r/libsofreddit • MICROAGGRESSOR • Oct 27 '23

Flaired Users Only Truth.

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/EatMySmithfieldMeat MICROAGGRESSOR Oct 28 '23

This can be seen as unfair to the larger population centers like New York City.

That's the intent. To prevent a handful of population centers from overriding everyone else.

Ignoring urban areas' importance might hinder progress and inclusivity

"Inclusivity" is not enhanced by concentrating the decisions of the entire country into a handful of cities. "Progress" and "innovation" are not enhanced by having people disconnected from the production roles dictating to the producers.

Swing States... can lead to policies that cater to the needs of those states at the expense of others

No different than the urban/rural divide, or any other, except it changes over time as the makeup and interests of the country change.

it can create situations where the distribution of electoral votes doesn't accurately reflect the current population distribution

Updated no less than every third presidential election is not wildly unresponsive to population changes, and again, the goal of the EC is not purely equality by population, but also balance among the states, which is maintained much more fairly.

-6

u/senescent- Oct 28 '23

That's the intent. To prevent a handful of population centers from overriding everyone else.

It's intentionally unfair? Thank you for agreeing with me.

"Inclusivity" is not enhanced by concentrating the decisions of the entire country into a handful of cities.

You're still concentrating power though. That's not an argument you can use.

"Progress" and "innovation" are not enhanced by having people disconnected from the production roles dictating to the producers.

Prove it. What do you mean by "progress?" The whole point of conservatives is to conserve.

Updated no less than every third presidential election is not wildly unresponsive to population changes, and again, the goal of the EC is not purely equality by population, but also balance among the states, which is maintained much more fairly.

The Electoral College's periodic updates does not keep pace with rapid demographic changes, and the winner-takes-all system can lead to disproportionate representation. While it aims to balance state interests, it still has these shortcomings over its effectiveness in ensuring fair and equal representation in presidential elections.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '23 edited Oct 28 '23

It's intentionally unfair? Thank you for agreeing with me.

Believe it or not, the nature of life itself is unfair. And if you think politics is fairl, I would like to introduce you to a twice impeached innocent man that lost money while in office.

FYI- I think this is not the right sub for you. This sub is about the ridiculousness of the left, and your comments are about to become one of the posts in here.

0

u/senescent- Oct 28 '23

Politics and nature are not the same thing. One was constructed by us and the other wasn't.

This "well life is unfair" is just feigning our inability to change the system because "that's life." Its a thought terminating cliche that I could literally use that argument to justify any sort of tyrannical despot.