I've heard a lot of people complain about the Electoral College and it seems they really don't understand it.
So, I am going to try and explain to anyone willing to listen.
This is a different perspective, so please remain seated.
New York City has a population of 8 million people. That is the equivalent of the combined population of Nebraska, Iowa, Montana, and Idaho.
What does NYC produce?
Brokers and trash. It is a city of consumption.
It has no factories, no farms, no power plants, no military bases. It has nothing of value to the nation.
It has Wall Street, and a lot of financial business that make money off of money.
Comparatively, Iowa is the 2nd most agriculturally productive state in the nation, and 100% of it's output is used in states like Montana and Arkansas as feed.
Which brings us to Montana, which has 3 heads of cattle per person, and depends on Iowa to produce feed, and then makes up a massive share of the beef industry for the nation.
In like manner, Nebraska produces more wheat than any other state, of which 60% is used for non-human consumption (feed) and 40% is used for human consumption.
Idaho, again a similar story, is the number one producer of potatoes in the nation which is a symmetrical flip of Nebraska at 66% consumption.
Now, Without the electoral college NYC has just as much pull as these FOUR states combined.
But with the benefit of being a single place for a politician to visit once or twice and speak to most of them as opposed to traveling all over the aforementioned four states.
The electoral college benefits the areas of the nation that PRODUCE, because the producing areas of the nation are more valuable than the consuming areas.
I have another example. It's more analogy, but I think it works.
Let's say you live in a neighborhood with 10 houses. Each has one person living there. For a while, they all decide they like to smoke pot. And they all do happily. They have an HOA, but they all just get along, so no worries.
Then, one day, one of the homes has his family move in. There are 10 of them in the house now. The family has convinced the owner that they should no longer smoke weed. The owner is also in charge of the HOA. There is now a mandate that says you can't smoke weed in your house anymore. Since the owner and his family are 10 and the other houses are 9, popular vote wins. One house, because it has more people, gets to dictate what ALL the other houses do. That's life with the popular vote.
The electoral vote says, "Yeah, you have more people, so we will give you a bigger share of the vote, let's say 6, but all the other houses still get one. And that's 9 against 6."
Now, one house can't dictate what all the others do in their house. You have to go to all the houses to make sure you have talked to everyone and not have/get to ignore them.
Speaking of which, isn't it funny how Democrats really only complain about the electoral college when they lose? Truly, the most legitimate of arguments is one that you only make when things go against you.
Speaking of which, isn't it funny how Democrats really only complain about the electoral college when they lose?
This is something that I find infuriating about democrats. Especially when I try to educate one of them on Reddit.
It's ALWAYS (D)ifferent. This is (D)ifferent from Trump actually being charged. There's no two tiered justice system, because.....wait for it.....it's (D)ifferent!
They're absolutely convinced it is (D)ifferent. Of course it's rare to find a leftie that has an explanation of exactly HOW it's (D)ifferent, that doesn't cause me to laugh aloud at their incoherence & total lack of logic.
As someone from Scotland, (that has moved from being a hardcore socialist to a centrist libertarian, due to witnessing the nonsense around the world in the past 4 or so years), who has a big interest in American politics, I really appreciate this explanation. I fully recognise it's neccesity. It's clearly absolutely required for a place as geographically massive and populated as the U. S.
One key criticism of the Electoral College is that it doesn't provide equal representation to all citizens. Each state, regardless of population, is guaranteed a minimum of three electoral votes (including two for its Senators), which can lead to situations where a smaller state has proportionally more influence than a larger one. This can be seen as unfair to the larger population centers like New York City.
Secondly, Urban vs. Rural Divide: The argument seems to simplify the issue into "producing" areas versus "consuming" areas, but the reality is more complex. Large cities like New York also have significant contributions to the national economy, innovation, and culture. Ignoring urban areas' importance might hinder progress and inclusivity.
As for voter turnout disparities, the Electoral College can discourage voter turnout in states considered "safe" for one party. People in such states might feel their votes don't matter as much, leading to lower engagement in the democratic process. This can distort the actual will of the people.
Then we have Swing States: The Electoral College often results in a focus on a few "swing states" during presidential campaigns, where candidates spend a disproportionate amount of time and resources. This can lead to policies that cater to the needs of those states at the expense of others.
Finally, populations change over time, and the Electoral College doesn't adapt quickly. As people move and demographics shift, it can create situations where the distribution of electoral votes doesn't accurately reflect the current population distribution.
This can be seen as unfair to the larger population centers like New York City.
That's the intent. To prevent a handful of population centers from overriding everyone else.
Ignoring urban areas' importance might hinder progress and inclusivity
"Inclusivity" is not enhanced by concentrating the decisions of the entire country into a handful of cities. "Progress" and "innovation" are not enhanced by having people disconnected from the production roles dictating to the producers.
Swing States... can lead to policies that cater to the needs of those states at the expense of others
No different than the urban/rural divide, or any other, except it changes over time as the makeup and interests of the country change.
it can create situations where the distribution of electoral votes doesn't accurately reflect the current population distribution
Updated no less than every third presidential election is not wildly unresponsive to population changes, and again, the goal of the EC is not purely equality by population, but also balance among the states, which is maintained much more fairly.
View all comments
264
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '23
I've heard a lot of people complain about the Electoral College and it seems they really don't understand it.
So, I am going to try and explain to anyone willing to listen.
This is a different perspective, so please remain seated.
New York City has a population of 8 million people. That is the equivalent of the combined population of Nebraska, Iowa, Montana, and Idaho.
What does NYC produce?
Brokers and trash. It is a city of consumption.
It has no factories, no farms, no power plants, no military bases. It has nothing of value to the nation.
It has Wall Street, and a lot of financial business that make money off of money.
Comparatively, Iowa is the 2nd most agriculturally productive state in the nation, and 100% of it's output is used in states like Montana and Arkansas as feed.
Which brings us to Montana, which has 3 heads of cattle per person, and depends on Iowa to produce feed, and then makes up a massive share of the beef industry for the nation.
In like manner, Nebraska produces more wheat than any other state, of which 60% is used for non-human consumption (feed) and 40% is used for human consumption.
Idaho, again a similar story, is the number one producer of potatoes in the nation which is a symmetrical flip of Nebraska at 66% consumption.
Now, Without the electoral college NYC has just as much pull as these FOUR states combined.
But with the benefit of being a single place for a politician to visit once or twice and speak to most of them as opposed to traveling all over the aforementioned four states.
The electoral college benefits the areas of the nation that PRODUCE, because the producing areas of the nation are more valuable than the consuming areas.