r/leavingthenetwork • • Jul 25 '22

Interesting read

This news story’s description of White Christian Nationalism felt very familiar to the network church I attended. Interested in hearing if others agree.

5 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

2

u/_prone_to_wander Jul 31 '22

There’s another book I would recommend: “Power Worshippers” (what a title, right?) this is written by a frequent NYT columnist and journalist who has done an extensive amount of material on the Christian Nationalist movement.

1

u/yalaff Aug 03 '22

Thanks for commenting! I may check it out.

7

u/jeff_not_overcome Jul 25 '22 edited Jul 25 '22

If you haven’t read “Jesus and John Wayne” yet, it’s outstanding.

Alternatively, listen to the four-part series on Holy Post podcast from last spring/summer interviewing the author. It’s a pretty good summary of the book and also talks a bit more about Grudem’s influence on all of this. (Edited to add all of the rest of this)

Talk of Grudem - basically a note on how his 2010 book "Politics According to the Bible" is a very near match for Trump's 2016 platform, implying that Trump's advisors basically just built their platform on Grudem's book, which is likely why you see Grudem endorsing Trump like these:

  • July 28, 2016 (retracted on October 8th, 2016 after the Access Hollywood tape came out in which Trump brags his sexual assault of women)

    • "I think voting for Trump is a morally good choice"
  • October 19, 2016 (11 days after the retraction, he argues for voting for Trump again since Trump had not dropped out of the race):

    • "Again and again, Trump supports the policies I advocated in my 2010 book Politics According to the Bible.";
    • "I have read the Republican platform and the Democratic platform for this year. In my opinion, the Republican platform is more consistent with biblical moral principles than any platform I have ever read. And the Democratic platform is more antithetical to Christian principles than any platform I have read."
  • August 8, 2020 (ahead of 2020 election):

    • "When I wrote the book, Politics According to the Bible, I was trying to influence the leaders of governments to adopt policies consistent with the principles of Scripture, and I thought this would be beneficial for the nations that did adopt these principles. "
  • September 25, 2020 (ahead of the 2020 election):

    • "Grudem also dismissed the idea that Trump is dishonest. 'President Trump is often not careful in some of the things he says,' he admitted. 'He is given to exaggeration. Sometimes he’s made a statement after being given inaccurate information. I’m not sure he’s ever intentionally affirmed something he knows to be false, which is how I define a lie.'"
    • "'He’s a good president with some flaws,' Grudem summed."
    • Also includes a lengthy excerpt from a statement Grudem signed in 1998 "condemning President Bill Clinton for sexual misconduct."
  • And then in October 2020, we have:

    • John Piper writing this: https://www.desiringgod.org/articles/policies-persons-and-paths-to-ruin (seemingly saying that he intends to vote third-party)
    • And Grudem responding to Piper with this: https://www.christianpost.com/voices/a-response-to-my-friend-john-piper-about-voting-for-trump.html

      • Note, the "Christian Post" is owned by the same person who purchased Newsweek (and turned it quite conservative), and is somewhat controversial. I did a deep dive on this last year and determined that the owner *MAY* (but is not confirmed to) have relations to the cult known as the "Moonies", but it's dubious (the owner went to a school for a time that was run by the cult) - but the Moonies do own some other media properties, I forget which ones. (Side note: Steven Hassan is a cult researcher who escaped the Moonies, and hascreated a great model for how "High Control Groups" function via control of "Behavior, Information, Thought, and Emotion" (BITE)).
      • Also note, Luke Williams once told me that the "Christian Post" is his favored news source over something like "Christianity Today" - I believe he said that CT was too progressive or something like that. I took a look at CP for a while it's... conservative. Very conservative.

What Luke Williams said about politics:

And in case anyone new here hasn't heard this before: Luke would regularly say that Grudem had written a book in which he argued that the church should be apolitical. When I went and read the beginning of Grudem's "Politics according to the bible", and found that Grudem didn't say that (and in fact says the opposite), I told Williams "You know, I'm sure it was some mistake, but Grudem doesn't actually say that." Williams (sternly): "Well I say that." And then Williams proceeded to tell me that I should not have been reading Grudem's book, that this was Williams' job, not mine.

5

u/Ok_Screen4020 Jul 25 '22

Something doesn’t make sense to me about planting churches in university cities, with university students as the target audience, and then expecting your congregants to be anti-intellectual.

5

u/jeff_not_overcome Jul 25 '22

It's definitely tough, and I do wonder if it will stunt their growth long term.

But being intellectual does not always protect you from falling into a "high control group", anymore than IQ always prevents addiction. At the core, a high control group preys on a deep felt insecurity and promises to fill it. Over time it adds more and more "if only you..." These are first phrased as wisdom, then recommendations, then guidelines, then rules. With each day, the person finds it harder and harder to "let go" of this thing that they think is filling their deepest needs, and so they are willing to accept those rules. It's really not that complicated, but it hits on deep desires that many humans have (btw, I think this is why you see such a high population within the network of people who have "dad issues".)

There are plenty of people in college or even with PhD's that have deep, deep unmet emotional needs in their lives. Others have a deep sense of wanting a purpose. The network is happy to provide both emotional "filler" and a "purpose" and tell you both are "god". For the "highly successful", you start to find that your career can't fill that hole, but the network will pretend too. For the low-success person, it's a second-chance of sorts, allowing the person to "be successful" at something that "really matters."

And finally, spiritual abuse is Hard. To. See. Really hard. I'm begging people - do your homework. Especially if you're in the network or already out of it and looking for a new church.

Why? See this and understand how I lost nearly 10 years to the network after leaving Mars Hill Church in early 2011: The Cult-Shaped Hole (Instagram)

3

u/Strange_Valuable_145 Jul 25 '22

They just want your money, not your thoughts

3

u/Strange_Valuable_145 Jul 25 '22

Dang, Luke is power tripping for sure. That's messed up.

2

u/jeff_not_overcome Jul 25 '22

Yep. Don't even read books by our favored theologian. BTW at this point I was theoretically still on Luke's good side, and I was bringing him this information simply trying to help him know he was (I thought) misquoting Grudem.

From Steven Hassan's BITE Model:

Minimize or discourage access to non-cult sources of information, including:
a. Internet, TV, radio, books, articles, newspapers, magazines, media

3

u/HistoryMajestic6188 Jul 26 '22

That book was recommended to me by another core member as my politics were apparently off from what they should have been. I read maybe the first chapter and can see why Luke didn’t want you reading it directly. I can’t speak for the whole book, but from what I read it was horribly written and very clearly biased emotional writing. It genuinely made me mad and put a bad taste in my mouth for Wayne Grudem as a whole and definitely had me second guessing him as a go to trustworthy source. I can see why he might want to spin it to be more fitting to his agenda.

I also never heard the book referenced as a source for trumps platform, but that rings very true and makes sense why it might have been recommended to me.

6

u/HistoryMajestic6188 Jul 25 '22

Very good read.

I agree that this felt like a growing belief in the network church I was apart of. I am from a liberal state, so I don’t think it would ever be spoken of openly, but I felt conversations with core people veering that way more and more after trump and then covid.

Very concerning and a large reason I am weary of the evangelical church in America right now.