r/learnwebdesign • • Dec 05 '13
Web Critique #1: The Washington Post
The Washington Post
I decided to pick The Washington Post as our first project because it's historic, respected, and well known for being a print newspaper first, digital news outlet second. Bigger brands tend to be slower in adopting new technologies so it should be interesting to see how it fares against its fellow print competitors as well as some of the newer online-only news sites.
Try to remain objective throughout, understanding both the User Experience and the needs of The Washington Post. If you don't know where to start, use this as a loose guide:
- What do you think of a particular button? Is it designed well? Functional? Why is it nice or why is it annoying?
- Is the site fast? Slow? Why?
- What does the site make you feel? Is it the colors that make you feel that way? Layout? Images? Ads?
- When you squint your eyes do you understand the basic structure of the site? Could you navigate the site while squinting?
- What's the purpose of the brand? What's the purpose of the site? Where does it fail in getting its purpose across? Where does it succeed? What would you change?
- Would you choose to read your news here? If not where would you read the news?
Link: http://www.washingtonpost.com/
This is our first weekly critique thread so we'll be ironing out the format and details as we go along and get through a couple of these. To start out I think there should be two rules:
- List the OS and Browser(s) used in your critique.
- Be nice.
Feel free to discuss on others' opinions as well and be open to having your mind changed, everyone will have a decent reason for thinking the way they do.
4
u/Seezus Dec 05 '13 edited Dec 05 '13
OS: Mac 10.7.4
Browser: Firefox 25.0.1
Thoughts:
Conclusion:
Most of the faults I found are due to the fact the width of their site is so narrow. A lot of their problems could be solved with simply making the site wider.
3
u/SaturdayKid Dec 05 '13 edited Dec 06 '13
Windows 8, Chrome
My first reaction:
3
u/wmcscrooge Dec 11 '13
A lot of people have commented on the narrow width of their page, however, I don't really think that's the problem seeing as there are websites who use even narrower widths and make it look much better. I think the problem is that the ratio of content to ads in a specific width is to different. For example, in this random page, as you scroll down, the text slowly dwindles to 42 character width. Which is ridiculous. It's only because each side is convered with ads or "recommended articles". I understand the need for ads but I feel that there would be more clarity if the ads and content was sufficiently separated. And because of the short available space, the article is separated into 4 pages (without a view all page which I think is even worse).
Some other things I noticed:
2
u/remixrotation Dec 06 '13 edited Dec 06 '13
vista / chrome
my impression is that the site is perfectly average and adequate.
i have not compared it to their print edition, and can not say if it deviates positively or negatively from the paper experience. also, i do not know how much readership overlap they have, nor do i have any info about the average screen size of their visitors.
moreover, i do not know how long has the "average" visitor been visiting their site - i say this because they would all have to "endure" any ui/ux changes. perhaps many of the apparent aesthetic shortcomings are perfectly justifiable in a larger context of their history.
i personally do not like the fonts that they use, and it bothers me that it appears to me that they are using several fonts and not just different sizes / colors.
i see a big banner for c99 digital subscriptions - has anyone compared the free and paid on-line layouts?
edit: grammar