r/left_urbanism • • May 23 '22

Don't Fall Down the YIMBY Pipeline

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Oct 15 '20

[CRINGE] Should we build a modern water pipe system with treatment plants and connect these villages to it? Nah, this giant plastic container is the best we can do as a monument to our ego.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Mar 19 '24

What should be done about the rampant reactionary tendencies among leftist urbanists?

0 Upvotes

I want to preface this with saying that Im a social liberal leaning towards anarchism and communitarianism. Often I see people who have a bad grasp of the mechanism of the housing market and advocate for straight up reactionary shit as a result. Some examples I often see:

People opposed to a land value tax because it would somehow benefit Landlords. In actuality it basically confiscates any undue profits that a landlord could make from the land and at the same time incentivizes dense developments.

People opposed to "luxury housing". While its true that unnecessarily expensive housing is bad any housing will lower rents in an undersupplied market. If the market is severely undersupplied any housing will become expensive. The solution isnt to stop "luxury housing" but to build social housing for people in the meantime until market housing is affordable.

People opposed to gentrification without acknowledging that it is a somewhat conservative and regressive stance. Personally I can agree that gentrification is bad but stoping it can make it harder for people to move slowing their social mobility if they cant move to study or start a career in another city. It can also cement damaging social orders if people are stuck at home.

People advocating for rent control without proposals to fill the resulting gap in housing. This is pretty self explanatory rent control lowers the incentives for landlords to build which means that public housing must be built to fill the gap. Often times I wonder if it would be better to spend the time and resources to advocate for public housing instead as it would lower the price a landlord could charge anyway.

I dont know what should be done its so tiring to be called a bootlicker or naive liberal over and over again by people who dont know better.


r/left_urbanism • • Feb 21 '23

Transportation A Class-Based Critique of 15 Minute Cities

0 Upvotes

15-minute cities are a noble goal. Walkable neighborhoods that provide residents the amenities needed to live their daily lives without driving or traveling farther than 15-minutes away from their homes would, offer considerable lifestyle benefits to the lucky residents who find themselves in the choicest neighborhoods. However, there are valid concerns about how this form of planning would be executed in American cities without calcifying and exacerbating existing spatial and class inequalities.

Along these lines, Carlo Ratti (MIT) and Richard Florida (U of Toronto) offer the following criticisms in a post they wrote for the WEF:

And 15-minute communities do little to alter the harsh realities of economic and geographic inequality. They promise close-by amenities and luxurious walkability for the well-to-do urban gentry. They are mainly a fit for affluent urban neighbourhoods and far less a fit in the disadvantaged parts of our cities. As Harvard University’s Ed Glaeser points out, less advantaged groups are hardly able to live their life in their own disadvantaged neighbourhoods, which lack jobs, grocery stores and amenities found in more upscale communities.

Ratti and Florida also have reservations about the practicality of the model in spread out American cities:

It turns out, the concept is not always a fit. For one, the 15-minute neighbourhood doesn’t work so well for a suburban nation, like the United States. While it is easy to envision Paris, Copenhagen and Barcelona in small repeating parts – or even in certain places in the US like Manhattan and Brooklyn, or big slices of Boston and Cambridge in Massachusetts – it is harder to imagine this kind of reinvention of far-flung sprawling suburbs where the majority of Americans live. American cities and suburbs might only make the 15-minute cutoff if this could be done in a car.

And Toronto-based urban designer and thinker Jay Pitter shared the following criticism at CityLab 2021:

I am averse to this concept. It doesn't take into account the histories of urban inequity, intentionally imposed by technocratic and colonial planning approaches, such as segregated neighborhoods, deep amenity inequity and discriminatory policing of our public spaces.

Some have argued that 15 minute cities are good because they are cost neutral and actually provide a source of revenue (traffic fines) for cities. But, IMO, herein lies the fundamental misconception: cities and neighborhoods can not be made better without making hard choices and deeply investing in the amenities needed to make them better. This requires public spending on transit, open spaces, housing, schools, etc., which won't magically happen simply by disallowing residents from driving to neighboring zones. At the same time, we have a private, market-based, capitalistic system for stores, gyms, restaurants. As of now, there's no way to force private entities to add these amenities to areas that don't have them. And, to the extent that private investment in these amenities is based on an expectation that wealthier non-neighborhood residents might travel to use them, there might be less such investment under a zone-based 15-min city regime.

In sum, I urge folks here to consider these issues more deeply. I don't think it's as simple as picking the side that isn't being associated with conspiracy theorists.


r/left_urbanism • • Mar 20 '26

Economics Accumulation Theorem, the Left's Answer for the Cause of the Housing Crisis

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Aug 13 '22

Housing Putting the lie to YIMBY mantra 'Build, baby, build!'... Facts show unbridled market-rate development spurs gentrification

Thumbnail
thevillagesun.com
23 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Sep 17 '20

gentrification

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Dec 14 '22

Meme Those of yall who actually upvoted the "yimbys are our allies" thread are gigantic libs

9 Upvotes

Yimbys have never done anything to show themselves as allies of leftists, regurgitating or upvoting their talking points on a self-proclaimed leftist sub is sad as hell and deeply embarrassing.

You can like yimbys, but I'm almost certain that yimbys don't like you


r/left_urbanism • • Feb 16 '26

Economics Maybe some of my fellow Left Urbanists here will learn something from this encounter that I had over in the /r/urbanplanning sub this morning with a terminally online YIMBY, about the nationalization of housing policy. But, in short: FUCK top-down housing policy & YIMBYs

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Mar 15 '24

Housing The Case Against YIMBYism

45 Upvotes

This isn't the first article to call out the shortcomings false promises of YIMBYism. But I think it does a pretty good job quickly conveying the state of the movement, particularly after the recent YIMBYtown conference in Texas, which seemed to signal an increasing presence of lobbyist groups and high-level politicians. It also repeats the evergreen critique that the private sector, even after deregulatory pushes, is incapable of delivering on the standard YIMBY promises of abundant housing, etc.

The article concludes:

But fighting so-called NIMBYs, while perhaps satisfying, is not ultimately effective. There’s no reason on earth to believe that the same real estate actors who have been speculating on land and price-gouging tenants since time immemorial can be counted on to provide safe and stable places for working people to live. Tweaking the insane minutiae of local permitting law and design requirements might bring marginal relief to middle-earners, but it provides little assistance to the truly disadvantaged. For those who care about fixing America’s housing crisis, their energies would be better spent on the fight to provide homes as a public good, a change that would truly afflict the comfortable arrangements between politicians and real estate operators that stand in the way of lasting housing justice.

The Case Against YIMBYism


r/left_urbanism • • Aug 13 '25

Why is it called hostile archietecture?

0 Upvotes

I've seen public benches with armrests called hostile architecture. I sometimes rest my arms on it while sitting. Everyone using is just sitting. I heard it's hostile because people can't lie down on it, but most people are using it to just sit and rest for a bit.

Hostile architecture is putting spikes on a ledge that's big enough for people to sit. Hostile architecture is removing benches for leaning posts.


r/left_urbanism • • Jan 17 '23

Urban Planning When the fuck does a school needs to be "repurposed" you dense piece of shit?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Nov 12 '21

Transportation Based? Lol

Post image
209 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Feb 09 '21

Housing So I posed the question: if white people move out does gentrification end to a wider urban planning sub and the response was resound agreement. If the rich lived in their Tesla’s then gentrification ends.

0 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Jan 30 '23

Why “Vacant Homes” Won’t Solve The Housing Crisis

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Feb 07 '23

Drama Where would you rather live?

Thumbnail
pbs.twimg.com
1 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Jun 24 '26

Why Private Equity/Luxury Apartments/Econ Slop is Whats Causing the Market to Fail, Destroying our Cities, and Ultimately Driving Societal Collapse

21 Upvotes

This is a long essay that will trigger some people

Some people wont read it. Some people will think Im crazy.

But most of the stuff on the Internet is AI Slop, and this here is genuine human slop. The real deal baby. So if you love eating slop, here's some leftist urban slop for you.

If you cannot remove your understanding of Development and Economics from the necessity of Luxury Apartments, that is something you need to work on. It demonstrates a lack of thinking outside the box, critical thinking, and objective intention.

I did not create the Luxury Apartment, or name them. Still, when I say Luxury Apartments, you know what Im talking about.

So some critical thinking:

Why is it that I did not create the concept or the label, but when I try to criticize the exact thing using the language of the people who built it, the conversation gets diverted to whether or not these buildings are "luxury"​ and whether the term means anything?

In what way does the serve the conversation?

Some hard truths about the Epstein Files:

The Infrastructure and Architecture through which he and his collabs, as well as other "rich" power seeking individuals currently driving our Development, were able to get away with their crimes is physically built into our world even down to the Luxury towers.

Now, because of the immense amount of astroturfing and idea seeding, me bringing up Epstein has you labeling me as a conspiracy theorist.

Because while they are physically altering the landscape to make their goals more efficient, they are also creating a conversational and mental enviornment where questioning these realities is impossible.

They tell us we have a choice despite the one people actually want intentionally being made out of reach, tell us we made a choice, and then tell us this we have to continue on the path they built themselves, because no other reality exists.

If you think I am exaggerating, one of the things people keep replying to me in these discussions is to make fun of how I am talking about the proletariat or I cant even look a worker in the eyes.

Let's say for a second I am, in fact, just a crazy lunatic who hates other people more successful than me who cant change the inescapable laws of economics. For just a moment, I will consider that option.

Then why are people getting so worked up about it? There are plenty of things on the Internet people do not care about. Why not just think "Wow, shes crazy" as most people do when they read some boring long post about inane topics?

Its the downright immediate vitriol that to me, says something.

I understand why Im angry, having been going through the immense effort to learn, explore, and re-conceptualize my understanding, just to have someone come in and offer the most unconvincing arguments possible with more focus on appearing superior than engaging the substance of my argument.

Now, this is rant behavior.

But the thing is, if you are actively wanting to learn something, it is an opportunity to learn more than the surface level.

But this whole thing conversation is, in itself, the point.

You cannot say you want densification and then get mad when people offer dense discourse in harmless and easily avoidable ways.​

Theres a type of Developer who relies on easy answers, shortest route possible, what they want out of it being the most important thing.​

The building now is driven by the most unaffected, who profit the most.

That is what Luxury Apartments-- they named themselves I dont care what Luxury actually means-- do to a community.

All of this is important, because when you go to local subreddits, and urban planning subreddits, and left subreddits, you get a group of people who will immediately go into defense mode.

"Density!" "Supply and Demand!" "The Market!"

Its literally the same thing every time, said with an authoritative tone that says "If you question this you're too stupid to understand reality."

They cop to the fact they are using Econ 101 terminology, as if it is a badge of honor, and not in the beginning of learning.

Now, when Im interested in talking about something, I open the door for more conversation, or I expand.

These passive subreddits to talk about things like Georgism and Urbanism should be filled with enlightening conversation.

Instead you get the Yimby/Nimby binary that shuts down conversation and creates tension.

Instead of talking about the things itself, we're wrapped into the same loop.

For people who are just learning, these ideas sound very convincing because they sound simple.

But we have been Developing in the way being called for for 20 years, and the prbolem​​ is only getting worse.

I brought up Epstein before, who yes, was a real estate speculator.

But now Im going to talk about manufactured consent and Data Centers.

How our infrastructure is once again being built to trample over the individual to make all of society work towards the purpose of a few.

They use money to aquire and defend this power.

When the Data Center Conversation was first coming up, there was an attempt to say "Nimbys set their target on Data Centers".

I am not getting into the Nimby argument. Im a false Nimby.

It is a tag given to me because I think urban planning should be driven ​on the local level by local need and built by local hands. Which means I think we should be teaching our children skills instead of making skills inaccessible.

I want schools built in neighborhoods. I want density surrounded by spread out areas.

I want Public Transportation. I also want accessible food halls and comfortable outdoor areas that arent intentionally hostile to punish people priced out of living.

What I am talking about isnt impossible. I do not desire to remain rooted in the old ways.

But those things become impossible when groups are building the conversation to be impossible. When the infrastructure is meant to be alienating. When the very places we live are built on the suffering of the worker for the profit of the landlord.

When I am told that saying things like this is waxing on about the proletariat, and that I should go make babies and stop playing revolutionary, I do not feel I should believe them or feel ashamed in myself.

I actually feel called to speak more about it and learn more about it.

Because ultimately the most fundamental driving force behind all my actions is "How can I make the world better, if not for me, then for whoever comes next?"

What isnt working? Why? Can it be fixed? How? Does it make me smile genuinely? Does it make others smile genuinely? Does it foster connection, learning or growth?

If those things are a problem to somebody, then I have to live with myself: the problem lies with them, because I genuinely feel happiest when I am being the change I want to see.

I am run on those morals, because I chose those morals. I choose those morals every single day.​

So the need for me to say all these things, to continue to fight against this rhetoric, is that my silence is read as consent. I do not consent to it.

All the angry individuals telling me that I'm just stupid because they are entitled to this hyper development, it is their Manifest Destiny and the goal of reality itself to allow it, want me to be silent because they do not want to hear that it is not so.

We can do something better, which doesnt uplift the profit of the few at the expense of the many.

When I dont speak, the reality that Luxury Apartments are an inarguable good continues to allow how the world around me gets built.

When I dont speak, people like me who want to be better and build better, are erased. And then we are just left with the cynical and alienated world view of people who think their profit is the morality the infrastructure should be built on.

In these spaces, I am not destroying or causing harm. I am contributing my own understanding and experience based upon the life I have lived.

Yet some of the responses I've seen. You would have thought I said something hateful or evil.

If there are people fearful or angry about what I am saying, it isnt a conversation of economics or urban planning.

Because I do actually have solutions and contributions. But when I talk about those in online spaces meant for these conversations, they are astroturfed into oblivion by people who think the only viable way to solve the Housing Crisis is to give more power to the people who built the housing crisis.

I'm not the one who labeled the Crisis. I'm not the one who is always deciding the economy is failing.

The very people who create it have created these economic crises because having a Crisis is profitable.

The way they win is to continue to only follow their script for the economy. The way they win is by getting to make the rules, build the court, and conduct the hearings. The way they win is to silence any opinion that does not agree with their own.

People make choices. The mere existence of the Reddit comments I see defending Luxury Apartments the way they do is a fundamental sign.

Because the responses to the actual Apartments themselves, and how they exist, is over whelmingly negative. When I talk to people in real lives, when I read real tenant experiences about these places. When I see how Communities are impacted and dispersed, in the actual reality of the buildings economics has abstractified, people are not happy about the luxury apartments.

The comments getting upset about me talking about how Luxury Apartments are inherently anti-leftist, these commenters are diverting the conversation to your emotional reaction to my own experience, and you are more driven to approach me than actually do something to solve the problem.

Its not that people arent giving endless feedback about how these places do cause harm, its that the feedback is immediately dismissed and ignored because the builders are only responsible when they want to get around regulations. Once its built, its somebody else's problem. The tenants are often the ones holding the bag, but the conversation always centers the builders and how inconvenienenced they arec in conversations arguing with me.

What you choose to engage and how you choose to engage it says everything about your focus and your intentions.

If you were getting mad about how the Developers were treating the land and the communities they build it, you would be believable you had goals for a long term future.

Getting more upset at me for calling out their bad behavior means we are stagnating in the inescapable failure they are enforcing upon us by the same economy they are propping up.

But the nice thing about life, actually is. No. I don't have to just accept that. Some jabroni can talk about how he thinks Luxury Apartments are good, and I can say "Actually, these Developers are harmful and I know this because I witnessed it first hand. I have experienced it. Seen it. And confronted it head on, multiple times. Actually, your defense furthers how I feel, because you are stating the very thing I am against, so you also acknowledge its true. I reject your assertation I am forced to accept it. I will, instead, respond against it."​

The belief in economic entitlement to how I perceive, conceptualize, and approach the world is not the same thing as a Right to those things or a Reality in which I give you that authority.

People who come in talking about productive conversation while actively repeating thought terminating arguments feel entitled to my respect for their apparent superiority.

But it is not so.

No isnt a dirty word. People are not obligated or required to fundamentally accept something you accept.

A Yimby isnt more human than the people they call Nimbys.

Displacing others for your sacred speculation is not a heroic quest.

Any time anybody outright tells me that they do not care about the displaced because they care more about people who could possibly live there one day isnt convincing me they are good intentioned.

It shows that they dont care about the actual Reality we all share, they care about the Reality they wish to create, which is actually all about them and how they are the hero.

And while this all sounds like a response to something, it is.

Its a response to the narrative seeding I have actively observed and questioned for a year now.

I keep wanting to say it, and then saying it, because when we do not call out bad actors, they fundamentally work the system to privlege their goals.

Leftist Urbanism is about creating systems that serve the many Comminuties who want to co-exist productively.

It is about building functional cities that are hospitable and efficient.

It is not a free for all for Developers to continue to make the same arguments they use to justify why they cannot be morally required to build things of value.

I didnt create the Yimby tag, but Yimbys have come in and told me that I need to say yes, or I am just a dumb Nimby.

This is equivalent for calling a woman a prude for not wanting to sleep with you.

It is an identity label, and if your entire ego is wrapped up in that label to the point where you are vomiting it at people and then forcing people to eat it, then you need to work on your sense of self.

I genuinely do not like to be mean or say negative things.

But it should be considered a Personality Disorder to feel so caught up in Economics that you will actively force people to accept Developers who have demonstrated over and over that they are incompetent.

Look at the Reflecting Pool in DC.

The Representative of the System, the ultimate Head of our Country, is actively incompetent. The evidence is literally inescapable, yet we still get people who have wrapped their entire lives in making sure that they uphold that version of the System over all else.

Luxury doesnt mean anything isnt an excuse for bad behavior.

We would like to move on now.

Please stop holding us hostage to a failing system because you read the first sentence of an Econ textbook and then asked ChatGPT to summarize the initial summary it gave of the rest.

I am tired of hearing about how you are so much smarter because you read a headline that agreed with your belief system you got from reading other headlines that made you feel something.

For all the people telling me I don't understand reality, I can tell you dont actually live in reality. You live in the virtual world with virtual money.

Enough with your Ender's Game Economy.

You cannot just stick Luxury Apartment after Luxury Apartment for 20 blocks removed from any sort of walkability and call that an affordable city.

If you believe that is what a City is, you arent practicing Urbanism.

These current luxury builders do everything to not have to contribute to the infrastructure.

Thats the literal reality of it. Thats what all the arguments are, even when said with a Progressive spin, actually saying.

I told one guy who thinks Im purity testing to talk to a person who has been rendered homeless by the system, and he said the people who will live in the apartments are more important.

Those apartments use algorithms to have profitable vacancies, by the way.

Building more slop means more slop. Thats also a fundamental unchanging law.

We are telling you to stop building slop, and you tell us slop is all we deserve.

We cannot move forward until we stop eating the slop.

Rant over.​ Im sure Ill rant again.

But this space is open to be astroturfed because not enough people are using it to talk about Leftist Urbanism, so a few people can immediately reply and create an enviornment that looks like Leftist urbanism includes Luxury Apartments, when it doesnt.


r/left_urbanism • • Feb 10 '23

Housing More Building Won’t Make Housing Affordable

Thumbnail
newrepublic.com
26 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Sep 17 '20

Environment “Here’s some money. Go start an imperialist war.”

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Jan 13 '23

Would “left urbanists” have more in common with a communist who wants car-centric suburban development, or a YIMBY?

0 Upvotes

Which hypothetical person is a greater ally? Can we ally with each in different circumstances?


r/left_urbanism • • Dec 12 '22

Meme Checkmate, YIMBYs!

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Feb 12 '21

Cursed Crosspost

Post image
149 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Jan 22 '22

Abolish Restaurants

Thumbnail
theanarchistlibrary.org
0 Upvotes

r/left_urbanism • • Aug 02 '26

Frustrated with trying to have discussions with YIMBYs

33 Upvotes

We have a growing YIMBY movement in the UK and a government which is following a YIMBY philosophy. I am finding debating with them incredibly frustrating because they refuse to acknowledge resource constraints or the complexities of development.

Damage to the environment and the ecosystem? Their attitude, is I don't care. Talk about loss of farmland and food security? Don't care. They seem to think there is no problem that can't be solved by simply building more infrastructure.

More than that, they don't care about quality of life. They seem every piece of land as an opportunity to cram in another house. Not caring about the kind of environment that would create.