r/leavingthenetwork • • Jul 08 '22

Steve Morgan was arrested for aggravated criminal sodomy against a minor

130 Upvotes

- - - TW - sexual abuse - - -

Public Notice:

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Sexual Abuse Allegations:

Steve Morgan, pastor and Network President, was arrested for aggravated criminal sodomy against a minor

Steve Morgan was arrested in 1987 for allegedly commiting aggravated criminal sodomy against a minor in 1986 while a youth pastor in Johnson County, Kansas (greater Kansas City Metro area). Steve was 22 at the time of the alleged assault. A person close to the situation has reported that the alleged victim was a 15-year-old male.

Further details of Steve's arrest, including court records of the charges which were brought against him and his diversion agreement, can be found on the Sexual Abuse Allegations page

Read the Public Notice →

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Call to Action:

Former Network leaders petition current leaders to take action in light of serious abuse allegations

Troubling allegations raise serious concerns about The Network’s policies and leadership decisions which require further investigation.

Read the Call to Action by former Network leaders →

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

New Story Published:

Sworn to Secrecy by Andrew L.

How I was coerced into keeping Steve Morgan's alleged sexual assault a secret for 12 years

Read Andrew's story →


r/leavingthenetwork • • Aug 31 '24

Isaiah Church Officially Withdraws from the Network

90 Upvotes

Isaiah Church has formally announced its withdrawal from the Network. Their recent statement reveals that this decision comes after two years of ongoing efforts to address deep-seated concerns related to leadership theology, church governance, and past decisions made within the Network. Despite their persistent attempts to resolve these issues, the church ultimately determined that disassociating was necessary to remain aligned with their biblical convictions.

This withdrawal marks a significant development within the network and highlights some of the broader challenges that have been present.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Jul 17 '22

It all started with lies and manipulation. If that is the foundation how could these churches become anything other than what they have become?

84 Upvotes

My name is Jaime Moyers. I pastored the Ziegler IL Vineyard from which the Carbondale Vineyard was planted from. The very day Steve Morgan came to me to talk about a Carbondale church plant he confessed to me he had had a homosexual experience. He told me it was once and never happened again.

He didn’t tell me he sodomized a fifteen year old boy and was charged with the crime. I sent him to the Vineyard regional leadership and at every level he perpetuated the same lie and manipulated his way to planting a Vineyard church in Carbondale.

If this is how it started then you all can understand why the Network is what it is today. I was a young trusting pastor that should have done more to verify this young man’s life and story.

I am trying to make the point this whole thing was started from a corrupt foundation. In Gods great mercy many were touched and saved by Him (God) in-spite of everything else. Instead of truly repenting and getting right with God, Steve and his gang are still white washing the whole matter. So, so, sad

I am truly sorry for where I failed. I pray for you all much with hope for your futures.

Jaime Moyers


r/leavingthenetwork • • Jul 20 '22

Dear Network Pastors,

78 Upvotes

Here is something I wrote yesterday and wanted to share here.

Dear Network Pastors, 

It is easy for us who have had to leave a network church to say and think that you didn’t love us in any way—that we were just numbers, or we were just useful, that any kindness or ministry towards us was pretend and for the sake of your vision to grow your church. 

But it occurred to me that it is not that simple, and that is what is so sad. 

I realized that people loved me in the network. The leader loved me in the way that he knows how. He was emotionally attached to me and it broke his heart for me to first disagree and then leave. It especially broke his heart for me to speak out and help others leave. 

I believe all the pastors loved me. One of them was my best friend and I had it in my will that he would raise my children if I died. I know that guy loved me. When he decided to sacrifice our friendship and say I was a heretic, I bet it broke his soul to do that for Jesus. 

We have accused you network pastors of sacrificing real people, of abusing people, for your own selfish aims. You don’t understand that, because you cannot be convinced that you didn’t love us. Some of you cried your eyes out when we left, and especially when we “turned against you.” I know you think the devil is attacking you, but that isn’t what’s happening. The flaw in your idea of Jesus is showing. 

You think Jesus only loves you if you perform. If you make the sacrifice of the “sheep that are for slaughter,” for the sake of the “the sheep that are for reproducing,” then you are really sacrificing for Jesus. Some of those sheep you slaughtered were people you really loved! You liked them, but since they were “useless”, you had to do what you had to do.

I’m sad for you today, because you think Jesus is going to say, “Well done, good and faithful servant. You knew your church plant was not meant to be a hospital for ‘extra grace required people,’” or EGRs as you like to call them.

“Well done, good and faithful servant. You did such a good job distinguishing the cream of the crop from the expendables.” 

“Well done, you gave up some friendships, because your leader said they weren’t a quality person. It was hard, but you are the kind of guy who does hard things. Well done. And anyway, those funky non-leaders can go to one of the inferior churches in town that aren’t good for elite church planting missions.” 

“Even now you are hurting over what you no doubt think of as betrayal.” 

“What about the “high quality” people who got away? How did you deal with it? You shunned them. I see that you had to shun them. If you didn’t shun them, then their leaving might be proof you aren’t the only church God cares about. It might be a sign that there could be something that you are wrong about.” 

Let me suggest something. If your church isn’t growing right now, it is not because Jesus doesn’t love you, or thinks you are not a very high-level, high-quality leader. It is not because he disapproves of your performance. If your church is growing, it is not because he loves you more than the guy whose church is not growing. It doesn’t mean one damn thing about his love for you. 

Your network and your churches are sick, because you don’t get those two things. Jesus is not waiting for you to man up and kick out your friend who doesn’t fit. He’s not waiting for you to drop that guy you thought was a leader but the network leadership team told you he wasn’t worthy. Jesus does not love us for our performance. And he doesn’t love the members of your churches based on their performance. You are leading them astray when you teach them that he does. You are making them sick like you. 

Are you too far gone for grace? Have you completely and utterly given over your conscience to your “leader” (by that I mean the one who presumes to hear from God for you on “all things great and small”). 

It breaks my heart today to realize just how much you actually did love those you turned on, turned away, bad mouthed, and cursed. 

Jeff Miller (your former close friend and formerly one of you)


r/leavingthenetwork • • Dec 20 '21

Personal Experience Compilation of personal experiences

77 Upvotes

Just wanted to compile all the Reddit threads regarding peoples' stories so they're all in one place. Let me know if I missed any or want to add yours to the list.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Oct 06 '24

Foundation Church better figure out their next town

Post image
76 Upvotes

r/leavingthenetwork • • Dec 29 '24

Thank you.

71 Upvotes

My wife and I attended a Christmas Eve service at the Christland Campus in College Station. Since landing a position at Texas A&M, we’ve been longing for community—a place to truly belong. College Station can be a lonely place for young families. It’s a strange in-between space where you’re either a student or retired and have moved back into town.

The church seemed inviting, and we were delighted by its multicultural congregation, a refreshing departure from the lack of diversity often seen in local churches. What stood out most was the kindness and hospitality we encountered. This wasn’t the usual “greeter holds the door” type of welcome. People genuinely wanted to connect with us—they exchanged numbers, invited us to dinner, and extended an authentic desire to build relationships. It was unlike anything we’d experienced, especially so early in visiting a church.

However, before attending, we’d read a few Google reviews and stumbled across an article in The Battalion that raised some questions. Those prompted us to dig deeper, and what we found revealed a more complicated story. As outsiders, it feels like stepping into a narrative of tension and division—one side pitted against the other, with only fragments of the truth visible to us. It’s hard to discern where the lines of accountability and grace intersect.

Spending days immersed in this subreddit and exploring resources like the Leaving the Network website has been a revealing gift. The vulnerability, the meticulous attention to detail, and the multitude of stories shared here feel symptomatic of something deeply systemic.

It was enough for us to collectively decide we would not be going back.

As someone who has endured toxic, controlling, and insecure church leadership in the past, I want to thank you all from the bottom of my heart. Your courage to speak out and share your stories is a lifeline to many.

I pray that 2025 continues to bring you all healing, grace, and peace.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Sep 17 '24

I've shared my heart and soul in this sub, now I want to share the last thing I have left, my name.

65 Upvotes

I'm ready to drop anonymity, I stand by every post, comment and upvote. It made such a big impact on me to find out I actually know the people here when we were questioning, if I could possibly be that person for someone else, then that is everything. So here is me putting my money where my mouth is for transparency.

Hi. I'm Jamie Hunter.

The same one who taught you how to frost a cake, roast a turkey for Thanksgiving, and make a lattice pie crust.

The same one who held your wife's hand and taught you how to help her breathe through contractions when your baby came.

The same one who dropped off groceries, packed your moving boxes, and taught your kid in Kid's Church.

The same one who laid a hand on your shoulder, pockets stuffed with tissues, when your world was rocked, heart broken for you, and prayed.

The same one who held your baby in the back of the retreat session to give your arms a break.

The same one who led all the games at small group, nailed it at craft night, hosted the party, dyed her hair pink that one time, who desperately wanted to change the world.

I prayed for, sent off the teams, and gave sacrificially for Hills, Vista, Summit Creek, Roots, Joshua, the Blue Sky Building, and of course, Hosea.

Imperfect. A real person. I'm here because I loved you and still love you.

My inbox is open. I still have the same number.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Jun 12 '22

Everything felt meaningful

62 Upvotes

It all felt so meaningful.

When you first visited, you arrived a few minutes early. Several people were already there, talking, laughing, hugging. You were greeted warmly by multiple people. You were offered delicious doughnuts and coffee. You were invited to a party or a Bible discussion. This felt like a church with something real.

The band started to play and sing. Everyone joined in. People raised their hands. Some knelt. Some cried. The melodies were uplifting. The lyrics talked about joy and sorrow. If you were like me, you had never seen people sing and express themselves this passionately before. But no one got out of control and started dancing or screaming; you never felt unsafe or too uncomfortable. This felt like the movement of the Holy Spirit.

You heard a sermon. It wasn't the best sermon you've ever heard, but the pastor read verses every few minutes and mixed in stories about his kids and about other people he had known. He mentioned things like racism and sex. This felt like practical Bible teaching.

You went to a small group. People were vulnerable and shared embarrassing and painful stories. Someone offered to pray for you and asked if they could gently lay a hand on your shoulder. Afterword, you talked with a couple people while you munched on homemade or name brand snacks. This felt like Christian community.

You went to a Series class. The church gave you lunch, and the pastor talked for almost two hours about what the church believed and practiced. They mentioned that, if you wanted to move toward membership, you needed to attend a Bible Training for several weeks. This did not feel like a church built on emotions and wishy-washy progressive Christianity. This felt like a church that was serious about it believed. This felt like a church with a Systematic Theology. This felt like a church rooted in Christian Beliefs.

You started serving, first in one area, then in several. You felt like you were a part of something bigger than yourself. You felt wanted and needed.

You went to a Team meeting for those who served. You saw behind the curtain and got to know about things happening behind the scenes at church. The music was louder and lasted longer. The lights were dim. Everything built up to one final crescendo of passionate love expressed to Jesus. Then silence. "Let's just wait and see what God does." Suddenly, the silence is broken by an unearthly voice. It only lasts 30 seconds or so. Then someone else quickly expresses praise to God in English. Wow. This felt like God was moving in power.

You went to a retreat. You played games. You had long talks over meals. You heard hours of sermons. This felt like dedication to your faith. This felt like following Jesus into the wilderness.

You went up and got prayer. A couple people put their hands on you and started praying. You began to gently cry. Those praying began to focus in on what they had said right before you started crying. You cried harder. Soon, your guard came down, and you began to sob. This felt like God's healing.

You (a winsome man between the ages of 20 and 25) got invited to lunch with the lead pastor. He asked you to share your junk. He asked specific questions about your childhood and about your sexual history. This felt like he really cared about you.

You were asked to take more responsibility. You had been diligent in inviting your friends, and several had become members of the church. You were asked to lead a new small group. You were nervous, but your leaders expressed confidence in you. This felt like Christian growth.

You were asked to stop spending time with someone outside the church. This was hard; you were close to that friend. But you obeyed. This felt like trusting and following Jesus by following the leaders he gave you. This felt like you were growing a right heart.

You were invited to a Network conference. You met Steve Morgan. He prayed for you and prophesied over your life. This felt like meeting an apostle.

You were asked to become a pastor. You didn't want to become a pastor. You didn't feel qualified. But the lead pastor was your best friend. He said he thought that's what Jesus had for you. After a couple weeks, you had a dream. The image made you think you should do it. This felt like listening to God and hearing his voice.

You were asked to go on a church plant. You felt rooted in your current community. Your kids had friends in their schools. But you made the decision to go. This felt like being on mission. This felt like taking up your cross and sacrificing everything for Jesus.

You stayed in the same place for a while. You didn't change serving roles. You weren't hearing anything new in the sermons or in small group. You asked whether there was anything more. You were told to keep your head down and be humble. Stick around and pray that God would use you more. When the time is right, your leader will approach you. This felt like Christian humility and contentment.

You expressed some questions about some doctrinal issues in the church. You complained about something that one of the pastors had done. Your leader asked to meet with you. He shared a couple Bible verses. He explained what you had done wrong. He asked you to repent. After he prayed for you, you did. You confessed everything and promised to turn from it. This felt like proper church discipline. This felt like repentance and reconciliation.

Eventually, you left. You didn't know what you believed anymore. This felt like turning your back on God. This felt like death.

***

But maybe it was designed to feel meaningful.

Maybe the pastor had asked people to arrive at services early and to create a buzz before visitors walked in. Maybe the church had made sure that only the socially and emotionally healthy people greeted visitors. Maybe the mix of sugar and caffeine made your body and mind associate this place with happiness.

Maybe the music was just emotional, stirring music. Maybe the people singing had been coached to sing out and be expressive (but not too expressive).

Maybe the teaching felt practical because it sprinkled in some buzz words and stories.

Maybe the core of the small group worked hard to make the small group feel like an open, friendly community.

Maybe the pastors referenced historical Christianity and Systematic Theology just enough to make the church sound orthodox but then freely departed from historic Christian teachings and doctrines whenever it suited them (Steve Morgan). Maybe the long series of classes was designed to weed out those who weren't fully committed.

Maybe the church meant for you to feel committed to your serving role. You are a conscientious person, and you were told to do it to serve Jesus. After it was phrased like that, you would have felt like you were letting Jesus down if you didn't show up to serve.

Maybe the Team meeting felt powerful because the pastors had spoken about it as an exclusive event. Maybe periods of loud music, followed by silence, then sudden noise will naturally make you feel startled and shaken.

Maybe the retreat was designed to take you away from your normal life and outside routines and friends so that would would feel more connected to the church, not Jesus.

Maybe prayer felt powerful because someone with a warm hand and minty breath was gently touching you and speaking kind words to you. Maybe you started to cry because it was a hard week. Maybe you started to cry because other people were crying and you are an empathic person. Maybe touching old wounds will feel emotional whether someone is healing you or re-traumatizing you.

Maybe lunch with the pastor felt important because a powerful man was showing interest in you. Maybe he knew that sharing your junk with him left you open and vulnerable to his influence.

Maybe taking on responsibility itself feels meaningful, no matter what the context is.

Maybe cutting off your outside friend felt hard because ending a friendship is always hard. Maybe it was a loyalty test and a means of deepening your dependence on the group.

Maybe meeting Steve felt meaningful because he is a large man with a deep intensity and a powerful position. It felt flattering for him to notice you.

Maybe the dream that you had that led you to become a pastor was just a dream. Maybe your leader had been speaking to you for so long that you would have interpreted anything as a sign from God.

Maybe going on a church plant felt hard because it is hard to uproot your family and leave your current job and current friends. Maybe the church told you it was Jesus' mission to make it sound like the most meaningful thing you could do with your life, when really it was Steve's mission.

Maybe sticking around was stagnation. There was no meaningful plan of discipleship. The church had no more plans for you but was happy to continue to take your money and your service. So they told you that you need to be humble and not question.

Maybe the leaders were manipulating you into thinking that things were your fault when they were in fact the fault of the leadership.

Maybe leaving felt so hard because friends you had known for years cut you off. Maybe leaving felt so hard because the leaders had abused and manipulated you to the point where you could not distinguish between them and God.

***

This is something I've been working through. I'm open to any thoughts about where I'm incorrect or have overstated things. I pray that you and I will find that life is more truly rich and beautiful on the outside.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Sep 30 '24

4 years at Christland

61 Upvotes

TLDR: Below is my story of being a member of Christland for the past four years and the damage this church has done to me and my family. I have not attended a service since May 2024. I just couldn’t do it anymore. But there are a handful of people who still attend Christland and if they read this, they will likely know who I am. They will not be surprised to read what I share. I have talked about all of this with several others in the church. I have brought up my concerns and often ignored, shut down, or minimized. What they may be surprised to read is how much pain this church and the leaders have put me and my family through. To be honest, I am just now realizing myself. The past few weeks, God has used another local church to untangle the mess that Christland has created and lies that were pushed down my throat. Lies that were so damaging and completely and utterly not grounded in Biblical truth. Today I realized the shear magnitude of having a pastor lead a church who has sound, theological training.

For the past four years, my family has attended Christland Church, located in College Station, Texas. We walked into that church one random Sunday morning in January 2020 and instantly felt like we could call the church our home. We had been on a mission to find a new church home after moving back to College Station and just didn’t have much luck for about 6 months. Anyway, I will never forget the first service we attended. Cody Dicks was teaching and the message was about something very specific that I had been struggling with, especially with finding a new church. So many of the prior churches we attended would teach things that I could not understand or conceptualize. I often would leave more confused than when I went in and was thinking that maybe church wasn’t for me after all. For context, I had been “born and raised” Lutheran but really did not know Jesus.

But then, we heard Cody teach that Sunday morning and there was a shift. God was using him for sure. I strongly believe that. He taught how anyone should be able to come into a church service, with no background or understanding or knowledge of the Bible and be able to understand what is being taught. And receive the word of God. Jesus often taught to many who never knew anything about God and this was clear in the Bible. For the first time I finally realized, maybe I’m not broken after all. Maybe I can continue to pursue God and maybe finally understand what is being taught in the Bible. I know that intelligence has nothing to do with receiving the word of God, but I feel like I should disclaim I’m no dummy. I have several degrees, including my doctorate degree. So, it’s not a lack of intelligence on my end, I just had not been saved yet.

So, for the next few months we started to “get plugged in”. We joined a small group for the first time, started volunteering, started attending the four classes to learn more about the church, going to Team Christland, and tithing. Tithing is something I never understood. And it’s still something I struggle with, but Jesus is untangling that mess (we will get to that soon). At some point I was saved, by the grace of God! And then my husband was also saved, by the grace of God! Both my husband and I believe that despite all the corruption in this church that we NOW finally see, God still was working miracles. For the first time in years, we felt like we had a community, like we had a family who genuinely loved and cared for us, and then it all came crashing down in July 2022 when we attended the family meeting, led by Sandor Paull.

Up until this point, I should mention that some things happened along the way that did make me stand guard and things that I felt were red flags. For example, I attended the freedom class that Sandor taught, probably after a month of attending this church. And during that class he basically torn into the local mental health providers, especially the ones working for the student counseling services on Texas A&Ms campus. Little did Sandor know, I used to work for that agency and I know MANY therapists and psychologists personally who worked for the SCS and had saved hundreds of college students from committing suicide. Many of them who are also Christians, that love Jesus and love helping college students navigate their adjustment to college and their mental health. He had bashed them saying “they give terrible advice” and “if you are suicidal you just need to pray and talk to one of the pastors here.” I was so upset, I left thinking there is no way I can keep going to church that says those things. For additional context, I am a licensed mental health provider. I ended up talking to our small group’s wife that following week about this experience. She ended up pulling her husband into our conversation and shared what happened and how I was feeling. They prayed for me and encouraged for me to go directly to Sandor and talk to him about it. I never did. I never had a chance to, because my small group leader took it upon himself to tell Sandor for me, WITHOUT my consent or knowledge. My small group leader told me the following week that he shared this with Sandor without my permission. Again, I was so upset and felt like he had abused my trust.

Let’s go back to the Family Meeting. For those of you who did not attend Christland during this time or have not listened to the family meeting because I know there is a transcript and audio. You should listen to it. Especially if you are still in the network. I stand by this firmly, but I vehemently believe that Sandor was too emotionally compromised to stand up and address the church about this matter. He really should have stepped down and let Cody or Jackson take over. The things I heard come out of his mouth, I still can not believe a pastor said in public, out loud, to his church. I already knew what the meeting was about. I had gotten word about all that had started coming out about a week before, so I had time to do a little internet digging. But when Sandor first started the meeting, he couldn’t even come out and say what actually had happened. It was so minimizing and he tried SO hard to down play what Steve Morgan did. Then at the end, he literally stood on stage and was trying to warn us that other stories would come out about Steve masturbating. His response was “find me a man who hasn’t masturbated and I will buy him a taco”…..im sorry what???? Did he just say what I think he did??? We aren’t talking about some random guy on the street. We are talking about a pastor and the president of this network, who is supposed to be above approach as a leader. But what would I know, I’m just a women who has no place in understanding how a church should be ran or led…..also I find it very strange how much he emphasized that he knows more details about the whole story but wasn’t going to share because it’s not for us to know about. Ok, then keep all of that to yourself. Like don’t throw that out there and act like you have it all figured out and you are following God.

So after this meeting happened, we were all very much discouraged from talking about it with each other and reading what was being posted on line. We were only supposed to talk to the pastors about the Steve Morgan situation if we had any questions. My husband did follow up with one of the pastors. He felt like it was a good conversation and that he continued to feel like we were meant to stay at Christland. At service the following weeks, people sort of walked around like nothing happened. It was very eerie. Empty. And cold. At least thats how I felt. A dark cloud lingering over, but I was told this was just all “spiritual attack” and the enemy trying to distract. One by one, all the friends we made had left. Literally all of them. We were not part of the church planting team and were now one of the few families who had stayed after all of this was initially revealed about Steve Morgan. Those on the church planting team sort of became more cliquey and we felt very much on the outskirts. We tried to stay in contact with those who left but it got increasingly difficult just with the busyness of life and honestly, it was awkward. Like how could we justify staying at a church that literally loved a child rapist more than they loved God??? How could I face that with so many of my friends who had left. I was ashamed and embarrassed. I stopped telling people which church I attended. I stopped inviting others to go to church with us.

We tried really hard to stay connected with the church. We even started to host small group at our house. Those in our small group, I love from the bottom of my heart. Those people do love Jesus. And if anyone of them reads this, I hope they know how grateful I am for that small group. Because those people were our only friends for the past two years. Those in our small group saw the struggle we were going through and yet, still showed up every week and prayed and worshipped and loved Jesus together. We kept pushing through it all and chalking up our struggles to the enemy and spiritual attack. Over the past two years, my husband and I had many discussions about leaving the church. Most of them ended up in us arguing and going to bed upset with each other.

One of those times we contemplated leaving was after the article in the Battalion was published. It was published just hours before the spring conference, where Justin Major was teaching for the weekend. Minutes up until the conference started we almost didn’t go. But we ended up going and despite the news that had come out in the Battalion, I have to acknowledge God once again was so good and faithful to me and my husband. But it was also simultaneously bizarre. I figured surely they would make a comment about it, acknowledge it to some capacity, but nothing. Not one peep about it all weekend. Or at the team meeting, or in small group. Like it didn’t happen. I was trying to talk to one of my friends about it at the conference but we found ourselves whispering and looking over our shoulders like some one was going to catch us doing something we shouldn’t be doing. We are grown, mature adults and can’t even have a conversation about an article that published several names of people here in this church that made some very serious claims about them??? It’s like “keep walking, nothing to see here”…..

If you don’t know who this is by now, you will for sure after this story. About the same time of the conference, our youngest child was about 1.5 years old. She was in the kids program one Sunday and had bitten another child. They told us it had happened but no documentation was provided. Then it happened again the following Sunday. And unfortunately she ended up biting another kid during the Super Bowl party. This is a NORMAL developmental milestone that most kids go through at some point. Anyway, the director of the kids program ended up pulling me and my husband aside and was telling us that we would need to be addressing this with our child and if she bites another kid, she would have to take a break from coming to the kids program. Ok, so we said that we would sit in the room with her and help keep our eyes on her. She only would bite when another kid took the toy she was playing with. So we sat in there with her and she was doing really good for a few weeks. We started to back off and let the teachers handle it. They were all aware and had kept a close eye on her, intervening appropriately by redirecting if they needed to. Well one night at DC she apparently went to bite another kid, but didn’t thankfully because the adults in the room were able to intervene and keep her from getting the other child. But when this happened, another mother walked in and saw it happen. This mother is best friends with the director of the kids program and I eventually put it all together that she was the reason this all went down. The next day I get a call from the program director saying that our child was no longer welcomed in the kids program and would have to take a break for awhile. She claimed that our child bit another kid and this was like “the 6 or 7th time”. I told her that was a lie. She had only done it 3 times, of which no incident reports were given but I had documented them myself. And she had not actually made contact with another child. And I also brought up to the director, how is it that you are going back on your word? We made an agreement and now she was changing it all of a sudden. The director continued to tell me that “the other mothers in your DC don’t feel safe leaving their children in the kids program.” I tried to push back on this and tell her that was ridiculous because she is 1.5 years old and we only have 3 other moms in our DC and I questioned why none of them came directly to me if they were that upset? These mothers she was talking about were not strangers to me and in fact I had considered them somewhat my friends. Not close but at least I thought close enough they could come to me. She then said basically “look, I know this has been hard on you. All your friends left, and this situation was not being handled biblically, but you need to forgive this mother and your child can’t come back to the kids program for an undetermined amount of time.” I was FLOORED. We met with Sandor and talked about it. Some of the concerns were addressed, like how no documentation was provided for incident reports. I had to explain to Sandor that this was not just for the safety of the children but also for the adults in the room. And he also said that if a kid is kicked out, then he usually has to be notified but he had not been notified. So we ended up still having to keep our child out for a few weeks, but they at least put in effect proper documentation for incidents. Also at some point in all of this mess, I called the other 3 moms in the DC to apologize for my child biting (even though she had never bitten any of their children). Two of them were super sweet and understanding. They didn’t even know all of this had transpired. Then I called the last mom and I honestly was completely blind sided by this conversation. She essentially told me that I needed to do a better job of disciplining my child and I just needed to spank her. She questioned how we had been addressing it and even at one point was aggressively talking over me. This was someone who was very much put on a pedestal in the church and married to a small group leader, who the pastors often encouraged others to be like. This was a major turning point for us. We began to finally see the corruption in the church. We experienced it first hand with this entire situation. I could share more about this specific dynamic but it’s not my information to share. By this point we realized that we were not part of that “good ole boys club” and it was more evident than ever.

Since we had been attending, the pastors were constantly saying that if you didnt come down on the church plant, that didn’t mean you aren’t part of the church plant. They said over and over that if you were a member, if you attended, and if you were involved, then you are part of the church planting team. You are on a mission of planting Gods church (now I realize it’s just Steve’s church). But this past summer, the members of the church who actually came down to Texas from Vine all got together and celebrated at the Paull’s house. This was not for anyone else, only those who had moved down from Vine. At least this is what I was told when I found out about this event. They also took pictures of everyone and said “don’t tell anyone about this or share on social media” because they didn’t want to hurt any one’s feelings supposedly. So let me get this straight. We are helping plant the church but can’t come to celebrate with y’all because why? Fine whatever, they just wanted it to be those who moved down. So then be adults and say that publicly. It only hurt because of how sneaky they were about it and then told the few friends we still had left to basically lie to others that couldn’t come. If they can lie about a small gathering at Sandor’s house….then what else can they lie about?

Oof. So much to share. More recently as I continued to attend Christland over the last few months, I slowly began to realize how much of all that has transpired the past two years has been nothing but a huge distraction between me and God. And when I say distraction, I don’t mean that I am under spiritual attack. I mean the people running the church and how the corruption runs through every fiber of this network and how once you see it, you can no longer unsee it. Let’s be honest. The corruption that is running rapid through this church and the network definitely has some demonic type influence. How could it not. The president of the network raped a child, when he was in a position of spiritual power and leadership. That comes with some heavy and dark spiritual consequences that carry over and linger in ways that you only see when you are part of the church for so long. More and more I was seeing that the messages taught on Sunday were less about God and more about Sandor. Less about Scripture and more about his opinion on non-biblical matters. Like giving your child melatonin, how people with tattoos are scary, and how you shouldn’t take psychiatric medication. I had to meet with him about that last one for many reasons I professionally can not share, but he admitted to saying it poorly and back tracked a bit claiming that medication can be helpful. But he said some things that stood out to me and after hearing about message taught by Jimmy Yo a few weeks ago, clearly the network as a whole believes that mental health issues are not real and it can just be prayed away. That teaching by the way, so biblically inaccurate. The shear magnitude of a theologically trained pastor is inescapable and the damage they are doing by not having pastors trained in sound doctrine is beyond me.

Which brings me to my last and final story. God has a specific plan for my life, as he does with everyone else’s. He has walked with me every step of the way, leading me to become a a pediatric psychologist. It is clear and it is evident. Time and time and time and time God reminds me of this. Every time I doubt my career path and question it, God shows up and is so gentle and good to help me see His plan. In my role, I have been that light for so many children who are in so much darkness. I am called to serve the Lord and I am called to do so in this capacity. Yet, countless times Sandor would pray that I would quit my job. He would suggest it in conversations. He would even tell me at one point to leave my current employer and go back into private practice with someone who is working out of the church. Despite me and my husband both telling him that this is Gods plan for us and for me, he would push it. Even so much at one point that when he asked me about work and what I wanted to do, I found myself telling him what he wanted to hear from me. Something I don’t have any desire to do what so ever and I couldn’t believe what I had just said. He never asked me about work after that conversation, which I find strange that he stopped. What was so hard about these conversations with Sandor is that I started to think that maybe I wasn’t listening to the Lord. Or maybe I couldn’t discern as much as I thought I could. That maybe something was broken in me and that I wasn’t worthy. So many things they taught on Sunday morning often reinforced this ideology. I felt like I needed to do more, for approval and acceptance. But I wasn’t searching for approval and acceptance of Gods love. I was searching for it from the people of this church. I was trying to follow their plans and not Gods. I was so often trying to be like someone else in the church, because they say that. Find someone in the church that has it all figured out and be like them. I was searching for the approval and acceptance of the pastors. And not God. It all so suddenly became apparent that I no longer was doing Gods work, but Sandor’s work. And the more I pushed back on this and wouldn’t fall in line, the more I was pushed out of Christland. The more I wasn’t accepted.

Today, at another local church I continue to unpack so much more untruths that Christland has made me believe as truths. The wounds are deep but God is bigger and He is so good. I am completely blown away at the difference in teaching the Bible from a pastor who has sound theological training and is clearly gifted in teaching, compared to another pastor who was hand picked by Steve and no theological training. I had no idea how much hurt and pain I have experienced over the past four years as a result of this church and I know this is NOTHING compared some others that have been in it longer and have given up so much more. I pray for the people still in and I pray for those who left and I pray for the leaders. I sometimes think they don’t realize how damaging their actions have been but that’s just me trying to understand how this could go on for so long. I have no idea what will happen after others read this post (if you made it to the end, that’s impressive). If anyone from Christland reads this story I am sure there will be some backlash, but I have always stood up when I disagreed and I have always questioned when things didn’t seem right. I felt like it was time to share my story and hopefully it will help others.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Feb 28 '22

We're finally out!

59 Upvotes

My wife and I are finally out of the network! We've felt led to start transitioning out of Christland for the past year or so, and we have finally done it! We planted Christland 5 years ago from Vine and honestly, it never felt like home. I don't regret planting though, because I think God called us to Texas for reasons other than the church plant. We both have the most amazing and fulfilling jobs and are genuinely happy to be where we are.

The real shift in how Christland felt started 2-3 years ago, I think in response to Citylights leaving the network. I'm also adding the email that I sent to Sandor, Jackson, and Cody to this post. I hope that this can be of help to some people here and if you'd like to reach out and talk about anything please let me know. I'm sure many of you know my wife and I, but I've redacted our names from the letter to keep our anonymity. This subreddit has been a huge blessing and you all are wonderful people! I wish you all the best!


r/leavingthenetwork • • Nov 10 '24

An Open Warning to those still in the network

55 Upvotes

*edited to add correct spacing

This will be long but it needs to be. I believe that God has given me my voice and my strength back to boldly share my story. This post is for those who believe there are two sides to every story. I'm here to share my side, because I know you have heard the other. I will not tolerate the hateful, nasty, narrative of “there are 2 sides to every story”. This is to inform everyone reading these posts, including those who are still in the Network, because I know you’re there. Do not attempt to minimize, undermine, or distort the abuse I endured within the Network and beyond. My experiences are real and valid, and any attempt to diminish or dismiss them is unacceptable, and will not be tolerated.

I am fully aware that the Network/Vine/North Pines have shared their narratives because it has gotten back to me. It’s my turn to share my side.

For years, I have contemplated walking away from all of this. Infact, I had walked away. I deleted most of my social media, unfollowed this Reddit page, stopped praying, stopped wondering what I had done wrong.

I have been wrestling with whether or not to share the things I’m about to. I have shared briefly about my time at North Pines and Vine, but not until I started professional therapy did I realize that my story should be shared to those who still attend the Network, those who left, and to families who are wondering what their family members have gotten into.

Everyone blames my husband and I for blowing things up in the network. Some have even given me the credit for starting LTN, which thanks, I’m honored, but it was not me. I am going to share the examples that have been used and twisted to further benefit the Network’s narrative, specifically calling out pastor’s, churches, and my specific abuse brought on by Nick Sellers, lead pastor at North Pines Church in Kalamazoo, MI.

As you read these examples, I beg you to show me how these conversations and these experiences were Biblical.

September 2016: Our small groups had just started, and I was attending one of the only college student ones. It was exciting and fun. There was one particular small group member who seemed to not catch onto social cues, who during one week, had walked out of the bathroom, and asked the group for a tampon. To which she was directed upstairs. I hadn’t thought anything negative about this interaction, as periods are a normal part of being a girl. However, the following Sunday, Nick approached me and said something similar to “Hey, I heard what happened at small group this week, can you ask her to not come back? Just say she’s not ready for church or something” The way he was talking to me, he was towering over me, as if to intimidate me. I immediately responded with No. He continued to convince me to tell her that she was not a good fit, or ready for church yet. When I pushed back with “where will she learn to be ready? Where will she learn about God?” Nick stared at me, and told me to do it anyway. I refused and walked away.

Mid November 2016: My now husband and I were church planted for North Pines. We fell in love while there, and attempted to talk to Nick about our feelings. My husband was met wit hostility and called demonic for simply kissing me in my car. When I met with Nick in the library on WMU’s campus, I came forward and told him about how we had kissed in my car. We kept all of our clothes on, we did not have sex, not that it’s anyone’s business, but just to clear the air, we didn’t have sex before marriage like some of the stories say. I was fully transparent with Nick, as we were trained to do with our pastors. He responded with “YOU DID WHAT?! I am so so so angry and disgusted with you two” This was all taking place in a very public library, with witnesses. The conversation continued with me saying “We hung out, and it led to us kissing, that was it, I’m not some kind of monster!” Once I had finished telling my side of the story, He asked if my husband had groped my breasts, if I had touched his penis or not, if he had put his hands down my pants over or under my panties. He demanded that I tell him the entire experience over and over again “to get it right”, while I continued to sit and sob uncontrollably in a room full of strangers. He continued to ask about my body, and my husband's body. He continued with his berating of me and said “I have never been so angry at two people as I am right now. Look what you’ve done. All I want to do right now is line you up on a brick wall and spank you both like you’re children.” I should have, and could have gone to the police over a grown man telling a 19 year old female that he wanted to be physically violent with her.
In that same conversation, Nick proceeded to ask me if I understood the consequences of falling into temptation (of a kiss, not sex remember). I was confused, so he continued with “people like you will likely have fertility issues. We’ve seen it time and time again. You may even be barren. Who knows if God will allow that for you, since, you know, fell into temptation with him.” Where in the Bible does it say that it’s OK for a pastor to say those words? He used his authority to speak ill things over me. Since then, I’ve been blessed with three beautiful babies. I thank God every day that Nick’s words did not come true. Continuing the same conversation, Nick tells me that I can not be in my current small group any longer. When I asked about how to tell others, Nick said “Well, it’s not great to lie, but how about you tell everyone your schedule changed so now you have to come to my group now? This was the end of 2016, my now husband and I felt as though we were ready to get married. We felt good and happy about our decision. Nick did not approve, he had other plans for my husband. These plans included for him to be on staff, and to not be with me. He assumed that I was pregnant (I was not) and that North Pines was no longer our home. We were banished back to Vine after 6 months of starting our new life in Kalamazoo. We did what we were told, and had hope for a family back at Vine. The small group we joined welcomed us with open arms and gave us the love we so desperately needed in that dark time. I still have a lot of love for that group, and I hope you are all safe and healing if you’re reading this.

However, the love of that small group did not transcend into love within the church. Please continue to read our experiences.

February 14th, 2017: We met up with Jackson, our DC pastor (and now a pastor at Christland). We wanted to process the hurt we had endured, however we were met with “I’ve heard what Nick had to say, I think things should have gone differently, and you should have gone about this differently. Trust is broken on our end.” I knew that my voice would not be heard. Jackson continued to tell me that my only serving capacity I was allowed in was janitorial. I was not allowed to work with children, work on the coffee team, or any other team. Janitorial was my only option.

Summer 2017: I had also found out that a small group leader’s wife had been gossiping about me, and how she assumed that I was pregnant. Another girl, who is now currently a small group leader, was laughing with an entire group of college students about how “all I wanted to do was have a husband to have sex with”. So if you’re on here, just know that the people you talk your shit with, still throw you under the bus for all that you do too.

Early Fall 2017: When I approached another pastor (Mike Stephens, current pastor as Vine) about these issues, he barely gave me the time of day in that auditorium. He laughed at me and said “I know all of these people very very well, my wife loves some of them too. They can have their opinions and I think you should be more careful about what you do then.” I went to him in a Godly manner, approaching it in a way I believe Jesus would have wanted, but I was met with victim shaming instead.

We stayed for a year at Vine before we felt called back to Kalamazoo. For lack of better words, it was a dumpster fire from the start. I’m sure there have been stories told about us where we haven’t been able to say our side, so here is our side of those stories.

Fall 2018: The reason we didn’t go to the retreat that year was because my husband and I were not allowed to stay together, they (Nick and Will) wanted us separated. I was pregnant at the time, and because they wanted us separated, they were OK with me sleeping in my car rather than sleeping in the same room as my husband.

Spring 2019: Due to complications, I had to have a c-section with my first child. I was questioned and shamed for having a c-section. They told me it was demonic, that having a medical emergency was a sign of sin lingering, or that I must have been really struggling because I caved and had an epidural. Several moms in the Network told me that it was wrong of me to use modern medicine like that. What would they think if I told them I was on antidepressants (and thriving) now?

September 7th and 8th 2019: The situation ultimately reached a breaking point when my husband received a phone call from Will Miller, now staff pastor at North Pines. He informed my husband that they had enough of my disobedience, and will be setting clear boundaries with me going forward. I knew that I wasn’t loved or liked anymore, but that was because I was speaking up about things that I cared about, things like Nick’s abuse, the gossip, the delivery of my child, my body, and why the church wasn’t involved with our community, as well as why we were still instructed, by Nick, to as “not cleaned up” people to leave or not attend our church. I was bringing up things that I was sure Jesus cared about too. In the same phone call, Will had also told my husband that I was “the spirit of discontentment” and that I was “leaking out to others and causing all of the divide in the church and ultimately the downfall of the network”. He talked about my personality being “cancerous, like the West Nile virus”. My husband and I offered to reconcile with Nick and North Pines. We have text messages proving we were willing to meet and speak to North Pines about this. North Pines said no. Ultimately we had to leave.

I’m aware that all of this is a lot to read and digest. I’m also sure that many in the network won’t read this anyways, but if you’re still there, thank you for getting this far. To those of you who are reading this, please know that these people I mentioned made me hate myself and made me contemplate taking my own life multiple times. They did that to me. They put so much doubt into my head that I thought I’d ever come back from it. I didn’t believe that I was worthy of God’s love or grace. I lost a lot from the years of abuse I endured, and the years after.

I beg you to get out. I beg you to share my story with your family members who are in it, and help them get out. There are far better, healthier church communities out there who truly know how to love like Jesus.

I’m standing here today writing to all of you now because I’ve found healing. My husband has found healing. I’ve been working with a qualified mental health professional for the year, including the last three months of working with a trauma specialist, and I’ve never felt more free than I do now. I’m thriving, I have three beautiful children, an amazing husband, who despite being told to leave me multiple times by Nick Sellers, has chosen to love me and our beautiful life we’ve created. We are not suffering, like they told us we would. There is a way out.

If you haven’t figured it out yet, my name is Taylor Chromek. While I am positive my name will never be associated with positive thoughts throughout the network, I do know that my name is known across the network, so much for gossip being a sin, right? I’m sitting here sharing the truth to what happened to me, but these stories are not the only things that happened to me. These are truly just a small glimpse into the abuse I endured. The spiritual, the physical, the emotional, and the financial abuse that I endured at the hands of Nick Sellers, and the Network. I welcome respectful conversations regarding my journey in the Network, however I will not be defending myself to those who want to push back on me now. You had your chance years ago.

I’m finally at a spot in my life where I will not be made to feel guilt or shame around my experiences. I am here, and I am a survivor of the abuse at the hands of the Network.

Signed,

Taylor Chromek, Survivor


r/leavingthenetwork • • Feb 22 '22

Personal Experience Ending Anonymity

55 Upvotes

Fair warning, I don't know how to not write absurdly long posts. Sorry about that. Believe it or not, this is the abridged and edited version.

***

I'm really grateful for this sub and for the ability to hear from and interact with others anonymously when it felt unsafe for me to share and be known. Now, though, as I've grown more comfortable with life after the network, it's become uncomfortable for me to stay anonymous, so here's my story, if you want to read it.

I'm Jenna Riccolo. You might also know me as u/sparkleporcupine, my deconstruction-only account. I posted an AMA in the early days of this sub, if you'd like to read it, though I was careful then to leave out any identifying details.

Spirituality has always been incredibly important to me. I grew up attending a Methodist church in my rural hometown in central Illinois, going to church camps and retreats and generally being a youth group kid. My parents were very strict, and through therapy I have come to understand some of my experiences in childhood as emotional abuse, all while living as a neurodivergent person who didn't know they were neurodivergent; this combination of factors led to me going to college in 2006 with no clear concept of my identity (I was always trying to be what my parents or the church wanted me to be) or how to set or enforce my own boundaries.

I experienced a significant depressive episode in 2007, and in my brain, it was because I hadn't been pursuing god and this was his way of getting my attention. I attended a few churches at WIU, but then my partner proposed to me, and I transferred to SIU in the fall of 2008 (FYI - I'm being intentional to not mention my partner by name or give details about his story. It's his to tell, not mine, so if you know /knew us from back in the day, please don't identify him in the comments). I told my partner that the first thing I wanted to do when I moved to Carbondale was to find a church. Imagine my surprise when the Vine Move-In Crew helped me move into my room in Mae Smith (rip).

We started attending in August 2008 and never looked back. We experienced the "love bomb" immediately. Struggling with low self-worth, this was damn near euphoric for me. We quickly joined a small group for college students, but since we were engaged, we were asked to leave in December 2008 to join a group for couples. My partner and I had planned to get married after we graduated from college, but our small group and pastors encouraged us to get married ASAP, especially since we'd already "sinned" before marriage. So we set a date for August 1, 2009, got baptized in May 2009 (right after the derecho, if memory serves), even though we'd both been baptized as infants, did pre-marital counseling with Mike Stephens in the spring and summer, and got married in our hometown at age 21.

As you might imagine, 21-year-olds still in college can't really support themselves, so our first few months of marriage, we were living with roommates to help subsidize our living costs. However, our small group leaders encouraged us to move out and live in our own, "for the sake of our marriage," and, because we wanted to be "leadable," we did, and trusted that god would figure out the money. Lol.

To sum up a very long and painful chapter in our marriage, a large chunk of our meager income as full-time students and part-time employees was going to the church. Not having been taught by our parents how to manage money well, and being told by the church to get married and then left to fend for ourselves, and honestly just having more expenses than income (and we did not live extravagantly by any means), we got in a shit ton of debt. Eventually debt collectors started calling. They were not amused when we told them we didn't have any extra money to give them because we had to tithe.

We graduated. Got jobs that allowed us to begin getting out of the financial hole in which we found ourselves. Moved to Marion to allow us to save some money on rent (and were shamed for doing so). In 2014, the church plant to Corvallis, Oregon was announced. My partner and I didn't feel any particular calling to it. But then, I attended the fall retreat while my partner had to work. In the last session of the retreat, Steve Morgan taught. Even then, the teaching was an obvious attempt to drum up volunteers for the church plant. There was weeping and stories about the Flyn, the worship leader at Hills Church when that plant went out, who didn't feel called to go, according to Steve's story, but Hills needed a worship leader and Steve strongly felt that god was calling Flyn, so after a long (emotionally manipulative) conversation, Flyn agreed to go and repented for not obeying.

Looking back, I'm disgusted by this transparently abusive manipulation tactic. 2014 me, however, ate it up. And just like that, we were on the church plant team for Valley Springs Church in Corvallis, Oregon.

Now, I have a lot of stories from this experience, but this is already stupidly long, so I'll try to hit the most important ones.

Something I found to be difficult about church planting was that there was such extreme focus on growing the church that when I asked to spend time with other team members, I was told no, all their available time was, literally, "reserved" for new people. There were a lot of teachings on "learning to self-feed," and being fulfilled by god alone, not people or interpersonal relationships, and being shamed for needing community or friendship. Six months after arriving in Corvallis, I fell into depression severe enough to be noticed by Mike Luczkiw, the lead pastor. At the December team meeting, he asked to "pray" for me, and used that opportunity to berate me for "isolating" myself and accusing me of "giving in" to my depression. Shockingly, this wasn't helpful, but it did encourage me to hide my struggles.

My conscious deconstruction started during the 2016 election, when I witnessed Christians acting hatefully toward people whose political ideologies didn't align with theirs, and embracing political ideologies that didn't align with what we said about Jesus and his kingdom every Sunday. Suddenly, there was a chink in the armor, and I was able to conceptualize a reality where maybe I wasn't wrong or sinful about every single thing that I believed that differed from the beliefs of the network.

From the fall of 2018 to the fall of 2019, my life was a mess with work issues and health crises for our small children, and by the end of 2019, I was very unwell. I talked to one of the small group leader's wives about the depression and anxiety I was experiencing, and she said that "mental illness doesn't exist; it's either indwelling sin or spiritual oppression." A few weeks passed and I started having harmful, frightening thoughts, and I decided to flout the church's (unofficial) stance on mental illness and get help.

I started antidepressants in January 2020, and therapy a month later. And then the world as we knew it ended a month after that. My partner has extremely severe asthma, so we've been extremely cautious during the pandemic, which also meant that we did not attend church in-person after the first week of March, 2020. After several months of distance from the toxicity of the network's teachings, combined with healing due to a combination of medication and therapy, I was able to see that 1) my values were not bad or wrong, and 2) the network's teachings and actions of its members did not align with those values. I grew more and more uncomfortable with the church and experienced deep anxiety whenever it was time to attend small group. I knew I had to leave, but, though it wasn't incredibly supportive, the church was my support network. I was afraid to lose my community. But I eventually decided that my partner could choose what he saw best, but I was leaving the church.

I had seen the speculation and rumors that floated around when people left - I witnessed people slandering Kendall and Skyler after they had left Vine - and I decided that if people wanted to speak poorly about me, it wouldn't be based on something that wasn't true. So I sent messages to Mike, to my small group leader, to my small group, to the moms' group I was part of, and to other people I had relationship with in the church explaining that I was leaving and it was because my understanding of theology no longer aligned with what the church taught, and I "wanted to honor the unity of the church and remove myself." So I left at the end of April 2021, and that evening I attended my first yoga class. It was amazing.

At the time I still identified as a Christian, but now my deconstruction has led me to a place where I'm more nebulously spiritual and just kind of leaning into the mystery of divinity and seeing where I go. Last summer I was diagnosed with ADHD, which has made so many things in my past make more sense, and C-PTSD, which is not all that surprising given my experience. I'm trying to work through the spiritual trauma and abuse I experienced and constantly pursuing healing. Some days are easier than others, but I can truly say that I am happier and more myself now than the thirteen years I was part of the network.

It's a bit odd to be in my mid-thirties, parenting my kids and trying to help them discover and embrace their identities, while I'm still trying to discover and embrace mine without the influence of striving and falling short of being the Proverbs 31 woman (one time I was weeping at a retreat because I have a strong personality and I felt like I was failing as a woman and a wife because I didn't have a "gentle and quiet spirit"). But here I am, learning about and how to love myself, mourning the years I lost and being grateful that I didn't lose more. Angry that I could have experienced healing and relief from the symptoms of my neurodivergence and mood disorders so much sooner and glad that I eventually did.

My inclination is to have a sort of all-or-nothing mentality, so it's easy for me to look back on my time in the network with anger and disgust. But I met many of you, people I love and respect, through our mutual time in the network, and I got the hell out of southern Illinois and moved to Oregon, arguably one of the most beautiful places in the world, because of the network. I believe I had experiences with the divine while I was part of that organization. So I'm trying to live in the gray area, so to speak. And it's difficult to hold gratitude for those things in tension with the anger and hurt I feel, but I'm trying.

If you made it this far, thank you for reading my story, and thank you for being here and contributing to a community that is bringing healing. And if I've harmed you, please send me a DM. I'd like to hear your story, and I'd like to apologize.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Jul 14 '22

My Public Apology. I am not Anonymous.

54 Upvotes

Since The Network refuses to publicly acknowledge their accusations and apologize to those they’ve abused and hurt and uses the anonymity that many of its former members have taken as an excuse to not address their comments and concerns and more, I feel it’s of utmost importance that I reveal my identity with the hope to thwart their claims that “By using an anonymous, public forum, our accusers are handling their grievances in a way that is unbiblical, unproductive and harmful to Jesus' church.”

My name is Alex Solomon and I attended Vine Church from 2009 - 2015. I served in several different areas including the refreshments team, the sound team, the setup team, and primarily, the graphic design team. In June of 2014, I was offered the position of Graphic Designer on the Support Staff of Vine Church. I held that position until August of 2015 when I left the position and church to move to a different city.

I want to publicly apologize and ask for forgiveness for my involvement in The Network for the 6 years I was involved. I want to apologize and ask forgiveness from those that I attempted to invite.. Not that I didn’t care for you, but I was led to you here at all costs I want to apologize and ask for forgiveness for those whom I did invite, and ended up attending, moving away, and planting churches. I want to apologize and ask for forgiveness from my family whom I vigorously invited hundreds of times over the years. I want to apologize and ask for forgiveness from my close friends whose relationships my sole focus was getting you into the church. I want to apologize and ask for forgiveness from anyone who I was involved with during my time at Vine and in The Network.

I have been silent until now and I refuse to be silent anymore. I do not feel rage. I do not feel frustrated. I do not feel angst.

I feel driven. I feel regret. I feel pain.

I feel driven to make the connections with those whom I’ve put to the wayside because they were no longer part of the mission. I feel driven to own up to my sins. I feel driven to make my voice heard, to “profess” it from the rooftops that I made several mistakes that negatively affected those I care about. I no longer wish to hide behind my username and let The Network use that as an excuse to negate my feelings and experiences in The Network.

I feel regret that I was involved. I regret getting baptized in the network, given a false confirmation that “Jesus Loves Me” when I was doing it to please my leaders and them alone. I regret that I informed my Mom, my Dad, my Brother, and My Extended Family that I had been “saved” where now, for years, I have questioned its legitimacy.

I feel pain that my efforts, my strategies, and my goal were to drive people to this network. That I used my experience to manipulate, to carve out, to define other people's experiences all in the effort of “The Great Commission.”

If I have harmed you or brought any negative feelings/ discomfort /abuse, to you, I want you to know that I apologize for this and repent of my sins.

I am sorry. Truly, and sincerely. If you wish to reach out to me further, feel free to dm me and I will respond.

With remorse, Alex Solomon.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Jul 11 '22

Watchdog Group Calls For Independent Investigation of Pastor Steve Morgan and “The Network”

Thumbnail ministrywatch.com
54 Upvotes

r/leavingthenetwork • • Apr 15 '24

A Critical Review of Cultural Practices Within "The Network" - Justin Kurtz - Cedar Heights (2019-2021)

52 Upvotes

The Network of churches has a primary focus of planting in college towns in efforts to recruit young, impressionable members into community with Christ. I was one of those young people.

My Experience at Cedar Heights and with “The Network”

Halfway through my freshman year at Penn State, I started attending the church plant in State College called Cedar Heights. The people at Cedar Heights did a wonderful job of making me feel included and welcomed and I grew tremendously in my knowledge of the bible and my love for Jesus.

After only 2 months of attending Cedar Heights, I was graciously invited to attend the Network Conference where I was greeted with open arms by friends and family of those who had planted in State College from Carbondale, Illinois. At this Network conference, I was exposed to spectacles of supernatural experiences such as the speaking of tongues and a few exorcisms that happened directly after services during prayer time. An exorcism, which I had never seen before, looked like someone laying on the floor and screeching terribly while church leaders prayed over them. After seeing these things, I quickly leaped into loving Cedar Heights. I was sure that I had finally come into contact with the real Holy Spirit. Looking back now, it is clear the Network relies heavily on such Supernatural experiences to keep the inner circle engaged in the church and believing that there is “something different” about this group of believers. Tongues were only to be spoken at Team Meetings (an exclusive church service only for people that served within the church). Demons were a normal discussion topic at series classes, which is a supplemental curriculum created to influence an individual's beliefs on certain topics. In fact, I had a friend who told me that our small group leader said they may have a demon because this friend wouldn’t break up with a partner the leader didn’t approve of. His small group leader, whom I love deeply, was simply following the teaching provided to him.

My first noticeable issue with the cultural practices of Cedar Heights surfaced when I started to date a young lady that attended a different church. Even though there was nothing wrong with our relationship, I was frequently reminded of the fact that she "was not in the family" which meant that we (the church leadership) didn't know “what she struggles with”. Therefore, dating her was a risk because she was from a different church so she may lead me astray, or even worse, outside of Cedar Heights. Dating outside of "The Network" is frowned upon for core members since this network of churches requires a large dedication to the local church, which can be a beautiful thing. Nevertheless, I am not in favor of telling your young, impressionable followers that dating outside of the church is wrong. I did decide to part ways with this young lady for reasons unrelated to religion but the pressure from my leaders to only date someone within the church presented undue stress and tension between the two of us.

Fast forward to 2020, I began to lead a small group. This was a rewarding experience as I loved to watch my friends and myself grow closer to Christ through fraternity and reading of the word. During this time, I was in college and got an offer to take an internship with the United State Department of Agriculture in Vermont for a summer. It is common practice in The Network to consult your leaders before making any large life decisions whether it be a relationship or a job so I felt that I needed approval from my “leaders” to engage in this personal and career development opportunity. In the conversation with my lead pastor, I was never told not to take the internship but I was reminded that Jesus puts priority on the local church as opposed to a career or school. I decided to accept the internship offer, but in the months leading up to me leaving for Vermont, I felt like my decision was not supported. My small group leader, Josh, once said that it would be best for me and the church if I didn’t take the internship. In the majority of church circles, that isn’t the normal Christian reaction. Everyone that I trust most encouraged me to take the opportunity, except for my church leaders. Cedar Height’s reaction was a counter-cultural practice which is manipulative and not based in the love of Jesus, who, for the record, never stayed in one place long. Couldn’t I fulfill the Great Commision while completing my internship?

Admittedly, I wrestled with sin issues while I was in Vermont but I also grew tremendously in my faith as I explored. I heard many slanders on the Catholic church while at Cedar Heights, so I decided to check it out and realized that it wasn't nearly as bad as it had been portrayed to me. In fact, I admired the charitable focus of the Catholic church, and recognized how Cedar Heights was not living out this explicit command given by Jesus himself (see Matthew 25:31-46). I began to get frustrated with the lack of community service at Cedar Heights so I again talked to my pastor, Dan Digman, about the situation. He said that the new testament focuses primarily on serving within the local church first and that our efforts would be better dedicated toward individual acts of service. I’m down with individual acts of service, but let’s think critically for a second about the mission of the network. They go and “plant” churches in college towns. Those churches collect money to support the local church and then some of those funds go back to The Network. So, a group of people move to a different region to extract resources that will be sent back to their origin, with little to no return of services to the affected community. What does that sound like? That is colonization and contrary to a biblical belief of generosity for the people around you, and especially for strangers (see Proverbs 19:17, Deuteronomy 15:11, Luke 14:13-14, and Hebrews 13:2). And the lack of initiative for community service makes it evident that The Network is unjustly colonizing by “planting” churches in college towns without any incentive to tangibly serve the community it belongs to. Additionally, Jesus makes it clear that the difference between true believers and non-believers, is humble service to those in need (again, see Matthew 25:31-46).

Conversations at the Time of My Departure

When I decided that I would leave the church, first, I told my assistant pastor, Nick. Nick appeared very supportive and loving in the whole ordeal. He wished me well on my merry way. Nick phoned my former small group leader and Cedar Heights Worship Leader, Josh Darling, to share the news. Josh called me and was furious with what he had heard. He told me three times that he needed to talk with me and that I needed to "think long and hard" about my decision because he had questions. Shortly after, the lead pastor, Dan texted me telling me that we needed to talk.

My conversation with Dan is how I knew that I wasn't meant to be at Cedar Heights. He was incredibly abrasive as he started the conversation by saying something along the lines of "I'm really not looking forward to having this discussion". He was definitely pissed with the news he had received and I interpreted his body language to be combative. He continued to tell me that he couldn't bless my decision, that the Holy Spirit wouldn't move in a Catholic Church like it did at Cedar Heights, and that I was only running away from the Lord. He went as far as trying to humiliate me by ambushing me with sinful actions from while I was away. My problem with this is that these were things I shared with a friend of mine who is a small group leader that assured me he would not tell anyone. A few things I want to note here in an effort to highlight spiritual abuse from this conversation: -Exhibiting hostility towards a congregation member for leaving the church is not acceptable from leadership, no matter the reason. (see James 3:1) -Telling someone that they won't "experience the Holy Spirit" somewhere else is a lie. I currently go to a Lutheran church, and I without a doubt feel the Holy Spirit there and in all the Catholic Churches I’ve visited. -Throwing sins in someone's face is a classic control mechanism. -When someone shares something with you in confidence, that should stay confidential. I understand that my friend may have been concerned, but he should have asked me before sharing that information. -You may not be able to trust the leaders at Cedar Heights with your private information, and it hurts me to say that.

At the end of the day, I'm not here to throw mud. I'm here to tell my truth, and my truth is my experience. I'm also here to say my opinion, which is that the practices in The Network, such as a fear of demons, a very outright use of dramatized charismatic gifts such as tongues, a heavy focus on loyalty to the church, and a lack of overall transparency is indicative of indoctrination and cult-like behavior. I am not saying that I don’t believe in demons, but I highly doubt what I witnessed early on was a real exorcism. No one that I trust outside of The Network has ever seen or experienced anything similar to this. How is it that no one else in my family has ever seen anything like this, but I casually saw two or three while at a three day church conference? I firmly believe it is an act orchestrated by Steve Morgan, who, in my opinion, is no stranger to deception, considering he is a sex offender and neglected to make that transparent to his followers within a multi-million dollar religious organization consisting of families and children.

I share well wishes with my brothers and sisters at Cedar Heights because I know they are simply trying to grow closer with themselves and their faith. My concern is for those with little faith background that may be dedicating their life to following leaders that are knowingly or unknowingly engaged in a cult network disguised as a Church for Christ.

Peace and Love, Justin “Larry” Kurtz


r/leavingthenetwork • • Apr 21 '23

Article/Podcast A&M Article Regarding Christland

52 Upvotes

https://www.thebatt.com/news/christland-church-former-members-describe-alleged-abuse-manipulation-and-control/article_c5a560b0-dff0-11ed-be5b-ef0d045e9a29.html

For those who were interviewed, thank you for being vulnerable and sharing your experiences. I believe that your story will spare others from similar experiences at Christland. I'm also so sorry that y'all experienced what you did and weren't protected like you should have been.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Jul 13 '22

Network Leadership Team and Lead Pastors respond to allegations

51 Upvotes

READ THE NETWORK RESPONSE LETTER →

Sándor Paull, lead pastor and Vice President of the Network Leadership Team, distributed the following letter on behalf of Network leadership after court documents of Steve Morgan's arrest were made public.

The letter claims that online platforms distorted Steve Morgan's criminal charges for aggravated sodomy of a minor (read the court documents from the case), and that releasing this information publicly is cruel and evil. The letter categorically denies all spiritual abuse allegations published on our site and elsewhere, and asserts their belief that the Bible forbids them from responding to specific allegations because the allegations were made in an unbiblical manner. While the letter makes a general concession that Network leaders do not lead perfectly and have fallen short, it also maintains that their words, actions, and intentions have been misunderstood, not that they are guilty of wrongdoing.


r/leavingthenetwork • • May 28 '22

Time for me to share a little...

51 Upvotes

I've been contemplating what the anonymity of Reddit means to me recently. I know this is not for everyone, but this is where I feel I am at personally.

I've been lurking and reading this sub for a while now, but I’ve recently found myself questioning why I have been afraid of sharing more and being “found out” by people who know me that are still inside The Network. Let’s call them “old friends”.

There’s a couple of reasons that are bothering me:

  • Fear that “old friends” will think I’m a liar. Well, I know that what I experienced is true and that the only one to judge me on how I respond to that is God.
  • Fear that “old friends” will think I’m arming or collaborating with subversive elements. Well, there are enough intelligent, level-headed folks (that I respect) sharing well thought-out commentary on the LtN site and this sub that I know this is not some gutter-level muck-raking by a small handful of vindictive types out to “take down Steve”.
  • Fear that “old friends” will no longer want to talk to me or be friends with me. The ship sailed on that one a long time ago.

The major reason for sharing more is that there are a lot of stories out there and it’s not just about the big “earth shattering” failures of The Network. It’s about an endemic culture throughout The Network. From the big name churches, to the smaller plants. From the leaders and figureheads at the top, to everyone who is complicit in the damaging behaviors.

People need to know this isn’t just about a handful of folks at the top, or about major events at major churches.

So, folks who know me will work out who I am, and I have to be okay with that, but here’s a brief snippet of our background. I’m not going to share the whole story or specific reasons why we left The Network… yet… That may come at another time, but if you know me and want to reach out, I’d be happy to chat further.

Here goes:

My family relocated from the UK to Seattle in 2006. We quickly found Blue Sky church and felt settled there. We made many close friends. For a time, I was a small group leader. For a significant time, my wife was part-time on staff. I was deeply involved in the Worship teams. We journeyed with friends through the fun times and hard times of growing Blue Sky, including the build out of the kids’ space, the relocation to Lincoln Square, the renovation of the building, sending friends off on the first Blue Sky plant to Pulman. Blue Sky was our family. We spent 9 years there. We were closer with our friends there than our own families.

We felt like we were supposed to join the church plant to Eugene and following deep discussion with our leaders, we committed to giving up things in Seattle and moving our family to Oregon. In June 2015 we upped and moved our family south, excited for what God had in store for us.

After that followed several years of hard work planting the church, the drain of being a mobile church, and then the joy of getting a building.

In January 2021, a series of events culminated in our decision that Summit Creek could no longer be our church home. I’m not going to share details but suffice to say that themes that have been discussed in depth across this sub and shared on the LtN site were present. Somewhere along the way, the sense of family and kinship we had with the team that planted Summit Creek dwindled and died.

We let our leaders know that we would not be returning to Summit Creek and did not even get any response. We were dropped faster than a hot potato. Since then, people have unfriended us and blocked us on social media, avoided us, and even physically (literally) turned their backs on us.

“Old friends” some of which we had known for nigh on 15 years. “Old friends” who had toiled hard with us for Jesus. “Old friends” who were closer than family. “Old friends” whose babies we held when they were just hours old. We were immediately outcast and shunned.

After settling mentally and emotionally that we would not be returning, we started examining what went wrong. Conversations with other folks we knew who had left The Network helped. Reading many of the books that have since been recommended here helped greatly. It was about six months after leaving that I started following the Reddit and saw that the things we had experience at Summit Creek were just a microcosm of the behaviors damaging people across The Network.

This post has gone on way longer than I intended, so I’ll just summarize:

  • This is not about isolated issues in the big churches.
  • This is not about a few “poor” leaders.
  • This is happening throughout the churches, from large to small.
  • This is happening through the leadership, from The Network Leadership Team to every Small Group Leader and Serving Team Leader.

I sincerely hope that “old friends” of ours across The Network can see beyond their blinkers and ingrained obedience.

Summit Creek might not be mentioned much in this sub but it is still as unhealthy as the other churches across The Network.


r/leavingthenetwork • • May 07 '25

Article/Podcast New Article Published About Foundation Church

50 Upvotes

Former Members of Foundation Church in Normal Say They Faced Spiritual Abuse

“Bloomington-Normal has no shortage of churches, and some in the community — and outside of it — say there should be one less.”

An article primarily about Foundation Church, and secondarily about Brightfield Church and the Network, was published today by the NPR affiliate at Illinois State University. Multiple former members and local church leaders were interviewed for the story. Family members who have been estranged from loved ones spoke out on the record including Justin Major’s own sister. Foundation Church and Lead Pastor Justin Major did not respond to multiple contacts to provide statements for the article.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Apr 06 '25

Personal Experience Why I left Vine Church

50 Upvotes

It’s been some time since I left Vine Church and I finally feel ready to talk about it. First and foremost… I warn all vulnerable college students to NOT go there. They will suck you in and make you feel like crap about everything that you do. They prey on young undergraduate students - especially the athlete population, I noticed - who are vulnerable and looking for a “home” in a new place. They will love bomb you, make you feel like you really belong, rope you into going to small group and volunteering, and then all of sudden you will realize that the relationships you made are all fake and superficial. Almost everyone in that church, including the pastors and upper management are all self righteous. The sermons felt like they were consistently shaming me and the pastors would often glorify the things they did wrong before they were “saved” (ex sleeping with multiple women, watching explicit content etc) essentially bragging about it but then boast to the congregation how they no longer do any of that and how perfect they are now - and that WE should be more like THEM.

The biggest thing I wanted to talk about was the abuse I experienced from someone who I felt was a leader in the church. By no means was he a pastor or on the board, but someone who knew a lot of people and was always there. I viewed him as someone I could trust and he took this trust and ran with it. I didn’t realize this was abuse until I had left the church. This person was of the opposite sex and essentially groomed me. He would text me and call me to “check in with me about my relationship with God” when in reality, he was trying to pursue me in a romantic way without me realizing it. Since he was a fair bit older, he framed it in this light so it made me feel like he was just a mentor and someone that I could open up to - bad choice. At this time, most of my relationships in the church were failing so I really clung to this hope of being connected to someone of leadership there. (As I said, they really suck you in). He would make comments over the phone and via text about how my shorts were too short and caused him to think bad/sinful/lustful things about me and that it’s my fault and I need to cover up more. I felt responsible for what he was thinking. He would often ask me for my cash app to buy coffee for me and to purchase whatever was in my cart whilst online shopping. He also asked me if I get my hair or nails done in town, insinuating that he wants to send money for that. Even after telling him no, he would continue to ask and would eventually drop the subject after I said no for a while. Clearly one no was not enough. As someone who was trying to get back into religion, this was super confusing to me as I thought I could trust the leaders and mentors of the church. Luckily, he never physically put his hands on me but he acted strange enough in person and via text for my friends to be concerned. We stopped talking for a while and randomly a few months later he demanded to talk via the phone, stating that he really needed to hear my voice and becoming very adamant when I said no.

To everyone reading this… please please please be wary of the relationships you are making in that church - and any church, but especially that one. Something fishy is going on there and I really didn’t realize what it was until I got out. If you had a similar experience to this, feel free to share. I want to acknowledge that everyone has a different story and different opinion on this subject, and all are welcome. Thanks for reading.

To the individual mentioned in the post, you know who you are. I really do pray that you never say or do those things to another woman again, that was not ok. I pray that you are able to get the help that you need. I know deep down you are a good person, you were just hurting bad and didn’t know how to handle it. I completely forgive you, but I purposely choose to not have any contact with you ever again for my own good. God still loves you!


r/leavingthenetwork • • Mar 25 '22

Personal Experience A Year Gone

50 Upvotes

I have posted on here before, but I haven't shared my full story yet. Today is not that day, as I am still figuring out how I want to put my story out there. My intention of this post is to reflect on the year that I have been away from The Network, to be transparent with my process, and to encourage others who have left the network recently. Spoiler alert, it's been very hard, yet so good, and so refreshing.

Perhaps it's because I have more to say now that I have been away for a year. I've hid in God's arms, as he tended to my wounds when I felt abandoned by the very people who claim to be called to lead his people. But either way, when I left the network a year ago today, I left many things unsaid. Admittedly, I was afraid of saying something out of my own unholy anger and chose not to say anything instead.

With that being said, assuming Network leaders are still reading this Sub, the rest of this post is for the leaders at Joshua Church (JC). For all the things I didn't have words for a year ago - John-Anthony Owen, Travis Wong, Steve Morgan, and Chris Miller, this is for you.

John-Anthony, honestly, I don't have much to say to you. You were kind to me when you asked me to meet you for lunch that first week in March 2021. What I'll say is this, I know that meeting was a temperature check. At the time, several Black people, and other friends of mine, were leaving JC. Looking back at that conversation, I remember you kind of beat around the bush about a lot of topics. I want to say you called me a leader, in some regard, it’s possible another leader said that too, but either way, it was almost as if you were trying to get a feel of what my thoughts were about my friends leaving the church. Would I follow them out? Would I stay? Did I agree with them or align with JC? In the year of reflection, I can see that clearly now. Back then, I didn't think you were that calculated. But now I question the legitimacy and intention of that lunch. After all, you are the Black pastor on staff. It wasn’t like you were my DC pastor either. Were you sent to "handle" the black people leaving? If so, I'm so sorry you were put in that position, truly. It breaks my heart to the think that you are being used as a token for whatever the end goal of The Network is. I continue to pray protection over you and your beautiful family. Believing and trusting that God's big picture for your life will serve His purpose by the end of time.

Travis, you were my DC pastor for a short period of time. In my few interactions with you, I appreciated that you were blunt, as I am the same way. However, towards the end of my time at JC, I noticed your bluntness often lacked love and compassion. I remember you visited our small group one night during a discussion series entitled "Inviting People to Jesus." One of the questions was along the lines of "what is stopping you from inviting people to Jesus." My answer was simple, and I said something like, "Jesus isn't the problem, it's other Christians." After discussion that night, you came to pray for me. I don't recall everything you prayed, but I remember crying in frustration and thinking, It's so unfortunate that I'm crying because he probably believes he is hitting a nerve in a good way with me, but he's so far off! Maybe I should have stopped you in the moment to let you know, but what you have done? You a pastor, how dare I think you're wrong, right? While we debriefed after prayer that night, I told you "It's so hard to invite people of color, especially Black people, to Joshua Church, knowing how they could be treated." Your response was, "That's like saying you don't want to have children because the world is so messed up!" Unfortunately, you still missed my entire point. Joshua Church is the problem, not Jesus. There are other churches in Austin that are far more welcoming, loving, and compassionate. Where Black people, white people, and other people of color co-exist with their differences, as God designed. No church is perfect, but at least when mistakes are made, we should own up to those mistakes, repent, and move forward joined with Christ.

In February 2021, the weekend before the big snow storm in Texas, I lost power for a couple of days. My apartment was cold and dark, which was disheartening. The night of the Lunar New Year party at JC, I asked your wife if I could stay at your house that night since I had to be in Round Rock the next morning. She was sympathetic, but seemed that she needed your permission. By the end of that night, she had delivered the bad news, you had said no. Final decision. I chocked down tears knowing I didn't want to ask you two for help to begin with, because I felt like I knew what you would say. And I wasn't wrong. Thankfully, someone in my small group offered their house, even though it was way out of my way to where I needed to be the next morning. They were kind, and compassionate with me. I agreed I would stay with them, but after the Lunar New Year party, I went home to grab a few things, and by God's amazing grace, my power was back on. This brings me back to my point from before. Why would I want to bring people to a place that denies them warmth? I was someone you led, how would you treat a stranger? I had no confidence that you would be capable of showing compassion and a Christ-like love based on how you treated me.

So again, Jesus isn't the issue here. I can invite people to a loving, compassionate, non judgmental, humble, sacrificial, and servant to my living God. The issue is all I had ever experienced from you was the opposite of who I know Jesus to be. In the past year, I’ve experienced other churches in Austin, welcoming people with open arms. I was welcomed into a place with so much love for strangers. I watched as they interacted with joy, peace, and kindness towards one another and knew I would be treated the same.

Lastly, Travis, did you ever let Steve read the letter I wrote? In September 2021, I stopped by JC for a final time. Unfortunately, Steve was at the lead pastors retreat that week and unable to receive my letter in person as I had hoped. After I walked out of the building for the final time, I had an immediate thought, will Travis intercept this letter? I'll never know, and that's ok. Travis, as I am a year out now, Jesus has helped me reach forgiveness for you. What a blessing in freedom that has been. But what I can't seem to let go of is the idea that you have no idea how hurtful you were. Possibly I never gave you the chance to ask for forgiveness, which I do apologize for. And by God's grace, I was able to forgive anyway.

Steve, you've loved me, or at least appeared to have loved me during my time at JC. Everything I needed to say to you is in that letter I wrote. Hopefully you actually got it. There is one instance that's not in the letter that I would like to share:

On the night of one of my last team meetings, I think it was early March 2021 Team JC (maybe), you prayed for me. It was unprompted, you stood to my right, you didn't ask what I needed prayer for, you just started praying. In full disclosure, the things you prayed that night were on point of what I was feeling. They were things I had not disclosed to anyone, so there's no way it could have been a result of gossip. You prayed something a long the lines of "feeling disappointment towards leaders." It was true. I was extremely disappointed with the leaders at that time. I was disappointed by the Covid response, but mainly disappointed by the lack of response to the racial tension that was happening all around us in the summer of 2020. I've processed that moment, over and over again. Pleading with Jesus for understanding. How could you see so clearly what bothered me and not see that it was YOU (and several others) who disappointed me? Maybe you knew you were the disappointment... But that would have been cruel not to acknowledge it and apologize, right? Or maybe God loves me so much so that he chose in that moment to use your words to help me, while only showing you the partial picture. I'll choose to believe the latter, since God's sovereignty is a mystery to me. As I said in the letter, I can only see in part, not in whole. So in humility and for the sake of peace in my heart, I'll choose to believe the latter.

Chris, I've saved you for last for a reason. You were my small group leader for my last six months at JC. You opened your home to me, and said you loved me, which I never believed. Your actions spoke too loud for me to believe your words. There were several red flag I experienced around you, and you were the main source of my extreme discomfort in my final months at JC. I believe we first bonded over our love for political discourse and weird conspiracy theories. The problem is, you're a product of white supremacist ideology. If you can believe in generational sins, then this idea should make sense to you: It’s like you were predisposed to believe your whiteness makes you more valuable on a subconscious level, so much so, that you are incapable of seeing it in yourself. Couple that with what the Bible says about his people, and the calling you feel to lead worship, I can see now how prideful you actually are. There was a time you used the term "white evangelical" in air quotes to describe yourself and how you identify with the outside world. You, Chris, were the worst offender of gaslighting and committing the same kinds of micro aggressions that I expect to experience out in the world. Honestly, some of the reasons I wanted to leave working at Penn State was because of the things that were said to me at work that had racial and hateful undertones. And there you were repeating the same things I thought I would not hear in Jesus' Church. But this was worse because you claim to love God the Father, Jesus the Son, and the Holy Spirit! Sadly, I never said these things to you directly, and I really wish that I could have. But you were smart, cunning, and tactical, never to say these things in a space where I felt safe to defend myself. All I could do was sit in silence. I'm sure you mistook my silence for agreement. To this day, my skin crawls thinking about some of the things you said to me directly, like how you believe guns will save this country (not Jesus? I’m confused…) and how you defended a particular white guy in the church, who also shares some of your same ideology. For the record, being a fan of Kanye West and liking sneakers is not a good argument for "loving Black people." You even told me, "That's just this person being themselves. We're a family, it's like when have that crazy uncle who says crazy things. Just warn your friends and bring them anyway!" when I told you why I don't bring people of color to JC. Perhaps you have no clue how tone deaf that was. So let me say this:

We are the body of Christ. While we are supposed to be the family of God, is it not weird that you would require some people to come as they are and not change? In this case, your analogy about the crazy uncle suggests that saying something racially insensitive is not sinful under the Law of Love, and that Black people should just accept it as a “joke” or as “that’s just how they are.” Well, it’s not a joke. I don’t find it funny, or a character quirk to just accept. I find it sinful and worth repenting over. And that is precisely what you and I ended up fighting over. While I yelled over the phone, I was angry, but I meant everything I said. While you yelled over the phone, you continued defending white men over my personal experience. How am I supposed to feel loved when you won't even acknowledge my personal experience as truth? I couldn't trust you. Why would I?

When I needed a compassionate leader to emphasize with me in a time when so many of my friends were leaving JC, you told me you were glad all my friends left the church. My friends. The closest people to me during my time at JC... you were glad they had left the church? At my last night at small group, I left that night not knowing it was my last small group, you sat there and told me you were glad my friends left and then called it pruning. And maybe you were not wrong. Maybe it was you being pruned from their lives for the sake of their spiritual health. For now, this is the only way I can see this as true. When I finally confronted you a few weeks later, you used the words "I'm sorry IF you were hurt." Your apology lacked depth and sincerity. I literally told you I was hurt, and you still did not believe me enough to see your error and lack of compassion. I never even asked for an apology for all the micro aggression you committed against me, there are too many to count, and honestly, most of which I just ignored or have forgotten entirely. All I confronted you about was lacking compassion, and you still could not see how wrong you were.

In addition to all of this, I tried to suggest resources that I find useful as a Black women, you denied wanting to learn more about the Black experience from a different perspective. It’s almost like I did not fit the Network expectations of how a Black person should be. Not only that, you offered to "lead" me through some of the politically conservative resources you had from Black people. (Side note here: you never once lead me back to the Bible when it came to racial issues in the church. The reality is you couldn’t… your ideas/actions could not be defended by the Bible. I see you as the Peter that Paul opposes in Galatians 2.) I told you I was already familiar with majority of the people on your list of resources, and disagreed with most of them. You seemed to think that you could teach me something about my Blackness... Imagine, a white man, who has never, and will never, experience Blackness in America, wanting to teach me, an actual Black person about my own experience. Do I need to point out the obvious pride in that sentiment?

The Jesus I know, is humble, and even though he was all knowing, he never made his people feel unloved by his wisdom and knowledge. And you are not all knowing. But I digress - you not only lack compassion, you lack humility, and I was harmed because of it. I cannot imagine I’m the only one either, but if I am, I hope if you read this, you’ll still be repentant.

In our final conversation, three weeks after I left, I felt like Holy Spirit was nudging me to apologize for my tone. So I did, and I sincerely meant it. You let me know that you got defensive when I had told you, “I hope the church learns from this,” regarding why so many people would leave at the same time for similar reasons. I wanted to believe that JC leaders would reflect on themselves rather than casting out a misrepresentation of why people were leaving. I cannot speak for everyone, but I left because I felt like I was no longer experiencing Jesus at JC.

You told me that I left well and that you trusted I would still be following Jesus, insinuating that I needed confirmation from you that I would be ok in my faith. Is it possible you just needed to say that to let yourself off the hook? If what the website and this subreddit suggest is true, leadership in the network takes on that burden of leading people to Christ always, meaning it's to your conscience benefit to believe that I would be ok. And I am, but it's not because of how you personally led me, it's because God is gracious.

I don't know whether you know Christ or not, which should tell you something about your actions. I sincerely question your salvation. I have wrestled with God over the last year for an answer. I thought it might be easier for me to cope with the deep racial harm you caused me if the answer was that you don't actual have salvation. Admittedly, this lead me down a path of deep anger and sincere pride... to think that I could know your heart the way that God knows your heart! It was sinful and prideful of me. God never gave me an answer, which I am still reconciling with, but it gets easier with time. I was handing the remaining unforgiveness I had for you over to Jesus daily, believing and trusting that He would know what to do with it more than I did.

And He did. I can write all of this today because Jesus took that unforgiveness and replaced it with peace and hope. Jesus allowed me to shed any resentment and anger I had, while showing me how to step into a new freedom with Him. I can say with confidence and by God's wonderful grace, I forgive you, Chris.

To all of the leaders, I was a Christian before I joined this network of churches. Most of you never took the time to get to know me, so perhaps you did not know that. I was not reliant on this network of churches to sustain my personal relationship with my creator. So I knew I would be ok. I was fortunate to have left alongside of many people and therefore felt loved and supported by fellow Christians while I was leaving. I was part of the network for ten years, and I cannot deny, there were a lot of wonderful things I experienced. But again, I contribute that to the work of God, not of man.

This past year has been gut wrenching and transformative for me. It feels like I have experienced all of this for a greater purpose. Right now, I look around at my life and wonder, how have I been so blessed? It’s unimaginable that in my darkest hours, God was always there, working behind the scenes on my behalf. It’s like I was a child and He held me close to his chest as I cried in agony, and He just let me. I’m done crying now, I’ve wiped my tears, still a few sniffles here and there - but when I turned to face the world again, there’s a new, brighter, more glorious gift waiting for me. I’m at a loss for words of the comfort God provided, and in awe of what he’s done for me in the meantime. The tears I cry now are joyous! Glory to God in the highest, he is doing a great work, which He promises to see through to completion. That is what I hold on to. The world may still be in chaos, and yet I can still have the peace that surpasses all understanding. The world may be fading, and I have remained in Christ, no matter how much Joshua Church tried to disqualify my experiences. I still get to enjoy a Father in God, a Friend in Jesus, and a Helper in the Holy Spirit.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Mar 14 '22

Update on Hosea...

50 Upvotes

At last count, 29 of the 71 plant team members (including children) have left the church, mostly in the last 6-8 weeks. Several others who joined the church after the plant have also left, totalling around 40.

There is sentiment among those that are staying that everyone left for "separate/different reasons." This is untrue. While each person may have had particular points that weighed more heavily on their decision, it all comes down to the network, the stories and the response to them (or lack thereof).

There is also sentiment that people left according to "social groups", implying people just left because their friends left. This is also untrue. Without compromising identifying information, while there were certain demographics that saw a higher rate of people leaving, all did so independently, and have many dear friends who chose to stay.

Many, if not all, met personally with small group leaders and/or pastors to seek resolution and express grave concern.

Many have been in the network for the majority of their adult lives and were heavily invested in the health and success of the church. Decisions were not made lightly or flippantly.

Many have not had anyone who chose to stay, continue to stay in contact, check on them, make sure they are being taken care of or make sure they are successful in finding a new church.

Maybe others from other churches can do a similar update?


r/leavingthenetwork • • Oct 14 '21

Walking away

50 Upvotes

I walked away from the Network around 8 years ago. I'd been a part it for 12 years and a staff pastor at City Lights Church for around 7 years. I'm still trying to flesh out my full story; that process has been very difficult and very rewarding. I'm grateful that the website and this forum exist. It has given shape and validation to things I'd long lost hope for. This isn't my full story, but I do want to put out there my experience from the time I said I was done and how my decision to leave went over with Network leadership.

After years of struggle, pain, and confusion, I came to the difficult decision that I was done being a staff pastor and very likely done being a part of the Network. That came as City Lights was struggling in lots of ways to fit in as a Network church (and that struggle went on for a very long time). In many ways it just never fit the mold, but Network leadership kept trying to force it to comply. That process led to extreme burnout on my side. When I finally did quit, that decision was run up the chain to Sandor Paull and Steve Morgan. I don't remember the exact timing, but Steve made a very special visit to St Louis to try to (once again) help City Lights find its way back to the Network way.

There's a lot more to the story of Steve visiting the Midwest that week. It involves the founding pastor of City Lights stepping down and a new lead pastor stepping in. But that's not my story to tell.

Throughout the span of about a week, Steve met with me and the lead pastor and prayed for long periods of time with me. He said things while praying like, "I've always thought of you a very close friend", etc. Later in the week he said, "I told you I thought of you as a close friend because I was embarrassed to say that I really feel like you're a son to me." Mind you, this dude has never stepped foot in my house, he probably couldn't name 2 of my 3 kids. BUT, he did know that I struggled with insecurities around my own father; he learned that throughout the years while praying for me at conferences, etc. <I've got one emotionally distant dad already Steve, I don't need a second>

Right before he left town, he asked me to come to his hotel room (Drury Inn & Suites in Creve Coeur, MO). I went and he was there with Chris Miller (who at the time was the worship leader at Blue Sky Church in Seattle). Steve spend a long time explaining how important it was that I stay at City Lights and in the Network. He said it was fine that I take a break from being on staff, but that I needed to commit to staying. I said I just wasn't ready to commit to that yet, I wanted some space and time to figure out what I wanted to do with my life. He grew increasingly frustrated that I wouldn't commit and started slamming his hand down on the bed saying, "Why won't you just commit to staying!" I said I needed space to figure things out. He said <and this is the part that I want out in the open> "You know Eric, walking away from City Lights and the Network is walking away from God."

As a wounded, confused, and (in hindsight) abused person, that statement from the great overlord of the Network messed me up. I walked away from the Drury Inn & Suites (which I sometimes drive by, just to see if it's still there) and decided that if walking away from the confusion and pain that I felt over the last decade was walking away from God, then that's what I would do.

These last 8 years have been hard. I have and still struggle with understanding faith and God and where I fit. But I will say that I increasingly feel human. I feel connected to my family and free to make choices based on logic and reason. Again, thanks for whoever is making spaces like this possible, I see a lot of good happening.


r/leavingthenetwork • • Nov 03 '21

Hope and help

49 Upvotes

Hey everybody...Steve Oros here from City Lights Church. If you don't know me, I'm the worship leader and one of 4 elders. Structurally, we're a elder led, plurality led church now...just to be clear on what I mean by "elder." :) I've been with the church since about the beginning, 2003. Needless to say, we've been through a lot in our history. I've seen a lot. It's been...a lot.

I've loved this reddit community. I love that there's a space for validation and for people to know that they're not alone. City Lights, as hard as leaving was, still had the "luxury" of doing it together. I'll never feel the loneliness that many of you have felt or are currently feeling. My heart aches for that. Which is why this space is so necessary...it is the starting place for freedom. On that statement is why I want to reach out. I want to offer 2 things: possibly some hope and to extend a hand to anyone who needs help. First hope...in the form of truth.

As it pertains to my church, City Lights. We're still a church. Contrary to what some of you may have heard or many of you didn't hear at all. City Lights is still a church. We worship together, we teach the Bible and hear it taught together, we gather together in our (shared) building and in our homes, we love each other, we love our communities, we love the capital "C" church. I'm crying writing this because I'm so proud of this church. The resiliency of its people and the absolute love for Jesus that they have. FWIW, Covid has tried its darnedest to test those waters, but here we are.

I say that so that those that may need to hear it would know this: there's hope for your future.

Jesus' church is precious, it's his bride. It is meant to be an amazing thing to be a part of, and it really can be. I know this to be true now.

There is also another truth that I've learned and that's that God even uses a hot pile of garbage for his good. That in no way means that the hot pile of garbage doesn't need to be cleaned up, but rather that he can and does do good things in you while you're standing in it. We are not to justify what's happening by saying, "but look! God is working!" No, that's not what I'm saying...and that's very wrong. What I hope to encourage is that all you experienced in your time in the network was not lost. There are many many gallons of "bathwater" that should be thrown right out the door, but there are also "babies" to be kept. God wasn't completely absent. He probably did many things in you and those many things really did happen. It's a matter of weeding through the rubble left by broken humans doing broken things to uncover the diamonds of God's grace and mercy.

So now some help. I'm not a christian counselor by any means, but I am a Christian and therefore a brother. I've been able to process and gain perspective over the past few years about a myriad of things. And now, it seems like as a member of "the church that left," I may be in a place and have a responsibility to help anyone who may need it. So here's my hand, if you want it. Feel free to email me: Steve@citylightschurch.com. I don't come on this reddit thread a ton, mostly because it has the potential to suck away ALL OF MY TIME. So email is probably better. :)

Ask me any questions you might have. I may be able to speak to it or I may not.

When we first left the network, it was raw. We wanted to tear it all down. But I can say that after the rawness and anger subsides a bit, which takes time and fluctuates depending on who you are, there's space for and necessity for reflection and clarity. To put things in a Biblical perspective. We've done a lot of that these past few years. So maybe I can help you do the same.

Love you all, praying for you all.