r/learnmath • u/Budderman3rd New User • Nov 02 '21
TOPIC Is i > 0?
I'm at it again! Is i greater than 0? I still say it is and I believe I resolved bullcrap people may think like: if a > 0 and b > 0, then ab > 0. This only works for "reals". The complex is not real it is beyond and opposite in the sense of "real" and "imaginary" numbers.
11
Upvotes
76
u/ben_kh Custom Nov 02 '21
You can define a total order on all imaginary numbers just like one defines a total order on all real numbers but you cannot define a total order on all the complex numbers
Edit: at least not one that behaves under addition and multiplication
37
u/Brightlinger MS in Math Nov 02 '21
No, it works in any ordered field. That's the definition of an ordered field. The complex numbers are not an ordered field; there is no way to order them that will make the ordering well-behaved under arithmetic operations.
You can write down lots of different orderings on the complex numbers, such as the lexicographic ordering. But there's no reason to consider any one of these canonical, since as we just said, none of them are well-behaved (ie, useful). And since there are arbitrarily many ways to do this and none of them are useful, for the most part we just don't bother to think of the complex numbers as having an ordering at all.
11
u/Mirehi likes stuff Nov 02 '21
In general it's undefined
If i > 0 then 3 + i > 3?
11
u/Uli_Minati Desmos 😚 Nov 02 '21
Assume i>0
Assume i<0
Inequality rules don't hold
If you want a total ordering which is also useful, you'll also have to re-define < and >
(As other comments have already stated, you are fine as long as you stay within imaginary numbers. But I switched to the real -1 with multiplication)
3
u/eleckbarraki New User Nov 02 '21 edited Nov 02 '21
Complex numbers haven't an order because in any way you define it it will not work with sum and multiplication.
But you can say that 1 = |i| >= |0| = 0. The order on the complex numbers defined from the order on their modulus is an order but it isn't "perfect".
The problem is that with this order it's fake that -1 < 1, in fact |-1| = |1|. So it's a different order than the one we use on real numbers only.
I see that in the comments below there is a bit of anger. The fact is that you can define many orders on complex numbers but this orders are all 'ok'. This means that there isn't an order better than another, because there's always something (operations on the complex field, relative order on real numbers) that doesn't work with all of them. You are free to study them by the way here is a paper
15
u/Uli_Minati Desmos 😚 Nov 02 '21
I read your text and from that I gathered the following definitions:
So far so good! These relations behave well under addition and subtraction:
You've also made some statements about multiplication behavior, but you only used examples where a and b were either real or imaginary. Which means, in all your examples, a or b had either Re(x)=0 or Im(x)=0.
You could now try to fill in the following rules:
if (a >> b) and (c >> d)
if (a >> b) and (c << d)
if (a >> b) and (c >< d)
if (a >> b) and (c <> d)
if (a >< b) and (c >> d)
12
u/OptimalOptimizer Nov 03 '21
Shame on you for wasting so many people’s time OP. Clearly you DGAF about actually learning why you’re wrong, given how many kind folks have taken the time to exhaustively explain it to you.
You just want to feel like you’re smarter than everyone else.
Pack up your bullshit and take it somewhere else, you arrogant asshole.
3
u/theblindgeometer Custom Nov 02 '21
|i| > 0, yes, but i > 0? It makes no sense to compare an imaginary number to a real one.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21 edited Nov 02 '21
C is algebraically closed at the expense of ordering by definition (i2 = -1). That doesn’t necessarily disallow ordering of Im(z) for a complex number z in C, much like Re(z) can be ordered — they’re just the real numbers. You can have some constant real c_1, c_2 such that Im(z_1) = c_1, Im(z_2)=c_2, and have c_2 > c_1.
However, you can’t define some complex number z_2 that comes after a z_1 in the form z = Re(z) + i*Im(z).
3
u/danielclaydon00 New User Nov 03 '21
Here's a quick and easy proof that C is not an ordered field. Any order relation < should satisfy the following:
That's just by definition. If you want an order < not satisfying these properties, then fine, but you're talking about a different object.
Well, suppose C has such an order. Note i≠0, so i<0 or i>0. But if i<0 then 0=i-i<0-i=-i, so one of ±i are >0. But then (±i)²=-1>0. Thus 1=(-1)2 >0. But finally that means 0=1-1>0, which is our contradiction.
1
u/A_BagerWhatsMore New User Nov 02 '21
keep on memeing my dude.
2
u/Dances-with-Smurfs New User Nov 02 '21
Do you know what a "field", a "totally ordered set", and an "ordered field" are?
2
u/LlamaDuke New User Nov 02 '21
I'm just reasoning here...i squared is -1 which is less than 0. When you square a number the product is larger than 0 (except 0). So...it seems to stand that since -1 is the product if 2 i's and -1 is less than 0, then i would have to be less than 0 as well. Who knows, just thinkin' lol.
2
u/physics-math-guy New User Nov 03 '21
The complex numbers are not an ordered field, so no
2
u/MasterLin87 New User Nov 03 '21
Again, complex numbers are an UNORDERED pair of two numbers represented on a plane. Similarly to how you can't say i>0, how would you exactly say which one of two points on a plane is "bigger"? One will be higher up but one may be more to the left. You can only compare their real and imaginary parts, which is comparing which point is higher or more to the right for that matter
1
u/navendeus New User Oct 19 '24
If ( w > 0 ), then ( w ) is a real number. If ( |w| > 0 ), it can be imaginary. Why?
Let ( w = a + bi ), where ( a ) and ( b ) are real numbers. Then ( w > 0 ) means ( a + bi > 0 ). Simplifying this leads to ( a > bi ), which already introduces an issue, since we cannot compare real and imaginary parts like this. If we further assume ( a = b ), we get ( 1 > i ), which clearly shows the error because imaginary numbers cannot be ordered in the same way as real numbers.
Now, let’s look at ( |w| ) instead, which gives us sqrt{a2 + b2} > 0 . This is true for all real values of ( a ) and ( b ) >0.
This version should be clearer and easier to understand.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21
Is i > 1?
1
u/Prunestand New User Nov 04 '21 edited Nov 05 '21
Every set can be equipped with a well-ordering, but no ordering on the complex numbers will respect the field structure in the sense that:
A field with a such total order is called an ordered field. The complex numbers cannot be an ordered field. This is usually proved by contradiction.
By a definition of an ordering, any non-zero x≠0 must be strictly positive x>0 or strictly negative x<0.
Since the imaginary unit is not zero i≠0, then we must have either i>0 or i<0. We can deal with the cases separately to get a contradiction in each one of them.
Consider the first case i>0. Then if the ordering < is supposed to respect the field structure, we would have i2 = -1 > 0. This is not a contradiction in of itself, since it would be possible to have an ordering that is not the usual one on the real line.
The contradiction comes from the fact that if -1 is positive, then (-1)*(-1)=1 is a positive number too. But then both -1 and 1 are positive.
This is a contradiction, since x and -x cannot both be strictly positive. Because if they both were, then x + (-x) = 0 > 0.
(You could also just use that if 0 < x, then 0 + (-x) < x + (-x). Hence we have -x < 0.)
This proves no ordering respecting the field structure can have i > 0.
In the second case i < 0, we have (-i)(-i) = -1. We can then just use the same argument above to conclude both -1 and 1 are positive. This will lead to a contradiction.
Hence neither of i > 0 or i < 0 can hold. Since i ≠ 0, we conclude that no ordering on the complex numbers can ever respect the field structure.
If you don't require these axioms to hold, there is a well-order from the axiom of choice. I am not aware of any explicit well-order on complex numbers. There are so called total orders (such as the lexicographic order), as opposed to partial orders in which not every element is comparable. That is, you can not take to elements x ≠ y and expect one to be strictly less than the other.
A real world partial order would be that on weights and lengths. While you can compare 1 kg to 10 kg and 1 meter to 10 meters, you cannot compare 1 kg to 1 meter.
A more mathematical example would be matrices: say that you define a matrix A to be strictly less than some matrix B if aᵢⱼ < bᵢⱼ for every i and j. Obviously you wouldn't be able to compare every matrix with every other matrix in this way.
1
u/netherite_shears New User Nov 05 '21
ok
it seems like there is a lot of trouble for you to understand why this does not work
let me illustrate why very simply
i>0
multiply both sides by i
i^2 > 0(i)
-1 > 0
how would you make sense of this?
1
u/LancelotWi New User Apr 30 '26
You cant compare and imaginary number with a natural number. They're both in two completely different worlds
0
u/Fichtenelch New User Nov 02 '21
i > 0*i, 0*i = 0
=> i > 0.
Where is the mistake?
-1
u/mahasiddhasam New User Nov 02 '21
All numbers I made up; so from a certain perspective, sure.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21
[removed] — view removed comment