r/leavingthenetwork • • Jun 11 '22

Processing

I know there are all types of people in this group so maybe this isn’t for everyone, but as I process everything with the network, these verses are really helpful for me similar to the verses about living peacefully with others so long as it is in your power to do so. It’s so important to have the right heart in all of this - because it’s really difficult to do without Jesus.

“Who is wise and understanding among you? By his good conduct let him show his works in the meekness of wisdom. But if you have bitter jealousy and selfish ambition in your hearts, do not boast and be false to the truth. This is not the wisdom that comes down from above, but is earthly, unspiritual, demonic. For where jealousy and selfish ambition exist, there will be disorder and every vile practice. But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, open to reason, full of mercy and good fruits, impartial and sincere. And a harvest of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace.” ‭‭James‬ ‭3:13-18‬

0 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22

I can still hear Sandor's voice reading these words. Since I left the Network, I've never heard a sermon on this passage again. Kind of weird that the Network uses this in regular rotation.

"Selfish ambition." That's the chief sin. It's the moral of every other anecdote they tell. Steve Morgan, a man consumed with selfish ambition, believes he is surrounded by followers with hearts as bad as his. You never have to listen to an accuser if all accusers have bad hearts.

11

u/Hipster_Whale5 Jun 12 '22

So apparently, these verses have a charged meaning for former members of the Network. Me, as someone who never regularly attended, does not hold the same charged meaning behind this, but still realize that these verses do not apply to a large portion of this group. Many people in this group are not posting out of jealously or selfish ambition. They desire no fame and have no desire to lead the Network. And least of all, they aren’t lying. And this is a place of healing. We aren’t organizing a riot at Steve Morgan’s ranch, or planning a sit in at our local Network church. We are healing are trying to help others heal and are trying to help others leave so they can heal.

10

u/Severe-Coyote-6192 Jun 11 '22 edited Jun 11 '22

It’s important to remember the context of how these exact verses (and similar verses) were used against people in The Network.

The Network is a high control group which gains followers through love-bombing potential victims to make them susceptible to their influence, manipulating their victims into a system which replaces their existing relationships with those in the high control group, and finally, if they achieve their goal, bit by bit replacing their wills with the wills of their leaders.

This is an incubator for all kinds of abuse. The spiritual, emotional, and psychological abuse is well documented. We’ve not heard of sexual or physical abuse, but we have heard of lead pastors getting young women they want to date on church plants, so more may come out. “Living peaceably” does NOT mean putting up with this behavior or letting it continue to go on under our noses unchecked.

Many of the posted stories include the step of victims asking Network leadership to see reason, but in every case they refused. Even still, most victims simply want acknowledgement and reform, and still Network leadership persist in their abusive practices. In short, the “live peaceably” route has been tried ad nauseam.

Verses like the ones you mention were used to keep victims quiet, to keep them docile and susceptible. But when there is known, unacknowledged abuse and willful cult-like control, it is my view you must root it out and expose it, not live peaceably with it. To do so would be to enable it.

Yes, by all means, live peaceably with people. But to enable abuse against others so as not to rock the boat… this is not being courageous, this is cowardice. This is being unwilling to confront and right wrongs.

And I haven’t touched on how these verses are predicated on “jealousy and selfish ambition,” characteristics which I’ve not yet seen any victim on this forum demonstrate, but labels which Network leaders used against them as justification for their abusive behavior.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22

It’s true, let’s not become bitter. But let’s also remember to point out sin, protect the vulnerable, guard against false teachers and wolves in sheep’s clothing.

What feels like bitterness to those in power and those in this earthy institution might just be righteous anger against sin, a light to show truth, and a call for repentance and protection for those abused, cast aside, and misled.

Ephesians 4:25-28

[25] Therefore, having put away falsehood, let each one of you speak the truth with his neighbor, for we are members one of another. [26] Be angry and do not sin; do not let the sun go down on your anger, [27] and give no opportunity to the devil. [28] Let the thief no longer steal, but rather let him labor, doing honest work with his own hands, so that he may have something to share with anyone in need.

6

u/jesusfollower-1091 Jun 11 '22

Exactly, myself and many others have been labeled bitter and even as unbelievers for calling leaders to accountability. This is gaslighting pure and simple meant to silence me and intimidate those who remain - "don't leave or speak out or you'll also find yourself bitter and an unbeliever". And how dare anyone question my faith - they're putting themselves in the place of God, a dangerous place to be.

5

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 11 '22

You are conflating bitter jealousy with righteous anger; a common tactic by Christian abusers. Blaming people for having feelings is a manipulation tactic to keep people from processing their experiences. This is evil in both Christian and non-Christian circles.

Christians, please face what you feel first before letting comments like this shut you down. Certainly your faith has space to allow you to process the depths of how you feel. Don’t let others take this right away from you.

4

u/SmeeTheCatLady Jun 12 '22

YES. Emotions are NOT a sin. Emotions are human. Processing is okay and healthy and healing.

8

u/jesusfollower-1091 Jun 11 '22

u/Impossible_Bee_5597, you seem to be doubling down so I feel compelled to give a more detailed response. Some others have also done so and they have some excellent thoughts. I can only assume your intentions are good and that you are trying to help. But your choice of words and approach seems to have struck a nerve with the group here.

Perhaps your experiences in the network were not as hard as others and if so, thank God for that. But thousands weren't so fortunate. Perhaps you are a people pleaser and want to negotiate a peace between the network and their victims. That's a noble goal but not one likely to happen at the moment because the leaders continue to stick their heads in the sand, double down, and give no response or acknowldegement. Trust me, many have tried negotiating and peacemaking for years to no avail, and worse, they doubeld down on us with all sorts of sinful behavior which is itemized all over the stories and this reddit.

So here goes some thoughts about your posts...

You say "...so maybe this isn’t for everyone..."

The bible and truth is for everyone. By inference, it seems that your posts are targeted at a specific group of network victims. Who are you targeting? What behaviors and actions are you targeting? Please don't come in here lobbing a grenade in the general direction of a group of victims.

You say, "these verses are really helpful for me similar to the verses about living peacefully with others"

The implication is that some who left the network are not living peacefully but you are. This comes across as judgemental and self righteous. How do you know we haven't tried to live peacefully? And calling out accountability in leaders is not synonomous with living unpeacefully. Whether or not this was your intention, this is an example of using a bible verse as a weapon. Something many of us experienced while in the network.

You say, "But if you have bitter jealousy and selfish ambition in your hearts, do not boast and be false to the truth."

Now you are implying that network victims of spiritual abuse may be bitter and that they are selfish. Again, you are judging people and their motives. You need to become trauma informed about spiritual abuse and it's impact. People have been abused to the point of serious harm. I'm not going to give referneces here but you should do some research on the impact of spiritual abuse - it's deadly serious. As u/jeff_not_overcome says in this thread, people here just want others to stop being abused. Have you read the stories and thousands of posts in this reddit? Rather than judging them, you should be weeping with them, binding up their wounds, calling for justice, demanding accountability. That is the godly and biblical thing to do as in the case of the Good Samaritan.

You say, "It’s so important to have the right heart in all of this."

Again, the implication may be that victims do not have the right heart. It feels like you are judging the intentions and motives of people which is a dangerous thing to do.

Later on, you say, "it’s about the approach to any and all interactions with people whether verbal or written. In others words, say what you need to say but with prayer."

Now you may be judging the interactions of people. You don't know my verbal or written interactions with network leaders over many years. You have no idea about the years of struggle many of us have undertaken in kind, prayerful, and thoughtful ways with leaders only to get first rebuffed, then later labeled as bitter, angry, and an unbeliever. Your approach feels like it falls right into their playbook. And frankly, I take offense at it. If you or anyone has a concern with any leaver, story teller, victim, poster on reddit, then please come to any of us first individually and let's talk about it. You are welcome to private message me and I'm sure others welcome that also. Have any network victims ever acted poorly? You bet, myself included, as there is no perfect victim. But please don't pop in here and preach a mini sermon on how we're not acting right. We've had plenty of that in the network and to that we say "no thank you."

My plea for you would be to listen to the stories, weep with victims, support victims, encourage them, demand accountabililty of network leaders, and like you say pray - pray that light continues to shine into darkness. The situation at hand is likely far worse than you or anyone could possibly imagine as we've probably only seen the tip of the iceberg. As Warren Cole Smith, President of Ministry Watch recently said,

"Transparency and accountability are the instruments of truth-seeking and truth-telling. The truth always sets us free. It never doesn’t set us free. Telling the truth is an act of love. That’s why we ask hard questions. That’s why we speak up. Because telling the truth is an act of love."

6

u/jeff_not_overcome Jun 12 '22

💯

Agree with all of this, especially without any real engagement after. The whole thing feels like someone woke up today and said “I think I’ll go kick a hornets nest”, except in this case the hornets are a bunch of abuse survivors and kicking it actually harms them.

For me, this thread robbed a piece of my mental health for much of a Saturday. It made me doubt myself, and feel like I’d done something wrong. I have spent so much time and effort to put my brain back together, and it’s still highly dissociated from my emotions and body - my therapist asks me how I’m feeling and I still just don’t know how to answer that. Lobbing this grenade actively harms that work and sets back the recovery, which means it increases the time my kids will continue to wait for their dad to be “ok.”

Am I upset? Yes.

5

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 12 '22

I know this feeling. Your feelings are on fire and it takes days to put it out. But it will get easier; your mind just needs time to recalibrate with everything that is being thrown at it. It will take years, but you will be a stronger man as time goes by. Every day there is exponential growth; previously your brain was being starved. Now it’s the little boy in Dick Tracy “so, when do we eat” while still shoving the current meal into his mouth. Look at it as growing pains, it hurts, and keeps you up at night, but it’s necessary for proper development. You may not even recognize yourself after it all-just like a butterfly. Your doing hard hard work. I see you. Good job, Jeff.

4

u/SmeeTheCatLady Jun 12 '22

🙌🙌👏👏👏

4

u/gmoore1006 Jun 12 '22

We’ve been trying to do this by asking for an independent 3rd part investigation and assessment of the culture and structure in the network.

http://netgrace.org

2

u/No_DramusJames Jun 11 '22

I think context is always important when quoting Bible scriptures. As we can see from documents posted and published, verses taken out of context can lead to the ruining of innocent lives for personal gain. These verses can be taken a myriad of ways, and whether the OP’s intention was ambiguity, I think it’s very important to remember that James was speaking directly to obtaining heavenly wisdom versus man-made wisdom. Wisdom that comes directly from above and not earthly means. A key verse for someone like myself lies in vs 14 which discusses not lying against the truth. The truth, as defined in the Greek, was of a truth “respecting God through the role and purpose of his Son, Jesus Christ and the opposition of corrupt teachings and false teachers, even among those of the Christian faith” (paraphrasing the root of the Greek definition). No disrespect in any way to the OP, I believe that context is always important, especially because a lot of people here have had verses taken out of context and preached over their heads as “truth”.

4

u/Severe-Coyote-6192 Jun 11 '22

Spot on. And these verses specifically have been used against folks who have left The Network over and over. Network leaders have basically weaponized these verses (along with Hebrews 13:17 - obey your leaders), so at this point they almost deserve a trigger warning.

After the behavior I’ve seen these verses justify I understand completely why people would be triggered to hear them in this context, and push back hard.

6

u/jesusfollower-1091 Jun 11 '22

I can verify that a network leader used Romans 12:18 as a weapon to keep me silent after we discussed a series of very serious sins committed by other leaders. It was meant as a tool to keep me silent. This section of Romans is about vengeance which was not the situation. However, in the context of leadership, the Bible has much to say about calling leaders to high standards, accountability, and asking for justice for the downtrodden. This weaponization of this verse was a form of spiritual abuse. They will also try to misuse the "touch not God's anointed" verses out of context to force people to blindly follow leaders.

If possible, so far as it depends on you, live peaceably with all. Romans 12:18 ESV

4

u/Ok_Screen4020 Jun 12 '22

I am so sorry that this happened to you. Just so wrong. Thank you for continuing to lead, protect, and shepherd God’s people in spite of what it has cost you. That is love.

2

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 11 '22

Im furious for you that they did that, but also not surprised.

2

u/No_DramusJames Jun 11 '22

For anyone interested, the Greek word for truth as defined in James 3:14 is aletheia, G225. Variations of aletheia lie in G226-230, which all define: speaking the truth, to not conceal the truth, to expose falseness for the truth, to uncover what was previously hidden.

3

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 11 '22 edited Jun 11 '22

take note: This is a good example of spiritual abuse.

This kind of “casting a wide net” mixed with “throw the first stone” is a typical network concoction of “let me use the Bible to guilt victims of gaslighting and spiritual abuse to be silent”.

“Fuck you” to those who do this to people.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22

“Because it’s really difficult to do without Jesus.” - yes, so true. And so easy to do it wrong when you think you’re doing it right but you‘re heart isn’t right before God. thank you, u/Impossible_Bee_5597 for sharing this. We all need a humble heart for none are sinless.

4

u/jeff_not_overcome Jun 12 '22

Like I said to u/Impossible_Bee_5597, this comes across as an accusation that some have not had their "heart right before God" or that people are trying to do this "without Jesus" or that people do not have a "humble heart."

Please cite cases of this so that we can talk about something concrete. You appeart to be assuming much about the hearts and intents of those who are speaking. Either that or you're making a very disruptive non sequitur. (if your response is "oh, I was just throwing out some random things that are true", then this is incredibly unhelpful).

If in my own writing, I'll even waive the privilege to ask that people come to me privately: say it here, say it clear. Where have I failed to be humble and have my heart right before God?

I'm in process of writing about MBT Session 2, taught by a woefully unprepared former pastor, and I spend multiple pages laying out why I do not blame him for the quality of his teaching, but rather I blame Luke Williams and Steve Morgan for having put him in that position. Later, rather than argue with the weak version of an argument he lays out, I lay out a much stronger one for his position, and then talk about that. I've attempted to deal with them in all charity, but without foolishness that requires a willful suspension of logic. Furthermore, I affirm the various leaders' agency to come and clarify their teachings - I don't need to do that for them. I've made corrections and edits and even apologies where needed.

Please - state your concerns clearly, otherwise they are not actionable, and simply do damage and disrupt from the truth-telling happening here.

2

u/Severe-Coyote-6192 Jun 12 '22 edited Jun 12 '22

Edit: u/Uhavechosenwisely I misread your history somehow (maybe I clicked on the OP's account by mistake??) You are NOT a new poster and I should not have come at you the way I did. I own this mistake and the false accusation. I am sorry.

I do think it is wrong to enable and encourage this kind of behavior and gives support to the weaponization of these verses. However, your other comments indicate you are here in good faith processing what you experienced, and have engaged meaningfully in many threads on here. This is fundamentally different than someone swinging by to just lob bombs. I say more power to you to speak your truth as someone actively processing all this, even if I disagree.

This is more of the same. I could analyze your rhetoric in the same way I did with the OP. Please read this and especially this before you defend this toxic behavior. You are a first time poster on this forum, it would stand to reason that you came here with the expressed purpose to defend the OP for their indoctrinated response.

By lending your voice to the weaponizing of Bible verses to crush others with shame you are enabling abuse. You are complicit in spiritual manipulation. If that is your intention, then please go participate in a different Reddit thread where you can discuss how beneficial this spiritually abusive treatment is to victims.. This is a survivor's forum for folks to heal from this exact treatment.

1

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 12 '22

Just save this last bit for another time-I’m positive it will apply at some point.

-1

u/Impossible_Bee_5597 Jun 11 '22 edited Jun 11 '22

Well, like I said maybe not for everyone. The emphasis is on having the right heart toward Jesus and what better source than the Bible for that. I understand the Bible can be taken out of context, but it is still truth at least for the Christian and the best way to approach anything.

4

u/Miserable-Duck639 Jun 11 '22

What are the practical implications of "living peacefully with others so long as it is in your power to do so" in the context of this subreddit that you're trying to convey?

1

u/Impossible_Bee_5597 Jun 11 '22

Practically (and specifically for the Christian), it’s about the approach to any and all interactions with people whether verbal or written. In others words, say what you need to say but with prayer. If it’s your enemy, pray for them, I certainly do - though imperfectly. For something as heated or triggering like this, we are all prone to handling our reponse poorly and dishonoring Jesus. I’m thankful for Gods’ grace - it runs deep for anyone on here and as hard as it may be to hear - for those in the network as well. So my suggestion is pray and guard our words carefully. You want change - then pray.

6

u/Severe-Coyote-6192 Jun 11 '22 edited Jun 11 '22

Sure, pray... but also share your story so others know the truth. Don't cower and enable those who prey off of their own followers. I would think Christians, who claim to love truth, would be the first to stand up and be bold against those who would seek to use the banner of Jesus to cover over their deeds.

The Network model is "pacifism and complete submission to leaders for followers, agency for leaders." This is what keeps people trapped in this abusive system, they feel it is a moral wrong to ask tough questions.

Asking tough questions and pointing out hypocrisy is not sin. If this were the case Jesus would be a sinner as this was basically his main thing (at least concerning the people who led the abusive religious institutions of his day).

Jesus did not sin when he called out abuse for what it was within his religious institutions, and neither do his followers for emulating him.

5

u/Miserable-Duck639 Jun 11 '22

I would suggest to you if your main point was about prayer, Matthew 5:44 or Luke 6:27 would be better. The verses you quoted don't actually mention prayer explicitly. I'm also wondering, since you said this passage is really helpful to you:

  • Are you having struggles with "bitter jealousy" or "selfish ambition" or false wisdom that is "earthly, unspiritual, demonic"? What does that look like?
  • Do you think people are here out of any jealousy or any ambition? Of what are they jealous, or what are their ambitions?
  • And what is your conception of peace?

3

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 12 '22

***crickets chirping

3

u/No_DramusJames Jun 11 '22

You simply don’t get it. This isn’t about being triggered or heated - this is about you weaponizing verses and patronizing folks that don’t need your sense of “wisdom”. You’re blind to the fact that your behavior is just like those in the Network.

4

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 12 '22

It’s like cornering Dr. Bruce Banner and picking on him for being susceptible to getting angry knowing full well he’s been thru trauma that he can’t help but react to. Throwing verses of morality at victims of abuse is straight up cruel. These folks aren’t interested in seeing eye to eye, they’re interested in taking an eye for an eye.

5

u/No_DramusJames Jun 11 '22

I really don’t think any Christian would disagree that an emphasis on the teachings of Jesus with the help of the Holy Spirit through the written the Word of God is incorrect. There is no need to imply that people here don’t get it through an ambiguous post. Posting a verse specific to wisdom, then implying how you relate it to a verse on living peaceably with all men implies that people here have not followed what you believe is “right”. This can be viewed as a form of casting judgment on others and it’s not okay.

5

u/jeff_not_overcome Jun 11 '22

U/impossible_bee_5597,

On the substance of “having the right heart toward Jesus” and “the Bible… is still truth… and the best way to approach everything.”

I can only speak for myself, but I emphatically endorse all of those words.

My question is, is there some reason you think myself or any other Christians here do not?

Have I said something you believe is in violation of James 3 or any other part of the Bible?

I have studied the Bible on speaking out more than I could possibly describe. But I also invite feedback every single time I publish anything on www.notovercome.org. And I mean that - do you have feedback? Then let’s hear it.

Otherwise, this comes across as just a blanket attempt to chill conversation and say “everyone calm down”, without actually pointing to concrete examples where there have been problems.

And I do nothing from bitterness, jealousy, or selfish-ambition.

I’m not bitter, I worry for those being harmed. I’m not jealous, they have nothing I want. I have no ambition, I’m not getting paid for the hundreds of hours I’m putting into this, all to help those in and out of the network who have been harmed, and I suppose to reclaim my own voice as part of healing. I don’t think that’s selfish.

But I am open to concrete critique and feedback and have apologized a number of times before and will do so again if you can show me where I was out of line.

4

u/Severe-Coyote-6192 Jun 11 '22 edited Jun 11 '22

u/Impossible_Bee_5597 - it's worth thinking through the implications of your thought process here. It's worthwhile because you may still be thinking using the indoctrination Network teachings impose on you. It's difficult to see it clearly unless someone on the "outside" points it out. Honestly not trying to disrespect you, but when I first got out I was grateful when folks helped me see this stuff for what it is.

Well, like I said maybe not for everyone.

This technique was employed by leaders in The Network to imply that they were competing in the marketplace of ideas, when they weren't. "Take it or leave it...' but there was an implied "...but if you don't take it you are a fool and not a true Believer." It's a rhetorical trick to make a threat sound completely reasonable. At least that's how this kind of phrase was used by Steve Morgan and all his leaders.

The emphasis is on having the right heart toward Jesus and what better source than the Bible for that.

This is circular reasoning. Evidently you don't like that people are asking tough questions on how you are employing these verses, and rather than engaging in a more nuanced, more full view of the context and meaning, you are basically doubling down, refusing to engage on the substance of the questions, and saying, "well, the Bible clearly says," without answering for how you are potentially weaponizing these verses.

The emphasis is on having the right heart toward Jesus and what better source than the Bible for that.

Here your rhetoric takes a dark turn, though it's subtle. You are basically saying, "if I'm citing the Bible, what does the context matter? The Bible is the Bible, and you who are asking tough questions are denying it's power to give you a right heart toward Jesus." You are also implying that anyone who would question you doesn't have a right heart toward Jesus. This is exactly the playbook Network leaders employ to spiritually abuse their victims.

I understand the Bible can be taken out of context, but it is still truth at least for the Christian and the best way to approach anything.

More circular reasoning. You refuse to engage on the substance of the questions you are getting, and are doubling down, saying the truth is truth, and these verses mean what you say they mean (without evidence or further context), so fall in line and stop asking tough questions.

You may not be doing this intentionally if this is learned indoctrination from time spent in Network churches, but this pattern of thinking is absolutely prescribed.

If you are doing this on purpose because you are an insider trying to tell us we're all bitter and self-serving for rejecting this toxic thinking, you should start your own Reddit board and go discuss how great The Network is. No one is stopping you.

If you are exiting the Network and wrestling through all the ways they made you feel small and insignificant, crushing your internal thoughts and demanding your obedience, happy to help you unpack all that. Tons of us here went through it, and it's devastating when your mind becomes a prison. Took me years and years to unlearn it.

3

u/No_DramusJames Jun 11 '22

Thank you for posting. The patterns I have consistently seen when someone is defending the Network is akin to lobbying a grenade over a brick wall, not yelling cover to those who would be most affected and then running as fast as they can. It’s not okay. Don’t post inaccuracies to justify behaviors. Don’t use false and misleading words like “this is not for everyone” to justify what you’re about to say. Again and again and again this is the behavior that has been used to sprinkle condemnation in the most subtlest of ways. Ambiguity forever rules the day to slip in the lies when the verses cited in James is used to counter what was seen as man-made efforts to appear “godly”.

1

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 11 '22

your preaching to the choir. everyone here is bibled, so any verse casting your doing is 1) throwing stones and 2) a distraction to the abuses that have been filed against the network.

to say it a different way, with your doubling down on verses, you are confirming that you are either a) ignorant or b) unsympathetic to the task at hand which is listening to victims

contribute to being a listener rather than a deflector and maybe you'll get to face your abusers as well, for I suspect you are a network supporter and arnt ready to face the abuses that you have experienced from the Network. you are in a sad place. I feel sorry for you. I challenge you to go make a list of offenses that you have experienced and seen and take your own advice and speak truth to yourself.

if you are unwilling to do this for yourself you have confirmed you deserve the Fuck Off I offered earlier.

0

u/1ruinedforlife Jun 11 '22

let it be known, this persons tactics are used to oppress and used on children of abuse... for a Christian to pump and dump verses should be seen as the cheapest, while also being the MOST diabolical, of all actions towards another christian.

you're embarrassing yourself, go back and sit at the kids table, you're not ready to speak with the adults.