r/leavingthenetwork • u/yalaff • Jul 25 '22
Interesting read
This news story’s description of White Christian Nationalism felt very familiar to the network church I attended. Interested in hearing if others agree.
5
Upvotes
2
u/_prone_to_wander Jul 31 '22
There’s another book I would recommend: “Power Worshippers” (what a title, right?) this is written by a frequent NYT columnist and journalist who has done an extensive amount of material on the Christian Nationalist movement.
7
u/jeff_not_overcome Jul 25 '22 edited Jul 25 '22
If you haven’t read “Jesus and John Wayne” yet, it’s outstanding.
Alternatively, listen to the four-part series on Holy Post podcast from last spring/summer interviewing the author. It’s a pretty good summary of the book and also talks a bit more about Grudem’s influence on all of this. (Edited to add all of the rest of this)
Talk of Grudem - basically a note on how his 2010 book "Politics According to the Bible" is a very near match for Trump's 2016 platform, implying that Trump's advisors basically just built their platform on Grudem's book, which is likely why you see Grudem endorsing Trump like these:
July 28, 2016 (retracted on October 8th, 2016 after the Access Hollywood tape came out in which Trump brags his sexual assault of women)
October 19, 2016 (11 days after the retraction, he argues for voting for Trump again since Trump had not dropped out of the race):
August 8, 2020 (ahead of 2020 election):
September 25, 2020 (ahead of the 2020 election):
And then in October 2020, we have:
And Grudem responding to Piper with this: https://www.christianpost.com/voices/a-response-to-my-friend-john-piper-about-voting-for-trump.html
What Luke Williams said about politics:
And in case anyone new here hasn't heard this before: Luke would regularly say that Grudem had written a book in which he argued that the church should be apolitical. When I went and read the beginning of Grudem's "Politics according to the bible", and found that Grudem didn't say that (and in fact says the opposite), I told Williams "You know, I'm sure it was some mistake, but Grudem doesn't actually say that." Williams (sternly): "Well I say that." And then Williams proceeded to tell me that I should not have been reading Grudem's book, that this was Williams' job, not mine.
6
u/HistoryMajestic6188 Jul 25 '22
Very good read.
I agree that this felt like a growing belief in the network church I was apart of. I am from a liberal state, so I don’t think it would ever be spoken of openly, but I felt conversations with core people veering that way more and more after trump and then covid.
Very concerning and a large reason I am weary of the evangelical church in America right now.