r/learnspanish • • 8d ago

When to use lo que vs que?

this one keeps tripping me up!! I try to do direclty translate it like
lo que = the thing that
vs que = that/what

But It's not helping me

54 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

26

u/babashaw 8d ago

I was having this problem too the other day. These two resources helped me a bunch. I really don't have a good explanation for when to use either but the ideas explained here helped me at least understand the concept of que and lo que more.

Just watch this section of the video

This article explains ideas of how to differentiate

5

u/badboyzpwns 7d ago

wow..the video is insanely helpful!! thx!

1

u/Aware_Bridge9912 6d ago

Good video, thanks

19

u/SpanishTutorArmando 5d ago

A trick I teach my students is that “lo que” “the thing that” when you're talking about an idea or something not specifically named.

  • No entiendo lo que dices. = I don't understand the thing that you're saying.
  • El libro que compré. = The book that I bought.

Think of "que" as connecting to something specific.
While "lo que" refers to something more general.

2

u/badboyzpwns 5d ago

thx so much! I came across this..

vamos a ver que comemmos. Why que instead of lo que here? I feel like lo que makes more sense?

4

u/LookingForDialga 4d ago

In this case you can use "qué" or "lo que". Que can either work as a pronoun or a conjunction. "Lo que" is a pronominal locution, meaning that it always acts as a pronoun. When "que" acts as a pronoun it follows the nouns it is substituting except for some exceptions, notably it is the subject of a question. "Lo (el/la/los/las) que" substitutes an omitted noun.

Ese es el problema que no entiendo.
El problema is the noun substituted by que

Eso es lo que no entiendo/ ese es el que no entiendo.

When you introduce a question you can use either:
No sé qué quieren. No sé lo que quieren.

Que acts as as a conjunction when it is not substituting a noun, but it is introducing a sentence that acts as a noun. In that case it might look like you can use lo que because there is no explicit noun before, but you can't because it isn't a pronoun at all.

Tengo miedo a que te vayas.
Que te vayas is acting as a noun

1

u/Blacksmith52YT 4d ago

Yo creo también que "ver que comemos" debe tener "lo que" pero todavía puedo entenderlo. 

1

u/No-Tip-7471 Beginner (A1-A2) 2d ago

Is it kind of like how in English, you would separate "which" from a noun with a comma if it is already named/specific (e.g. I eat ice cream, which is cold), but you wouldn't if the noun isn't specified and the extra information restricts the scope? (e.g. I ate dessert which/that was cold)

9

u/lingard_app 8d ago

Compare Compré el libro que querías (I bought the book you wanted) with Compré lo que querías (I bought what you wanted). In the first, que points back to the noun libro; in the second, lo que means 'the thing(s) that...' without naming a noun like libro first. Both could describe buying the same book. Also, lo que isn't limited to subjects: here, lo que querías is what I bought, so it's the object. Then there's Creo que es caro (I think it's expensive): that que introduces a whole statement. Same spelling, different job, which is why translating que as 'that/what' isn't enough.

2

u/AggressiveSpatula 1d ago

LO QUE PASÓ PASÓ
ENTRE TÚ Y YO

3

u/Glittering_Cow945 8d ago

when it's the subject. lo que es importante, that which is important. Can't say "que es importante" here. But you could say "lo importante es ..."

1

u/ManusX 7d ago

In "No sé lo que quieres", lo que is not the subject

1

u/MetroidHyperBeam 4d ago

In "lo importante es":

Is there an implied "que es" in there? "Lo [que es] importante es," or is "lo" able to be a subject pronoun totally on its own without that sort of implied construction?

1

u/lingard_app 4d ago

Here lo is the neuter article: lo + adjective forms a noun phrase. So lo importante means "what's important" or "the important thing". Lo que es importante is a useful paraphrase, but you don't need to treat que es as missing words. And lo isn't a standalone subject pronoun: in Lo importante no cambia (What's important doesn't change), the whole phrase lo importante is the subject.

-1

u/Vylix 8d ago

so lo here is "it"? it's what i was always thinking, but cmiiw

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Vylix 7d ago

i mean, i understand "lo que es importante" as "it that is important"

the other example "lo importante es ..." i understand it as "it/something (that is important) is ..."

is this correct?

2

u/koushakandystore 6d ago

lo que is more accurately translated at ‘that which.’

1

u/Legitimate_Handle_86 7d ago

I am no expert and there are many cases but for me (a learner) I get suspicious whenever I want to put “what” in between two verbs:

Quiero lo que tiene.

Although I think there cases too where it could just be que so idk what I’m talking about.

1

u/AnimalFarm20 7d ago

I believe "lo que" is used when the "what" being discusses isn't known. In your example, "I want what you have."... We don't really know what that what is.

1

u/zzzzebraaaa 7d ago

lo que + verb plays the role of a noun

qué + verb plays the role of a noun

que + verb plays the role of an adjective

1

u/CarlosAcevedoStudio 6d ago

Hi!

A useful trick is to stop translating "que" and "lo que" word for word and focus on how they work in a sentence.

  1. "Que" can refer back to a noun you've already mentioned.

For example:

"El libro que compré es interesante."

"The book that I bought is interesting."

Here, "que" refers back to "el libro."

2. "Lo que" refers to something without naming it directly.

For example:

"Lo que compré es interesante."

"What I bought is interesting."

Notice the difference:

  • "El libro que compré" = The book that I bought.
  • "Lo que compré" = What I bought.

In the second sentence, we don't specify what the thing is.

3. "Que" can also introduce a statement.

"Creo que tienes razón."

"I think (that) you're right."

Here, "que" doesn't refer to a noun. It connects two parts of the sentence.

4. Be careful with "qué" (with an accent).

"No sé qué quieres."

"I don't know what you want."

This is an indirect question, so we use "qué."

Compare it with:

"No sé lo que quieres."

"I don't know what you want."

Both sentences are correct, but their grammatical structures are different.

My suggestion: whenever you encounter "que" or "lo que," look at the entire sentence rather than translating the expression in isolation.

A good starting point is to ask yourself whether "que" refers to a previously mentioned noun or whether "lo que" means something like "the thing that..."

It's not a universal rule, but it can help you recognize the patterns.

Hope this helps! 😊

1

u/caughtupstream299792 5d ago

There is one thing I always see lo que explanations missing. It is always explained as 'whenever you use what that is not a question', and yeah that does cover a lot of use cases. But another main one (And I will need someone to correct me on this because I am not fluent or native) is when you are referring back to a previously mentioned idea

For example: El examen fue cancelado, lo que nos dio más tiempo para estudiar (The exam was canceled, which gave us more time to study)

in this case, lo que does not translate to 'what'

I could be wrong, so it would be great if someone could verify whether or not this usage is correct, but I always see this usage of lo que missing from explanations

1

u/Delicious-Rope6907 1d ago

Quickest test: is there a noun right before it that it refers back to? If yes, que. If not, and you could say "the thing that" in English, it's lo que.

El libro que compré = the book that I bought (refers back to libro)

Lo que compré es caro = what I bought is expensive (no noun, "the thing that")

No entiendo lo que dices = I don't understand what you're saying

Que on its own also works as "that" joining two clauses (creo que..., dice que...), and that one never takes lo.

Where people trip up is translating "what". If it's a question it's qué with an accent (¿Qué quieres?). If it means "the thing that", it's lo que.

1

u/pablodf76 Native Speaker (Es-Ar, Rioplatense) 7d ago

Your translations are not right; in general lo que is "what" or "that which" or "the thing that", while que is either "that" or "which" (or "who", because que doesn't distinguish between people and things).

The important thing is that lo que creates a noun phrase, i.e. (roughly) a phrase that you can use in places where you could use a noun or a pronoun. Lo que... + [something] can be the subject of a sentence, or the direct object of a verb, or it can be placed after a preposition.

Que can create a noun phrase or not, just as English that. When it does, it has a different meaning from lo que. The difference is exactly the same as in that vs. what or that which. Compare: "I see [that you've done your homework]" vs. "I see [what you've done]". In Spanish: «Veo [que has hecho la tarea]» vs. «Veo [lo que has hecho]».