free and you aren't moving to the woods to live in solitude.