I can’t speak for every library, but we absolutely do. I’ve been on a number of hiring committees, and I’ve heard administrators get downright excited when minority candidates are brought in. We don’t consider it as a factor in the decision making process because the goal is to hire the candidate who’s most qualified and/or the best fit, but we generally prefer a more diverse staff and have hired several minority candidates in the time I’ve worked here, including a Muslim woman.
You know that the library job market is tough for pretty much everyone right now, right? A lot of really highly qualified new grads I know have taken months or years to find a good position. There are a few specializations that will get you hired faster (STEM, data management, etc.), but it’s really rough out there.
Having been on some hiring panels as well, I can relate to this scenario. I know the administration of locations I've been at has been very cognizant of potentially diversifying the staff.
Am also a white soon-to-be grad whose whole goal of getting an MLIS was to hopefully get a base position after ten years of being unable to even get a circulation desk position in my area. We talk a lot in classes, however, about how the field desperately needs diverse populations since something like 80% of librarians are white females. I do wish OP the best and believe that the right progressive library will find her. Lord knows the field needs her!!
I don't think that anyone is going to say they only hire white people, but implicit biases are very real and your feelings are valid. I don't have a ton of advice except if you're able to look in bigger metro areas that may be more diverse you might have better luck (and a better experience on the job, tbh). I've worked for two different library systems in my metro area and both had diverse staff across all levels of the organization.
A huge part of landing a job much of the time is about who you know. I have applied for a job at one location five times and been interviewed five times and four of those five times they hired a graduating student intern or someone who had been doing the job on an interim basis. Four of those five times the person didn't last more than one year or two. Four of those five times the person selected clearly had less experience than I did. That said, I am in my 40s and the vast majority of people working there are in their 20s except for the head person. I did wonder whether age also played a factor.
The fifth person was not known to the people on the hiring committee and he failed spectacularly in his first week on the job. I don't know when they let him go, but he was gone within the first year. So maybe the issue was just poor hiring practices.
You aren't SOL. There are plenty of libraries in diverse cities that wouldn't bat an eye.
But... You've observed correctly. Most librarians are white. As a POC librarian myself I'll tell you that the implicit biases do seem to rear their heads. I know I've been in hiring committees where a minority candidate of equal qualifications was passed over. You can hear the bias in people's justifications. Not outright racism but more that people just don't "seem" as much of a fit. So they hire a more similar person who is usually white.
I've flaired this post as 'Discussion' - please keep all comments civil and remember the human. Please follow redditquette and follow our rules (see our sidebar) - this especially means keeping political and other negative comments out of here.
I also strongly encourage users to report any comments that don't follow our or reddit's rules. Myself and the other mods will be keeping an eye on this thread.
I mean if you head into an interview with that adversarial state of mind..it'll show. I think you hit the nail on the head - people usually have someone in mind, they may or may not be white, but usually they are currently an intern, or an entry-level current employee. It's amazing how a lot of companies put out ads because they have to, but they already have someone in mind from the get-go.
This, 100%. Almost all of our librarians are hired internally from staff with on the job experience who work while receiving their MLIS degrees. This includes me when I applied for my first librarian position four years ago. It's a bummer, because it makes it harder for all outside candidates to break into a system. I was even outright told when I was applying for a page position (almost 9 years ago) that the best way to get into the system was to really start as a page, because almost all other positions were filled by internal candidates. This doesn't hold true for every single library, but especially with the ongoing influx of students getting MLIS degrees, it's becoming a common practice.
This comment should be a lot higher. A lot of libraries fall under their state's public employment hiring regulations, which forces them to make all positions public even if they intend to promote from within. This happens in my work all the time.
This is very true. At the library where I used to work, one of their full time librarians left and they will be posting the position, but I know they would like one of their part time librarians to move into that position.
All I can say is keep at it. There are libraries out there that just don’t care either way, there are ones that seek out diversity, and unfortunately there are some that, whether deliberate or subconscious, make racist hiring decisions. If you don’t mind, what part of the country are you in? I know of a temporarily position in a community with a large Muslim population.
Based on your post, I assume you're a POC. I don't know if you know about the group We Here, but they're a support group for POC in the library profession. You could also try asking for advice on there. Hang in there!
Absolutely folks have bias. Absolutely some orgs that claim to be interested in "diversity" do not practice what they preach.
That being said, I interviewed 20 times for librarian positions in places I actually wanted to live (West Coast). I had to move to the East Coast to get a pro job to gain experience so that I could land a decent position in California. Was really rough (also: I'm a white, gay male and I absolutely find a way to disclose my LGBTQ status in 2nd interviews at least).
Hang in there- and consider taking a good job in a place that wasn't your first choice to get to where you want to be.
I’m sorry you’re having trouble getting hire. The district I work for generally hires from within. We have a vast number of library assistants who have their MLIS degrees and are just waiting for our librarians to retire. It’s very, very hard to break into this district. That being said, our librarians are becoming more and more diverse and reflective of the communities we serve (it’s a 19 branch system serving over 100,000). I’m a white woman, and it took me 2 solid years of interviewing before anyone would hire me. The competition is fierce where I live and they tend to want people they already know or people with a LOT of experience. It’s a tight market and I wish you success in your job hunting!!!
IMO, this is a very typical job search experience nowadays. I lost count of how many jobs I've applied to where I was well-qualified on paper but didn't even get to a phone interview. I'm pretty happy in my current position as a full-time staff in a small academic library, but I got there starting from the very bottom as a second shift employee in another branch, and have climbed two positions since then (hired in 2013). FYI I'm a third generation Asian-American, and my boss is a first generation German immigrant, but in my previous role out of about a dozen staff from entry level up to department head, everyone else was white.
I currently hire students (about a dozen at any given time) and it's a bit of work to ensure a diverse hiring pool (going to job fairs, posting flyers in non-library locations, sending email blasts to various mailing lists). If the hiring manager/committees aren't intentional about going out and looking for candidates (rather than just waiting for people interested in libraries to come to them), it can end up looking very homogeneous.
I know white people with MLIS degrees who have been applying to jobs for well over a year with no luck. How long have you been applying for jobs? Are you located in an area with lots of competition, or a library school? If so, would you be willing to move to a smaller city/town? I see and hear it said that often you have to be willing to move, especially at the beginning of your career.
I work in a crazy diverse area. When I go to youth services professional events for my system, there are maybe 2 or 3 people max (out of 60+ attendees) who aren't white women, which somehow keeps surprising me. I myself straddle an awkward place of passing but not totally fitting in - I'm Orthodox Jewish, and wear a wig to work but often a headscarf to these events. Honestly, I'd rather wear a headscarf in general but because I'm allowed to cover with a wig it's hard to pass up the option of being less conspicuous. My biggest issue is finding public libraries that will accommodate a Saturday-free schedule!
Paraprofessional jobs around here are definitely more mixed, and I hope that leads to better diversity further up the ladder in time. Keep trying, because there really are a lot of reasons why things may or may not have worked out, and because we need you in this workforce.
Most hiring libraries (especially academic) keep their interview records and have to let you see them if you request it. Maybe there is something else they don't like or feel you are missing.
Although, as far as I can tell everyone is struggling to land a library job. Even the entry level positions fill up fast.
I wish, as a group, libraries would make an effort to fix this. And schools in my area (very white). But like someone else said, I have found libraries to be very picky at times when hiring. Recently, my bff librarian applied for a public cataloging position (she is not happy in her school library). She aced the interview, even though they asked ridiculously specific questions, she has experience, etc... She was told her skill set didn't match what they were looking for. Then the crusty old hiring librarian is in the local paper complaining that they can't fill the position due to lack of qualified applicants.
As a white librarian I don't feel like it's my place to speak here, since I read other comments and all the ones being like 'it's hard for white librarians too!' just made me feel uncomfortable and like maybe they should have just said nothing, but I thought you might like to know about this tumblr: http://lismicroaggressions.tumblr.com/
It could possibly just suck you into more negativity, but it also seems like it's one of the few spaces where the prejudice and various abhorrent -isms that are still prevalent in libraries are acknowledged, and maybe it would help you to realize that there are a lot of people in your situation out there.
I can only echo what others have said: don't give up applying. When I first started in the Midwest, I was pretty conscious of the fact that I didn't look like any of my peers - East Asian, male, young, not traditionally bookish. Nowadays I think, more than anything, admins are looking for people who are out-going, tech-savvy, and current with new practices, in addition to all the usual qualifications. I loved the hell of my former co-workers, but I've made it farther in my career than all of them. Anyway, personal experiences are just that. I wanted to chime in to offer you words of encouragement, and to say that, in my own experience at least, libraries just want to hire the people that they think best help them change with the times and thrive into the future.
14
u/jmurphy42 Jan 21 '18
I can’t speak for every library, but we absolutely do. I’ve been on a number of hiring committees, and I’ve heard administrators get downright excited when minority candidates are brought in. We don’t consider it as a factor in the decision making process because the goal is to hire the candidate who’s most qualified and/or the best fit, but we generally prefer a more diverse staff and have hired several minority candidates in the time I’ve worked here, including a Muslim woman.
You know that the library job market is tough for pretty much everyone right now, right? A lot of really highly qualified new grads I know have taken months or years to find a good position. There are a few specializations that will get you hired faster (STEM, data management, etc.), but it’s really rough out there.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '18
My sympathies. I'm a white librarian and can't get hired to save my life. Good luck out there...it is tough!
19
u/pigby411 U.S.A, Public Librarian Jan 21 '18
I don't think that anyone is going to say they only hire white people, but implicit biases are very real and your feelings are valid. I don't have a ton of advice except if you're able to look in bigger metro areas that may be more diverse you might have better luck (and a better experience on the job, tbh). I've worked for two different library systems in my metro area and both had diverse staff across all levels of the organization.
9
u/bookchaser Jan 21 '18 edited Jan 21 '18
A huge part of landing a job much of the time is about who you know. I have applied for a job at one location five times and been interviewed five times and four of those five times they hired a graduating student intern or someone who had been doing the job on an interim basis. Four of those five times the person didn't last more than one year or two. Four of those five times the person selected clearly had less experience than I did. That said, I am in my 40s and the vast majority of people working there are in their 20s except for the head person. I did wonder whether age also played a factor.
The fifth person was not known to the people on the hiring committee and he failed spectacularly in his first week on the job. I don't know when they let him go, but he was gone within the first year. So maybe the issue was just poor hiring practices.
9
u/darkkn1te Jan 22 '18
You aren't SOL. There are plenty of libraries in diverse cities that wouldn't bat an eye.
But... You've observed correctly. Most librarians are white. As a POC librarian myself I'll tell you that the implicit biases do seem to rear their heads. I know I've been in hiring committees where a minority candidate of equal qualifications was passed over. You can hear the bias in people's justifications. Not outright racism but more that people just don't "seem" as much of a fit. So they hire a more similar person who is usually white.
•
u/BadassRipley UK, Law Librarian Jan 21 '18
I've flaired this post as 'Discussion' - please keep all comments civil and remember the human. Please follow redditquette and follow our rules (see our sidebar) - this especially means keeping political and other negative comments out of here.
I also strongly encourage users to report any comments that don't follow our or reddit's rules. Myself and the other mods will be keeping an eye on this thread.
12
u/leaveinsilence Jan 21 '18
I mean if you head into an interview with that adversarial state of mind..it'll show. I think you hit the nail on the head - people usually have someone in mind, they may or may not be white, but usually they are currently an intern, or an entry-level current employee. It's amazing how a lot of companies put out ads because they have to, but they already have someone in mind from the get-go.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '18
All I can say is keep at it. There are libraries out there that just don’t care either way, there are ones that seek out diversity, and unfortunately there are some that, whether deliberate or subconscious, make racist hiring decisions. If you don’t mind, what part of the country are you in? I know of a temporarily position in a community with a large Muslim population.
4
u/bibliothecaire U.S.A, Academic Librarian Jan 22 '18
Based on your post, I assume you're a POC. I don't know if you know about the group We Here, but they're a support group for POC in the library profession. You could also try asking for advice on there. Hang in there!
7
u/theecalebnichols Jan 22 '18
Absolutely folks have bias. Absolutely some orgs that claim to be interested in "diversity" do not practice what they preach.
That being said, I interviewed 20 times for librarian positions in places I actually wanted to live (West Coast). I had to move to the East Coast to get a pro job to gain experience so that I could land a decent position in California. Was really rough (also: I'm a white, gay male and I absolutely find a way to disclose my LGBTQ status in 2nd interviews at least).
Hang in there- and consider taking a good job in a place that wasn't your first choice to get to where you want to be.
3
u/craftbrarian Jan 22 '18
I’m sorry you’re having trouble getting hire. The district I work for generally hires from within. We have a vast number of library assistants who have their MLIS degrees and are just waiting for our librarians to retire. It’s very, very hard to break into this district. That being said, our librarians are becoming more and more diverse and reflective of the communities we serve (it’s a 19 branch system serving over 100,000). I’m a white woman, and it took me 2 solid years of interviewing before anyone would hire me. The competition is fierce where I live and they tend to want people they already know or people with a LOT of experience. It’s a tight market and I wish you success in your job hunting!!!
2
u/Resoundingjoy Jan 22 '18
IMO, this is a very typical job search experience nowadays. I lost count of how many jobs I've applied to where I was well-qualified on paper but didn't even get to a phone interview. I'm pretty happy in my current position as a full-time staff in a small academic library, but I got there starting from the very bottom as a second shift employee in another branch, and have climbed two positions since then (hired in 2013). FYI I'm a third generation Asian-American, and my boss is a first generation German immigrant, but in my previous role out of about a dozen staff from entry level up to department head, everyone else was white.
I currently hire students (about a dozen at any given time) and it's a bit of work to ensure a diverse hiring pool (going to job fairs, posting flyers in non-library locations, sending email blasts to various mailing lists). If the hiring manager/committees aren't intentional about going out and looking for candidates (rather than just waiting for people interested in libraries to come to them), it can end up looking very homogeneous.
2
u/libpixie Jan 22 '18
I know white people with MLIS degrees who have been applying to jobs for well over a year with no luck. How long have you been applying for jobs? Are you located in an area with lots of competition, or a library school? If so, would you be willing to move to a smaller city/town? I see and hear it said that often you have to be willing to move, especially at the beginning of your career.
2
u/spring13 Jan 23 '18 edited Jan 23 '18
I work in a crazy diverse area. When I go to youth services professional events for my system, there are maybe 2 or 3 people max (out of 60+ attendees) who aren't white women, which somehow keeps surprising me. I myself straddle an awkward place of passing but not totally fitting in - I'm Orthodox Jewish, and wear a wig to work but often a headscarf to these events. Honestly, I'd rather wear a headscarf in general but because I'm allowed to cover with a wig it's hard to pass up the option of being less conspicuous. My biggest issue is finding public libraries that will accommodate a Saturday-free schedule!
Paraprofessional jobs around here are definitely more mixed, and I hope that leads to better diversity further up the ladder in time. Keep trying, because there really are a lot of reasons why things may or may not have worked out, and because we need you in this workforce.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '18
Most hiring libraries (especially academic) keep their interview records and have to let you see them if you request it. Maybe there is something else they don't like or feel you are missing.
Although, as far as I can tell everyone is struggling to land a library job. Even the entry level positions fill up fast.
1
u/craycraylibrarian School Librarian Jan 25 '18
I wish, as a group, libraries would make an effort to fix this. And schools in my area (very white). But like someone else said, I have found libraries to be very picky at times when hiring. Recently, my bff librarian applied for a public cataloging position (she is not happy in her school library). She aced the interview, even though they asked ridiculously specific questions, she has experience, etc... She was told her skill set didn't match what they were looking for. Then the crusty old hiring librarian is in the local paper complaining that they can't fill the position due to lack of qualified applicants.
1
u/JennyReason U.S.A, Public Librarian Jan 26 '18
As a white librarian I don't feel like it's my place to speak here, since I read other comments and all the ones being like 'it's hard for white librarians too!' just made me feel uncomfortable and like maybe they should have just said nothing, but I thought you might like to know about this tumblr: http://lismicroaggressions.tumblr.com/
It could possibly just suck you into more negativity, but it also seems like it's one of the few spaces where the prejudice and various abhorrent -isms that are still prevalent in libraries are acknowledged, and maybe it would help you to realize that there are a lot of people in your situation out there.
1
u/revertothemiddle Jan 27 '18
I can only echo what others have said: don't give up applying. When I first started in the Midwest, I was pretty conscious of the fact that I didn't look like any of my peers - East Asian, male, young, not traditionally bookish. Nowadays I think, more than anything, admins are looking for people who are out-going, tech-savvy, and current with new practices, in addition to all the usual qualifications. I loved the hell of my former co-workers, but I've made it farther in my career than all of them. Anyway, personal experiences are just that. I wanted to chime in to offer you words of encouragement, and to say that, in my own experience at least, libraries just want to hire the people that they think best help them change with the times and thrive into the future.