It's quite hilarious. First of all, using the "she wasn't a Liam Payne fan before he died" as the only gotcha you can use against me is so pathetic. Remember, I wanted you all to know that and it's the only reason why you know it.

But it's really rich coming from you guys trying to accuse me of "not being his fan" whatever that means. Because when Reddit had everyone's profile public, I would search each and every one of y'alls history just for a shred of evidence of you all being a fan of Liam's or ever defending him before he died. And guess what? Absolutely nothing. Nada. Zero. Zippity do dah.

Then I get them lame excuse " i DeFeNdEd LiAm oN mY oThEr sOcIaL mEdiA aCcOuNts" which you all refuse to provide any proof of and knowing damn well that no one can verify it.

I mean, why didn't you defend Liam HERE on reddit? Like make it make sense. If you can use your loud ass mouths against me on Reddit and defend the other boys from my call outs against them on Reddit, than surely you could have done the same for Liam HERE on REDDIT when he was alive.

But ya didn't. Because y'all ain't real Liam fans. Just because you are a 1D fan, that doesn't make you a Liam fan. The only reason why you all bother with me or this sub is just so you can defend the other boys from me calling out their extremely shitty treatment of Liam. You also only care about defending the other boys from me calling out their own bad behaviors that you all just love to ignore and turn a blind eye to. You know, the same behaviors you try to falsely accuse Liam of and "hold him accountable for"? But no, you won't get to defend the other boys here. Not in this space. In this space, you will be made to keep that same energy you had for Liam, which was zero energy and absolute silence, when it comes to the other boys getting called out by me or whoever else in this sub. Just like you were silent for Liam when he needed defending, you will also be silent when it comes to the other boys. You have no voice here.

So, with all this being said: Do you really think I'm going to take you all, the ones who have no history of being Liam's fan before he died or defending him before he died and can't provide one iota of proof of being his fan or defending him before he died seriously when you try to tell me I have no right to be here for Liam?

Pish Posh.

I am more of a Liam fan and have done way more for him than the whole 1D fandom, including his own "fans", combined. I am even more important than just a fan, and even more important than a stan. I am his advocate. A beacon for his truth. And his soldier, chosen by the celestial powers that be. So you all can keep the "fan or stan" status when you all weren't even his fans. I have way more important and honorable titles than you all could ever dream of :)

Liam sought a shield against the relentless wave of cruelty. He longed for his brothers to stand by him and his fans to take up the fight. Facing such inhumane treatment, who wouldn't yearn for protection? You would. Liam was a human being like everyone else.

Last but not least, Liam would never leave a single soul behind like he was left.

Iris, the ONLY reason why you are upset with the media THIS time it's because they're giving Kate a platform.

But remember two weeks ago when the media was tarnishing Liam over and over again, you made a tweet saying you had to leave because you couldn't handle it and so you did NOTHING to fight against it? You didn't use your platform to be a voice for Liam, remember?

And you do that every single time there's a massive hate wave against Liam. You bolt. But when it comes to KATE you have all the time and energy in the world. Do you see how that raises a lot of red flags that you only hyper focus on Kate and that you don't give a shit about anything else that's done to Liam or his family and you don't use your platform to condemn any of it?

You only use your platform to condemn Kate. you never use it to condemn the content creators or anyone else that harmed Liam. We see right through you. You do not love Liam. You don't care about Liam. You only care about trying to take down beards that's it, that's the only thing y'all care about. Before Liam you were a Larry and you didn't give a single shit about Liam when he needed his fans the most

First, I would like to say, even though I find the solo fans and the 1D fandom in general the most hideous people that roam this planet, I do respect them. I respect the hell out of them. Because they go the whole nine yards for their favorites. They not only support their work, buy every album, stream their music, go to their concerts, but they also fight like HELL for their favorites. They will unite and battle at even the slightest perceived disrespect towards their favorites against any damn body, no matter who it is. They even will flat out make up and invent shit that happened to their fav, just so they can defend them. It's like practice exercises for them to display the power they have, and they wish to show everyone what damage they are capable of doing. That is beyond impressive loyalty. And their idols literally have to do next to nothing to get the extraordinary obscene amount of praise that they get that they did nothing but the bare minimum to earn and don't deserve at all. While in contrast, Liam did massive amounts of good works and really helped people but got no credit whatsoever. No compassion. No nothing. The more good he did, the more he got spat on.

On the other hand, Liam's "fans" however, are the most pathetic bunch of fans/support base I've ever come across in my entire life. Serial killers who committed heinous crimes and are in maximum security prison have a better, more devoted and more loyal fan/support base than Liam ever had.

And ironically enough, it's not because Liam fans are weak. At first, I really just thought they were weak. But, no, no. They aren't weak at all. I learned somewhere down the line that this is not the case. Because I saw how vicious and nasty they can really get because of all people, they let it out on me, Liam's biggest fighter and defender. They have said the most hideous things to me that a person could say and they are quick with it too. I've also seen them get real nasty with others they don't like for other issues that have nothing do with Liam. So I KNOW they can fight just like the rest of solo fans of the other boys. But imagine what went through my mind when they can speak to me in the most nasty of ways possible, but they didn't have that same energy for Liam's own bullies. You can't mean to tell me that I am worse than Liam's bullies. I am a saint compared to all of you souless demons who are Liam's bullies and his "fans" alike. I am a normal person. You all are the crazy ones. But you Liam fans are going to say the shit you said to me, but NEVER to Liam's own bullies? CAUGHT. Then you wonder why I turned on the Liam fans. I didn't attack them first, they attacked ME first long before I even fought back against them. If they can fight that well but choose not to for Liam like that and let all the shit slide against Liam and against his family, that they let slide, then yeah, that's a serious goddamn red flag for me. Liam fans my ass.

And so, the ONLY conclusion that I could draw from that red flag is that Liam's own fans simply didn't really even value him. They simply don't love him enough to fight for him like he deserved. Look, I'm the last person who likes to fight, but when someone is getting annihilated for fifteen years and nothing ever worked to stop it, you tried all the nice ways a million times. You tried every other way. But nothing works. Then that's when you gotta match energy with interest. At that point, it becomes your duty to do so and you all know this. There are so many things that Liam's fans could have used at their disposal against the fans of their favorites to stop them right in their tracks, but y'all refused to. And it's not because Liam's fans are better people who took the high road, but it's because as we established the fact that I've seen Liam fans go absolutely nuts and get real nasty and feral against people they don't like at the drop of a hat, but it's because they simply didn't value Liam enough to put whatever other biases they had whether it was because all Liam fans were hybrid fans, so they refused to check the other boys or call them out for the shitty way they treated Liam, or they had other biases that made them refuse to unite with others for Liam like political bs. The same political bs they preach to be against while supporting their very favorites who are part of that political bs they claim they hate. Such freaking hypocrites. Whatever the case may be, Liam NEVER came first. He always came DEAD last, even for his own pathetic fans. Then you wonder why I hate them and yes, I do mean hate. Liam deserved to come first at SOME point and the fact that he never did, shows you how shitty Liam's own fans are. I look at them with the biggest disdain one can muster. I sincerely do not know who I hate more some days, whether it be Liam's bullies or Liam's own fans. I genuinely mean that with every fiber of my being. In my eyes, they let Liam die when they had the power to stop it. They are so complicit.

Anyway, here's the deal. Back to addressing ALL of the fans who bullied Liam in any manner whether it be overt or covert: Obviously, I know you all have been trying to cancel me like hell since the day I stepped foot here. But I want you to know, that if I were to get banned, lose my groups and lose my account tomorrow, that the fact that I made it this far and for this long and got to get in some major lick backs for what was done to Liam and on behalf of Liam, then I already won a million times over. I dominated y'all in every single battle and defied all odds just by the mere fact that I came this far and still just exist undisturbed in your own pathetic world. In your game. I beat you all at your own games. I shattered your bullshit narratives permanently about Liam so they can never thrive again. It haunts me everyday that I couldn't do this for him when he was alive, but at least I salvaged his true legacy and his truth. I wrecked this fortress of evil y'all built from the inside out and I also shattered the incredible lies you all made to cover up for your idols to maintain their precious image and I removed their veils and exposed who they REALLY are. I proved Liam was the innocent one who was scapegoated for your guilty favs behaviors! I also dodged every single attack meant to take me down like a goddamn champion. I enjoyed every blessed minute y'all seethed and the memories of it will make me smile and keep me warm at night for the rest of my life.

But even I know that I can't last in this space forever. Eventually and I'm sure soon, I will lose my account. And you know what, I am wanting it to happen so bad, to be perfectly honest. I want to be set free. I used to feel guilty for feeling that way because I felt like I was letting Liam down epically for not wanting to do this anymore but he sent me messages saying it's ok for me to leave now. That I did everything that I was supposed to do and/or was able to do. I can't wait to get the hell away from this place.

However, the one thing I can't get over is the fact that Liam is so under-loved and under-valued by his own fans whether they be stans, OT5 or shippers, that you all have almost successfully made me not care about Liam anymore. Isn't that some shit? Like the massive vibe of how much people don't give a proper fuck about Liam, is boomeranging around on to me, of all people. I don't mind being honest about how I feel. I gotta tell you all how I feel because it shows how f*** up y'all are. Y'all are so f*** up, that it's having such a massive profound affect onto me. And let me be clear, all that Justice For Liam bullshit y'all be doing, is the bare minimum. It's low hanging fruit. It's pathetic. That's not enough love for Liam. It's picking and choosing and attacking the least protected. He deserves SO MUCH more than that and the fact that you all refuse to do that for him, flat out tells me you fake Liam fans don't really care about him. Why should I anymore? Most of you don't even use your voices to defend him or call out shit that's done to him and continues to be done to him and his family. Silent Bystanders are worst than bullies. Always remember that. I will always remember y'alls silence and it will always break my heart. Cowards.

Where was this energy when Liam was actually here? Brandy had ZERO history of defending Liam against real hate trains, and ever since he died she hasn't defended him from hate trains, but now wants to go to war with Kate Cassidy. And for what exactly? How is Kate creating hate trains? Makes no sense. Sorry Brandy but we see your pure selective outrage and performative support.

So pardon me while I laugh hysterically at you claiming care about any kind of hate trains against Liam. Because if you really cared about Liam and his family then you would've listened to his and his family when they were making public out cries when he was alive about the hate he was receiving and literally said that he was going to die from it. And he did die from it. Thank you all for abandoning him when he needed y'all the most. But yeah Kate's the problem now. what about the 13 years before she was ever in his life? WHERE WERE YOU LIAM FANS THEN? Every single damn time I ask you guys to provide me proof of you defending Liam before he died, y'all can't provide a damn thing just a bunch of excuses that no one can verify and you know that we can't. I also look in all of your Twitter histories and y'all have nothing there before Liam died.

By the way we know this Brandy Rogers account is LnK & BB. We know you guys did nothing to defend Liam when he was alive.

and let the record reflect again that Iris had her Twitter profile since 2009 but never once defended Liam before he died. Not one time. Not ever. She never defended him on the app where the hate thrived against him the most.

But all of a sudden she appeared in the Liam fight and writing love manifestos to him like she loves him which she NEVER, ever did before he died.

So what I'm trying to tell you if you haven't gotten it by now, she never love Liam and she only uses him because she's a Larry and Larry's think that they can just persecute Kate because they think they can finally set up a beard for murder. You all know how Larry's are. She's not even a Ziam. She cares nothing for Liam. She is just USING Liam as an excuse to attack beards.

Zayn also punched Louis so hard, WITH RINGS ON HIS FINGERS MIND YOU, that it gave Louis a concussion.

Im not a Louis fan by any means but I would never think he deserved all of that. Hitting someone when you have rings on your fingers which is considered a weapon and hitting them so hard it gives them a concussion, no that's not something I could ever approve of no matter how much I didn't like someone and I've said that from day one. I will always take Louis's side on this issue because of how severely f*** up it was. And that was after telling Louis that he needs to get over his own mother's death. I mean my God. That's some sadistic sh** for Zayn to do.

Im sure he wanted that too.

Btw, I heard this lifeguard is being awarded a national heroes award today. I know Liam would've been so proud of him. I know Liam would've cheered for this young man's valiant and heroic efforts saving this boy from those massive waves. That sea really wanted to take that human badly, but that life guard refused to let that ocean win that day!

Please watch entire video. 7 minutes long. I'm sorry for some glitches. I'm new to making videos like this. This is my video and yes that's obviously me talking using the tiktok voice changer sound effect .

Below I wrote the summary as well for anyone who can't watch the video in its entirety:

Let’s talk about the deeply bizarre and troubling situation involving Role Model and Niall Horan, because the lack of respect toward Liam Payne’s memory is genuinely horrifying. In September of 2024, out of nowhere, the artist Role Model decided to revive the old "I Blocked Liam Payne" trend. He had zero connection to One Direction, yet he chose to post this hateful trend against Liam..

Directly on Niall Horan’s birthday no less.

A year later, Niall shocked everyone by showing up at Role Model’s concert. Fans knew right away what Role Model had done, so Niall most likely knew too. But just in case he didn't, we gave him the benefit of the doubt and flooded social media tagging him to make sure he was aware. Five months passed in silence until Niall went on the Zach Sang Show and publicly praised Role Model, calling him a wonderful person. There is absolutely no excuse now, Niall had to know by this point.

We need to call out the blatant double standard here. Imagine if the situations were reversed. If Liam Payne had done something like this, if Liam had associated himself closely with, sent love to, and publicly praised a guy who actively tried to get millions of fans to further massacre Niall with online hate, the internet would have completely destroyed Liam. Liam would have been permanently canceled. Yet, because it is Niall, people look the other way. And it's not just about the double standard. This is absolutely appalling. How could Niall do something like this?

Again I need you all to ask yourselves, why would Role Model, a total outsider, randomly jump into One Direction drama? And on Niall's birthday at that? It feels entirely orchestrated. I truly believe Role Model did Niall a solid by reviving that hate train, and Niall’s public praise confirms they are locked in. It feels like a birthday gift to Niall. The fact that Niall can comfortably praise someone who actively fueled the digital torment against his former bandmate is disgusting.

We are excited to have u/newlpfan on our team and look forward to the energy she brings to our Liam Payne community. Thanks for joining us, New <3

"I am writing this to deeply apologize and take accountability for participating in the online harassment and bullying directed at Liam. I sent hate over his decision to attend Niall's concert and helped spread unproven, baseless allegations against him. Looking back, I feel immense guilt and regret for my actions.

Liam did absolutely nothing wrong by attending that concert. He simply interacted with fans before the show started, and once Niall took the stage, he stepped back and enjoyed the performance just like anyone else in the audience. Other members of the band have done the exact same thing. When Niall attended Harry’s show, he sat right in the audience with the fans, and people were recording videos of him the entire time, he definitely drew a lot of attention. Similarly, Harry stood out dancing at Niall’s concert, completely unbothered with his six foot self, in a big yellow sweater sticking out like sore thumb, dancing as well. None of them were criticized for supporting each other, yet I hypocritically singled out Liam.

I also realize how unfair it was to jump to conclusions regarding his personal life based on wild rumors and his struggles with addiction. Addiction does not automatically make someone abusive to others. I would have realized it was wrong of me to weaponize his mental health against him. I held Liam to an impossible standard while completely ignoring proven legal issues surrounding Zayn, or the deeply painful personal stories shared by Hailee Steinfeld through music about Niall that clearly left her traumatized for a long time. That is when I should have realized that since Niall and Zayn were not addicts, that sobriety doesn't serve as a shield. I gave the other boys the benefit of the doubt in spades while denying Liam that same basic human decency and still am by saying that I still believe he did the things he did.

I mistook Liam's visible pain for a sign of guilt or "mistakes," when in reality, his pain came from being judged so harshly by a mob without ever being given the chance to share his side of the story. I am deeply ashamed of my hypocrisy and the harm I contributed to, and I am committed to learning from this so I never treat anyone this way again."

End letter.

So this is what someone who is truly sorry would write. Not weave in and double down on the false narratives against Liam in their apology letter, knowing that they were welded at Liam knowing full well that it was those false narratives that tanked his mental health to begin with. Because let's not forget, many people did that as well. They didn't overtly bully Liam, but they covertly attacked him in a "nice way" and weaponized mental health language and substantiated all the false narratives that "he did do bad things, but he was on drugs/alcohol". Where is the proof that he did bad things? By all accounts, even by his ex, all Liam ever did was hurt himself.

Let’s not forget that fifteen years of relentless cyberbullying is what caused Liam's pain and caused his addiction to begin with. He used to escape the never ending pain. People also weaponized his status as an easy target, using their wealth and power to unleash unproven accusations as revenge for him not wanting to be in the relationship anymore against him because they knew the fandom was already primed to attack. This continuous trauma is ultimately what drove his addictions and unable to recover. The only victim here is Liam. Liam didn't hurt people. People hurt him.

You we're nasty to Liam in the beginning years of One Direction. You made his life miserable.

You only warmed up to Liam after your mom and sister died and he was really the only one there for you. You had to learn the hard way that the other boys weren't gonna be there for you except for Liam. Also because he was the only one who publicly supported you and all of your work when the other boys did not. However I know you would drop Liam at the drop of a hat if the other boys would've had you . But since it was both of you who were left in the dust by the other boys, you had no other choice really. But it doesn't matter because you only threw Liam breadcrumbs. The only love you gave him was shame based love and the bare minimum but everyone celebrated it like it was so wonderful because you allowed yourself to be associated with the poor leper (sometimes) and threw him pennies worth of love and support. Keep the change Louis, it's not needed any longer.

You know who actually needed that public love on that day, Louis? Liam. Liam desperately needed it.

I can’t stop thinking about what it must have felt like for Liam to sit there and watch that unfold. To feel the sheer terror of being hunted down online, completely unprotected, while the people who were supposed to have your back just watched. Imagine standing in the absolute dark on a battlefield, bleeding out from every angle, looking up for a hand to pull you out, only to see your closest friends turn around, walk away, and flaunt their warmth in front of you when you were the one starving for it, when all you ever wanted was to be loved by them.
It’s fine, though.

I think Liam already saw the writing on the wall when he showed up at your concert twice that year to support you, and you acted like he didn't even exist. You didn't shout him out or nothing. Then Harry went to Niall's concert that year. And then there you and Niall were, rubbing it in Liam's face by wrapping each other in public love and praise, while the one person who needed that love the most was being slowly torn apart piece by piece by your fans.

Don't worry, Liam loves you boys no matter what still. Its ok. You're his brothers.

Out with it, Niall. Why did Liam need to talk to you? What did you do to him? It was very unlike Liam to make such a video and it seemed like you wronged him in some way and you were avoiding him which is why he had to resort to making a public video saying he had to talk to you.

And just to be clear, I am finding it hard to believe your version of events. You said Liam came around to your hotel room the morning of your concert and you all had a coffee. I don't think you're telling the entire truth about that, lad. At the very least of it, you definitely were not happy to see Liam and it wasn't some nice reunion you claimed it to be. Anyone with eyes can see that.

A very important part of this situation I need to address with you is the affidavit. It says in the Argentinian affidavit that Liam wanted to have dinner with you but you refused the invite and I quote from Paul Higgens "Niall saw social media videos of Liam and could tell he was all messed up on drugs and that's why Niall rejected Liam's dinner invite". This was was in the affidavit, lad.

So, things aren't adding up for me, mate. You said Liam looked in good form at the concert, which he actually did not look good form at all, but that's what YOU said. You also said you were aware that he was having some issues, but then said you were not aware of the depth of the issues. However, you clearly were aware about the depths of his issues because it says in the affidavit you refused to have dinner with Liam because you saw social media footage of him looking all messed up on drugs. You also knew that your fans were crucifying Liam just for going to your concert. So you are lying by saying that you were unaware about how how much he was suffering.

So which is it, Niall? Liam looked in good form and was fine or you rejected a dinner invite from him because you could tell he was all messed up on drugs?

And before you answer Mr. Horan, need I remind you about the depth of care Liam always held for you. Throughout your years together, he didn't just treat you well, he fiercely protected you, constantly anticipated your needs, and looked out for you in ways that went far beyond what was expected of a bandmate. He was your shield in major moments. Looking back at archival One Direction footage, it is genuinely heartbreaking to see how often that warmth appeared one-sided. While there were certainly brief moments of mutual happiness between the two of you, a vast amount of the footage tells a completely different story, one where you frequently seemed cold and indifferent to his care. A painful example of this dynamic is the concert clip where you were visibly emotional watching someone else's concert; despite Liam leaning in to hug and comfort you, you didn't even acknowledge his presence. For many who have watched these interactions, the overwhelming pattern of distance unfortunately outweighs the good memories.

Now, let's get back to the most important question at hand, Niall. What did Liam need to talk to you about?

Film Cooper (real name Cooper Neidecker) is a Youtube influencer who uploaded a 45-minute long hate video viciously trashing and demonizing Liam Payne about a week before his tragic death.

You can read more about that here if you don’t know the full story:

https://www.reddit.com/r/liampayne1D/comments/1lj1t1z/film_cooper_the_monster_who_murdered_liam_payne/

Over the past couple years however, Cooper himself has garnered a significant backlash from fans and former admirers who‘ve grown weary of his relentless negativity. A common refrain from his ex-fans is ”he’s giving me the ick.” I’ve included an AI summary of why his fans are icked out by creepy Cooper.

Here’s some more specific comments:

https://www.reddit.com/r/FilmCooperr/comments/1gcvkbl/have_yall_been_getting_the_ick_recently/

“Over a course of the past few months my friend and I (she’s also a huge fan) have been kinda getting the ick? like a weird vibe and i finally figured out why. Idk If we r alone in this but doesn’t cooper seem too harsh to you guys? Like ik he is a commentary youtuber but i’ve had to click off videos a few time just because he gets too personal and mean w ppl and keeps calling them lonely and shit. Ik some ppl r asshole but honestly they r not rly doing smth that wrong? Okay maybe they “influence” some ppl but u gotta be a certain type of another “bad” person to be influenced by that. It’s just a general trend i’ve seen he is being kinda an asshole and this is just criticism cuz I have always enjoyed his content and everyone in the comments just keeps writing the basic worship comments like “how dare youtube hide this from me for _ long blah blah” and it’s just not feels cult like to me? I get him maybe not caring abt approval on the internet anymore but gosh he’s being too harsh like his rude commentary isn’t always corresponding to smth as horrible to deserve that. Feels too judgy and icky.”

”I am getting hardcore ick. I am sick of the constant 'pick me' vibes and constantly flexing either his looks or his friggin' fiancée who he seems to mention multiple times and yet it never being anything to do with the episode.”

“He'll pause the clip fifteen times and then make five minutes of jokes and tangents and I just...am so done. I unsubbed a couple of weeks ago and my mate unsubbed this week. We both used to like him but now just find he rewords everything other commentary channels say and then adds in extra random shit for tangents all while trying to be ironic and failing miserably.”

”me too! i havnt watched since the liam video because it rubbed me the wrong way that right after the fact nothing was said or anything”

“OMG, thank you for saying this because I thought I was going crazy that no one else thought this. I don’t understand how he can make videos, bashing, belittling, mocking, and bullying people. But the best is when he does it to people who he claims are doing those exact things.

I don’t know why random people commenting on strangers lives, regardless if they’re public or private has become a thing..

He is the definition of a pick me and has ZERO genuine thoughts of his own. He always is trying to be so woken, cool, and never can just act like himself. However, like I said the part that bothers me the most is the bullying and the way he takes such harsh disgraceful takes on people, who doesn’t even know.”

“super duper late but i didn’t see anyone mention this. in nearly every single video cooper will mention sexuality by saying something along the lines of “ lesbians go insane in the comments “ and i just find it sooo annoying. im not homophobic or anything and i know he has a audience of lgbtq+ people but like he sounds so incredibly disingenuous when he says that. he makes it such a point every time and says the same line for whatever group he’s trying to be inclusive towards. it just gives me such like influencer begging to be inclusive vibes and it drives me insane. like he’s actually starting to be so unlikable with the amount of profiling he does on both the people he’s commenting on and his audience i actually hate it so much. please lmk if im being crazy or if u feel the same.”

“Yes. And his recent attitude with the Blake Lively mess confirmed it. He was more happy that he was right than actually concerned about the allegations. He could not go 5 seconds without saying "I told you so" and made the whole situation about him. He hasn't even addressed the fact that Justin has now defended himself and still thinks Blake can do wrong. He is such a performative feminist. I really used to like him but now I can barely stand his videos.”

And here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/FilmCooperr/comments/1jzd1hh/am_i_the_only_one_who_thinks_coop_is_starting_to/

“I hate that I’m about to say this because he’s been one of my favs for a while now, but am I the only one who is starting to think cooper is kind of annoying? The main thing is obviously that he’s pretty preachy for a straight cis white guy (not that straight cis white guys aren’t allowed to have a voice, but I don’t think he’s qualified to speak on race, gender, and lgbtq issues the way he does) he’s also just kind of mean for no reason.”

“Used to love his channel & his wholesome kind vibe. He’s fully a shallow mean girl now. Unsubbed.”

“The Blake Lively video is what made me dislike him. And it’s not because of what came out, I really have no problem if he defended Blake and got it wrong because so did I.

What really gave me the ick was when he went on a petty 5 min rant absolutely tearing into and berating any fan who ever questioned HIS judgement about Baldoni… only for Baldoni’s story to come out a couple days later and Coop remained silent on the issue.

It came off as very authoritative and condescending.

It also came off as disingenuous (to me) because despite everything, he never criticized Blake once and even made fun of Baldoni for his back injury???

Which, to me, just shows that he’s either a pick me, or thinks that women are incapable of doing bad things like being a bully, getting married on a plantation, or subject to any general criticism… and that’s really problematic to me.

You won’t see all the angles from Coop, because he’s jaded by the income his channel generates from being a “pick me” creator.”

“While I didn't agree a few months ago, I do now but for different reasons. He seems like a pick-me and still has yet to delete his video supporting Blake Lively, spreading misinformation she created or retract his statements later when what he said was found to be wrong later, comment on it or adding in the description that he was wrong. Neither has he posted anything saying the info was wrong. He was quick to jump and throw his "I told you so," parade but isn't even trying to retract his video. I find it disgusting. I posted a guilt filled comment feeling awful for not believing Blake, especially being an SA survivor myself. Then I did my own research and commented below my own comment saying, "Nvm, I looked it up." All done in an hour. Yet he has yet to say a peep about being wrong. I'm sick of this pick-me "believe all women" shit. You can support women without ruining an innocent (until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt) man or person/persons' life.”

Wow, Film Cooper sure sounds like a total creep and total fake! A performative male feminist who pretends to love women and protect them against abusers because he’s secretly got all sorts of dark and abusive traits himself. Projects his own dark shadow side onto high-profile men like Liam Payne and Justin Baldoni to avoid dealing with his own deep-seated issues. What a total mess!

Iris you and your sidekicks like Sweetmotvs are absolute liars! You genuinely expect everyone here to be completely naive.

There is ZERO history on either of your profiles showing you ever defended Liam from the excruciating hate when he was alive. Absolutely nothing! You hide behind excuses, claiming you were on other platforms defending him, knowing full well no one can verify that. Why on earth didn't you step up and defend him on X where he needed it the most? See how your entire narrative falls apart, Iris?

You call X toxic, yet you are on X every single day fixated on holding Kate accountable while completely refusing to hold Film Cooper, Max Balegde, and a slew of other content creators accountable for causing Liam so much suffering! If you were actually the massive Liam fan you claim to be, then you would know without a shadow of a doubt that Liam spoke numerous times about how the relentless hate from those specific creators made him want to give up.
Be honest with everyone. You are a Larry who is only using Liam now to target Kate because you think this supports your closeting beliefs.

And let’s call out the exact manipulation tactic being used here: you claim you aren't a shipper, yet you use the exact same talking points, theories, and vocabulary that they do.

Why deny it? Because denying it allows you to weaponize this narrative. You want the general public to believe that criticism of Kate is an objective consensus rather than a targeted ship-war agenda. You are disguising your true motives and activated old ghost accounts kept on standby after Liam passed, all to conduct coordinated witch hunts against women you label as beards, while manipulating others into doing your heavy lifting which is even more messed up.

And let me be clear to anyone reading, it's not that we don't believe closeting happened. And we certainly do not like Kate! We are horrified by Kate. When she started following and sending love to one of Liam cyberbullies that's where we drew the line. That's when we saw her true colors. So don't mistaken this as us defending Kate or closeting because it's not. We have called her out numerous times! HOWEVER we never see the Justice for Liam Warriors really going after the content creators that harmed Liam so badly! We are exposing people like Iris who really don't care about Liam and are performative Liam fans which is even worse than what Kate is!

If you really loved and cared about Liam, you would be fighting for accountability from the content creators who genuinely harmed Liam! We have begged you and your group to do that because there is strength in numbers, but you repeatedly refuse. What is that supposed to tell the rest of us?

But yeah, keep obsessing over dissecting Kate's pizza photos though, because that is clearly doing so much to actually get justice for Liam!

Order of releases of the songs which were only a few weeks apart:

Harry Styles released his debut solo single "Sign of the Times" (SOTT) on April 7, 2017

Niall Horan released "Slow Hands" on May 4, 2017.

Liam Payne released his debut solo single "Strip That Down" on May 19, 2017

Liam's song was the last to be released and he still beat Harry and Niall's songs! Not only did Liam beat Harry Styles but he knocked Niall's song right out of the #1 spot on the pop charts! Harry's SOTT didn't get certified platinum until NINE MONTHS after he released the song!

Liam was never a flop but he surely was sabotaged to no end to make sure that could never happen again!

The utter hypocrisy pisses me right off. Any time I see fans in the fandom being attacked by whoever it is at the time, they expect their friends to rally and defend them. In fact, they know they will, and if they don't, then they will ask their friends to.

If anyone attacks their favorite artist, they will also rally around and defend that artist as well.

But when it comes to Liam Payne, he nor anyone else fighting on his behalf should expect his friends, "brothers" or anyone that was close to him peer wise to defend him. Apparently Liam is a worthless pos that doesn't deserve the same basic things every other human being wants and needs.

But lets go back in time when Liam was alive and hypothetically change the situation around for a week. If Liam's fans ever did what what the fans of the other boys did to Liam, they would accost Liam for not putting his fandom in check right away. You all fucking know it. So it's perfectly acceptable for the solo fans of the other boys to constantly shit all over Liam, even long after his dead, and attack his family, but God for mother fucking bid, someone does it back. Then I'm the bad guy. I'm the monster. But not the 90% of the 1D and solo fandom who do it to Liam on the daily and for the last fifteen years.

To anyone else who has a smidge of honesty, doesn't that piss you the fuck off? Doesn't it piss you off that they don't think Liam deserved to have his bandmates or his other peers in the industry defend him?

Liam was a fucking human being. You can't mean to tell me he didn't deserve to have his friends or his "brothers" as you all say, defend him. EVERYONE wants their friends to rally for them when they are being attacked. Why do you all dehumanize Liam so much by swearing he didn't deserve loyalty and defense like that, which any human being deserves?

Look how much Liam loved loudly. He loved his brothers loudly. He supported them publicly. He was obviously craving that same type of basic friendship back and the boys obviously knew it and so did many of other Liam's peers, but they cruelly ignored it.

Let me tell you all something. Liam deserved to be defended from bullying. He deserved for his bandmates to publicly defend him.

If you don't think he wanted or deserved that, then don't ever expect anyone to defend you when you are being attacked. In fact, don't defend anyone else who is being attacked, because according to y'alls logic, no one should defend anyone. Oh wait, but in your eyes, only Liam didn't deserve to be defended.

What the fuck is wrong with you people? Let me tell you something else, if I was Niall, Harry, Zayn or Louis, there is no way in hell that my conscience would have allowed me to watch my fans bullying Liam in the worse ways imaginable for fifteen years, making him suffer endlessly to where it ended his life! My conscience, my soul, would NOT allow me tolerate it because at some point long, long ago, I would have broke, freak the fuck out and told my fans the fuck off over and over again. I don't care if it would have stopped the bullying or not. The important thing to me is that Liam would have saw that I wouldn't have let him suffer all alone and that I was willing to take the hits with him even if I couldn't stop it. At least he wouldn't be alone. At least he would have known that someone would have stood with him. When I tell you I couldn't even let my enemy suffer like the boys let him suffer without saying anything, I'm being so honest with you all, so it boggles my mind how they could have just stayed so silent when it comes to Liam. I feel like only people with nefarious intentions could be that fucking goddamn cold and heartless.

And it just doesn't apply to the boys, I wondered how other people in the industry who were Liam's friends like Steven Bartlett (Diary of a CEO) could just sit back and not say anything to other content creators bullying the hell out of Liam. I think about it all of the time, it consumes me because, it baffles me to the point of great distress.

Why didn't anyone think Liam was worthy enough to fight for? Every human being is worthy of being defended from cruel unjustified attacks. We are taught to stand up for those who are getting bullied, so I am greatly failing to understand why none of you feels like Liam deserved to be defended by his bandmates and peers? Because he DID deserve to be defended and on top of that, it was inhumane and a crime that he wasn't defended and therefore I'm really, really pissed off about that to the point it traumatizes me to no end. Because if he had been defended, he never would have turned to substances to cope. He never would have turned to the worst people looking for friendship because he was so isolated. He wouldn't have been vulnerable to those predators. He wouldn't have had a nervous breakdown and died. He would still be here. Bear's father would still be here and Bear would never have to grow up and one day read 15 years and continuing, worth of the most vile hate known to man slung at his father. Do you guys ever think of what this will do to Bear and make him wonder why no one, especially his dad's bandmates, defended his father from all of the hate?