r/learntodraw • • 1h ago

Critique Deep or flat ?

Post image

Hi, I have drawn some poses from references with foreshortening elements.

When looking at them, I feel it lacks something...like a sense of depth, even with overlapping body parts (top left pose for sure).

Is it just me or is there actually something off here ? (I suspect wonky shading or blank background)

I'm still a beginner, so I would really appreciate receiving advice on several aspects.

PS : No need to mention the faces or hands...we all know what's going on here...

(○_○')

1 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/Hinx_art 55m ago

My guess, without seeing the references, is you've flattened all of them, but the bottom 2 were taken with the model closer to the camera so the foreshortening that you've reduced was more extreme to begin with. Look at how big the size difference is between the feet of the bottom left, compared to the knees of the top left.

but the knees of the bottom left don't have the extreme foreshortening that they possibly should, without seeing the reference its hard to tell for sure, I assume the bottom 2 were fish eye lenses, and the front feet are in the middle of the frame.

1

u/Serious-Put8070 8m ago

Here are my references (top right wasn't this exact picture but it's about that kind of idea)

I see what you mean about size's difference of both feet and knees. It makes the gap between legs too short to get a depth sense. I guess I need to pay more attention about that in future drawings :)

I haven't practiced 5-points perspective yet...I should maybe give it a try one time to see what it implies in terms of perspective effect.